What happened to mourning?

  • Thread starter Thread starter acadiANNA
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

acadiANNA

Guest
My mother would not allow me to attend the Senior Prom because we were in mourning for my grandmother. For a whole year, we did not listen to radio or watch TV, attend parties, weddings were only the church and not the reception, and anywhere else we would leave when music began to play. We could not wear red clothing and only natural makeup. The year was spent praying for the deceased. My aunts, uncles, cousins, it was 6 months. This is custom , not a church law. I did the same mourning for my parents and brother, but I did watch the local and national news. Does anyone still observe this?
 
I don’t know what happened to the custom. I have, of course, read about mourning but have never seen a family practice it.

I don’t think I could do it. When my mother died I was a wreck and needed anything cheery and good to keep me afloat. Weddings, dances, etc. reminded me that life went on and those who have left us want us to be of good cheer.
 
What culture is this sort of mourning associated with? I’m Irish and German so I know absolutely nothing about what you are describing. In my family, we always seemed to feel that the best way to acknowledge the passing of a loved one was to get sloshed with the extended family and show photo albums. And this is supposed to last for a year? Good luck with that if you have a large family! I know we lose at least one family member a year in our family. We’d be in a state of perpetual mourning!
 
I’ve from New Orleans and I’ve never heard of this custom. My Mom did tell me that they used to stay all night at the funeral home with the body. That is why we called it a wake instead of visitation. Was this a custom in your area of Louisiana or widespread?
 
I haven’t ever heard of the custom you are describing, but I wish there were more customs today to mourn.

In my personal experience it seems like the way to deal with a persons passing is by largely ignoring it and trying to just “move on” right away, and that doesn’t seem to go so well.
 
What culture is this sort of mourning associated with? I’m Irish and German so I know absolutely nothing about what you are describing. In my family, we always seemed to feel that the best way to acknowledge the passing of a loved one was to get sloshed with the extended family and show photo albums. And this is supposed to last for a year? Good luck with that if you have a large family! I know we lose at least one family member a year in our family. We’d be in a state of perpetual mourning!
I have heard people say that an Irish wake was more of a parity then a Polish wedding. Btw, I’m part Irish. 🙂
 
My grandmother used to wear black for an entire year whenever someone would pass away. Of course someone would be passing away all the time it seemed (didn’t necessarily have to be family), so she was almost always wearing black. That’s the extent of it that I’ve heard.
 
I’ve from New Orleans and I’ve never heard of this custom. My Mom did tell me that they used to stay all night at the funeral home with the body. That is why we called it a wake instead of visitation. Was this a custom in your area of Louisiana or widespread?
It’s also an old Irish custom coming from having the body (and wake) at home. In Louisiana it may have come from the French. Some of the ‘fancy’ funerals in New Orleans, they even have a band escort the body from the wake to the cumetery. 🙂
 
When my mother died I was a wreck and needed anything cheery and good to keep me afloat. Weddings, dances, etc. reminded me that life went on and those who have left us want us to be of good cheer.
👍

I suffered a tragic loss right before my 13th birthday. All I wanted was to go to school to make sure my friends were still there for me. My mom was shocked at that ‘ridiculous notion’ and forbid me to go to school. When my birthday came, I just wanted to have a party so I could see my friends because I needed to know life would go on. My mom’s exact words were ‘What will the neighbors think?’. It made the whole less much worse

Honestly, I don’t think anyone expects people to go around moping for a year just because they die. Our loves are hopefully in Heaven interceding for our happiness not wishing we are depressed.

On the other hand, when my uncle died, I went out and bought new clothes and wore them for 2-3 weeks and went I felt ready, I threw them away. I felt a need to mark the occasion and wearing drabby clothes was how I felt was appropriate for the situation. But that was a personal situation for the circumstances.

Grief is one of the most delicate subjects and there is no right way to do it

Angie
 
I have always had trouble dealing with death. One of my last acts upon leaving the Church during high school was to shirk my grandmother’s funeral by driving up north to go record shopping at my favorite store. That is a prime example of my priorities in those days and it is an act that I regret deeply. I had seen her in the hospital very frail and unwell and I just couldn’t deal with it anymore.

Back in the Church today as a practicing Catholic, I still have trouble relating and mustering sympathy. When someone close dies, I schedule a Mass intention for him/her and send a sympathy card to the family. No close family deaths in the past 10 years, thanks be to God. I fully expect to fall apart on the death of a parent, though…
 
I think it’s most important to have a plan for mourning. The actual details of what the plan are may not be as important as just having a plan.
 
Some of the more traditional / devout members of my former husband’s family would observe a year of mourning. They are of the Jewish faith. This is the only example with which I have knowledge.
 
