What do catholics think of protestants (methodist)?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zundrah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Z

Zundrah

Guest
So in a nut shell, what do you catholics think about protestants? Do you feel the need to desperately convert them? …or do you guys see protestants as blasphemers and heresy commiters that should never enter your catholic church because of their objections?

Have you ever befriended a protestant? I thought that your church taught you people not to have to close a relationship with protestants incase you are drawn away from the catholic church. Are you not allowed to marry a protestant? 🤷

Are there some catholics that really hate protestants?
 
I see protestants as brothers and sisters in Christ. I love talking to them about our Christian faith because the Catholic faith and the protestant ones will almost always mesh in most topics. If they want to know specifically Catholic things, I’ll try my best to explain them. Meaning, the first thing I’ll say to them WON’T be “JOIN MY CHURCH OK?” Oh, and even if you’ve done the most abhorrent of things yet repent, you can be Catholic. No one is excluded from our faith.

Oh yes I’ve befriended a protestant! He is such an inspiration for me, I can just see the love of God in him. He makes me want to be a better Catholic.

And yes, there will always be snotty Catholics who don’t like protestants. But know that a genuine Catholic will always love his/her neighbor, no matter their faith. 🙂
 
So in a nut shell, what do you catholics think about protestants?
Speaking for myself, it depends on the person, and why they’re Protestant. Some are Protestant because they can’t fathom the idea that someone else may be more right on religious issues: they can’t submit to the Church as much out of pride as any religious conviction, no matter how many times it’s proven that their initial assumptions fail close Biblical exegesis and examination, while the Church’s pass muster. Other Protestants are in whichever denomination they are because they have an intense love of Christ and feel that it’s the best place to express that love, or the place where they feel that love being nurtured the best. Still others (like members of any denomination) are lukewarm. I’ve met plenty of people in all three groups: the middle group I have a ton of respect for, even if we have some disagreements (plus, I don’t think any Catholic familiar with conversion stories will deny that God often uses Protestant denominations to nurture a love for Him and His teachings).
Do you feel the need to desperately convert them? …or do you guys see protestants as blasphemers and heresy commiters that should never enter your catholic church because of their objections?
Neither. Protestants are “incomplete Catholics,” in our view. We agree on a lot of the big issues. There are some important ones which separate us, and the further one gets from the Reformation, the greater the issues (by that I mean, the Lutherans and Anglicans, first-generation reformers, have much more in combination than later splits, like Independent Baptists: there’s an unfortunate drift further and further away from the historic and living Church founded by Christ). So I think that there’s a need to correct faulty views of the Church, and to encourage them to come home, but it’s arguably not a conversion: a conversion suggests giving up your old beliefs and embracing new ones; this is a plea to direct your passion and zeal for Christ at the institution which He describes as His Body in Acts 9, and at the Eucharist which He describes as His Body in John 6, at the Last Supper, and in 1 Corinthians 11:23-27.

No one is too much of a sinner to become Catholic. We’re a hospital for sinners, not a museum of saints. And there will be some self-proclaimed Protestants entering Heaven ahead of some self-proclaimed Catholics.
Have you ever befriended a protestant?
Countless. I’m dating a Protestant “convert” to Catholicism (I use convert just b/c it’s the easiest term).
I thought that your church taught you people not to have to close a relationship with protestants incase you are drawn away from the catholic church.
A close relationship with anyone of different religious persuasions can be really powerful or really destructive, and you should be careful about it. If you’re confused about your own faith, it’s probably a bad idea to develop a really close relationship with someone of a different faith who knows their faith really well (unless you’re willing to convert). On the other hand, if you know your faith really well and can defend it, befriending people of different religious persuasions can be an important part of evangelization, unless your friendship impedes you from speaking the truth to them. I’ve never heard anything from the Church against befriending Protestants.
Are you not allowed to marry a protestant? 🤷
We are, as long as it is within the Catholic Church, and we raise the kids Catholics. At least, those are the traditional two requirements - it’s possible they don’t exist anymore (I’m not positive).
Are there some catholics that really hate protestants?
Yeah. Northern Ireland doesn’t lack them. But in a lot of cases it’s for reasons which are more than just religious (like in N. Ireland), and culture plays a big part. In the US, I think there’s much less, because it’s a largely Protestant country - most of us live and work with Protestants on a daily basis.

