what are some good resources to understand the non-catholic side?

  • Thread starter Thread starter josephback
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

josephback

Guest
hi all. I’ve been building a religous library including many apologetics details, but so far I lack any real authoritative resources for the non-Catholic viewpoint. How for instance, do I understand Baptist thought? For Lutherans I know I should get the Book of Concord and the Augsburg Confessions, but otherwise I’m stumped. I realized talking with a Pentecostal that everyone has reasons for believing what they do, and although my purpose is to challenge the non-Catholic side I want to understand it so that I don’t set up strawmen. Heaven knows we all do plenty of that. For each of you, what is your faith and what are some good resources I can purchase to understand it? Thank you.
 
For Reformed theology get the Westminster Confession and Cathecisms as well as Calvins’ Institutes of Religion. Then for historic Anglicanism get the Book of Common Prayer.
 
hi all. I’ve been building a religous library including many apologetics details, but so far I lack any real authoritative resources for the non-Catholic viewpoint. How for instance, do I understand Baptist thought? For Lutherans I know I should get the Book of Concord and the Augsburg Confessions, but otherwise I’m stumped. I realized talking with a Pentecostal that everyone has reasons for believing what they do, and although my purpose is to challenge the non-Catholic side I want to understand it so that I don’t set up strawmen. Heaven knows we all do plenty of that. For each of you, what is your faith and what are some good resources I can purchase to understand it? Thank you.
There are so many protestant denominations; and keep in mind none of them accept the concept of infallibility when it comes to defining doctrines. So, what you learn this year regarding what they teach could well change by next year.

Anyway, with all the denominations, your best option might be just to google – eg. googling “baptist teachings”, this was one of the links that came up. It’s for the southern baptist religion. sbc.net/aboutus/basicbeliefs.asp (you can click on the “full text” link in the second paragraph to get a lengthier explanation of each topic.) Keep in mind, not all Baptists are Southern Baptists.
Hopefully you’ll be able to distinguish which sites have some sort of validity for the particular denomination.
 
Is the Heidelberg catechism a good statement of reformed beliefs? Or should I get Calvin’s Institutes first?
 
For Reformed theology get the Westminster Confession and Cathecisms as well as Calvins’ Institutes of Religion. Then for historic Anglicanism get the Book of Common Prayer.
Saw your comment after I made mine.
 
Thanks for the link to the book of concord. I’ve had trouble finding a good copy.
Joseph,
RE: the Book of Concord, I suggest you start with the Augsburg Confession, the Apology of the Augsburg Confession, and The Small Catechism.

Jon
 
hi all. I’ve been building a religous library including many apologetics details, but so far I lack any real authoritative resources for the non-Catholic viewpoint. How for instance, do I understand Baptist thought? For Lutherans I know I should get the Book of Concord and the Augsburg Confessions, but otherwise I’m stumped. I realized talking with a Pentecostal that everyone has reasons for believing what they do, and although my purpose is to challenge the non-Catholic side I want to understand it so that I don’t set up strawmen. Heaven knows we all do plenty of that. For each of you, what is your faith and what are some good resources I can purchase to understand it? Thank you.
Basically read Mere Christianity to understand Protestantism
 
If you want to know about Anglicanism read the Church Fathers. Also Hooker, Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity; Andrewes’ exchange of letters with Cardinal Person, the works of C S Lewis, etc.
 
A good resource for Episcopal liturgy is the Book of Common Prayer (1979 edition).
 
Calvin’s Institutes is a 20-volume set–not easy reading!

I’m a convert to Catholicism from Evangelical Protestantism.

I higly recommend subscribing to Christianity Today. Money will be well-spent. This magazine contains scholarly articles by people in all realms of Protestantism, from High Church Anglican to back-country Pentecostalism. The magazine also clearly includes Catholicism and Orthodoxy in the list of “Christian” religions; in other words, it’s not anti-Catholic.

I think you’ll learn more about current Protestantism through this magazine than you will reading the ancient Protestant creeds and confessions. Evangelicals are the largest group of Protestants in the U.S., and the fastest-growing group of Christians in the world, especially the Pentecostal Evangelicals. These groups don’t have creeds and confessions.

And in the mainline denominations that do have creeds and confessions, many of the members and attendees know nothing about them, and many of these denominations are dropping any emphasis or classes on their creeds because they turn people off and cause them to stop attending church. Many of the mainline denoms are using more of the Evangelical Protestant methods (praise and worship music, non-liturgical worship services, discussion classes, activity-based children’s and youth programs, needs-based programs such as exercise classes, etc. to attract people back to their churches. However, their efforts are wasted and won’t work, because many of these mainline denominations have very liberal polices, both theological and political/social, and THIS is what is driving people AWAY from their quasi-Christian churches. Maybe when they figure this out and stop being liberal, people will return, but in the meantime, the mainlines in the U.S. are losing members exponentially to the Evangelical churches.

If you would like to read a good history of the Church written by a Protestant, try Church History in Plain Language by Bruce L. Shelley. This book was a major factor in my decision to convert to Catholicism. It’s very Catholic-friendly. But it also describes briefly the historical origins of the major divisions of Protestantism, including many of the modern denominations. It’s an easy and interesting read. Make sure to get the latest edition (3rd?).
 
This would be good for me I never understood protestantism when I was in the protestant church.
 
I’m wondering if you want to understand modern-day Protestantism or historical Protestantism?

Many Protestants have no idea about deeper teachings of their faith. They know that they love Jesus and have invited Him into their heart. They understand the Bible and can probably find chapters and verses quicker than most Catholics. They know basic salvation doctrines (e.g., “Believe on Jesus and you will be saved”) and can tell others "how to be saved"using their Bible and pointing out a series of verses.

But IMO, if you understand the historical Protestant creeds, confessions, and catechisms, you will NOT understand modern Protestantism.

Think about it this way. A hundred years ago, Methodists would never have allowed a practicing homosexual to be part of their fellowship. Now, the United Methodist Church is “inclusive,” and not only welcomes practicing and vocal homosexuals into their fellowship, but ordains them (males or females) to be their pastors.
 
=josephback;10662622]hi all. I’ve been building a religous library including many apologetics details, but so far I lack any real authoritative resources for the non-Catholic viewpoint. How for instance, do I understand Baptist thought? For Lutherans I know I should get the Book of Concord and the Augsburg Confessions, but otherwise I’m stumped. I realized talking with a Pentecostal that everyone has reasons for believing what they do, and although my purpose is to challenge the non-Catholic side I want to understand it so that I don’t set up strawmen. Heaven knows we all do plenty of that. For each of you, what is your faith and what are some good resources I can purchase to understand it? Thank you.
Karl Keating; the Founder of this FORUM wrote a book entiled:
“Catholism and Fundalmentalism” by Ignatius Pess. That I have found to be a facanating Read. Google it.

And I challange your assumption that they all have reasons for what they do.

Competing faiths are more or less successful based on their ability to:
  1. Be easier to get to heaven than what the CC teaches and has taught with consistancy for 2,000 years. The inventions of “faith alone”; “faith through grace alone” and OSAS come to mind.
  2. And [sadly] how effective they are in discrediting the CC teachings; in favor of man-made and devised religions.
I certianly DO agree with the need for us catholics to understand their positions; and how they arrive at them.

God Bless,
pat/PJM
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top