I’m not sure if I have any real answers to this question, but I will share a bit of my belief and experience. I began my real journey in the Church fairly late in my life. I was 21 years old when I was confirmed. Two short years later, I entered a religious community. I had many illusions about religious life that were very quickly dispelled. First, I held the belief that all clergy and religious were wonderful, holy people specially blessed by God. Second, I thought that by donning a religious habit, I would become one of those people. Third, I believed that by becoming a sister, I would finally be “accepted” by God and the Church. What I learned during the three years of my formation amazed and transformed me. Regarding my first belief that **all ** clergy and religious were wonderful, holy people…well, what I discovered was that each of us was irrevocably human. We were all flawed, struggling, straining toward holiness, just as everyone in the laity was doing. What I had battled outside the convent in terms of temptation was still there for me to battle inside. And those women that I had held above all others as untainted and holy were struggling just like me. Regarding my second belief…wearing a habit did not turn me into a saint as I had believed it would. It set me apart from the laity in a visible and concrete way, but again, I realized that my struggle to become holy would continue, and now I felt an unbelievable pressure to be what I had always envisioned a religious to be - better, holier, and closer to the Lord than the average Jane. I felt with every breath that I was disappointing the Lord by not instantly being transformed into the most pious of souls. Third, I realized something fairly profound about being accepted by God. It wasn’t dependent upon my entering religious life. It had happened at the instant of my baptism. In short, what I discovered was that for me - there was nothing about religious life in terms of deepening my life with the Lord and with the Church that wasn’t available to the laity. I feel that there is a lot more to say, but at the moment, I’m not able to articulate it properly. In short, I think that there is a belief among the laity now that has been lacking at various points in Christian history - that we are ALL specially blessed by God. That we are called to perfect holiness but have not yet achieved it. I wonder if people aren’t entering religious life now because they don’t see it as being any different from lay life in any real measurable way? There are individuals in the world who lead deep, prayerful contemplative lives while working full time and raising families. And in religious life, there are worldly and secular souls who lead lives vastly contradictory to the spirit of religious life.
Sigh.
I wish I knew how to answer this question. I can only pray that each of us answers the Lord’s call to do HIS will no matter what our state in life.