What do women think of potential spouse with health problems?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Madaglan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Madaglan

Guest
Hey, I’m just wondering what women think of potential spouses who have chronic health problems. Do women reject men as future spouses if they see that they have a health problem, even though he might be the sweetest guy in the world? I mean, let’s say that a guy has some bad asthma–would many women consider that as a major turn off for marrying a guy? What about back problems? Poor immune system? etc. Especially with Catholic women: do they see such men and have a natural inclination not to be near them? Is there some kind of Darwinian reaction?
 
If my husband (cradle Catholic) looked at me and decided not to marry me because of my health I’d be up the creek without a paddle.
My health is terrible, so I really wouldn’t have room to talk .
 
my boyfriend, who i plan on marrying, has many health problems: bad asthma, food allergies that cause his throat to swell shut, outdoor allergies that cause his body to swell up in the spring and force me to keep all the windows shut when he comes for visits, animal allergies (not to dogs though) so when we do marry i’ll have to leave my beloved kitties with my mom or brother, he has problems with swallowing food from time to time (it gets stuck in his throat and he starts to choke), he gets all kinds of body pains that leave him terribly uncomfortable not matter what he does, and he gets horribly worn out quickly.
but you know what? i love him with all my heart and he loves me just as much. he is the sweetest person i have ever met. he treats me like a queen and makes me completely happy. so if i could chose between someone who is perfectly healthy and treats me like ****, or my horribly unhealthy perfect boyfriend. i would chose him in a second, and i don’t mind having to give up some things i love to be with him.
 
40.png
Madaglan:
Hey, I’m just wondering what women think of potential spouses who have chronic health problems. Do women reject men as future spouses if they see that they have a health problem, even though he might be the sweetest guy in the world? I mean, let’s say that a guy has some bad asthma–would many women consider that as a major turn off for marrying a guy? What about back problems? Poor immune system? etc. Especially with Catholic women: do they see such men and have a natural inclination not to be near them? Is there some kind of Darwinian reaction?
Marriage is partly about the fitness of the father of your children. Some health problems are worse than others, and can be passed along with more drastic consequences. Sure, we’re all going to die some day but prudence should guide one into seriously deliberating about marrying a person with a known family history of severe diabetes, heart disease at a young age, certain forms of cancer, the male-linked genetic form of alcoholism, certain genetic diseases – i.e., crippling or life-limiting conditions for which there is little or no treatment.

Asthma, these days, is marvellously treatable. My spouse used to have frequent life-threatening attacks and use his machine 3 times a day. With newer medication, he has been almost completely asymptomatic for 5 years. As I said, some conditions have more severe consequences than others.

For example, if I knew my daughter were thinking of marrying somebody with a family history of von Hippel Lindau syndrome, I would urge genetic testing of that man and if he showed positive for the gene, I would do everything in my power to convince her not to marry him. It’s one thing to stick with a spouse “in sickness and in health,” but quite another to walk into a catastrophe with your eyes wide open and hold future generations hostage to it.

It has been shown that both men and women are attracted to people who are good looking and smart. Yeah, it’s a Darwinian thing.
 
Depends on the person…I guess.
Not only did I look very closely at my future spouse but extended family as well. I think obvious health problems would have made me think long and hard. Must be Darwin was correct…for me anyway.
 
Nope- not a consideration for me. I would have married my husband regardless of any health problems - I can’t imagine spending my life with anyone else. And I would not have used a health issues as a criteria when it came to dating, I’m more interested in the persons heart.

As a teen I used to wonder what guys would think of me. I have a huge scar down the front of my chest from open heart surgery I had as a child, and a pacemaker as well. I wondered if this would freak guys out. When I met my husband (when I was 16) he was completely unphased. In fact he found my pacemaker rather facinating. I showed him how if you patted over the spot where it was implanted my heart rate would go up. (It’s made to respond to movement.) Everyonce in a while he would lay his head on my chest and play around with it.

I asked my husband not too long ago about my scars ( have a couple more now -pacemaker implanted in a differant spot and also a c-section). He says he doesn’t even think about them.

I think it’s kind of pointless to try to limit your dating choices to only seemingly healthy people because health problems can develope at anytime. If someone doesn’t marry a certain person because they don’t want to deal with health problems - I would guess they shouldn’t marry at all.
 
