What does this quote by Pope Benedict mean?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Monica4316
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Monica4316

Guest
I am talking to a sedevacantist person and he posted this quote by Pope Benedict… can someone explain to me, what it could mean? because it does seem like the Pope is saying there are different ways to salvation but we know this is not Catholic teaching 😦 or is this talking about invinsible ignorance? Someone please help me out cause this is confusing to me. There were also provided quotes about how a manifest heretic could no longer be Pope.
"“The question that really concerns us, the question that really oppresses us, is why it is necessary for us in particular to practice the Christian Faith in its totality; why, when there are so many other ways that lead to heaven and salvation, it should be required of us to bear day after day the whole burden of ecclesial dogmas and of the ecclesial ethos. And so we come again to the question: What exactly is Christian reality? What is the specific element in Christianity that not merely justifies it, but makes it compulsorily necessary for us? When we raise the question about the foundation and meaning of our Christian existence, there slips in a certain false hankering for the apparently more comfortable life of other people who are also going to heaven. We are too much like the laborers of the first hour in the parable of the workers in the vineyard (Mt. 20:1-16). Once they discovered that they could have earned their day’s pay of one denarius in a much easier way, they could not understand why they had had to labor the whole day. But what a strange attitude it is to find the duties of our Christian life unrewarding just because the denarius of salvation can be gained without them! It would seem that we – like the workers of the first hour – want to be paid not only with our own salvation, but more particularly with others’ lack of salvation. That is at once very human and profoundly un-Christian.”
(I think it’s from Co-Workers of the Truth, page 217)

Is this out of context perhaps??
 
I am talking to a sedevacantist person and he posted this quote by Pope Benedict… can someone explain to me, what it could mean? because it does seem like the Pope is saying there are different ways to salvation but we know this is not Catholic teaching 😦 or is this talking about invinsible ignorance? Someone please help me out cause this is confusing to me.

(I think it’s from Co-Workers of the Truth, page 217)

Is this out of context perhaps??
First of such would be from before he was Pope…

Secondly he is not I would think meaning that there are really “other ways” of salvation. He is using a way of speaking perhaps that is including what “some may think”…or speaking perhaps in that conversational -colloqual way.

In the document from the CDF (signed by him) such is made quite clear. Noting though that it is possible for those who are as you say “ignorant” etc to still be saved (though they are still saved by Jesus etc…)

as Vatican II teaches:

Second Vatican Council:

“Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, and, moved by grace, try in their actions to do his will as they know it through the dictates of their conscience – those too may achieve eternal salvation. Nor shall divine providence deny the assistance necessary for salvation to those who, without any fault of theirs, have not yet arrived at an explicit knowledge of God, and who, not without grace, strive to lead a good life. . . .” (Lumen Gentium 16)

…if they are saved in such a manner…they will be saved by Jesus Christ (and in a mysterious relation to the Church) …by grace …in ways we do not know or see…

but we still need to proclaim the Glad Tidings of Jesus Christ to all!! Such is the way…

Such is held quite firmly by Pope Benedict XVI
 
Thanks for the reply… I am not familiar with the CDF document, do you by any chance have a link to it? that would help a lot… or anything else where the Pope talks about the necessity of Christ for salvation.

I see about invinsible ignorance… but the person I am speaking to is saying the Pope supports having different religions, “unity in multiplicity”, that he prayed with Jews for the coming of their messiah, etc. Is this true??
 
Excerpt:

From the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith:

"He himself explicitly asserted the necessity of faith and baptism (cf. Mk 16:16; Jn 3:5), and thereby affirmed at the same time the necessity of the Church which men enter through baptism as through a door”.77 This doctrine must not be set against the universal salvific will of God (cf. 1 Tim 2:4); “it is necessary to keep these two truths together, namely, the real possibility of salvation in Christ for all mankind and the necessity of the Church for this salvation”.78

