T
Trebor135
Guest
The following is inspired by this and this thread:
When I’ve thought about the Christian faith and prayed as of late, it keeps occurring to me that I may just be wasting my time–God isn’t hearing my requests for help if heaven isn’t really there, and Sts. Mary and Joseph can’t hear my requests for their prayers because they’ve passed on a really long time ago.
For a while I’ve been going back and forth between Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy, and I’m not really making a lot of progress in figuring out which one I should be. After all, members of this forum have gone both from Catholicism to (Eastern/Oriental) Orthodoxy and from (Eastern/Oriental) Orthodoxy to Catholicism. If either is the “one true church”, why is it so common for thoughtful, sincere, intelligent, discerning Christians to come to different conclusions? Why did God allow the Great Schism to happen, no healing realistically in sight, and thereby force people to have to choose between the two even though it isn’t obvious at all now which path to take? Isn’t this kind of cruel, given that eternal souls ostensibly hang in the balance?
Plus, agnostics/atheists and nominal Christians around me seem to be pretty fulfilled and upright without following any religion with dedication. Why should I be Christian simply because it’s the only thing that will ultimately keep me content? Wanting something bigger and better outside of oneself to believe in is such a pleasant notion, but what if it’s all a scam? Why did Jesus have to live in first-century Palestine, with no printing press, let alone video cameras or Facebook, to record his words and deeds and those of his disciples in a timely, thorough, and unquestionably credible manner? What if neither Catholicism nor Eastern Orthodoxy are the “one true church” after all? If life means, as Jean-Paul Sartre would have us believe, whatever we want it to, wouldn’t that make things easier? So many fewer “obligations” to fulfill. One could eat, drink, and be merry, or work hard in whatever fields of interest catch one’s fancy. But no need to go to Mass and beat back distracting thoughts. No need to accept difficult propositions like the violence in the Old Testament being directly ordered by the God of the New Testament and the impermissibility of divorce and remarriage in nearly all circumstances.
If God is really up there and Christ started the Catholic Church, why didn’t they engineer the Bible and history in such a way as to point to these facts with such blatantly obvious clarity that only a fool would refuse to heed them?
What is going on? What if Jean-Paul Sartre and, despite his irritating style, Richard Dawkins are right? Why keep living in a nice dream world where some Palestinian Jewish guy many, many centuries ago was supposed to be God incarnate and was crucified, died, was buried, and rose again, all after being born of a perpetual virgin named Mary who was spared from all sin (a favour strangely not granted to the rest of us) and assumed into heaven with little literary evidence of the belief in the early centuries of Christianity?
My faith is faltering, but I’ll ask for your prayers anyway. I see the complete disjunction between the two just as you do, but humour me
If you want to reply to the content of this post, feel free to PM me.
When I’ve thought about the Christian faith and prayed as of late, it keeps occurring to me that I may just be wasting my time–God isn’t hearing my requests for help if heaven isn’t really there, and Sts. Mary and Joseph can’t hear my requests for their prayers because they’ve passed on a really long time ago.
For a while I’ve been going back and forth between Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy, and I’m not really making a lot of progress in figuring out which one I should be. After all, members of this forum have gone both from Catholicism to (Eastern/Oriental) Orthodoxy and from (Eastern/Oriental) Orthodoxy to Catholicism. If either is the “one true church”, why is it so common for thoughtful, sincere, intelligent, discerning Christians to come to different conclusions? Why did God allow the Great Schism to happen, no healing realistically in sight, and thereby force people to have to choose between the two even though it isn’t obvious at all now which path to take? Isn’t this kind of cruel, given that eternal souls ostensibly hang in the balance?
Plus, agnostics/atheists and nominal Christians around me seem to be pretty fulfilled and upright without following any religion with dedication. Why should I be Christian simply because it’s the only thing that will ultimately keep me content? Wanting something bigger and better outside of oneself to believe in is such a pleasant notion, but what if it’s all a scam? Why did Jesus have to live in first-century Palestine, with no printing press, let alone video cameras or Facebook, to record his words and deeds and those of his disciples in a timely, thorough, and unquestionably credible manner? What if neither Catholicism nor Eastern Orthodoxy are the “one true church” after all? If life means, as Jean-Paul Sartre would have us believe, whatever we want it to, wouldn’t that make things easier? So many fewer “obligations” to fulfill. One could eat, drink, and be merry, or work hard in whatever fields of interest catch one’s fancy. But no need to go to Mass and beat back distracting thoughts. No need to accept difficult propositions like the violence in the Old Testament being directly ordered by the God of the New Testament and the impermissibility of divorce and remarriage in nearly all circumstances.
If God is really up there and Christ started the Catholic Church, why didn’t they engineer the Bible and history in such a way as to point to these facts with such blatantly obvious clarity that only a fool would refuse to heed them?
What is going on? What if Jean-Paul Sartre and, despite his irritating style, Richard Dawkins are right? Why keep living in a nice dream world where some Palestinian Jewish guy many, many centuries ago was supposed to be God incarnate and was crucified, died, was buried, and rose again, all after being born of a perpetual virgin named Mary who was spared from all sin (a favour strangely not granted to the rest of us) and assumed into heaven with little literary evidence of the belief in the early centuries of Christianity?
My faith is faltering, but I’ll ask for your prayers anyway. I see the complete disjunction between the two just as you do, but humour me