What does this saying by St Thomas Aquinas mean?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ResoluteSheep
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

ResoluteSheep

Guest
"“Venial sin becomes mortal sin when one approves it as an end”

Can anyone shed some light onto this? Does this mean any venial sin done for the sake of one self is mortally sinful?
 
“We might call sins excusable because they can be excused; in this sense Ambrose says repentance excuses every sin (and such excuse follows the sin). Or we can call sins excusable because something in them partially or totally allows them to be excused: partially as when they are committed out of ignorance or weakness (and such excuse lies in a sin’s cause), and wholly when they do not disrupt our relationship to our ultimate goal and so deserve only temporal and not eternal punishment.”

“Whenever the will sets itself an objective opposed to the love of charity that relates us to our ultimate goal (be it opposed to the love of God – like blasphemy or perjury – or to the love of our fellowmen – like murder and adultery) then the sin is fatal by nature. But when the immediate object of our will, though disordered, is not opposed to the love of God and fellowmen – as in frivolous chatter or immoderate laughter – such sins are non-fatal by nature. Sometimes it can happen that a sin non-fatal by nature because of its immediate objective is made fatal by the sinner choosing it as his ultimate goal or using it as a means to something fatal by nature.”

“A non-fatal sin like frivolous chatter can become fatal if we add to it disorder fatal by nature, directing it to illicit sex, for instance; but a fatal sin can’t become non-fatal by adding to it some non-fatal disorder: illicit sex isn’t less of a sin when indulged in for the sake of frivolous conversation!”

I admit, it’s really hard to digest everything that Aquinas says, but hopefully this helps you understand.
 
"“Venial sin becomes mortal sin when one approves it as an end”

Can anyone shed some light onto this? Does this mean any venial sin done for the sake of one self is mortally sinful?
If I know where Thomas said this, I could answer more fully, but it would appear that this probably means when you make the end of a venial sin your ultimate end, as Thom18 says, then the sin becomes mortal. That is because all mortal sins are those acts by which we make our ultimate end something other than God, who is our ultimate end.
 
Venial sin is so called from “venia” [pardon]. Consequently a sin may be called venial, first of all, because it has been pardoned: thus Ambrose says that “penance makes every sin venial”: and this is called venial “from the result.” Secondly, a sin is called venial because it does not contain anything either partially or totally, to prevent its being pardoned: partially, as when a sin contains something diminishing its guilt, e.g. a sin committed through weakness or ignorance: and this is called venial “from the cause”: totally, through not destroying the order to the last end, wherefore it deserves temporal, but not everlasting punishment. It is of this venial sin that we wish to speak now.

For as regards the first two, it is evident that they have no determinate genus: whereas venial sin, taken in the third sense, can have a determinate genus, so that one sin may be venial generically, and another generically mortal, according as the genus or species of an act is determined by its object. For, when the will is directed to a thing that is in itself contrary to charity, whereby man is directed to his last end, the sin is mortal by reason of its object. Consequently it is a mortal sin generically, whether it be contrary to the love of God, e.g. blasphemy, perjury, and the like, or against the love of one’s neighbor, e.g. murder, adultery, and such like: wherefore such sins are mortal by reason of their genus. Sometimes, however, the sinner’s will is directed to a thing containing a certain inordinateness, but which is not contrary to the love of God and one’s neighbor, e.g. an idle word, excessive laughter, and so forth: and such sins are venial by reason of their genus.

Nevertheless, since moral acts derive their character of goodness and malice, not only from their objects, but also from some disposition of the agent, as stated above (Question 18, Articles 4 and 6), it happens sometimes that a sin which is venial generically by reason of its object, becomes mortal on the part of the agent, either because he fixes his last end therein, or because he directs it to something that is a mortal sin in its own genus; for example, if a man direct an idle word to the commission of adultery. In like manner it may happen, on the part of the agent, that a sin generically mortal because venial, by reason of the act being imperfect, i.e. not deliberated by reason, which is the proper principle of an evil act, as we have said above in reference to sudden movements of unbelief.

newadvent.org/summa/2088.htm#article2

Christi pax.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top