E
EphelDuath
Guest
I’ve given up snacks, and cigarettes.
Just answer the question without your analyzing it…there are **many **non-Catholics who do not do Lent. If you don’t know this, try and do some research.Are you saying you know 8 Protestants? Do you know their denomination(s)?
The question remains: why did you post the thread here if your assumption is that non-RCC don’t do Lent? Why not put it in the obvious forums it would belong in like Spirituality?
Wow, you pray the Divine Mercy chaplet? This is shaking up my preconceived ideas of what liberals are likeI gave up soda,** added the Chaplet of the Divine Mercy to my daily devotions**, added readings from Rumi, and a book on Contemplation by a OSA monk. I’m also attending a day of silence at our church on Saturday and weekly hour sessions with a speaker on each Sunday morning before services.
Yes many non-Catholics now participate in this pious Catholic tradition. However many can’t explain why or where it comes from. This is from the St. Andrew Missal…When I was Episcopalian we observed Lent. My Lutheran in-laws do, too. It’s a liturgical Christian thing, not just a Catholic thing.
This Lent we are abstaining from sound: TV, radio, CDs, DVDs, etc. We might actually learn to talk to each other in the evening instead of sitting with glazed eyes on the tube.
Of course, we’re recording American Idol–gotta save that for our Sunday treat. :dancing:
Protestants do not do Lent. At least not the 8 ones that I know. They simply feel that it is a “Catholic” thing…still baffled??![]()
Which is it? Protestants don’t do Lent? Many non-Catholics do not do Lent?Just answer the question without your analyzing it…there are **many **non-Catholics who do not do Lent. If you don’t know this, try and do some research.
Exactly…and these are ALL Protestant sects…Which is it? Protestants don’t do Lent? Many non-Catholics do not do Lent?
Some research indicates the following:
The following denominations/communions have liturgies for, and recognize, the Lenten season:
Plus, any tradition that uses the Common Lectionary will necessarily “do” Lent, since the readings coincide with the Catholic lectionary.
- United Methodists, AME, AME Zion, and CME
- The Presbyterian Church
- The Lutheran Churches, both ELCA and Missouri Synod
- The Anglican Communion, including the Episcopal Church in the USA
- The Christian Church (Disciples of Christ)
- The United Church of Christ
My research consisted of pulling the books of worships and hymnals from the above traditions off of my office shelf and looking them up. Also, many local communities around here celebrate daily community Holy Week services, that include local Catholic parishes.
But…Exactly…and these are ALL Protestant sects…
Some do, most don’t. Lent has been observed in the early church by Catholics.But…
I thought (see your post #6 in this thread), that Protestants don’t do Lent.
GKC
True enough.Some do, most don’t. Lent has been observed in the early church by Catholics.
Complaining.What Have You Given Up For Lent?
And God Bless you.True enough.
It seems that your posts frequently require a little explanation, amendment, or qualification, particularly when they contain sweeping generalizations.
GKC
There are 70 million Anglicans, and around 70 million members of the World Methodist Council. I don’t know the numbers for Lutherans and Presbyterians.Some do, most don’t. Lent has been observed in the early church by Catholics.
Many thanks and Dominus tecum. I’ll continue to provide the requisite emendations.And God Bless you.
Like I said, the early church which observed Lent were Catholics. Case closed. There are many sects that do not observe Lent.There are 70 million Anglicans, and around 70 million members of the World Methodist Council. I don’t know the numbers for Lutherans and Presbyterians.
I’d need to see your research that “most [Protestants] don’t” observe Lent.![]()
I was simply responding to the first two posts you made.Like I said, the early church which observed Lent were Catholics. Case closed. There are many sects that do not observe Lent.
I decided to attend Mass every day at 9:00 because I think it is a wonderful way to start the day, and my Lenten Journey.
I don’t think the Good Lord cares if I give up my M&M’s…
I try to do what might be pleasing to God. What have you given up? Are there any non-Catholics who observe the Lenten season? Do you know how Lent started and what it means? Thanks.
If you want to “close the case” that is certainly your right. I guess my question would be, why did you ask questions if you didn’t want the answers? I could be wrong, but this sounds like a Strawman.Protestants do not do Lent. At least not the 8 ones that I know. They simply feel that it is a “Catholic” thing…still baffled??![]()
I did very early on. I didn’t understand your reply that you knew 8 Protestants. You’re the one who asked if any Protestants who did Lent? That prompted my question why you put this thread on this forum if you didn’t think there were any. You said you knew 8 Protestants and they didn’t. You continue to avoid answering. I seems more like you just assumed we didn’t, and wanted to teach us.Just answer the question without your analyzing it…there are **many **non-Catholics who do not do Lent. If you don’t know this, try and do some research.