The Church is the “universal sacrament of salvation”,79 since, united always in a mysterious way to the Saviour Jesus Christ, her Head, and subordinated to him, she has, in God’s plan, an indispensable relationship with the salvation of every human being.80 For those who are not formally and visibly members of the Church, “salvation in Christ is accessible by virtue of a grace which, while having a mysterious relationship to the Church, does not make them formally part of the Church, but enlightens them in a way which is accommodated to their spiritual and material situation. This grace comes from Christ; it is the result of his sacrifice and is communicated by the Holy Spirit”;81 it has a relationship with the Church, which “according to the plan of the Father, has her origin in the mission of the Son and the Holy Spirit”.82
  1. With respect to the way in which the salvific grace of God — which is always given by means of Christ in the Spirit and has a mysterious relationship to the Church — comes to individual non-Christians, the Second Vatican Council limited itself to the statement that God bestows it “in ways known to himself”.83 "
…However, from what has been stated above about the mediation of Jesus Christ and the “unique and special relationship”84 which the Church has with the kingdom of God among men — which in substance is the universal kingdom of Christ the Saviour — it is clear that it would be contrary to the faith to consider the Church as one way of salvation alongside those constituted by the other religions, seen as complementary to the Church or substantially equivalent to her, even if these are said to be converging with the Church toward the eschatological kingdom of God."

…One understands then that, following the Lord’s command (cf. Mt 28:19-20) and as a requirement of her love for all people, the Church “proclaims and is in duty bound to proclaim without fail, Christ who is the way, the truth, and the life (Jn 14:6)."

The Sovereign Pontiff John Paul II, at the Audience of June 16, 2000, granted to the undersigned Cardinal Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, with sure knowledge and by his apostolic authority, ratified and confirmed this Declaration, adopted in Plenary Session and ordered its publication.

Rome, from the Offices of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, August 6, 2000, the Feast of the Transfiguration of the Lord.

Joseph Card. Ratzinger
Prefect
 
It seems like he’s simply trying not to be offensive to other’s beliefs. There are many religions whose people think will bring them to heaven. I think he’s just saying “if we have all these ways to go to heaven, why is Christianity the correct way?”.

I don’t think he’s admitting there are other paths, just asking a theoretical question in an inoffensive way.
 
Thanks for the info!

that helps to explain that the Pope doesn’t consider other religions paths to salvation. “it is clear that it would be contrary to the faith to consider the Church as one way of salvation alongside those constituted by the other religions, seen as complementary to the Church or substantially equivalent to her, even if these are said to be converging with the Church toward the eschatological kingdom of God.”

But the person I am speaking to is saying that the part about non Catholics being saved, is stretching invinsible ignorance - which originally was only intended for those who aren’t mentally able to understand the Gospel.

I feel all this is kind of over my head, I don’t know enough to figure out what to think
 
Also there’s the whole part about Pope Benedict being a heretic because he prayed with non Catholics. ???
 
As Jimmy Akin the Senior Apologist at Catholic Answers has noted regarding some who use such arguments: that they have…

"forgotten is that they are not the interpreters of previous papal statements; the Magisterium is, and their personal interpretations may not go against the authoritative teaching of the current Magisterium.

The idea that they can by private conscience interpret centuries-old papal decrees puts them in the same position as Protestants, interpreting centuries-old biblical documents. (He)… simply has a larger “Bible,” but the principle is the same: private interpretation rules! This completely defeats the purpose of having a Magisterium, which is to provide a contemporary source that can identify, clarify, and explain previous authoritative statements, whether from the Bible, Apostolic Tradition, or itself."

–Jimmy Akin
 
Anyone have a source of the quote? There seems to be thoughts missing that lead up to that which could well include invincible ignorance. Page 218 of this book preview is cut off for me, and I think that’s what gives the reference.
 
I am talking to a sedevacantist person and he posted this quote by Pope Benedict… can someone explain to me, what it could mean? because it does seem like the Pope is saying there are different ways to salvation but we know this is not Catholic teaching 😦 or is this talking about invinsible ignorance? Someone please help me out cause this is confusing to me. There were also provided quotes about how a manifest heretic could no longer be Pope.

"“The question that really concerns us, the question that really oppresses us, is why it is necessary for us in particular to practice the Christian Faith in its totality; why, when there are so many other ways that lead to heaven and salvation, it should be required of us to bear day after day the whole burden of ecclesial dogmas and of the ecclesial ethos. And so we come again to the question: What exactly is Christian reality? What is the specific element in Christianity that not merely justifies it, but makes it compulsorily necessary for us? When we raise the question about the foundation and meaning of our Christian existence, there slips in a certain false hankering for the apparently more comfortable life of other people who are also going to heaven. We are too much like the laborers of the first hour in the parable of the workers in the vineyard (Mt. 20:1-16). Once they discovered that they could have earned their day’s pay of one denarius in a much easier way, they could not understand why they had had to labor the whole day. But what a strange attitude it is to find the duties of our Christian life unrewarding just because the denarius of salvation can be gained without them! It would seem that we – like the workers of the first hour – want to be paid not only with our own salvation, but more particularly with others’ lack of salvation. That is at once very human and profoundly un-Christian.”