Do you know any Catholics in London?
 
So in a nut shell, what do you catholics think about protestants? Do you feel the need to desperately convert them? …or do you guys see protestants as blasphemers and heresy commiters that should never enter your catholic church because of their objections?

Have you ever befriended a protestant? I thought that your church taught you people not to have to close a relationship with protestants incase you are drawn away from the catholic church. Are you not allowed to marry a protestant? 🤷

Are there some catholics that really hate protestants?
My family was half Catholic and half Protestant (Methodist and Episcopalians). They were great! Loved them dearly. Learned a lot from them. Only time religion was discussed was when Grandpop said he’d never be a Catholic because he wasn’t going to tell his sins to a priest. And I thought, “And I’d never be an Episcopalian because I don’t think a man who had two of his wives killed should be the head of any church.” But I never said that outloud because he was my Grandfather. By the way, he was born in Birmingham.

My Presbyterian college roommate befriended me as well as her family. They were wonderful people. Never knew they were anti- Catholic until my senior year when my roommate told me her family were always staunch Democrats but swithced because they’d never vote for JFK, a Catholic.

Without any fuss, they always made sure I had fish on Friday when I visited and they checked to make sure what time Sunday Mass was at the local parish and would drive me there. I never had to ask. My Protestant family did the same.

I worry today about their souls because I worry where some of the Churches are headed. You know with Catholics most of the criticism is about the Pope. I have always had difficulty figuring out who the heads of the various Protestant churches are. Only recently did I get an explanation that the Methodists appoint a council every four years. When the new council is appointed, policies can change. For instance, for four years abortion could be prohibited but when a new council comes in, abortion could be accepted. I don’t see how something can be a sin and then not a sin switching every four years.

My Presbyterian roommate shared with me that her niece was pregnant and aborted one of the embroys because she felt it would be too hard to raise two. She just looked at me and I at her and we both shook our heads.

She is also concerned about her church allowing gays to be ministers and having gay marriages in her church. It is still under discussion.

I would be happy to discuss religions if she approached the subject and asked me questions.

What has your experiences been with Catholics? And what denomination are you?
 
I don’t choose my friends on the basis of religion. However, my closest friends are Catholics or Protestants who love God. I’d be happy if my Protestant friends would become Catholic (one did!) but they are already Christians and God will lead them where he wants them. I’ll answer any questions they have about the Catholic church. I don’t know any Catholics who hate Protestants; some of them used to be Protestants. I don’t hate Jews either, or Muslims but I’m somewhat suspicious of Muslims.
 
My family was half Catholic and half Protestant (Methodist and Episcopalians). They were great! Loved them dearly. Learned a lot from them. Only time religion was discussed was when Grandpop said he’d never be a Catholic because he wasn’t going to tell his sins to a priest. And I thought, “And I’d never be an Episcopalian because I don’t think a man who had two of his wives killed should be the head of any church.” But I never said that outloud because he was my Grandfather. By the way, he was born in Birmingham.

My Presbyterian college roommate befriended me as well as her family. They were wonderful people. Never knew they were anti- Catholic until my senior year when my roommate told me her family were always staunch Democrats but swithced because they’d never vote for JFK, a Catholic.

Without any fuss, they always made sure I had fish on Friday when I visited and they checked to make sure what time Sunday Mass was at the local parish and would drive me there. I never had to ask. My Protestant family did the same.

I worry today about their souls because I worry where some of the Churches are headed. You know with Catholics most of the criticism is about the Pope. I have always had difficulty figuring out who the heads of the various Protestant churches are. Only recently did I get an explanation that the Methodists appoint a council every four years. When the new council is appointed, policies can change. For instance, for four years abortion could be prohibited but when a new council comes in, abortion could be accepted. I don’t see how something can be a sin and then not a sin switching every four years.

My Presbyterian roommate shared with me that her niece was pregnant and aborted one of the embroys because she felt it would be too hard to raise two. She just looked at me and I at her and we both shook our heads.

