What did Jesus sacrifice?

  • Thread starter Thread starter FaighDoSolas
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You didn’t? You said “The fact that he was also god detracts very much from the suffering.” I’m saying that it doesn’t. Because Jesus was fully human he had the full capability to experience human pain. Knowing that He was suffering that pain for the salvation of the world and that it wouldn’t last long compared to eternity doesn’t reduce His very real human suffering.

You also said “It detracts from the severity of the sacrifice, and even if it doesn’t detract from the physical pain, mentally he had comfort and assurances that we wouldn’t have.” I disagree. People suffer horrific pain and sacrifice with strength and determination because they believe something good will come out of it. That knowledge does not detract from the pain.
I didn’t mean that he physically suffered any less, but that the fact that he knew what he was going to, the knowledge that he posessed and the being that he was detracts from the suffering.
 
Again, it wasn’t the pain that was the sacrifice, it was the act of dying itself that completed the sacrifice.
Exactly. But the fact that he dies was a non-event for him, because of his knowledge. He didn’t really care that he was going to die, because he knew what and who was waiting for him. MUCH more than any human could ever know.
Christians think that they know, they have an idea, and that’s fine that they believe that (Whether it’s true is another, and ongonig, debate) but being jesus, he would have had first-hand knowledge of god and heaven. That is exactly what detracts from the sacrifice and what makes it not as terrible as everyone thinks that it is.
Well said (even if you were trying to make the opposite point)
 
Exactly. But the fact that he dies was a non-event for him, because of his knowledge. He didn’t really care that he was going to die, because he knew what and who was waiting for him. MUCH more than any human could ever know.
Christians think that they know, they have an idea, and that’s fine that they believe that (Whether it’s true is another, and ongonig, debate) but being jesus, he would have had first-hand knowledge of god and heaven. That is exactly what detracts from the sacrifice and what makes it not as terrible as everyone thinks that it is.
Well said (even if you were trying to make the opposite point)
Just because Jesus knew that he would rise again doesn’t mitigate the suffering he endured before he died. He didn’t just go through that torture as a man (thousands of other men have endured that same torture and worse). He went through it with the terrible weight of all the sins of humanity on his shoulders. How can you possibly know how hard it would be to bear that? So yes, he had paradise waiting, but he had to go through hell to get there.
 
In trying to clarify my faith, one rather large obstacle for me is the question of what did Jesus actually sacrifice?
Everything. In short, He gave all.

You are going to rise again too, will you go through the same suffering He did for me?
 
Just because Jesus knew that he would rise again doesn’t mitigate the suffering he endured before he died. He didn’t just go through that torture as a man (thousands of other men have endured that same torture and worse). He went through it with the terrible weight of all the sins of humanity on his shoulders. How can you possibly know how hard it would be to bear that? So yes, he had paradise waiting, but he had to go through hell to get there.
Yes, true. I’m not talking about the suffering, I’m talking about the sacrifice. The suffering is there, but I’m arguing that how jesus (supposedly) was and the knowledge that he had, detracts from the sacrifice that christians seem to make a big deal about.
 
Yes, true. I’m not talking about the suffering, I’m talking about the sacrifice. The suffering is there, but I’m arguing that how jesus (supposedly) was and the knowledge that he had, detracts from the sacrifice that christians seem to make a big deal about.
Every Christian martyr went to his or her death with the same sure knowledge that heaven was waiting for them. Did that help them to endure their torture? Undoubtedly, that knowledge was the only thing that made it bearable. It was also the only thing that made it meaningful. Without hope in the resurrection, all death is meaningless. That’s something that non-believers don’t seem to get.
 
Every Christian martyr went to his or her death with the same sure knowledge that heaven was waiting for them. Did that help them to endure their torture? Undoubtedly, that knowledge was the only thing that made it bearable. It was also the only thing that made it meaningful. Without hope in the resurrection, all death is meaningless. That’s something that non-believers don’t seem to get.
How is this different to Islamic martyrs?
 