I think entering a marriage with a man with severe health problems would depend on a lot of factors. Does his overall character and morals out weigh the fact that he has health problems? DOes the potential bride mind that she might have to adopt instead of being able to give birth to her own children? Will he be able to help with childcare or is he so physically incapacitated that this would be a problem? Does he handle his problems with a sense of humor or is he likely to sink into depression or lash out at those who love him?

I wouldn’t neccesarily say that no, that I wouldn’t marry such an individual but it would take more soul searching on my part. I would certainly care for my beloved husband if anything-GOd Forbid-happened to him, but I think that as a young woman, I was too immature and selfish to have taken on such a task.

I have to admit that given a choice, I would rather marry someone with a physical disability then someone with an out of control temper.
 
I guess it all depends on the woman in question. I look at women like Stephen Hawkings’ wife and have a tremendous amount of respect for her. Probably because I don’t think I would have the patience to start courting a handicapped man. However, if my boyfriend (who I intend on marrying) were to lose a leg, arm, nipple, finger…whatever, I would still love him and not leave him. Love can transcend many bridges and obstacles. DB has back and feet problems, but compared to other things, its skin on an apple.
 
ABSOLUTELY NOT! my husband is a type 1 completely insulin dependent diabetic and he is the absolute love of my life. when hes sick i care for him, just as he would care for me. its called your vows! in sickness AND in health. you dont love someone because its convenient. you love them because you love them. i had people telling me (some of this forum even) to be prepared to be widowed young, to hurry up and have kids before its too late. its sickening really. my husband cant control his illness, God gave it to him for a reason and he gave me him as a husband for a reason. im prepared for whatever may come. ive been with him in the hospital and emergency room 3 times in two years. but i also remember how he was with me after my surgery for endometriosis. youve never seen a man more loving and caring and nurturing. so i will always no matter what be there for him. through thick and thin. he may be struck blind, he may have to have amputations someday. its doesnt matter. hes the love of my life. hes my heart, theres nothing in the world i wouldnt do for him. i think any woman who wouldnt marry the man she loves just because hes sick is a coward and doesnt deserve that man anyway. sorry if i seem so heated about this. its something i deal with daily. God Bless.
 
My husband has chronic high blood pressure and severe heart arythmia caused by a rare kidney disease.

He didn’t tell me at first, for a long time, because he was afraid I would treat him different, worry about him all the time, consider him fragile. Well I do worry about him and nag at him to take his medicine, but only because I LOVE him!!!

I have to admit I was worried at first, worried about making him have a heart attack you know. My dad said he was worried about it too, didn’t want his daughter to become a “young widow” right after the honeymoon. But we were right for each other, and this is just one of those burdens the Lord put in our lives for now, and we handle it the best we can. Actually most of the time I think he does better than me lol!

But how bad would that be if you turned a guy down cause he was sick, and then the man you did marry became sick!! If you divorced him over it, you’d be a terrible person, and if you didn’t you’d be a hypocrite!!!
And I never for one second thought about not marrying him because of it!!!
 
40.png
mercygate:
Marriage is partly about the fitness of the father of your children. Some health problems are worse than others, and can be passed along with more drastic consequences. Sure, we’re all going to die some day but prudence should guide one into seriously deliberating about marrying a person with a known family history of severe diabetes, heart disease at a young age, certain forms of cancer, the male-linked genetic form of alcoholism, certain genetic diseases – i.e., crippling or life-limiting conditions for which there is little or no treatment.

Asthma, these days, is marvellously treatable. My spouse used to have frequent life-threatening attacks and use his machine 3 times a day. With newer medication, he has been almost completely asymptomatic for 5 years. As I said, some conditions have more severe consequences than others.

For example, if I knew my daughter were thinking of marrying somebody with a family history of von Hippel Lindau syndrome, I would urge genetic testing of that man and if he showed positive for the gene, I would do everything in my power to convince her not to marry him. It’s one thing to stick with a spouse “in sickness and in health,” but quite another to walk into a catastrophe with your eyes wide open and hold future generations hostage to it.

It has been shown that both men and women are attracted to people who are good looking and smart. Yeah, it’s a Darwinian thing.
i find this whole entire post just horribly horribly, sad and disheartening. sorry thats just my opinion. i love my husband, diabetes and all. i would love my children if they got the illness. its about love not convenience. not to offend you. its just my opinion.
 