She is also concerned about her church allowing gays to be ministers and having gay marriages in her church. It is still under discussion.

I would be happy to discuss religions if she approached the subject and asked me questions.

What has your experiences been with Catholics? And what denomination are you?
My denomination is Methodist. I think that is the most common protestant church isn’t it?
My mum is catholic because her whole family is Irish!
For instance, for four years abortion could be prohibited but when a new council comes in, abortion could be accepted.
This is TRUE! I once spoke to my ministers about it! It must sound crazy to a catholic! 😃 But then again it sounds crazy to me too!
but swithced because they’d never vote for JFK, a Catholic.
…personally I wouldn’t change my vote if I found out that the person I was voting for was catholic! I would change if they were mormon though! 😛
She is also concerned about her church allowing gays to be ministers and having gay marriages in her church. It is still under discussion
.

This is also true… gay people are still missionarys in protestant denominations but I’ve never heard of a married gay couple ordination though… But I don’t doubt it.
By the way, he was born in Birmingham.
Birmingham is okay… though I don’t like their accents! 😉 …but I just have a normal London accent! …y’know, english and normal! 😃

I don’t know any other catholics other than my mum… 😦
 
Speaking for myself, it depends on the person, and why they’re Protestant. Some are Protestant because they can’t fathom the idea that someone else may be more right on religious issues: they can’t submit to the Church as much out of pride as any religious conviction, no matter how many times it’s proven that their initial assumptions fail close Biblical exegesis and examination, while the Church’s pass muster. Other Protestants are in whichever denomination they are because they have an intense love of Christ and feel that it’s the best place to express that love, or the place where they feel that love being nurtured the best. Still others (like members of any denomination) are lukewarm. I’ve met plenty of people in all three groups: the middle group I have a ton of respect for, even if we have some disagreements (plus, I don’t think any Catholic familiar with conversion stories will deny that God often uses Protestant denominations to nurture a love for Him and His teachings).

Neither. Protestants are “incomplete Catholics,” in our view. We agree on a lot of the big issues. There are some important ones which separate us, and the further one gets from the Reformation, the greater the issues (by that I mean, the Lutherans and Anglicans, first-generation reformers, have much more in combination than later splits, like Independent Baptists: there’s an unfortunate drift further and further away from the historic and living Church founded by Christ). So I think that there’s a need to correct faulty views of the Church, and to encourage them to come home, but it’s arguably not a conversion: a conversion suggests giving up your old beliefs and embracing new ones; this is a plea to direct your passion and zeal for Christ at the institution which He describes as His Body in Acts 9, and at the Eucharist which He describes as His Body in John 6, at the Last Supper, and in 1 Corinthians 11:23-27.

No one is too much of a sinner to become Catholic. We’re a hospital for sinners, not a museum of saints. And there will be some self-proclaimed Protestants entering Heaven ahead of some self-proclaimed Catholics.

Countless. I’m dating a Protestant “convert” to Catholicism (I use convert just b/c it’s the easiest term).

A close relationship with anyone of different religious persuasions can be really powerful or really destructive, and you should be careful about it. If you’re confused about your own faith, it’s probably a bad idea to develop a really close relationship with someone of a different faith who knows their faith really well (unless you’re willing to convert). On the other hand, if you know your faith really well and can defend it, befriending people of different religious persuasions can be an important part of evangelization, unless your friendship impedes you from speaking the truth to them. I’ve never heard anything from the Church against befriending Protestants.

We are, as long as it is within the Catholic Church, and we raise the kids Catholics. At least, those are the traditional two requirements - it’s possible they don’t exist anymore (I’m not positive).

Yeah. Northern Ireland doesn’t lack them. But in a lot of cases it’s for reasons which are more than just religious (like in N. Ireland), and culture plays a big part. In the US, I think there’s much less, because it’s a largely Protestant country - most of us live and work with Protestants on a daily basis.

