What did Pope Benedict XVI mean?

  • Thread starter Thread starter thebookofesther
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

thebookofesther

Guest
I’m reading Absolute Relativism (made it to the end of the first paragraph of the foreword) and wanted an explanation less for me and more for my utilitarianistic Ron Paul supporting friends on the meaning of, “the tyranny of mammon which perverts mankind” and that they result from, “a fatal misunderstanding of freedom which actually undermines man’s freedom and ultimately destroys it.”

Thanks!
 
I’m reading Absolute Relativism (made it to the end of the first paragraph of the foreword) and wanted an explanation less for me and more for my utilitarianistic Ron Paul supporting friends on the meaning of, “the tyranny of mammon which perverts mankind” and that they result from, “a fatal misunderstanding of freedom which actually undermines man’s freedom and ultimately destroys it.”

Thanks!
From the Catholic perspective, freedom is not the ability to do whatever we want to do. It is the ability to live as we ought, according to God’s will. We tend to think that rules and requirements make us less free. However, when applied properly and justly, and when correctly understood, the opposite is true.

Here is an example. Take a virtuoso pianist. He/she has studied and practiced for many years. She/he knows the rules of musical theory, proper technique, etc. This level of mastery of one’s self allows them to express themselves on the piano with great freedom. Whatever they hear and desire to play, they can. Any piece of music they pick up and wish to play, they can. Now, take an untrained person who desires to express his or herself in the same way. They cannot. They are not free because they have not mastered the necessary skills to do so. The training, rules, and requirements necessary to become a master pianist have made them free in a way that the other person will never know.

In a similar way, when we do not master our own desires for sin, money, prestige, etc. we become slaves to that desire. This is where God’s laws and the teachings of the Church come in. If we follow them, we are able to master that desire and we become free to be the person we were meant to be. We remain in the world, but we are not of the world. That, is true freedom.

I hope that helps somewhat.

Peace of Christ,
 
From the Catholic perspective, freedom is not the ability to do whatever we want to do. It is the ability to live as we ought, according to God’s will. We tend to think that rules and requirements make us less free. However, when applied properly and justly, and when correctly understood, the opposite is true.

Here is an example. Take a virtuoso pianist. He/she has studied and practiced for many years. She/he knows the rules of musical theory, proper technique, etc. This level of mastery of one’s self allows them to express themselves on the piano with great freedom. Whatever they hear and desire to play, they can. Any piece of music they pick up and wish to play, they can. Now, take an untrained person who desires to express his or herself in the same way. They cannot. They are not free because they have not mastered the necessary skills to do so. The training, rules, and requirements necessary to become a master pianist have made them free in a way that the other person will never know.

In a similar way, when we do not master our own desires for sin, money, prestige, etc. we become slaves to that desire. This is where God’s laws and the teachings of the Church come in. If we follow them, we are able to master that desire and we become free to be the person we were meant to be. We remain in the world, but we are not of the world. That, is true freedom.

I hope that helps somewhat.

Peace of Christ,
Nice post.
 
Nice post.
Thanks. I wish I could say that I came up with it but in reality I took bits and pieces of what I had heard in other places and tried to make a coherent thought out of it.

I think it is also important to note something that I forgot to mention in my first response which is when rules and laws are implemented unjustly, they can and do limit freedom. God’s laws have the benefit of being perfect which means that the teachings of the Church rest on a solid foundation of revealed truth. The laws that we make up? Not so much.

😉

Peace,
 
that was pretty good.

I liked what Frank Sheed said that by knowing the laws of gravity and air pressure we can fly tons of metal through the air. If I jump off a building ignoring these laws, I don’t break the laws they break me! LOL
That’s very good.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top