What do you call her?

  • Thread starter Thread starter RCWarrior821
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

RCWarrior821

Guest
In the Gospel of Luke it is obvious that atleast some reverence should be shown to The Blessed Virgin Mary. Luke 1:48
Why don’t protestants call her blessed…It’s in the Bible! 🙂
 
Because Protestants do not acknowledge her. Even though to get to Jesus, she would be the surest bet ever.

To deny the Virgin Mary, is to deny Christ’s Divinity.
 
and i’m pretty sure Christ did not refuse to show honer to His mother…aren’t we suppose to imitate Christ?? hmmm…
 
and i’m pretty sure Christ did not refuse to show honer to His mother…aren’t we suppose to imitate Christ?? hmmm…
Good point RC, but believe me, they won’t look at it from our view, although it is SO clear.
 
Because Protestants do not acknowledge her. Even though to get to Jesus, she would be the surest bet ever.

To deny the Virgin Mary, is to deny Christ’s Divinity.
No Christians deny Mary or her virginity, she is the Mother of God. Protestants is such a bad term in trying to lump all beliefs together as if it was one group. I deny that Grace is more than Gods disposition to us, that it is accumulated in quantity.
 
In the Gospel of Luke it is obvious that atleast some reverence should be shown to The Blessed Virgin Mary. Luke 1:48
Why don’t protestants call her blessed…It’s in the Bible! 🙂
Ahem, raising my hand I call her BLESSED. She got the chance to bare Christ and raise Him. She spent every day with Him. She held Him in her arms as He grew. And she was a part of His ministry at it’s earliest stages. How could she not be blessed??? GOD CHOSE HER, when He had the choice of anyone.

Just because protestants go straight to Christ and don’t pray to her doesn’t mean they think she is nothing. I tire of these sweeping generalizations… :rolleyes:
40.png
RCWarrior821:
and i’m pretty sure Christ did not refuse to show honer to His mother…aren’t we suppose to imitate Christ?? hmmm…
Honor, what does it mean:

To show respect.

How do protestants not respect Mary if they choose to do what Christ said and go to God with their issues? I think that as long as we are going to Christ and to God like we are instructed, then Mary is a pretty happy lady. I don’t think she is offended at all. 😊
 
Because Protestants do not acknowledge her. Even though to get to Jesus, she would be the surest bet ever.

To deny the Virgin Mary, is to deny Christ’s Divinity.
There you go again, Righteousone. Book of Concord refers to her as the Blessed Virgin Mary. And we don’t deny her. You have seen Luther’s quotes here before, haven’t you? And you also know that many of us don’t view your veneration of the Blessed Virgin as idolatry. So put the broad brush away.

Love you, man. Sometimes I just love reading and responding to you. 😃 Not sarcasm, either.
 
Mary may not be offended, but her Son is.😦
I highly doubt it.

If we spat on her, kicked her, called her gruesome names… then maybe, but going straight to Him? Doubtful he is disappointed or offended by that… In fact, He encourages it…
Matthew 6:6:
But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen. Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you.
Matthew 6:9-15:
9"This, then, is how you should pray:
" 'Our Father in heaven,
hallowed be your name,
10your kingdom come,
your will be done
on earth as it is in heaven.
11Give us today our daily bread.
12Forgive us our debts,
as we also have forgiven our debtors.
13And lead us not into temptation,
but deliver us from the evil one.[a]’ 14For if you forgive men when they sin against you, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. 15But if you do not forgive men their sins,** your Father **will not forgive your sins.
Straight from Christ’s mouth. Pray to your Father in Heaven. That’s all I need to know…

Does this make Mary any less? No, what a wonderous thing she did to give birth to Him and go through that horrendous pain of losing Him on the cross. I just can’t imagine seeing my child (if I had one) in that situation and not be able to do anything about it…
 
You don’t find any more information on the Blessed Mother than what is in the gospels because the gospels were about Jesus. The stories of the annunciation and visitation for example were written to explain why Mary and Joseph had Jesus when they had not been married 9 months. The story of finding the boy Jesus in the temple was told to show how the Spirit of God was with Jesus even as a boy. The Story of the Wedding at Cana, the story of Jesus’ Mother and Brother’s waiting for Him outside, these were all stories about Jesus with Mary His Mother in them.