Tar Ashely, what I find ironic about this person’s post is they have the word “Mercy” in their screen name. Their post is anything but!
 
40.png
TarAshly:
i find this whole entire post just horribly horribly, sad and disheartening. sorry thats just my opinion. i love my husband, diabetes and all. i would love my children if they got the illness. its about love not convenience. not to offend you. its just my opinion.
Understood are your feelings but when it comes to marriage all things can and should be taken into account. What you consider important might be different than what someone else thinks important. There is nothing wrong with weighing out what the future holds. AFTER the vows it is until death do you part.
 
Would take spouse with potential health problems over:

alcoholic
gambler
drug addict
porn looker
freeloader
liar
cheat
lazy person
grumpy all the time person
hot tempered person
swears in front of children person
doesn’t want children person
doesn’t believe in God person
mean to waitresses person
and someone who hates my dog.

All things considered, health problems really aren’t a big deal.
 

There is nothing wrong with weighing out what the future holds.​

One can never be sure of the future. Look at all those folks who mistakenly believed that where the Tsunami hit was a good place to vacation.
 
The man I loved most in this world, was the first man I could pray the Rosary with and also the Liturgy of the Hours.

Although his health issues were pretty heavy (he had everything from flat feet to high blood pressure and of course the meds for that would prevent him from having intercourse)
I loved him dearly and I still do.:love:

He also suffered TA which was a mini stroke. Still, to this day, had he asked me, I would have married him in a heart beat! I am praying to the Blessed Mother and to the Lord about this, but I’ve not heard anything as yet.

It is what’s on the inside that counts - not how well the human shell works.
Blessings,
Joanie
 
Thanks everyone for your responses! :yup:

I can understand that some health problems might be a problem: like chronic alcoholism, anger problem, etc. (if they can be considered health problems and not personality problems). What I was mostly meaning though were health problems that debilitate the man either morally, physically, or both (such as diabetes, back injuries/problems, battle wounds, structural/bone disorders, constant pain, etc.–basically those problems which are not fully the person’s fault but which are crosses that the person has to bear. I’m glad that most Catholic women here online say that such problems do not deter them from being the significant other of whom they love.

I mostly asked this question because I’ve had lots of chronic health problems much of my life, although nothing deathly serious, for which I am gracious. But my back problems oftentimes cause me constant pain, day and night, and I have trouble bending over and picking up things on the ground because it hurts my back too much. It has to do with a back disorder called Sherman’s Disease, and it’s chronic. I feel like a gimp with it, and every thirty seconds or so I have to noticeably twitch my back to try to loosen up the discomfort. I’m really self-consious when I do it in public. I’ve been to the doctors and everything, and I do my exercises, but I wonder if I’ll have this problem all my life; and I wonder what any future girlfriends might think of this back problem that causes me to noticeably squirm a lot. I guess for some reason I think they might see me as a worm or something 😦
 
I mean, I’m not trying to evoke pity or anything, but how do you think most girls would react to the twitching and so forth? :confused:
 
40.png
Madaglan:
I mean, I’m not trying to evoke pity or anything, but how do you think most girls would react to the twitching and so forth? :confused:
Are you worried about initial impressions? I can’t see someone not marrying someone over twitching.
Guys are more attracted by looks, where I think girls are more attracted by the type of personality a guy has. Not to say we don’t turn our heads at a cute guy, but a cute guy get’s ugly really fast when his personality is ugly. And an average guy (not saying your average) becomes much more attractive when his personality is attractive. What I’m saying is externals are not as important to women as they are to men -generally speaking. So if you’ve got a good personality you’ll find a good woman. 🙂

My husband has this thing where he jiggles his leg all the time, I mean constantly. And when he’s lying down he rubs his feet together -constantly. He even does it in his sleep. He’s done it as far back as he can remember. In the scheme of life squirming is low on the totem pole of concerning issues.
 
My husband was terrifically healthy when I married him, and still is, as far as I know. However, his wonderful father was diagnosed with prostate cancer at age 40 and died from the disease way too early. His maternal grandfather also had the disease and died early. I knew this when I married him and knew that the risk of him getting the disease and dying early was high. I married him anyway. I love him, he is the best man I have ever met. He is a wonderful father to our children and I cherish the time I have with him. I pray we will be spared this awful disease and early death, but I wouldn’t miss out on what we have because of it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top