What are your favorite Hollywood musicals?

  • Thread starter Thread starter 7_Sorrows
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I never cared for the religious musicals Jesus Christ Superstar or Godspell.
Yeah, I can see it. I have been on the fence in the past about JC Superstar, with it’s hippiness of Christianity and glorification of Judas. But dang it if it just doesn’t stick in your head like a bad song on the radio. 😃

Godspell was horrible, but what do you think of musicals like Fiddler, or Joseph and the tefchnicolor dreamcoat that have a religious theme? Do you like any? Honestly some of the more serious ones have a very religious bent. Les Mis, Even Miss Saigon, though not a movie touches on the realities of faith and religion. Evita etc.
 
Yeah, I can see it. I have been on the fence in the past about JC Superstar, with it’s hippiness of Christianity and glorification of Judas. But dang it if it just doesn’t stick in your head like a bad song on the radio. 😃

Godspell was horrible, but what do you think of musicals like Fiddler, or Joseph and the tefchnicolor dreamcoat that have a religious theme? Do you like any? Honestly some of the more serious ones have a very religious bent. Les Mis, Even Miss Saigon, though not a movie touches on the realities of faith and religion. Evita etc.
I suppose when JCSuperstar came out I liked because I was young. I had the album. The worst song was I Don’t Know How to Love Him.
I am sure they were trying to show Jesus as hippie like, but I didn’t care for either movie.

I didn’t like Les Miserables either-the recent movie version. I walked out.
 
I didn’t like Les Miserables either-the recent movie version. I walked out.
Wow, tough room!

It came no where near the Broadway. But then few musicals are better as a movie anyway. That is another list we could come up with. Movies better than the Broadway counterparts. I put Chicago on that list.
 
“Mame” the Lucille Ball version (which was Hollywood) and the Angela Lansbury version (Broadway)
 
Oh! How could I have forgotten Bye Bye Birdie! Ann Margaret was so great in that!
:amen: to that!

And the other of similar vintage – How could I forget? – How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying

:whistle: A secretary is not a toy
No, my boy
Not a toy…


tee
 
“Mame” the Lucille Ball version (which was Hollywood) and the Angela Lansbury version (Broadway)
I forgot about Mame. That’s another good one but best seen live on stage I think. I’m surprised folks don’t like Godspell. I still think it’s one of the best. Love the music. Can’t stand Jesus Christ Superstar though I’ve only seen a few minutes of the movie I should give it a chance live sometime to be fair.
 
I love musicals as this list will show.
State Fair
My Fair Lady
The sound of music
Easter Parade
Oliver
Singing in the rain
Fiddler on the roof
Willy Wonka & the Chocolate factory
Godspell
Grease
White Christmas
Hans Christian Anderson (first half & all the scenery)
shine on harvest moon
And one with Deanna Durbin singing Ave Maria at the end (I can’t remember the name of it sorry)

But my very favourites are
Calamity Jane
Scrooge
On Moonlight Bay
By the light of the silvery moon
The Bells of St. Mary’s
Going my way
:tiphat:
Love your list! I’m assuming the Scrooge you refer to is the Albert Finney version? and I really love Calamity Jane, too. And all of the Howard Keel musicals are awesome.
 
Another musical I love is Paint Your Wagon. Crazy story, but I just loved the music. And I’m sorry, but how can you not love a show with Clint Eastwood AND Lee Marvin singing???
 
Damn Yankees: SUCH a wide variety of music, great story with many aspects to it. Comedic. Dramatic, Scary. Romantic. 🙂 “You’ve Gotta Have Heart”, “Whatever Lola Wants”, “Two Lost Souls,” “Good-bye Old Girl,” “Shoeless Joe From Hannibal, Mo!” “Those Were the Good Ol’ Days!” “A Little Brains, A Little Talent!” “There’s Somethin’ About An Empty Chair!” In the movie version “The Game” was done without words as a rollicking theme song with the opening credits, which moved the show along (good call). “Empty Chair” replaced the “A man doesn’t know … a woman doesn’t know” songs from the play. It changes the whole story somewhat … but the abandoned (yet hopeful) wife’s song (coupled with the conflicted husband’s “Good-bye Old Girl” really makes the movie more a love story than baseball movie, musical comedy, or spiritual drama. But it is all of these … and quite a unique movie.