(I think it’s from Co-Workers of the Truth, page 217)

Is this out of context perhaps??
Seems to be musings and sort of thinking of things outloud. Now what did he say are the conclusions to all this 😉
 
First of such would be from before he was Pope…
I find it telling that sedevacantists who claim to be so because they adhere to traditional teaching of the Church suddenly become incapable of identifying what is or what isn’t an ex cathedra statement if it should suit the argument of sedevacantism.
 
As Jimmy Akin the Senior Apologist at Catholic Answers has noted regarding some who use such arguments: that they have…

"forgotten is that they are not the interpreters of previous papal statements; the Magisterium is, and their personal interpretations may not go against the authoritative teaching of the current Magisterium.

The idea that they can by private conscience interpret centuries-old papal decrees puts them in the same position as Protestants, interpreting centuries-old biblical documents. (He)… simply has a larger “Bible,” but the principle is the same: private interpretation rules! This completely defeats the purpose of having a Magisterium, which is to provide a contemporary source that can identify, clarify, and explain previous authoritative statements, whether from the Bible, Apostolic Tradition, or itself."

–Jimmy Akin
 
Here…this from BL. Pope John Paul II will help:

vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/audiences/alpha/data/aud19950531en.html

And know that arguing with them…may not get you very far.
thanks for the link… the person I am talking to disagrees that non Christians can be saved, he is saying that preVII no one taught this. I don’t even know.
As Jimmy Akin the Senior Apologist at Catholic Answers has noted regarding some who use such arguments: that they have…

"forgotten is that they are not the interpreters of previous papal statements; the Magisterium is, and their personal interpretations may not go against the authoritative teaching of the current Magisterium.

The idea that they can by private conscience interpret centuries-old papal decrees puts them in the same position as Protestants, interpreting centuries-old biblical documents. (He)… simply has a larger “Bible,” but the principle is the same: private interpretation rules! This completely defeats the purpose of having a Magisterium, which is to provide a contemporary source that can identify, clarify, and explain previous authoritative statements, whether from the Bible, Apostolic Tradition, or itself."

–Jimmy Akin
good point…
I find it telling that sedevacantists who claim to be so because they adhere to traditional teaching of the Church suddenly become incapable of identifying what is or what isn’t an ex cathedra statement if it should suit the argument of sedevacantism.
the person I’m talking to believes that it doesn’t have to be ex cathedra; if the Pope says a heresy in public he is a manifest heretic and outside the Church and no longer Pope; and he also says that VII can’t be a pastoral council it’s either false or infallible.
 
I guess the question is, DID the Church teach that non Christians can be potentially saved, before VII?? (I mean through invinsible ignorance). Does anyone know?

the person I’m talking to is saying you need to be visibly in the Church, and there is no such thing as invisible participation
 
“it is clear that it would be contrary to the faith to consider the Church as one way of salvation alongside those constituted by the other religions, seen as complementary to the Church or substantially equivalent to her, even if these are said to be converging with the Church toward the eschatological kingdom of God”

what does the last part mean? :confused:
 
I guess the question is, DID the Church teach that non Christians can be potentially saved, before VII?? (I mean through invinsible ignorance). Does anyone know?

the person I’m talking to is saying you need to be visibly in the Church, and there is no such thing as invisible participation
Yes. To the first.

The second part was condemned as an idea.
 
Seeking often to argue with a sedevacantist -that is a person who thinks there is no current Pope–

can often be similar to seeking to argue with someone who actually…thinks he is Pope…
 
There will be non-Catholics in heaven. Once you realize that, the pope’s quote is not confusing.

There could be people who are not catholic now, and convert later in life. These will be like the workers who were called to the vineyard for only an hour but got a full days wage.

There could be people who are not catholic nor convert to Catholicism but still make it to heaven. God’s mercy is endless. We can say who definitely IS in heaven (the saints) but we cannot say who is not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top