What canon laws regulate women?

  • Thread starter Thread starter fakename
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

fakename

Guest
Are there any church laws that do this?

For instance I know that there were old canon laws against women not veiling, wearing men’s clothes (do female pants count?), and holding public office.

Also when people say women shouldn’t speak in church, they clearly mean that women shouldn’t preach right, since if they couldn’t speak then they would couldn’t vocally pray which seems contradictory.

why were the laws changed?
 
**No Canons “regulate” women. Have you read the Code of Canon Law? Are you referring to specific Canons? Within the last 30+ years the Church has never elevated women like the writings of Pope John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI have.

Please let this forum know where you received the impression that the laws of the Catholic Church “regulate women?”

Bless you for your searching on this question…please be open to what you read.**
 
I think that now the canons and rubrics refer to where the person referred to is a man (vir). So, for instance, there isn’t a rule that says women can’t preach a homily. Rather, there are canons that say only men can be ordained and only the ordained can preach. A laywoman is barred from preaching a homily by virtue of being a layperson, then, and not by virtue of being a woman.

As for what people say, read what the Church has taught. You will find Mulieris Dignitatem (John Paul II) wonderful reading:
vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/apost_letters/documents/hf_jp-ii_apl_15081988_mulieris-dignitatem_en.html
 
I think this thread belongs on the Clubhouse where youz guyz can come up with all your laws to regulate us galz and we of course are free to give our versions of how to regulate you-awl
🍿
 
I think this thread belongs on the Clubhouse where youz guyz can come up with all your laws to regulate us galz and we of course are free to give our versions of how to regulate you-awl
🍿
All bishops are guys, but not all guys are bishops.

For this, may we all give thanks.
 
Are there any church laws that do this?

For instance I know that there were old canon laws against women not veiling, wearing men’s clothes (do female pants count?), and holding public office.

Also when people say women shouldn’t speak in church, they clearly mean that women shouldn’t preach right, since if they couldn’t speak then they would couldn’t vocally pray which seems contradictory.

why were the laws changed?
To my knowledge, there aren’t canons in Canon Law dealing specifically with women any longer, though, as follows are some examples which can apply to women and men in general:

Can.s 208-223 in general to all the Christian faithful.
Can.s 224-231 in general, though some apply solely to men.
Can. 861 n.2

Also, from what I’ve heard about the updates of Canon Law is that there were canons to add to the codex since the law had been codified in 1917. I am guessing that the reason why the canons dealing specifically with women were removed as a matter of Church Law (i.e., Canon Law) is that they were already binding matters of morality in Catholic doctrine.

– Nicole
 
Are there any church laws that do this?

For instance I know that there were old canon laws against women not veiling, wearing men’s clothes (do female pants count?), and holding public office.

Also when people say women shouldn’t speak in church, they clearly mean that women shouldn’t preach right, since if they couldn’t speak then they would couldn’t vocally pray which seems contradictory.Do you have a problem with women?
 
Are there any church laws that do this?

For instance I know that there were old canon laws against women not veiling, wearing men’s clothes (do female pants count?), and holding public office.

Also when people say women shouldn’t speak in church, they clearly mean that women shouldn’t preach right, since if they couldn’t speak then they would couldn’t vocally pray which seems contradictory.

why were the laws changed?
You started a thread “Is it okay to believe that females are degenerated males?”. You were asked your purpose for such a question and it was explained to you that this is not okay. Now you come up with this thread. Do you have a problem with women?
 
**No Canons “regulate” women. Have you read the Code of Canon Law? Are you referring to specific Canons? Within the last 30+ years the Church has never elevated women like the writings of Pope John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI have.

Please let this forum know where you received the impression that the laws of the Catholic Church “regulate women?”

Bless you for your searching on this question…please be open to what you read.**
Ulpian (Dig., I, 16, 195) gives a celebrated rule of law which most canonists have embodied in their works: “Women are ineligible to all civil and public offices, and therefore they cannot be judges, nor hold a magistracy, nor act as lawyers, judicial intercessors, or procurators.” Public offices are those in which public authority is exercised; civil offices, those connected otherwise with municipal affairs. The reason given by canonists for this prohibition is the preservation of the modesty and dignity peculiar to woman. For the preservation of this same modesty many regulations have been made concerning female apparel. Thus, women may not use male attire, a prohibition already found in the Old Testament (Deuteronomy 22:15). The canons add, however, that the assumption of the dress of men would be excusable in a case of necessity (Can. Quoniam 1, qu. 7), which seems to apply to the well-known case of Bl. Joan of Arc. Authors are even so benevolent as to say that if the face is painted to hide some natural defect, it is entirely licit, owing to the words of St. Paul (1 Corinthians 12:12, 14): “And such as we think to be the less honourable members of the body, about these we put more abundant honour; and those that are our uncomely parts have more abundant comeliness. But our comely parts have no need.” Canonists strictly condemn female clothing that does not cover the person properly (Pignatelli, III, consult. 35), and Innocent XI issued an edict against this abuse in the city of Rome.

