What do you think about todays reading?

  • Thread starter Thread starter rcwitness
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

rcwitness

Guest
What do you guys think about a thread started every Sunday about the Gospel reading?

I have always wanted to have fellowship/study with what we are suppose to be focusing on in the calendar of readings. I’m just not sure if this is already done in some way and in some part of this forum…? Or is this forum not the best way to do that? I could see it being really cool, but maybe without a specific question its not what the forum is geared for…?

Thanks,
Michael
 
It sounds like a good idea.

You could list the reading with a few questions to kick off the discussion.

Pretty much anyone would jump in.
 
This has been done EXTENSIVELY by some people on this website and they seem to have become exhausted doing it.

They post SO MUCH commentary that they can get their hands on, that it’s almost impossible to digest.

There was also very little response, for the most part.

It’s been done both ways, of starting a new thread each week, and the other way, of putting week after week in the same thread – that gets busy quickly, and it’s hard to find the right entry point in the discussion.

Rather, what I’d like to see is a thread for each verse in the Bible (or perhaps each chunk of related verses), that anyone wanted to comment on or to research.

For example, Exodus 8:1 and following. God says that Moses is supposed to be “God” to Pharoah.

WOW. That’s packed with ideas. What is actually the best translation of that text? The Jewish Publication Society 1985 translation says that Moses is supposed to act the role of God to Pharoah – quickly deflecting the whole Christian nuance that God could be a man, or any such thing.

But, JPS gives a plausible explanation for God’s decree here. In the Egyptian mindset,
Pharoah was a god. So, here, Moses is given a temporary promotion, you might say, to at least act like God to Pharoah. Moses is a prophet (speaks for God) to begin with. But, by God’s decree, that’s not quite enough to convey what Moses’ mission was to Pharoah.

Interesting ideas, deep thoughts, about a verse (or verses) that someone might just gloss over, in their bible-in-a-year marathon.
 
This has been done EXTENSIVELY by some people on this website and they seem to have become exhausted doing it.

They post SO MUCH commentary that they can get their hands on, that it’s almost impossible to digest.

There was also very little response, for the most part.

It’s been done both ways, of starting a new thread each week, and the other way, of putting week after week in the same thread – that gets busy quickly, and it’s hard to find the right entry point in the discussion.

Rather, what I’d like to see is a thread for each verse in the Bible (or perhaps each chunk of related verses), that anyone wanted to comment on or to research.

For example, Exodus 8:1 and following. God says that Moses is supposed to be “God” to Pharoah.

WOW. That’s packed with ideas. What is actually the best translation of that text? The Jewish Publication Society 1985 translation says that Moses is supposed to act the role of God to Pharoah – quickly deflecting the whole Christian nuance that God could be a man, or any such thing.

But, JPS gives a plausible explanation for God’s decree here. In the Egyptian mindset,
Pharoah was a god. So, here, Moses is given a temporary promotion, you might say, to at least act like God to Pharoah. Moses is a prophet (speaks for God) to begin with. But, by God’s decree, that’s not quite enough to convey what Moses’ mission was to Pharoah.

Interesting ideas, deep thoughts, about a verse (or verses) that someone might just gloss over, in their bible-in-a-year marathon.
I post commentary with an apologetic bent- daily on my blog. And The Sacred Page posts commentary on every Sunday reading.

Instead of reinventing the wheel, you might want to join someone who is already doing that.
 
Instead of reinventing the wheel, you might want to join someone who is already doing that.
No way ! Its my bible!

Just kidding. I agree, just didnt find something. I’ll look into yours,
Thanks,
Michael
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top