The Music Man

Oklahoma

My Fair Lady

Mary Poppins

Man of La Mancha

Wizard of Oz

Umbrellas of Cherbourg (Thought it looked crazy. Finally saw the whole thing. Tears. Smiles).

Guys and Dolls

Showboat - (Either version. My dear departed mother, on her sick bed, watched it with me. In the beginning she had her eyes closed and just smiled. By the end she’d sat up, was watching furtively and clapping her hands like a little girl. Can’t hear a song from this anymore without tearing up).

^

My top 10 - though this changes each time I see another musical.

Special mention: The Mr. Magoo version of “A Christmas Carol” wonderful music.

**Peter Pan: ** The version that has “I’m Flyin’” “Never, never Land” “I gotta crow!”

**West Side Story: ** GREAT music makes up for the story (which Shakespeare did better).🤷 I liked the dancing too. If only street gangs really danced … instead of … :whistle: *“The Jets are in gear, our cylinders are clickin’ …” ! *

Thanks to the OP for starting this thread. I’ll be humming to myself tomorrow.
 
Love your list! I’m assuming the Scrooge you refer to is the Albert Finney version? and I really love Calamity Jane, too. And all of the Howard Keel musicals are awesome.
Thanks Pax2u.:tiphat:
(Albert Finney version) Absolutely.
Howard Keel has a voice that is powerful, beautiful, crisp and clear.
How can one not love his work. 🙂
 
I loved The Music Man when I was a kid.

Funny Girl is another favorite.
 
Thanks Pax2u.:tiphat:
(Albert Finney version) Absolutely.
Howard Keel has a voice that is powerful, beautiful, crisp and clear.
How can one not love his work. 🙂
Ha ha, Pete you should have said “Thank you very much, thank you very much that’s the nicest thing that anyone’s ever done for me!” 🙂
 
Gotta say, all three That’s Entertainment movies (compilations of the best MGM musicals), also, That’s Dancing (ditto but from all studios) – I stop everything to watch Astaire and Powell’s “Begin the Beguine” and Astaire and Rogers “Start All Over Again” (Could o a whole thread on favorite numbers from Hollywood musicals.

Does “That Thing You Do” count as a musical? The title song is just soooooo catchy.
Ditto for “The Competition” and “Six Weeks”: Not musicals per se but I watch them for the piano performances (the Competition, especially Richard Dreyfus’ The Emperor Concerto) and the Nutcracker (Six Weeks, my introduction to Journey through the Snow which is now my favorite portion of the Nutcracker).

Gigi
Wizard of Oz
Singin’ in the Rain
Brigadoon are my favorites of all but I love all Hollywood Musicals.
 
👍👍👍

Here are two of my favorites of his. “Where is the Life of Late I Led?” from *Kiss Me Kate *(1953):

youtube.com/watch?v=e_ui18maOq0

And “They Say It’s Wonderful” with Betty Hutton from *Annie Get Your Gun *(1950):

youtube.com/watch?v=VLCEJH6qzK4
Thank you NeedsMercy, here are two for you.

Black Hills of Dakota from Calamity Jane (1953)
youtube.com/watch?x-yt-cl=84503534&v=p59nrGixAYY&x-yt-ts=1421914688
Ol’ Man River
youtube.com/watch?v=JyKoNMnOnBM&index=5&list=PLB7FFCBACF322187D
 
Does “That Thing You Do” count as a musical? The title song is just soooooo catchy.
Ooooooooooooooh – If “non-traditional” musicals are okay, then this son of Pittsburgh must amend his top pick…

Flashdance

:dancing:
He’s a maniac, ma-ni-ac on the floor
And he’s dancing like he’s never danced before…
tee
:rotfl:
 
Ha ha, Pete you should have said “Thank you very much, thank you very much that’s the nicest thing that anyone’s ever done for me!” 🙂
:rotfl::rotfl::rotfl::rotfl:

Pax2u… I fired my cannon, didn’t you here it ???
:yup::bounce::yup:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top