What does pride mean-is it good or bad?

  • Thread starter Thread starter music2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

music2

Guest
I’ve heard my dad say he was ‘proud of himself’ for fixing something he wasn’t previously able to fix.
Is this considered “bad” in Catholicism?
Also,people say things like “im so proud of my child” “a proud new parent” “im proud of how you did at the audition” etc…

Are these types of “pride” bad or is the word “proud” used in different contexts and some are “bad” and some are ok/healthy?
What is the “bad” proud that Catholicism says is opposition to spiritual life?
 
No, of course your dad isn’t wrong for thinking that. Taking pride in what you do is fine. For example, I’m very good at chess. I’m proud that I’ve worked hard, studied the game, and practiced.

Now, in order for it to be wrong, is when you start thinking your a better PERSON because of your ability to play chess/fix cars/whatever. That is very wrong. When I beat someone in chess, or a person fixes a car with a difficult problem, they shouldn’t walk away saying they are a more moral person than someone who doesn’t have those skills, but they have every right to feel good and accomplished about what they have done.
 
I think we may be confusing boastfulness with the sin of Pride. Boasting, as Rascalking says, can be okay as long as it doesn’t go too far. I have great pride in my children and boast about their acheivments regulalrly. I don’t think this is bad. We’ve instilled a good work ethic and a desire to excel in all they do and it shows. Plus, I think its important for them to hear me baost about the esteem I have for them. I think it boosts their self-esteem and there’s pleanty of good evidence that people with better self-esteem tend to do better in life.

The sin of pride as I understand it has to do with thinking that you can solve your problems or acheive something without God. In other words, forgetting that all things through God. All for his glory.
 
I think we may be confusing boastfulness with the sin of Pride. Boasting, as Rascalking says, can be okay as long as it doesn’t go too far. I have great pride in my children and boast about their acheivments regulalrly. I don’t think this is bad. We’ve instilled a good work ethic and a desire to excel in all they do and it shows. Plus, I think its important for them to hear me baost about the esteem I have for them. I think it boosts their self-esteem and there’s pleanty of good evidence that people with better self-esteem tend to do better in life.

The sin of pride as I understand it has to do with thinking that you can solve your problems or acheive something without God. In other words, forgetting that all things through God. All for his glory.
Pride is not good when we do not give God the glory for our gifts of everything. When we
ourselves take credit for all that we do and are.

" There but for the grace of God go I" Peace, Carlan
 
Pride is not good when we do not give God the glory for our gifts of everything. When we
ourselves take credit for all that we do and are.

" There but for the grace of God go I" Peace, Carlan
Yes. I thought I made that point. Did you read something different in to my post?
 
I’ve heard my dad say he was ‘proud of himself’ for fixing something he wasn’t previously able to fix.
Is this considered “bad” in Catholicism?
Also,people say things like “im so proud of my child” “a proud new parent” “im proud of how you did at the audition” etc…

Are these types of “pride” bad or is the word “proud” used in different contexts and some are “bad” and some are ok/healthy?
What is the “bad” proud that Catholicism says is opposition to spiritual life?
the way we use “proud” in these examples is not what is the root of the deadly sin of pride. These are justifiable acknowledgements of human accomplishments.

Deadly pride is that offense against the 1st commandment, the sin of our first parents, which places our own will in place of God’s, when we take on ourselves the definition of right and wrong, disobeying his commandments, and make gods of ourselves.
 
Pride is not good when we do not give God the glory for our gifts of everything. When we
ourselves take credit for all that we do and are.

" There but for the grace of God go I" Peace, Carlan
I think though you are confusing boastfulness and the sin of Pride. They are two different things. I am not committing the sin of pride when I say, “I’m proud of my children, their acheivments, and the way that they comport themselves.” If I fail to recognize that it is through God’s providence that I and my wife have had the ability to teach them rightly so that they do well, I may be committing the sin of pride. If I fail to teach my children that all that they do and all that they accomplish is for God’s greater glory then, I may be committing the sin of pride. If I look at the challneges, fears, and disappointments that fill my life and look to myself for relief instead of putting it at God’s feet and trusting that he is working in my life for his own purpose and that that purpose is good, then I am certainly committing the sin of pride.
 
the way we use “proud” in these examples is not what is the root of the deadly sin of pride. These are justifiable acknowledgements of human accomplishments.

Deadly pride is that offense against the 1st commandment, the sin of our first parents, which places our own will in place of God’s, when we take on ourselves the definition of right and wrong, disobeying his commandments, and make gods of ourselves.
Nice puzzleannie. Very nice.
 
Hmm…thanks.I’m not sure if everyone is on the same page though as there seems to be conflicting theories.

In general,i don’t think he was boasting but was more saying that he was proud of an accomplishment he made regarding fixing some heater or something that he couldn’t fix before.
It made me uncomfortable cause of the “pride” word,so i was just like “oh thats nice” and changed the topic.
So i think theres still general confusion regarding the meaning of “pride” and if there ok pride and “bad” pride etc?
I wish the English language wouldn’t use the same words for so many different feeling states.
 
Hmm…thanks.I’m not sure if everyone is on the same page though as there seems to be conflicting theories.

In general,i don’t think he was boasting but was more saying that he was proud of an accomplishment he made regarding fixing some heater or something that he couldn’t fix before.
It made me uncomfortable cause of the “pride” word,so i was just like “oh thats nice” and changed the topic.
So i think theres still general confusion regarding the meaning of “pride” and if there ok pride and “bad” pride etc?
I wish the English language wouldn’t use the same words for so many different feeling states.
Why is pride a sin?

I think of pride as forgetting God as the source of accomplishment

I am not responsible for the grace I receive from God in my life, or the support I receive from others.

I think of sinful pride as that which exaggerates my role in my success, to the exclusion of the role of God and others. I am not the author of the majority of my good fortune or accomplishments.
 
Why is pride a sin?

I think of pride as forgetting God as the source of accomplishment

I am not responsible for the grace I receive from God in my life, or the support I receive from others.

I think of sinful pride as that which exaggerates my role in my success, to the exclusion of the role of God and others. I am not the author of the majority of my good fortune or accomplishments.
Do you mean sort of like when actors receive an award and in their speech they say “I thank God…” or am i misunderstanding?
 
Pride is not thanking God but puffing-out your chest at your accomplishments. Not being humble [it’s opposite]. Holding yourself in higher esteem than God.
 
I am not responsible for the grace I receive from God in my life, or the support I receive from others.

I think of sinful pride as that which exaggerates my role in my success, to the exclusion of the role of God and others. I am not the author of the majority of my good fortune or accomplishments.
You get all the grace you will need to defend the faith, and to live a godly life is given to you at confirmation. You are responsible to whether you use the grace God’s given or not. It’s how you use or fail to use all that since you have a choice you are responsible for it. God’s going to hold everybody accountable for that.
 
You get all the grace you will need to defend the faith, and to live a godly life is given to you at confirmation. You are responsible to whether you use the grace God’s given or not. It’s how you use or fail to use all that since you have a choice you are responsible for it. God’s going to hold everybody accountable for that.
Yes, Me1234. Peace, Carlan
 
Do you mean sort of like when actors receive an award and in their speech they say “I thank God…” or am i misunderstanding?
you are not misunderstanding, It is as Me1234 says in Post#13. Peace, Carlan
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top