Do you know any Catholics in London?
I don’t know any catholics in London… But I am a member of a Roman Catholic church - EVEN THOUGH I AM A PROTESTANT! 😃
God often uses Protestant denominations to nurture a love for Him and His teachings
YOU GOT THAT RIGHT, AND SOME TIMES MORE AND BETTER THAN THE CATHOLIC CHRUCH! 😉
 
I don’t choose my friends on the basis of religion. However, my closest friends are Catholics or Protestants who love God. I’d be happy if my Protestant friends would become Catholic (one did!) but they are already Christians and God will lead them where he wants them. I’ll answer any questions they have about the Catholic church. I don’t know any Catholics who hate Protestants; some of them used to be Protestants. I don’t hate Jews either, or Muslims but I’m somewhat suspicious of Muslims.
I am suspicious of muslims too… But no more than I am suspicious of the catholic chruch! 😃
 
There is at least one Methodist currently on CAF who is more “Catholic” than some of the Catholics here. She knows who she is and the great esteem in which I hold her.

I grew up in a 'mixed marriage". My paternal grandfather was a Catholic and married a German congregationalist protestant :bigyikes: in Catholic south Louisiana in the 1910s. To make it worse, my grandmother was divorced :bigyikes::bigyikes:!

My father and my mother could not be married on the altar in 1947. They were married in the sacristy. My father agreed to raise his kids Catholic and he did just that. He worked two jobs to put the three of us through Catholic school and it was he who got me up at 5:15 in the morning and took me to church so that I could serve all of those 6 am Masses in Latin when I was an altar boy.

What? Was I suppossed to hate my grandmother or my father? I don’t think so.

Come to south Louisiana, mon ami. We can show you how to co-exist. We know all about the Irish thing too. Our only problems are dealing with the Sassenach’s in those non-denominational churches. You know. The ones that live across the street from you and tell everyone in the community that because you burn votive candles with decals of a saint on them during hurricanes, you are witches. Has nothing to do with the fact that they burn forever and don’t go out during gusts of wind.
 
There is at least one Methodist currently on CAF who is more “Catholic” than some of the Catholics here. She knows who she is and the great esteem in which I hold her.

I grew up in a 'mixed marriage". My paternal grandfather was a Catholic and married a German congregationalist protestant :bigyikes: in Catholic south Louisiana in the 1910s. To make it worse, my grandmother was divorced :bigyikes::bigyikes:!

My father and my mother could not be married on the altar in 1947. They were married in the sacristy. My father agreed to raise his kids Catholic and he did just that. He worked two jobs to put the three of us through Catholic school and it was he who got me up at 5:15 in the morning and took me to church so that I could serve all of those 6 am Masses in Latin when I was an altar boy.

What? Was I suppossed to hate my grandmother or my father? I don’t think so.

Come to south Louisiana, mon ami. We can show you how to co-exist. We know all about the Irish thing too. Our only problems are dealing with the Sassenach’s in those non-denominational churches. You know. The ones that live across the street from you and tell everyone in the community that because you burn votive candles with decals of a saint on them during hurricanes, you are witches. Has nothing to do with the fact that they burn forever and don’t go out during gusts of wind.
What was that about lighting candels!?

I know that catholics are accused of goddess worship ( Hail Mary, holy queen ect.), and they are accuessed of worshipping statues of saints too! But being called a witch for lighting a candle?.. that’s crazy!

xxx zundrah xxx
 
http://www.monasteryicons.com/products/regular/727VC.jpg

These are rather on the more lurid style (at least for Our Lord) but we can buy in our local grocery stores candles with decals/icons of the saints on them. These candles burn during hurricanes when the power can go out for as much as two weeks at a time. They are much safer than hurricane lamps (which if knocked over can be a serious fire hazard). They are not blessed and if knocked over will only cause a wax spill.

My across the street neighbor is the pastor of a large non-denominational protestant church. I see the candles as strictly utilitarian. He sees them as “witchcraft”. No. I am not making it up. No. I am not exagerrating. He has railed against us from his pulpit. Word has gotten back to us. (DW teaches English at a local state university).

Kerosene hurricane lanterns are all well and good if you don’t have cats. The cats can knock over a seven day votive candle and all that will happen is a wax spill which can be easily cleaned up once it has cooled. No danger of fire. We have to watch our cats like a hawk with conventional hurricane lanterns. They knock one of those over and there could be a serious fire hazard very quickly.