Every Christian martyr went to his or her death with the same sure knowledge that heaven was waiting for them.
Lol, now that’s just funny.
Did that help them to endure their torture? Undoubtedly, that knowledge was the only thing that made it bearable. It was also the only thing that made it meaningful. Without hope in the resurrection, all death is meaningless. That’s something that non-believers don’t seem to get.
Yeah, we don’t get it 'cuz it’s not true. No one ***knows ***for sure. If they did, they would be able to prove it.
They have faith, yes, but faith is a far cry from knowledge.
That’s something christians don’t seem to get.
 
I think there was a suffering our Lord experienced that transcended the full humanity that He shared mysteriously with His full divine nature, and that was the rejection, shame, and loss of dignity that can never be erased out of time and space. It was the whole Christ who was rejected, the whole Christ who was stripped naked and hung on that cross in the public square, the whole Christ who’s infinite love was unrequited.

God the Father sent His only Son into the world knowing this. Where’s the omnipotence in that? It is the omnipotence of love over hate, forgiveness over revenge, mercy over our maligned sense of justice.
 
Not much point to dying when you can get rezzed so easily.
I’m arguing that how jesus (supposedly) was and the knowledge that he had, detracts from the sacrifice.
No, it doesn’t detract from His sacrifice. It’s the same for you and me. If you are willing to die to self with Christ, you will rise with Him. Are you willing?
 
No, it doesn’t detract from His sacrifice. It’s the same for you and me. If you are willing to die to self with Christ, you will rise with Him. Are you willing?
From your point of view it remains the same…he died…sure, I guess…

From god’s point of view, it wasn’t such a big deal since he knew that he was going to be alive and well and at a big banquet in his honour really soon.
What’s the point of a sacrifice if the deed doesn’t mean much to you? From god’s point of view, it’s pretty inconsequential.

I’d like to have seen god sacrifice his son to himself if he didn’t get resurrested afterwards. I bet you he wouldn’t have…your stroy would have had a different ending, I’ll tell you that.

As to your question, am I willing to die to self? Heeelllllll no! I like myself and I refuse to have anyone tell me that I’m “evil” or "bad"just because I don’t pray to the same imaginary friend as they do.
 
The question was not did Jesus suffer, it was what did he sacrifice. The short answer is nothing.

He came from heaven for what was to him a millisecond, ‘died’ then went back to rule the cosmos.

Its like a billionaire sleeping in the street for a night then going to back to his mansion. Not much of a sacrifice.
 
The question was not did Jesus suffer, it was what did he sacrifice. The short answer is nothing.

He came from heaven for what was to him a millisecond, ‘died’ then went back to rule the cosmos.
You are still equating sacrifice with suffering by asking what Jesus gave up. The word sacrifce in this case means simply an offering to God. It has nothing to do with suffering. God had prescribed different kinds of offerings, or sacrifices, to be offered for different reasons. They could be bloody (animal) or unbloody (grain and wine). The animals that were used for sacrifice weren’t made to suffer, in fact it was required that they did not suffer unduly.

Jesus’ bloody sacrifice was “to accomplish the reconciliation of God and humanity, which had separated itself from God through sin. God’s justice required an atonement for sin from humanity if human beings were to be restored to their place in creation and saved from damnation. However, God knew limited human beings could not make sufficient atonement, for humanity’s offense to God was infinite, so God sent his only Son to become the sacrifice of the everlasting covenant.” (from Wikipedia)
In the Mosaic sacrifices also the essence of the sacrifice lay, not in the actual slaying of the victim, but in the letting, or rather in the sprinkling, of the blood. Consequently, the sacrifice of the Cross, at which Christ functions as sole priest, must likewise be referred to the free offering of His blood for us men, inasmuch as the Redeemer, while outwardly submitting to the forcible shedding of His blood by His executioners, simultaneously offered it to God in the spirit of sacrifice. newadvent.org/cathen/13309a.htm
Its like a billionaire sleeping in the street for a night then going to back to his mansion. Not much of a sacrifice.
You really want to equate being crucified to sleeping on the street? Watch “The Passion of the Christ”. You think Jesus was “cool” with it, since he was God and all? Read Matthew 26:36-43.
 
