What apologetic subject could use a boost?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MarcoPolo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

MarcoPolo

Guest
There is much devoted to Marian dogmas, the Papacy, the Eucharist, Purgatory and other common doctrines that repel Protestants for whatever reason. But what topic or teaching of Catholicism do you think isn’t discussed enough or that Catholic apologists should write about? If you want you can pick the above topics too, I won’t yell. :o

p.s. Just one thing—remember, apologetics is about defense, so please don’t pick something like “why denomination X is wrong about doctrine Y.”
 
I haven’t seen Communion of Saints haven’t been talked about much. When I talk to Protestants about this teaching, they tell me the saints in Heaven are dead to us and only alive to God. It almost sounds like they are saying the people in Heaven don’t have life after death to us, but at the same time they do (which is kind of weird to me).

We should try to remind them that physical death is when the soul seperates from the body. Just because people died on earth does not mean there life is completely over. They still live on spiritually.
 
I haven’t seen Communion of Saints haven’t been talked about much.
I second that.

It seems that most protestants don’t really have the stomach to debate the Communion of Saints because *many of them believe in it *(though they won’t admit it). My Baptist friend is quite sure that his departed mother is “looking over him” from heaven - hey, buddy, that’s the Communion of Saints. Welcome to Catholicism!

I know lots of protestants who believe that their departed relatives are still somehow spiritually connected to them. The only thing that Catholics need to convince them of is that the saints in heaven do not limit their love to those they loved on earth. On earth, our capacity to love is very limited. We won’t have that problem in heaven.
 
The Incarnation. You can’t adequately defend Mary unless you explain Jesus.

"…There is, in the Catholic vision of reality, a profound understanding of the impenetration of matter by grace which we call the Incarnational principle. The Incarnation of God the Son as Jesus Christ is the bedrock which underlies the Christian vision of the relationship between God and man. In assuming a human nature, God demonstrates at once that creation, including human nature, is not only good but is capable of being further elevated through the impenetration of the Divine life… By Dr. Jeff Mirus
http://www.catholicculture.org/commentary/otc.cfm?id=560

**THE WOMAN’S SEED: THE HUMANITY OF THE SON OF MAN **By Kyle Reise Eleison
Evangelical Protestants, along with believing Catholics, embrace the Biblical doctrine of the corporeality (i.e., fleshly substance) of the Incarnation (cf. John 1:14; 1 John 1:1, 4:2, etc.). However, since the evangelical profession of the mystery of the Incarnation is uninformed by Tradition, it is susceptible to errors besides the anti-corporeal heresy of the Docetists that compelled the Apostle John to forcefully emphasize Christ’s fleshliness. In particular, there is a strain of evangelical Christology that is vague or even questioning of the *authentic humanity *of the Incarnation. This strain is typically manifested by the denial of Christ’s genuine descent from Adam along with all mankind.
matt1618.freeyellow.com/immac.html

The Pernicious Heresy of Nestorianism Raises its Ugly Head Again:
 
I think more explanation and defense of Catholic spirituality is needed. So many people who leave the Church say things such as “I didn’t get anything out of it”, “I wasn’t being fed”, etc. Explaining what apologists typically explain is very important, but I’d like to see more discussion on Catholic spirituality. I think this is important for helping Catholics who have either left the Church, or who aren’t practicing or are only partially practicing the Faith. The Faith is not boring or lifeless. It’s not just some abstract idea. God is a person- a trinity of persons- living the Faith is so much more than a dramatic ritual. It’s a very deep, very personal relationship with our most loving and trustworthy provider, our truest friend, and our wisest counselor. It’s something very real and personal for those who care about it, and it can be that way for whoever wants it to be if they just know it can be and they know how to make it that way. It isn’t enough to just do it once in awhile either- it has to be a way of life. A friendship isn’t a true friendship when it is only considered when one person needs something that the other person can help them to get.
 
Soul and immortality… a lot of sects have abandoned the idea that we have a soul. They claim, if the body die, the soul dies along with it… it will “reanimate” after Armageddon… yes! you know what im talking about!..Jw’s, christadelphians, etc…

This is a topic i want to reach out to them, sadly, as i found, not many catholic resources have this defense… most likely because most apologetics is directed towards mainline protestantism…(who btw also believes in the hereafter)
 
Bravo to all who have posted so far. Great topics to be sure. The Communion of Saints, Incarnational Theology (one of my life long favorite study topics), Mariology, Catholic Spirituality, etc.

Many, many years ago I had the very good fortune of participating in rigorous study of the Pope Pius XII’s Encyclical “Mystici Corporis” (The Mystical Body of Christ) a profound and erudite doctrinal commentary. An Encyclical which, sigh, has been shelved and gathering dust for the last three or four decades. It is my own opinion that this great Encyclical should be re-examined again. The reason I say this is because the times we live are so perilous, with so many souls at stake, all Catholics should have a firm, solid grasp of the late Holy Father’s teaching. All of the above topic suggestions are included in one way or another in what I personally consider to be one of the greatest Encyclicals of the twentieth century.

ewtn.com/library/ENCYC/P12MYSTI.HTM
 
I have an article on my blog that may help with this some.
The Intercession & Communion of Saints
So do I. :o

Praying to Saints: A Visual Aid

I do think focusing more on the “communion” side than the “praying to” side may be worth a look though. Like how our suffering is connected…one body, many members and all that… Maybe how the receipt of the Eucharist is beneficial to the whole world, not just the recipient if I recall my Trent text correctly…
 
