What if all religions are work of Satan?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bahman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
There is an assumption here that God is good which is part of religion teaching. What if God is evil?
What if good is bad and bad is good? That’s the same as saying that G-d is evil. In Judaism, HaSatan is not thought of as evil either: he is not the adversary of G-d and there is no duality between the forces of evil as represented by Satan and the forces of good as represented by G-d. Rather, Satan is an angel, not a fallen angel, in the service of G-d, a clever tempter who is sent to earth by G-d to severely test our free will in order that we might choose good over evil. Satan is also our accuser in the heavenly tribunal so that we might better defend our earthly lives before G-d.
 
What if good is bad and bad is good? That’s the same as saying that G-d is evil. In Judaism, HaSatan is not thought of as evil either: he is not the adversary of G-d and there is no duality between the forces of evil as represented by Satan and the forces of good as represented by G-d. Rather, Satan is an angel, not a fallen angel, in the service of G-d, a clever tempter who is sent to earth by G-d to severely test our free will in order that we might choose good over evil. Satan is also our accuser in the heavenly tribunal so that we might better defend our earthly lives before G-d.
Hi Meltzerboy. While Christians do not see Satan as a rival of God (that is, as an opposite evil force), it is interesting that the Jewish faith (according to one website) understands him as an angel “with a dirty job” to do (beingjewish.com/basics/satan.html), basically being God’s tempter on earth and not a fallen angel.

This is interesting because the idea of Satan as a devil comes from the lips of Jesus from the earliest sources, and I wonder if there was such a development in Second Temple Judaism. Furthermore, theologically, it seems to suggest that God directly tempts us and consequently causes (or contributes significantly) to sin rather than simply allows it to happen.

Would love to hear your thoughts.
 
Here is your answer.

All religions are not the work of satan.

If you believe they are, then you believe in God who created satan.
This doesn’t follow from previous premise. We can imagine a world with Satan but not God.
Who would not allow all religions to be the work of satan.

I hope that answers your question.
The conclusion doesn’t follow. Please read previous comment.
 
Your premise is also contingent upon your understanding of Satan in the Biblical sense that he is evil. If the Bible didn’t come from God, why would you assume that their was actually a being named Satan, who was bad, and that we got the Bible from and wanted us confused? The source you seem to be using for your premise of understanding of satan comes from the very bible in question.

The premise immediately falls apart at every conceivable logical angle
You are making a big assumption that Bible is from God. This is the main topic of this thread which claim that all religions are work of Satan.
 
What if good is bad and bad is good? That’s the same as saying that G-d is evil.
That depends on how do you define bad and evil.
In Judaism, HaSatan is not thought of as evil either: he is not the adversary of G-d and there is no duality between the forces of evil as represented by Satan and the forces of good as represented by G-d. Rather, Satan is an angel, not a fallen angel, in the service of G-d, a clever tempter who is sent to earth by G-d to severely test our free will in order that we might choose good over evil. Satan is also our accuser in the heavenly tribunal so that we might better defend our earthly lives before G-d.
Interesting so there is a conflict of idea of what Satan is in Christianity and Judaism.
 
That is correct which means that Satan was interacting with other people as he does now.

What do you mean?
Hi Bahman, what I mean is if our information about Satan comes from the Judeo-Christian religious tradition and one argues that this religious tradition is itself a product of satanic influence or trickery, then how can we trust what it says about Satan in the first place.
 
Hi Bahman, what I mean is if our information about Satan comes from the Judeo-Christian religious tradition and one argues that this religious tradition is itself a product of satanic influence or trickery, then how can we trust what it says about Satan in the first place.
That is true.
 
Im not sure on the answer to the OPs question, but I do think its important to remember, at some point, Satan is going to try to deceive us, and Im going to bet, HOW he goes about this will not be something easily spotted, he is MUCH more intelligent than any of us, he knows the right way to deceive us, as to have us all arguing what is deception and what is not.

Just look at many current topics, that very thing is happening right now within the CC.
 
What if good is bad and bad is good? That’s the same as saying that G-d is evil. In Judaism, HaSatan is not thought of as evil either: he is not the adversary of G-d and there is no duality between the forces of evil as represented by Satan and the forces of good as represented by G-d. Rather, Satan is an angel, not a fallen angel, in the service of G-d, a clever tempter who is sent to earth by G-d to severely test our free will in order that we might choose good over evil. Satan is also our accuser in the heavenly tribunal so that we might better defend our earthly lives before G-d.
Meltzerboy, you continue to impress me with the merits of Judaism.

It is fascinating that one of the central tenets of Christianity, the whole idea of “believing in one God”, is so frequently violated (but violation is vehemently denied), . Many, many, Christians believe in two gods, though they claim obedience to only one of them.

As the OP implies a second power, many, if not most Christians say that there is a second power, which makes Christianity much closer to Zoroastrianism than Judaism.

The gospel leaves the question of dualism unanswered in any explicit way. Jesus calls for forgiveness, which if enacted erases all dualism.

A second power capable of “works” in this world? That’s called dualism, right? Now, the way I look at it, there is a place for dualism, but there is a way to see beyond it.

So “religion the work of satan?”. Nope, it is more like “the depiction of satan is the work of religion.”

🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top