II. In religious and moral matters, women, are not capable of certain functions pertaining to religion. Thus, a woman is not capable of receiving sacred orders (cap. Novae, 10 de poen.). St. Paul (1 Corinthians 14:34) declares: “Let women keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted them to speak, but to be subject, as also the law saith. But if they would learn anything, let them ask their husbands at home. For it is a shame for a woman to speak in the church”. The Apostle also says that in the church “ought the woman to have a covering over head, because of the angels” (1 Corinthians 11:10). It is not allowed to women, however learned and holy, to teach in monasteries (cap. Mulier, 20 de consec.). Ministering at the altar, even in a subordinate capacity, is likewise forbidden. A decree says: “It is prohibited to any woman to presume to approach the altar or minister to the priest” (cap. Inhibendum, 1 de cohab.); for if a woman should keep silence in church, much more should she abstain from the ministry of the altar, conclude the canonists.

-From the section “Women in Canon Law” Catholic Encyclopedia 1912.

My questions are do we have anymore sex-specific laws and if we don’t then why not?

From the responses I assume that we don’t have anymore sex-specific laws but I’m not sure why we don’t, for if we don’t, then in what sense are we fulfilling certain commands like “no woman is to serve in public offices due to her modesty”, or “no woman should speak in the church” -I’ve seen women speaking in church all the time so I’m not sure how this command is still followed :confused:
 
II.
In religious and moral matters, women, are not capable of certain functions pertaining to religion. Thus, a woman is not capable of receiving sacred orders (cap. Novae, 10 de poen.).
There are several impediments (obstacle) to priesthood. If you read below these impediments also refer to men.
Canon 1040 Those bound by an impediment are to be barred from the reception of orders. An impediment may be simple; or it may be perpetual, in which case it is called an irregularity. No impediment is contracted which is not contained in the following canons.
Canon 1041 The following persons are irregular for the reception of orders:
1° one who suffers from any form of insanity, or from any other psychological infirmity, because of which he is, after experts have been consulted, judged incapable of being able to fulfill the ministry;
2° one who has committed the offense of apostasy, heresy or schism;
3° one who has attempted marriage, even a civil marriage, either while himself prevented from entering marriage whether by an existing marriage bond or by a sacred order or by a public and perpetual vow of chastity, or with a woman who is validly married or is obliged by the same vow;
4° one who has committed willful homicide, or one who has actually procured an abortion, and all who have positively cooperated;
5° one who has gravely and maliciously mutilated himself or another, or who has attempted suicide;
6° one who has carried out an act of order which is reserved to those in the order of the episcopate or priesthood, while himself either not possessing that order or being barred from its exercise by some canonical penalty, declared or imposed.
Canon 1042 The following are simply impeded from receiving orders:
1° a man who has a wife, unless he is lawfully destined for the permanent diaconate;
2° one who exercises an office or administration forbidden to clerics, in accordance with canons 285 and 286, of which he must render an account; the impediment binds until such time as, having relinquished the office and administration and rendered the account, he has been freed;
3° a neophyte, unless, in the judgment of the Ordinary, he has been sufficiently tested.
 
Are there any church laws that do this?

For instance I know that there were old canon laws against women not veiling, wearing men’s clothes (do female pants count?), and holding public office.

Also when people say women shouldn’t speak in church, they clearly mean that women shouldn’t preach right, since if they couldn’t speak then they would couldn’t vocally pray which seems contradictory.

why were the laws changed?
I am calling BS on most of these old canons. I suspect non of them ever existed. Sources please to back up your “knowledge”. I get sick and tired of people telling such lies about the church in the past, as if it wasn’t even worth being Catholic until after 1965.

edited to add:
now I see your follow up, I am still not buying it. Women monarchs existed in Catholic countries and were certainly sanctioned by Rome. I will have to check into the sources.
 
You started a thread “Is it okay to believe that females are degenerated males?”. You were asked your purpose for such a question and it was explained to you that this is not okay. Now you come up with this thread. Do you have a problem with women?
I second this question.
 
I second this question.
I’m thinking one of two possibilities on why we keep having threads like this pop up…we either have a man who truly hates women and therefore is using CAF as a platform to spew out his misogyny while trying desperately to use scatterings of Church documents and Scripture taken out of their historical context to try and prove his point…

Either that or this is a rabid feminist of the worst kind who is using the same tactics I mentioned above with the bits and pieces taken out of historical context to show “how misogynistic the Church was through the ages”.

With the general skirting of direct answers when questioned, I would say there is a possibility of either or a very bored troll.

I, too would like to know what and where the OP is coming from…and I wonder what they’ll pull out of their, uh, hat, with their next thread.
 