I think more explanation and defense of Catholic spirituality is needed. So many people who leave the Church say things such as “I didn’t get anything out of it”, “I wasn’t being fed”, etc. Explaining what apologists typically explain is very important, but I’d like to see more discussion on Catholic spirituality. I think this is important for helping Catholics who have either left the Church, or who aren’t practicing or are only partially practicing the Faith. The Faith is not boring or lifeless. It’s not just some abstract idea. God is a person- a trinity of persons- living the Faith is so much more than a dramatic ritual. It’s a very deep, very personal relationship with our most loving and trustworthy provider, our truest friend, and our wisest counselor. It’s something very real and personal for those who care about it, and it can be that way for whoever wants it to be if they just know it can be and they know how to make it that way. It isn’t enough to just do it once in awhile either- it has to be a way of life. A friendship isn’t a true friendship when it is only considered when one person needs something that the other person can help them to get.
Where would you begin in apologetic for this?
 
Soul and immortality… a lot of sects have abandoned the idea that we have a soul. They claim, if the body die, the soul dies along with it… it will “reanimate” after Armageddon… yes! you know what im talking about!..Jw’s, christadelphians, etc…

This is a topic i want to reach out to them, sadly, as i found, not many catholic resources have this defense… most likely because most apologetics is directed towards mainline protestantism…(who btw also believes in the hereafter)
Is this what “soul sleep” is all about?
 
So do I. :o

Praying to Saints: A Visual Aid

I do think focusing more on the “communion” side than the “praying to” side may be worth a look though. Like how our suffering is connected…one body, many members and all that… Maybe how the receipt of the Eucharist is beneficial to the whole world, not just the recipient if I recall my Trent text correctly…
A good point Marco.

Some folks have missed St. Paul’s remark about suffering.

Colossians 1:24] Now I rejoice in my** suffering**s for your sake, and in my flesh I complete what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions for the sake of his body, that is, the church,
 
Where would you begin in apologetic for this?
I guess just by showcasing different expressions of Catholic spirituality, explaining how it is centered on Christ (especially when people object to certain Marian devotions), talking about contemplative prayer, etc. Apologetics is not a strong area for me, so I’m not really sure how it would be done here- but I do think more people need to understand that the Catholic Faith is deeply personal and spiritual- and apologists need to be able to defend that it is when confronted by non-Catholics (and disenfranchised Catholics) who argue that the Faith is spiritually dead.
 
I know it suppose to be one thing, but I just thought about this. I think this is a subject that probably a pretty big issue that needs to be discuss.

"Is Christianity a religion?"

As Catholics we belief Christianity is not only a religion, it is the true religion. However, do to the misues and abuse of the word “religion,” a lot of people I here talking at various churches says it is not a religion; it is the way of life. In addition, some people look at religion as a pleasure for themselves. This should be address and clean up the misconception.
 
I know it suppose to be one thing, but I just thought about this. I think this is a subject that probably a pretty big issue that needs to be discuss.

"Is Christianity a religion?"

As Catholics we belief Christianity is not only a religion, it is the true religion. However, do to the misues and abuse of the word “religion,” a lot of people I here talking at various churches says it is not a religion; it is the way of life. In addition, some people look at religion as a pleasure for themselves. This should be address and clean up the misconception.
Great minds think alike, and so do ours. :o
 
There is much devoted to Marian dogmas, the Papacy, the Eucharist, Purgatory and other common doctrines that repel Protestants for whatever reason. But what topic or teaching of Catholicism do you think isn’t discussed enough or that Catholic apologists should write about? If you want you can pick the above topics too, I won’t yell. :o

p.s. Just one thing—remember, apologetics is about defense, so please don’t pick something like “why denomination X is wrong about doctrine Y.”
Topic –
The defense of Adam and Eve as real, living, fully-complete human beings who are the sole parents of humanity from **both **the Catholic position and the scientific position. In the 21st century, apologetics needs to treat scientific issues in a fair and proper manner. No bashing or unreasonable generalization. Note: this topic needs to be presented to Catholics as well as others.

Blessings,
granny

The human person is worthy of profound respect from the moment of conception.
 
I’d like to see a lively, accessible debunking of various myths about the Middle Ages. There are a few resources out there, like Regine Pernoud’s book Those Terrible Middle Ages, but they’re not exactly light reading. Something in a Q&A format, with illustrations, would be great.
 
I’d like to see a lively, accessible debunking of various myths about the Middle Ages. There are a few resources out there, like Regine Pernoud’s book Those Terrible Middle Ages, but they’re not exactly light reading. Something in a Q&A format, with illustrations, would be great.
I don’t know if there’s a book on the Middle Ages specific to the whole period. I know there are apologetic books on the Crusades, or “Pope Fiction” by Patrick Madrid that I believe covers myths about the Papacy in that period. So I think you can at least piece together good apologetics on the various issues of that period even if it’s not in one tidy resource with illustrations. :o
 
Salvation.
There is quite a bit of confusion surrounding this all-important topic.
 
Salvation.
There is quite a bit of confusion surrounding this all-important topic.
I agree with this one. There is a lot to be learned about the nature of the atonement, the significance of shedding blood, that Christ’s ransom was for all men, etc… Not a whole lot out there I know of that covers all that. There is more apologetics focusing on the role of works in salvation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top