I have always had trouble dealing with death. One of my last acts upon leaving the Church during high school was to shirk my grandmother’s funeral by driving up north to go record shopping at my favorite store. That is a prime example of my priorities in those days and it is an act that I regret deeply. I had seen her in the hospital very frail and unwell and I just couldn’t deal with it anymore.

Back in the Church today as a practicing Catholic, I still have trouble relating and mustering sympathy. When someone close dies, I schedule a Mass intention for him/her and send a sympathy card to the family. No close family deaths in the past 10 years, thanks be to God. I fully expect to fall apart on the death of a parent, though…
You should not regret it. Every death is unique, and the survivors deal with it in different ways.

When a friend’s father passed on after a lingering illness, he and his folks coped by watching football together.

I, myself, have never regretted not attending a funeral. I do regret having gone to wakes, however, because my last memory of the person became a memory of a dead face and hands.

ICXC NIKA
 
I think that mourning (wearing black for a year, avoiding parties, dancing, music, etc.) is one of those traditions that just doesn’t fit into modern American life.

Mourning was often powered by the women of the family, because they determined the “social activities” of the family and children. Nowadays, so many women work, and many jobs would not allow a woman or man to wear deep black for a year. Also, at the workplac,e there is often music, a party for someone, food, etc., and to avoid these activities would be seen as “not being a team player.”

Also, children’s activities today are often of the team-type (sports, choirs, bands, clubs, scouting, etc.), and children can’t just “skip them” for a year. Schools, both private and public, have "happy’ activities. In many schools, children would not be allowed to wear black.

However, the wearing of deep black does continue in today’s culture–the “goths” wear black and glorify “death” in their lifestyles, music, etc.

It is my opinion that Christians in the year 2013 in the United States need to strike a balance between mourning and grieving for loved ones who have passed on, and not giving too much due and honor to “death.” We live in a “culture of death,” and we need to do what we can to be part of a “culture of life.” Our loved ones in Christ who have died have the hope of glory. Yes, we miss them (my dad died less than a year ago, and I miss him everyday), but as someone else said, life continues here on earth. We must live the life of Christ in front of others, and that means joy in the midst of our sorrow.
 
When my grandparents died, the TV went off limits for some time. Nothing approaching a year, though.

A sibling picked up the practice when the FIL passed.

I believe that mourning enforced upon others is more likely to generate conflict than to achieve anything good. Children, especially, will see it as punishment, at a time when they are already traumatized by being in a hectic environment full of grieving adults.

Grief is individual; let everybody deal with it the way they know how. IMNAAHO.

ICXC NIKA
 
Just as grief is a very personal experience unique to every indivdual maybe so also expressions of mourning should be tailored to our own needs and desires. Rather than being something forced on anyone, it can be an opportunity of self expression.
 
My personal custom is to attend the prayers and the funeral, and to remember the person in photos and by having Masses said for them.

But life does have to go on, and unless you are independently wealthy with a house full of servants, you have to get on with making a living and looking after yourself - I don’t think most people can afford a year off from their life every time someone dies.
 
What culture is this sort of mourning associated with?
It used to be American, tho the Protestants didn’t pray for the dead. I first came across this custom in Eight Cousins by Louisa Alcott.
 
BTW, they called it a “wake” in the past for a reason. Medically, someone may appear to be dead while, in the absence of modern diagnostics, still being barely alive; so the body was laid out for a time to assure that they were not going to wake up, before burying them.

Someone had to stand watch over the body in case they did wake up; today, however, diagnostic technology has made all of that unnecessary.

Q: How is an Irish wedding different from an Irish wake?

A: There is one less drunk at the wake.
 
I have heard people say that an Irish wake was more of a parity then a Polish wedding. Btw, I’m part Irish. 🙂
Lucky you! I’m a good old fashioned American mutt with no irish in me 😦

I actually like the Irish wake. When I die I want people to have a few drinks, eat some tasty grub, talk and laugh about things that happened in my life and not mourn but hold me in their hearts.
It’s also an old Irish custom coming from having the body (and wake) at home. In Louisiana it may have come from the French. Some of the ‘fancy’ funerals in New Orleans, they even have a band escort the body from the wake to the cumetery. 🙂
My mothers friends family are of French descent. The grandparents refuse to speak English although they have been in the US since they were young and they insist everyone be bilingual as well as learn the old customs.

When my mom died the friend and her family moved like a well ordered drill team. While we were still shocked (she was 44) and making calls to notify friends and family that lot was arriving with tables, chairs, food, and liquor. Bless them, they really helped us through. Lot to be said for some of those old customs.

It was the day before my 21st birthday. I’ll never forget that I had my first legal drink at my moms wake.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top