Faighdosolas

Often times in the traditional view things get hashed as we can or can’t relate. Truly many suffered the same death for whatever reason without the Benefit of Christ’s knowledge. But there are things to be considered that rarely if ever get consideration from certain perspectives. The logic presents itself is at times selfish.
At times It presents, look what God has done for me because I believe! And it’s true it is one of the most power themes of the Bible. People believe for reasons and for gain. I mean why believe if ther isn’t anything to be gained? The apostles even make remarks such as “”we have forsaken all to follow you””. Kind of like what’s in it for me! What are the specifics? Christ replied you haven’t forsaken all for me for nothing. He calls them on it! Yep, they all had to own up that they were following him for reasons deep inside that trumped their earthly possessions. They were simple people with little earthly possessions and high expectations. Not unlike many believers today.

It isn’t only what had Jesus sacrificed, But what God sacrificed. Everybody gets all bent on things that are non issues at times or incomplete thought, Trying to explain for others what they invent to justify their reasoning of rejection for following. It’s our human nature at times. The truth is a bit more panoramic then we often first understand or have been explained. One might even consider what God gained from the sacrifice. “Turn the tables a little in reciprocation”. Did God have things he desired of his creation? I mean why waste my time and go through something that ultimately has no meaning or purpose? What do we gain in this world for doing things that end our life? Too what part would God have to play to achieve what it was that God was doing? Was God just doing something for our benefit or was it mutual? That both God and Man were fulfilling something thru something of which both are mutually joined and benefited from such a thing? And both have to make sacrifices. Was Gods sacrificing his or just sending him and was the only son just for man or was the sacrifice reciprocation? Lots of Questions!

The sacrifice can reciprocate if God sacrificed his only son. The son Pray’s take this cup from me if possible, but your (Father) will be done. For thousands of years people are sacrificing to God or gods. Even human sacrifices are made historically and for what purpose? A human sacrifice? Such an evil thing to most and yet Our God allowed his son to offer himself as such a thing.

Often times people sacrifice to appease a God who could be angered by” SIN” or simple rejection. Also people sacrificed to draw from their God a blessing. They often sacrificed those things important to their very human existence. They sacrificed sheep and goats and bulls and doves and crop’s in offerings, so that their God would continue to bless in bountiful harvest themes. Basically they sacrifice so their God would continue to work on their behalf in the causation of their existence. Christ’s sacrifice had a universal significance because all peoples were doing it for their own reasons and this is by nature through Christ seen as a Gift. Christ sacrificed to show man what God would work toward and who God will work for. But as in all covenants with the God of Israel it reciprocates. That’s right 2000 years ago God sacrificed his only Son and in the reciprocation it means that now it was time for us to go to work for him. To a believer God said 2000 years ago you can’t remain as you are and I the Lord your God am going to work to glorify your existence as are you going to work to glorify my existence. It was time for those who say they Worshiped the one true God to now bare fruit as the old saying goes. What is God actually trying to do that would provoke God to such extremes?

The old Atheist itch of what was the benefit of theism in the evolution of man. I mean the superior traits and all in the genes. Survival of the fittest and all. That one of Mans greatest assets this theism has no material attributes. That something with no mass is the bedrock of so many things in cultures around the world.
That in reality that which has no mass and technically doesn’t exist by the nature of what so many call existences and yet like a thought it creates or forms a basis for everything we see. That by the Nature in creative forces that our imaginings and Ideas which have no material existence cause to spring so many creative tangible things. The very well spring of Reality comes from a non existence by all objective standards. If it has no mass it isn’t real but yet the reality is that which has no mass is responsible for often what we see as real and tangible. Like the computer I’m typing on. It didn’t exist until that with no mass caused it to happen.

Peace and Godbless
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top