I second this question.
I seriously doubt Fakename will ever address this. He seems to be a “hit and run” sort of poster, in that he posts a provocative question, may stop back in very infrequently to post an obscure or ambiguous comment, and then disappears until another equally provocative question is posted by him.

I think he is more interested in riling up the others, rather than seeking real answers.
 
I seriously doubt Fakename will ever address this. He seems to be a “hit and run” sort of poster, in that he posts a provocative question, may stop back in very infrequently to post an obscure or ambiguous comment, and then disappears until another equally provocative question is posted by him.

I think he is more interested in riling up the others, rather than seeking real answers.
Well I certainly think that concluding I’m a provocateur is incorrect since I am asking sincerely. As to whether I dislike women, I suppose the word dislike is said in many ways and fashions and nothing prevents someone from disliking something in someway and liking it in another way. From what I’ve read from chruch approved documents I suppose I “dislike” women serving in public offices (granted that there are contradictions to this view, for there were catholic queens), for the reasons presented seem rather weighty and not too improbable. But for the most part I’m rather confused on the whole issue since what catholics said on the matter has changed from either “keep women silent and out of public office” to “women can say the homily” and complete silence on the subject of public office. This explains why I put the confused face on the end of my last post and the same thing I said here can be applied to all my posts and threads -as for any obscure comments, sorry is all I can say, in the words of any misunderstood person: “they didn’t seem so obscure to me”.
 
Well I certainly think that concluding I’m a provocateur is incorrect since I am asking sincerely. As to whether I dislike women, I suppose the word dislike is said in many ways and fashions and nothing prevents someone from disliking something in someway and liking it in another way. From what I’ve read from chruch approved documents I suppose I “dislike” women serving in public offices (granted that there are contradictions to this view, for there were catholic queens), for the reasons presented seem rather weighty and not too improbable. But for the most part I’m rather confused on the whole issue since what catholics said on the matter has changed from either “keep women silent and out of public office” to “women can say the homily” and complete silence on the subject of public office. This explains why I put the confused face on the end of my last post and the same thing I said here can be applied to all my posts and threads -as for any obscure comments, sorry is all I can say, in the words of any misunderstood person: “they didn’t seem so obscure to me”.
So basically, you don’t care for women being in any role other than subservient to men and you are looking for Church teachings and documents to back that up so you can justify your personal biases?

Well, better to have your misogyny out in the open now. At least we all know where you stand on things…
 
So basically, you don’t care for women being in any role other than subservient to men and you are looking for Church teachings and documents to back that up so you can justify your personal biases?

Well, better to have your misogyny out in the open now. At least we all know where you stand on things…
Not to justify personal biases -to test them to see if they are true: as everyone with ideas must do.🤷
 
Well I certainly think that concluding I’m a provocateur is incorrect since I am asking sincerely. As to whether I dislike women, I suppose the word dislike is said in many ways and fashions and nothing prevents someone from disliking something in someway and liking it in another way. From what I’ve read from chruch approved documents I suppose I “dislike” women serving in public offices (granted that there are contradictions to this view, for there were catholic queens), for the reasons presented seem rather weighty and not too improbable. But for the most part I’m rather confused on the whole issue since what catholics said on the matter has changed from either “keep women silent and out of public office” to “women can say the homily” and complete silence on the subject of public office. This explains why I put the confused face on the end of my last post and the same thing I said here can be applied to all my posts and threads -as for any obscure comments, sorry is all I can say, in the words of any misunderstood person: “they didn’t seem so obscure to me”.
Well, now we know where you stand! Misogyny indeed. Where did this come from in your viewpoint? Misogyny is certainly NOT what the Catholic church teaches, and you will not find any Catholic documentation supporting Misogyny. At least you are honest about your dislike of women.
 
Not to justify personal biases -to test them to see if they are true: as everyone with ideas must do.🤷
Whether an individual has personal biases against a sex or not, whether it still appears in Canon Law that women should not speak in the assemblies or that they should be covered and have their heads covered at the sacred services, those things are still binding Catholic doctrine regarding morality none-the-less. That doesn’t make women less in dignity than men, as they are both human beings, but it merely makes women specialized. Women can do things men can’t do, just as men can do things women can’t do. Women can do things that men ought not do, just as men can do things that women ought not do. There’s no shame in that, it’s just life.

I don’t know why threads like this rise the indignation of so many women. I am a woman and find it better to share the truth about women as God both made us and restored us in Jesus Christ, than spread post-1960 feminist error that women and men are utterly interchangeable.

– Nicole
 
Well, now we know where you stand! Misogyny indeed. Where did this come from in your viewpoint? Misogyny is certainly NOT what the Catholic church teaches, and you will not find any Catholic documentation supporting Misogyny. At least you are honest about your dislike of women.
If fake name’s post manifested misogyny, then I am a feminist. You might do good to re-read this post and re-consider your apparent rash judgment.

– Nicole
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top