What do you think of (Anglican) REV. S. BARING-GOULD Lives of the Saints?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Abba
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Abba

Guest
It’s available online from the Gutenberg Project:
gutenberg.org/files/46947/46947-h/46947-h.htm
I have no wish that my work should be regarded as intended to supplant that of Alban Butler. My line is somewhat different from his. He confined his attention to the historical outlines of the saintly lives, and he rarely filled them in with anecdote. Yet it is the little details of a man’s life that give it character, and impress themselves on the memory.** People forget the age and parentage of S. Gertrude, but they remember the mouse running up her staff**.
A priest of the Anglican Church, I have undertaken to write a book which I hope and trust will be welcome to Roman and Anglican Catholics, alike. It would have been unseemly to have carried prejudice, impertinent [Pg ix] to have obtruded sectarianism, into a work like this. I have been called to tread holy ground, and kneel in the midst of the great company of the blessed; and the only fitting attitude of the mind for such a place, and such society, is reverence. In reading the miracles recorded of the Saints, of which the number is infinite, the proper spirit to observe is, not doubt, but discrimination. Because much is certainly apocryphal in these accounts, we must not therefore reject what may be true. The present age, in its vehement naturalism, places itself, as it were, outside of the circle of spiritual phenomena, and is as likely to deny the supernatural agency in a marvel, as a mediæval was liable to attribute a natural phenomenon to spiritual causes. In such cases we must consider the evidence and its worth or worthlessness. It may be that, in God’s dealings with men, at a time when natural means of cure were unattainable, the supernatural should abound, but that when the science of medicine became perfected, and the natural was rendered available to all, the supernatural should, to some extent, at least, be withdrawn.
He seems to have done a good research and he provides details that did not fit in Butlet’s presentation of noting the parents etc…
 
He wrote “Onward Christian Soldiers” so can’t be all bad. 😃

Other than that, I do not recall having heard his name.

What do you think of him?
 
He wrote “Onward Christian Soldiers” so can’t be all bad. 😃

Other than that, I do not recall having heard his name.

What do you think of him?
Weeelll, since you asked…😃

I am considering on purchasing the 16 volumes (which would be the complete work of his Lives of the Saints) which is going for about $250 and then some. It looks interesting and I think I may find some pearls of wisdom and some nice treasures.

It is certainly a great endeavor and I like it that he seems to have researched much the same documents as Butler but has chosen to note little things that Butler did not. I understand the system Butler used was to note the date and town of birth, parent’s name and occupations etc. And, Baring Gould notes things Butler did not mentioned.

I would want to make sure that he really did researched the original documents etc… and that is why I wonder what people thought. He seems to have done so and is very humble about what appears to be a monumental task. If so, I wonder why it is not more known. Maybe, because not all the saints and martyrs he mentioned as Catholic? Yet, he invites Catholics and considers there should be no problem.

I would be interested in reading translations of all the actual documents we have on some of my favorite saints. They are for the most part available, like for; Saint Francis de Sales and Saint Anthony of Padua. But, it would be nice if someone would someday take the task of translating the complete works and references of each saint. 🙂

Yeah, so, Baring-Gould’s Lives of the Saints is available in Gutenberg.org but I don’t like to read volumes like that on line. I like to have them in my hands and skim the complete works etc…

He seems to focus on the saints and martyrs of Ireland, Scotland, England etc…
 
I have never heard of this particular author or his volumes on the saints, but I am intrigued.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top