Through the centuries we have relied on Tradition to learn the lives of those who followed the teachings of Jesus. Tradition, not the Bible, tells us that the Blessed Mother lived with the Apostle John until the end of her life, around the age of 90, on a Greek Isle. These bits and peices of information about Holy People, are passed down like old family recipes. The Holy Spirit maintains the authenticity of these stories within the Catholic Church. In the fullness of time the Spirit moves the successor of Peter to put these traditions into formal doctrine.
 
she is the Mother of God.
tbuley

I may be wrong, but I have not met too many Protestants who would say this about Mary. I do believe it may have been a belief held by the reformers, but it seems to have died out over the centuries. Is this something which Protestants believe?

God bless
 
Yes this is something protestants believe in so much as Jesus is true God and true man, some might have a hard time getting there head around the fact she gave birth to her Creator.
 
Yes this is something protestants believe in so much as Jesus is true God and true man, some might have a hard time getting there head around the fact she gave birth to her Creator.
Even though there is no difference from Christ and God the Father I usually am more comfortable distiguishing Mother of God the Son as Mother of God indicates something MUCH greater. For she did not mother the trinity, but God the Son only.
 
Even though there is no difference from Christ and God the Father I usually am more comfortable distiguishing Mother of God the Son as Mother of God indicates something MUCH greater. For she did not mother the trinity, but God the Son only.
“as Mother of God indicates something MUCH greater.” can you clarify?

begotten of His Father before all worlds,
God of God, Light of Light,
very God of very God,
begotten, not made,
being of one substance with the Father,
by whom all things were made
 
Yes this is something protestants believe in so much as Jesus is true God and true man, some might have a hard time getting there head around the fact she gave birth to her Creator.
I have had debates with protestants who have denied that Mary is the mother of God. She was basically just a vesel. They also happened to say that she was just an ordinary woman who was no more virtuous than any other woman. But I reallize that many protestants do consider her the mother of God. To deny so would be to either say that Christ was God or it would be nestorianism.
 
In the Gospel of Luke it is obvious that atleast some reverence should be shown to The Blessed Virgin Mary. Luke 1:48
Why don’t protestants call her blessed…It’s in the Bible! 🙂
are you personally acquainted with every person who belongs to a Protestant denomination or self-identifies with that term? are you well versed in the teaching of every Protestant denomination (referring to those bodies who trace their origin to the Reformation) to the extent that you can without fear of contradiction declare that each and every one of them refuse to show reverence to the BVM and do not call her blessed? If you are not, I think you should tone down your deliberately provocative comment and limit your address to those who, in fact, show respect to the BVM. these generalizations, esp. the habit of using “Protestant” interchangeably with “non-Catholic” adds absolutely zilch to apologetics and evangelization efforts.
 
I have had debates with protestants who have denied that Mary is the mother of God. She was basically just a vesel. They also happened to say that she was just an ordinary woman who was no more virtuous than any other woman.
This is probably a way to be expedient at what ever point they are pushing, and a knee jerk reaction to what they perceive as idolatry. I think she is ordinary in that she is flesh descending of Adam a fallen man like the rest of us and that she doesn’t posses divine nature, I agree with Saint Augustine that man is like a beast between two riders, in that we have a “slave-will”. It is only of the power of God that she was saved.
 
This is probably a way to be expedient at what ever point they are pushing, and a knee jerk reaction to what they perceive as idolatry.
I too believe denying Mary as the Mother of God is a knee jerk reaction by non-Catholic Christians, but I am not sure if it is a knee jerk reaction to idolatry though. More of a knee jerk reaction towards any Catholic belief.

God bless
 
Oh in my time I’ve seen protestants get around the issue of denying Mary is the mother of God. They seperate Mary into “the Catholic Mary” and “the real(biblical) Mary”. This apparently gives them free reign to say whatever they wish because “it’s not the real Mary” at this point she is not only NOT the mother of God but she becomes everything from fictional to a demon to the whore of babylon.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top