What are your thoughts on post-abortive Catholics?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ForGood
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

ForGood

Guest
Hello all,

Just curious and would like some feedback. What is your opinion or feeling toward catholic women who have had an abortion? How would you react if a post abortive woman who has sought and received forgiveness now gives talks and speeches on abortion? Do you think post abortive Catholics are best equipped to fight the prolife fight?

Would welcome any feedback. Thank you!
 
**Just curious and would like some feedback. What is your opinion or feeling toward catholic women who have had an abortion? **

That would depend on if they have true remorse for their “choice.”

**How would you react if a post abortive woman who has sought and received forgiveness now gives talks and speeches on abortion? **

I would hope anyone who had committed this atrocity would find some way to use his or her sin to help others avoid the same. To me, it would be similar to a reformed murderer getting out of prison and starting a ministry to help other kids from going down the same path. Doesn’t make the initial crime okay, but it is a positive way to channel the pain and destruction that has been caused.

Do you think post abortive Catholics are best equipped to fight the prolife fight?

Best equipped? No. But I do think they can be helpful.

Would welcome any feedback. Thank you!
 
Hello all,

Just curious and would like some feedback. What is your opinion or feeling toward catholic women who have had an abortion? How would you react if a post abortive woman who has sought and received forgiveness now gives talks and speeches on abortion? Do you think post abortive Catholics are best equipped to fight the prolife fight?

Would welcome any feedback. Thank you!
I think… that if a Catholic woman has had an abortion but then repented, confessed it, and is now a pro life advocate and gives talks against abortion - that is great, praise God 🙂 not only is it encouraging to others, but it’s a great way of offering reparation… it’s also a much more effective way to spread the pro life message than if only people who’ve never had abortions talked about it. For example, another woman who is considering abortion might hear the story and think: “wow she knows what I’m going through, but she regrets having had the abortion”.

If the woman has not repented, then - well I hope that she would…
 
Hi all 🙂

I don’t know if I’m the type of Catholic you are talking about since I’m a convert (confirmation this Pentecost!!). But if you don’t mind, I’d like to tell my story.

I abhorr myself for the decisions made when we chose to kill 😦 our two babies. Our Blessed Two would be in high school and middle school now, respectively. I was NOT educated when we made this choice. I was scared, and we are full of regret. I married him, and together, we have 8 children. Our Blessed Two, four girls, and two sons born still. One son was anencephalic, and we had to induce labor. At this point, though, I had pastoral council and an army of Catholics praying for me.

I want to spend my dying breath proclaiming the evils of abortion. It has taken YEARS for me to claim these children as my own because of the shame, regret, and hate I have for myself. But I broke down in RCIA one day and told my whole group. I was shown biblically how I was forgiven, and that helped. Then my Deacon told me my children forgive me and I need to forgive myself…that is why He died for me.

I have shared my story with all who would listen. I will continue to do so until I draw my last breath.
 
Hi all 🙂

I don’t know if I’m the type of Catholic you are talking about since I’m a convert (confirmation this Pentecost!!). But if you don’t mind, I’d like to tell my story.

I abhorr myself for the decisions made when we chose to kill 😦 our two babies. Our Blessed Two would be in high school and middle school now, respectively. I was NOT educated when we made this choice. I was scared, and we are full of regret. I married him, and together, we have 8 children. Our Blessed Two, four girls, and two sons born still. One son was anencephalic, and we had to induce labor. At this point, though, I had pastoral council and an army of Catholics praying for me.

I want to spend my dying breath proclaiming the evils of abortion. It has taken YEARS for me to claim these children as my own because of the shame, regret, and hate I have for myself. But I broke down in RCIA one day and told my whole group. I was shown biblically how I was forgiven, and that helped. Then my Deacon told me my children forgive me and I need to forgive myself…that is why He died for me.

I have shared my story with all who would listen. I will continue to do so until I draw my last breath.
thank you for sharing 🙂 I think there are many women who need to hear :hug1:
 
Hi

I think post abortive women can do great things in the pro life movement. I once heard a woman’s testimony and it moved everyone to tears and it really presents the reality of why a woman might choose abortion and the horrible consequences afterwards. Many young people at the lecture came away completely changed after hearing this poor woman’s story.

I simply admire women that can do this because it takes a whole lot of humility to tell a group of strangers the sin you’ve committed and how horribly it has shaped your life.

👍👍👍
 
SanctaMommy, it’s great that after 6 solid days in our midst, you’d have the moral authority to answer a post in a Q&A format. You’re obviously a sensitive, caring, and loving soul, your post exudes all those in overflowing abundance.
 
Just a snippet from JP II…

With the friendly and expert help and advice of other people, and as a result of your own painful experience, you can become the most eloquent defenders of everyone’s right to life. (EV, 99)
 
SanctaMommy, it’s great that after 6 solid days in our midst, you’d have the moral authority to answer a post in a Q&A format. You’re obviously a sensitive, caring, and loving soul, your post exudes all those in overflowing abundance.
Robert, is sacrasm sensitive, caring, and loving? 😦 plus SanctaMommy could easily be any of those things. We don’t know each other’s souls based on posts at CAF :eek:
 
**Just curious and would like some feedback. What is your opinion or feeling toward catholic women who have had an abortion? **

That would depend on if they have true remorse for their “choice.”

**How would you react if a post abortive woman who has sought and received forgiveness now gives talks and speeches on abortion? **

I would hope anyone who had committed this atrocity would find some way to use his or her sin to help others avoid the same. To me, it would be similar to a reformed murderer getting out of prison and starting a ministry to help other kids from going down the same path. Doesn’t make the initial crime okay, but it is a positive way to channel the pain and destruction that has been caused.