So, can we say there is something extremely Pythonesque in this scenario? How about the 18" terra cotta statue of St. Francis we have in our garden? Do we worship that too or is it simply garden ornamentation?

Our children are now grown but ultimately we had to forbid them from playing with the pastor’s children across the street and with the Methodist missionary’s kids who came from South America each year to visit their grandparents a little down the road. The grandparents were the essence of Southern gentility - the kids anything but.

I did not raise my children to “hate” protestants but I did have an obligation to protect them from them.
 
I am suspicious of muslims too… But no more than I am suspicious of the catholic chruch! 😃
:eek:🤷

I’m glad my husband wasn’t too suspicious of me to marry me.

I have nothing against Protestants unless they are telling me that I’m going to hell. I tend to avoid the ones that would rather quote scripture at me than have a nice conversation.
 
I think Protestants are swell people, in general. Just as I find true with Catholics, there are some Protestants that I don’t necessarily get along with or agree with; especially those that do not have the same respect for me and my beliefs as I have for theirs.

I do have issues with Protestants who claim to be educated about the Catholic faith and yet are not, and who work to defame my Church or my beliefs. I have Protestant friends, but my closest friends and my husband are Catholics. Why? Because I attended Catholic grade school and high school and the majority of Christians in my town are Catholic.

Most of my good friends are people I’ve known since I was a tiny tot. I would not choose to marry a Protestant, and I would discourage my friends and family members from doing so. The reason I would do so is because I know from experience that marriage can be very difficult and have found great strength in the commonality of my husband’s faith. It is imperative to me that should I ever have children that they be raised as Catholics. A Catholic has a duty to do so and I don’t know how one is absolutely positively assured of this when marrying a non-Catholic. I’ve heard too many stories about disillusioned new parents whose spouses changed their minds after marriage.

As far as choosing to worship at a Protestant church on Sunday, I would not do so without also attending a Catholic Mass on Saturday evening or on Sunday and probably would have no reason to do so unless I were invited by one of my Protestant friends for a special occasion like a wedding or something. The best analogy that I could give you is that for me, a Catholic mass is like a 5 course meal of my very favorite foods. I leave satisfied and full, from a spiritual perspective. There could be nothing offered by another faith that could fill me any more. I have attended protestant worship services before (for the reasons listed above and also as part of world religion classes I took in College) and just felt completely empty afterwards. For me, the True Presence of the Eucharist is essential, and one can’t find it anywhere else!
 
:eek:🤷

I’m glad my husband wasn’t too suspicious of me to marry me.

I have nothing against Protestants unless they are telling me that I’m going to hell.
Oh redtech, did a protestant minister tell you that you were going to hell!? Can you tell me why?
I tend to avoid the ones that would rather quote scripture at me than have a nice conversation
Yes, unfortunately some protestants will try to get you to leave your faith of the communion of saints and the holy catholic chruch by restateing scripture that would prove your church wrong. Don’t listen to that rubbish… I can openly say that there is nothing wrong with the catholic church, their teachings or beliefs. Most protestants ( at least the ones I know from my methodist church ) would never try to misslead you or cause you to believe that their is anything wrong with being catholic! Contradictive you might say? He, he, he! 😃
 
:eek:🤷

I’m glad my husband wasn’t too suspicious of me to marry me.
Well… I mean that I am suspicious of the catholic chruch - not the people that go there but rather the people who work there… Can you understand that? Perhaps not… Some times I just find that some catholics are too religious and scaringly serious!!! 😊 …
 
http://www.monasteryicons.com/products/regular/727VC.jpg

Our children are now grown but ultimately we had to forbid them from playing with the pastor’s children across the street and with the Methodist missionary’s kids who came from South America each year to visit their grandparents a little down the road. The grandparents were the essence of Southern gentility - the kids anything but.

I did not raise my children to “hate” protestants but I did have an obligation to protect them from them.
Why would you stop your kids from playing with the methodist ministers kids!? I don’t understand that at all… Please explain that in more depth to me! I’m not in protest ( get it protest? 😃 “protestant” ) ahem… any way but why!? I don’t understand, did you maybe think that they would try to convert your kids and tell them that the catholic chruch is wrong? 🤷

xxx zundrah xxx
 
I think Protestants are swell people, in general. Just as I find true with Catholics, there are some Protestants that I don’t necessarily get along with or agree with; especially those that do not have the same respect for me and my beliefs as I have for theirs.

