What exactly is lust?

  • Thread starter Thread starter PureGrace
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

PureGrace

Guest
I am quite confused when it comes to lust.

I have read many many Church definitions of it, but I need some help in understanding what these definitions mean. I tend to be very scrupulous (sp?), and often find myself not going to communion because I am worried that I have lusted.

Please don’t just quote definitions of lust for me…I have seen most of them. I need an explanation…clarification.

Thanks,
Katherine Anne
 
The sin of lust (sexual lust) is willingly desiring/thinking about/fantasizing about sexual situations. That can be achieved through daydreaming, desiring an attractive person for reasons of their appearance, etc. Most sins of lust are venial and in no means require you to abstain from communion, unless you allow yourself to act on your lust and engage in other sinful acts.

Josh
 
That’s a good way of describing it.

I would add also that sexual attraction itself is not a sin. It only becomes the sin of lust when we willingly choose to entertain thoughts or act on the attraction. When one feels sexual attraction to one’s spouse and desires to love them in a unitive and procreative way, that is not a sin at all. In fact, that is exactly God’s design for sex and is very good. Real lust, however, puts personal pleasure above the good of the other and is purely selfish. Hope this helps.
 
That isn’t a very good definition at all because you havn’t specifically defined what loving them "in a procreative and unitive way " means, as in actual thoughts. Not very useful either, cause most peoples thoughts/feelings, about their spouses, exist somewhere inbetween (what you might call) lust and purity. I mean really, sexual attraction is ok, but your not allowed to be physically attracted to your wife? or at least not think about that (er, what?). Unity is ok, but you can’t do it for intimacy, cause your not allowed to have any wordly attachments - everything has to be done for worship… and you can’t be thinking about your spouse when your with your spouse, only the spiritual significance of it. Not much room to move there.
 
40.png
threej_lc:
The sin of lust (sexual lust) is willingly desiring/thinking about/fantasizing about sexual situations. That can be achieved through daydreaming, desiring an attractive person for reasons of their appearance, etc. Most sins of lust are venial and in no means require you to abstain from communion, unless you allow yourself to act on your lust and engage in other sinful acts.

Josh
This is highlighted part is actually incorrect. Let’s look at it objectively…

Mortal Sin Conditions:
  1. It must be a serious or grave matter.
  2. The one acting must clearly know it is a sin.
  3. The one acting must freely choose to commit the sin.
We know that lust itself is grave matter. It is the self-indulgent desire for something (or someone) that does not belong to you. Recall that Jesus said that if you look upon a woman with lust, you have already committed adultery/fornication.

Think of lust as an impure thought of another person (same or opposite sex) and it can even include an impure thought with yourself.

One has to know it is a sin to think impurely. It is not sinful for an impure thought to pop into your head. But, when looking back to self-analyze, you have to ask yourself if you knew the thought, word or act was sinful. In this case, we are talking about a thought. So the first one is related to the matter itself, the second point is related to your knowledge of the matter.

Lust, a capital sin, is grave matter and knowledge of it being grave matter are the first two components of mortal sin. The final point of reflection pertains to the will.

Once you are aware that you are in the midst of an impure thought you have two choices: “Change the subject” or continue to dwell. At this point it is very simple. If you choose to dwell in the impure thought, you are now committing a mortal sin. At this point, you are no longer free to receive Holy Communion. Please don’t confuse persistence in temptation with dwelling. If the impure thoughts keep popping in your head all day long and you work hard at “changing the subject” by getting into some other activity or going and talking to others to get your mind off of it, then it is not sinful. What is sinful is to wilfully engage in the thought for the sake of pleasure and an unwillingness to “change the subject”.

Also, if you dwell, you are now placing yourself in the “near occasion of sin” - something that is wise to confess regardless. You bring yourself to the brink of some other sin, such as masturbation (aka self-abuse). If you fall into this trap, know that it is also considered grave matter. If you then consent to this act, you have committed a secondary mortal sin. There are some circumstances that lessen the degree of severity of this mortal sin, such as maturity and habit, but these things never negate the need to work on stopping this habit.

Note the critical issue that it is easy to fall into a spin-off sin. That means in order to correct the secondary sin, you must first work on eliminating the primary one - or lustful thoughts. The same would apply to pornography as it too often leads to secondary sins.

When in doubt, discuss it with a confessor. However, do an honest self-assessment and ask yourself if you knew that you were in the midst of an impure thought. If you deliberately chose to continue dwelling, then you need to mention this to a confessor. Simply tell him that you continued to take pleasure in the impure thoughts AFTER you realized it was there and that it was sinful.

For more reading on issues of purity, read the FAQ’s from the Pure Love club:

pureloveclub.com/chastity/index.php?id=7
 
I think of it in a very simple way.

Lust is the intent to USE another for pursuit of pleasure.

Love is the desire to GIVE yourself to another as God has given Himself to us.

The “USE” and “GIFT” is obviously different in different relationships. This has different application between spouses than between a person and others. Still it contains truth in both instances.

This definition can be applied to other non-sexual things. If it is an intent to USE it is concupisence and sinful. This is why a man can commit adultery with his wife. (JPII said this). If he desires her primarily for his own pleasure and release, he is using her and this is adultery of the heart. As christians we should seek the good of others and not single-mindedly pursue our own pleasure.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top