Do you think post abortive Catholics are best equipped to fight the prolife fight?

Best equipped? No. But I do think they can be helpful.
Jesus used Paul, then known as Saul, who consented to the murder of many Christians, to spread his Gospel.

I believe those who have had abortions and are remorseful are very effective at speaking to women who are considering or have had abortions.

It shows the power of God to convict people of sin.
 
Hello all,

Just curious and would like some feedback. What is your opinion or feeling toward catholic women who have had an abortion? How would you react if a post abortive woman who has sought and received forgiveness now gives talks and speeches on abortion? Do you think post abortive Catholics are best equipped to fight the prolife fight?

Would welcome any feedback. Thank you!
I happen to know quite a few of these women. It is way more common that most people realize. First, all women who have had abortions are victims. They are victims of the money-making “industry” (and it IS an industry) of the abortion providers. Most of these women are scared to death and are talked into abortions by the “doctors” and are given no other options. They are made to feel like they are backed into a corner and abortion is their only way out. The ultrasound (if taken) is turned away from them so as not to disclose the sex of the child or the developmental progress of the child. The child in the womb is completely dehumanized. Here is a web site with abortion marketing quotes. It’s quite interesting to see how these abortion clinic workers are trained to reel in the “customers” at all costs. clinicquotes.com/site/story.php?id=502

Second, I think post abortive women who give talks on abortion are beyond courageous. They are courageous for so many reasons: Just the fact that they can openly discuss this painful aspect of their past is commendable. It’s so hard for any of us to admit our shortcomings, even privately, let alone giving talks to groups!

They are more than equipped to fight for the pro-life movement, as they have experienced first-hand the horrendous damage caused by abortion. I applaud these women. They have more zeal for the pro-life movement than most of us. This is one way that God can turn the evil of abortion into good. The most compelling testimony against abortion I ever heard was that of a woman who was post-abortive. The Silent No More Awareness Group gets two 👍👍!!!
 
Hi all 🙂

I don’t know if I’m the type of Catholic you are talking about since I’m a convert (confirmation this Pentecost!!). But if you don’t mind, I’d like to tell my story.

I abhorr myself for the decisions made when we chose to kill 😦 our two babies. Our Blessed Two would be in high school and middle school now, respectively. I was NOT educated when we made this choice. I was scared, and we are full of regret. I married him, and together, we have 8 children. Our Blessed Two, four girls, and two sons born still. One son was anencephalic, and we had to induce labor. At this point, though, I had pastoral council and an army of Catholics praying for me.

I want to spend my dying breath proclaiming the evils of abortion. It has taken YEARS for me to claim these children as my own because of the shame, regret, and hate I have for myself. But I broke down in RCIA one day and told my whole group. I was shown biblically how I was forgiven, and that helped. Then my Deacon told me my children forgive me and I need to forgive myself…that is why He died for me.

I have shared my story with all who would listen. I will continue to do so until I draw my last breath.
Wow! Did you read my post? You are exactly whom I was talking about!! I didn’t see yours until after I wrote mine. I want to give you a hug!!
 
I know one of these women, she has a Masters in Social Work, and works for Project Rachel. She also helped my mom and a group of other dedicated Christians to open a Crisis Pregnancy Center. That center has been in operation for over 15 years, the biggest service they do is provide material assistance. Many of the clients said that they would have had the abortion if they didn’t have the help of the center. There is a pro-life doctor that provides free pre-natal care for the clients who have no means to pay. The center has become so well known, that the area health department and county social services send their clients to the crisis pregnancy center. The center, in return, helps the clients obtain assistance from the health department and social services. And that woman with the degree in social work, provides post-abortion counseling for those who seek it, and cannot afford it. She is somebody who has walked that walk, and if anybody is to be listened to, it’s her. God can use the worst of sinners to do his work, St Augustine for example. .
 
What would have stopped me would have been ultrasounds. Definitely. I had NO idea of who I was carrying. None. I was 6 weeks along each time, and the clinics make it sound like you are having a wart removed…

ugh.

For those who embrace me into the church, thank you. It took 3 years of being in RCIA before I felt like this wouldn’t hold me back as far as coming into the church.

For others…I have met few, not many, women who don’t regret it. Unless you’ve worn the cloak of self-condemnation, you’d have no idea how it feels to know that you have committed this great thing that seems to transcend any sin you could comprehend. Judge not, please.
 
I am a post abortive woman, and I now have five children living here on earth. I have a hard time with people equating the term “choice” to a woman having an abortion. I don’t feel I really had one at the time. Technically I did, but emotionally? Psychologically? No. I was 17 and honestly had no clue.

“Behold, I make all things new…” Is this not what God said? I still have a hard time with holier than thou Catholics who feel superior to women who have had abortions. Yes, what we did is unspeakable, but you are pretty much stating it’s also unforgiveable, which is putting a limit on God’s mercy.

And if I wasn’t Catholic, I’d honestly want to tell those people what I think of them and where to stick it.

Sorry…not very charitable, but I don’t appreciate it.

You have NO idea of the hell (utter hell, literally) we went through before, during, after, and will continue until we die.

Oh, and by the way, when we were pregnant and had no where to go, were you there to help us? Take us in? Give us medical care? No. You weren’t. You were out there with your picket signs instead.

I’m sure I’ll get flamed for this, but I could care less. It took me TEN years to go back to confession because of comments like the previous poster, and honestly just OP’s like this.
 
A woman getting an abortion is like an animal chewing off it’s own leg to get out of a trap, a good priest once said.

Just to give you an idea…
 
Of course, all sins are forgiveable. God makes our souls “white as snow” in Confession. All sins disappear from the soul after absolution.
 
Just wondering if anyone cares about the thoughts of post-abortive male Catholics, not just female?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top