I do have issues with Protestants who claim to be educated about the Catholic faith and yet are not, and who work to defame my Church or my beliefs. I have Protestant friends, but my closest friends and my husband are Catholics. Why? Because I attended Catholic grade school and high school and the majority of Christians in my town are Catholic.

Most of my good friends are people I’ve known since I was a tiny tot. I would not choose to marry a Protestant, and I would discourage my friends and family members from doing so. The reason I would do so is because I know from experience that marriage can be very difficult and have found great strength in the commonality of my husband’s faith. It is imperative to me that should I ever have children that they be raised as Catholics. A Catholic has a duty to do so and I don’t know how one is absolutely positively assured of this when marrying a non-Catholic. I’ve heard too many stories about disillusioned new parents whose spouses changed their minds after marriage.

As far as choosing to worship at a Protestant church on Sunday, I would not do so without also attending a Catholic Mass on Saturday evening or on Sunday and probably would have no reason to do so unless I were invited by one of my Protestant friends for a special occasion like a wedding or something. The best analogy that I could give you is that for me, a Catholic mass is like a 5 course meal of my very favorite foods. I leave satisfied and full, from a spiritual perspective. There could be nothing offered by another faith that could fill me any more. I have attended protestant worship services before (for the reasons listed above and also as part of world religion classes I took in College) and just felt completely empty afterwards. For me, the True Presence of the Eucharist is essential, and one can’t find it anywhere else!
I like what you’ve said Chovy! And it makes complete sense to me! You are doing good to stay around catholic only’s! Also you are right again when you say that protestant and catholic marriage will go wrong at some point…
I have attended protestant worship services before (for the reasons listed above and also as part of world religion classes I took in College) and just felt completely empty afterwards.
Well if you came to my methodist church you would love it and you would feel so at home and welcome! 😃 I only wish that I could take you there! Not to convert you or anything like that! But just to show you that you can be fullfilled at protestant churches too! 😛
 
My denomination is Methodist. I think that is the most common protestant church isn’t it?
My mum is catholic because her whole family is Irish!

This is TRUE! I once spoke to my ministers about it! It must sound crazy to a catholic! 😃 But then again it sounds crazy to me too!

…personally I wouldn’t change my vote if I found out that the person I was voting for was catholic! I would change if they were mormon though! 😛

.

This is also true… gay people are still missionarys in protestant denominations but I’ve never heard of a married gay couple ordination though… But I don’t doubt it.

Birmingham is okay… though I don’t like their accents! 😉 …but I just have a normal London accent! …y’know, english and normal! 😃

I don’t know any other catholics other than my mum… 😦
I read your profile. Are you still a Methodist? Did your Catholic Mum ever raise you in her faith?

I did a quick check and there are, reportedly, between 20 to 40,000 Protestant denominations in the US. I don’t know if the Methodist is the largest but it is known by most Catholics as are Lutherans, Presbyterians, Episcopalians, Baptists, and the assorted Evangelists.

London is a big place. I’m sure your Mum’s family has many Catholic relatives. Have you been to Ireland?

Since JFK, attitudes have changed in the US. He broke the ceiling so to speak.
 
=aicirt;5414475]I read your profile. Are you still a Methodist? Did your Catholic Mum ever raise you in her faith?
I did a quick check and there are, reportedly, between 20 to 40,000 Protestant denominations in the US. I don’t know if the Methodist is the largest but it is known by most Catholics as are Lutherans, Presbyterians, Episcopalians, Baptists, and the assorted Evangelists.
Wow that is quite a lot isn’t it?
London is a big place. I’m sure your Mum’s family has many Catholic relatives. Have you been to Ireland?
She never raised me as a christian… only my beloved protestant methodist ministers did that for me! I was an athiest all my life until just one year and a half ago! Praised the lord! 😃
Since JFK, attitudes have changed in the US. He broke the ceiling so to speak.
I think that methodist is definately the most well known to catholics and the baptist denomination too!

…what does this mean???
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top