What if it's all a fraud?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Trebor135
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Trebor135

Guest
The following is inspired by this and this thread:

When I’ve thought about the Christian faith and prayed as of late, it keeps occurring to me that I may just be wasting my time–God isn’t hearing my requests for help if heaven isn’t really there, and Sts. Mary and Joseph can’t hear my requests for their prayers because they’ve passed on a really long time ago.

For a while I’ve been going back and forth between Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy, and I’m not really making a lot of progress in figuring out which one I should be. After all, members of this forum have gone both from Catholicism to (Eastern/Oriental) Orthodoxy and from (Eastern/Oriental) Orthodoxy to Catholicism. If either is the “one true church”, why is it so common for thoughtful, sincere, intelligent, discerning Christians to come to different conclusions? Why did God allow the Great Schism to happen, no healing realistically in sight, and thereby force people to have to choose between the two even though it isn’t obvious at all now which path to take? Isn’t this kind of cruel, given that eternal souls ostensibly hang in the balance?

Plus, agnostics/atheists and nominal Christians around me seem to be pretty fulfilled and upright without following any religion with dedication. Why should I be Christian simply because it’s the only thing that will ultimately keep me content? Wanting something bigger and better outside of oneself to believe in is such a pleasant notion, but what if it’s all a scam? Why did Jesus have to live in first-century Palestine, with no printing press, let alone video cameras or Facebook, to record his words and deeds and those of his disciples in a timely, thorough, and unquestionably credible manner? What if neither Catholicism nor Eastern Orthodoxy are the “one true church” after all? If life means, as Jean-Paul Sartre would have us believe, whatever we want it to, wouldn’t that make things easier? So many fewer “obligations” to fulfill. One could eat, drink, and be merry, or work hard in whatever fields of interest catch one’s fancy. But no need to go to Mass and beat back distracting thoughts. No need to accept difficult propositions like the violence in the Old Testament being directly ordered by the God of the New Testament and the impermissibility of divorce and remarriage in nearly all circumstances.

If God is really up there and Christ started the Catholic Church, why didn’t they engineer the Bible and history in such a way as to point to these facts with such blatantly obvious clarity that only a fool would refuse to heed them?

What is going on? What if Jean-Paul Sartre and, despite his irritating style, Richard Dawkins are right? Why keep living in a nice dream world where some Palestinian Jewish guy many, many centuries ago was supposed to be God incarnate and was crucified, died, was buried, and rose again, all after being born of a perpetual virgin named Mary who was spared from all sin (a favour strangely not granted to the rest of us) and assumed into heaven with little literary evidence of the belief in the early centuries of Christianity?

My faith is faltering, but I’ll ask for your prayers anyway. I see the complete disjunction between the two just as you do, but humour me 😛 If you want to reply to the content of this post, feel free to PM me.
 
I’ve had similar thoughts, but I circle back eventually.

Now, come on, can you really imagine an audio/visual recording of Jesus? That would be ridiculous. Keep in mind that this life is a test. For Him to have become incarnate when technology was booming would not have fit into the history of mankind rightly. It is most definitely a test a faith. And I think it’s beautiful. We have His words; they are the most difficult to read passively and brush aside as some hoax. I believe His timing was perfect.

So who made up the fraudulent religion and for what purpose? Why did the followers of Jesus die for Him, and why do we have evidence of this outside of the Bible?

Overall, I found this to be an extremely depressing post. I myself doubt my faith often, but it truly is the Catholic Church that holds me in place. I am sure that if I had been exposed to Protestantism as opposed to Catholicism, I would have already tossed religion aside.

But I could never cease to believe in God. I always remained strong with that conviction, before I knew anything about Christ and the Bible in general. Truth is eternal. The “white light” is impossible to ignore.

I would love to start up a conversation with you, especially because we could probably help each other out as well as intellectually relate with one another. I hope you don’t lose your faith. I’ll be praying for us both!

P.S.
Everybody (oh, generalizations) hates Catholics and hardly anyone really pays attention to Orthodoxy (at least from what I’ve noticed). I’ve always found this compelling. Blessed are those who are persecuted! Basically, what I’m trying to say is that we’re harder to ignore. Amidst moral relativism, the Catholic Church fights back more strongly than anyone.
 
For me, when I doubt, I consider that I am a dramatically better person now due to Christianity. Even if it’s false, it’s been the best self-help, character-improvement course I’ve ever taken 😃
 
I am reminded of a debate I read between a priest and an atheist.

The priest finished the debate by saying “If I am wrong, I have lost nothing. If you are wrong, you have lost everything”.
 
First…don’t feel like the “lone ranger”…you are not alone.

Second, you must remember that all of your prayers are the result of a grace from God…you say that there is no answer…so you pray again…well guess what…God has answered your very first prayer…he is telling you that he wants you to keep praying…so he gives you the grace to pray again…and again…AND AGAIN! Like Saint Monica prayed for 20+ years for St. Augustine’s conversion. This is so very critical…all goodness comes from God’s grace…praying to God is a great “goodness”…a goodness that can only be generated by/in his grace…so the grace to pray…to even think about praying is all from him.

Third…from the** Catechism**
Prayer as God’s gift
2559 "Prayer is the raising of one’s mind and heart to God or the requesting of good things from God."2 But when we pray, do we speak from the height of our pride and will, or “out of the depths” of a humble and contrite heart?3 He who humbles himself will be exalted;4 humility is the foundation of prayer**, Only when we humbly acknowledge that "we do not know how to pray as we ought,"5 are we ready to receive freely the gift of prayer**. "Man is a beggar before God."6
2560 "If you knew** the gift of God**!"7 The wonder of prayer is revealed beside the well where we come seeking water: there, Christ comes to meet every human being. It is he who first seeks us and asks us for a drink. Jesus thirsts; his asking arises from the depths of God’s desire for us. Whether we realize it or not, prayer is the encounter of God’s thirst with ours. God thirsts that we may thirst for him.8
2561 "You would have asked him, and he would have given you living water."9** Paradoxically** our prayer of petition is a response to the plea of the living God: "They have forsaken me, the fountain of living waters, and hewn out cisterns for themselves, broken cisterns that can hold no water!"10** Prayer is the response of faith to the free promise of salvation and also a response of love to the thirst of the only Son of God.**11
Pax Christi
 
Trebor, the short answer to your question is this.

If religion is a fraud, then the life you’re living now is almost certainly the only life you’re going to get. And that’s not a horrible thing.
 
Trebor, the short answer to your question is this.

If religion is a fraud, then the life you’re living now is almost certainly the only life you’re going to get. And that’s not a horrible thing.
Would you keep writing an exam knowing of the distinct possibility that not only was there no proctor to tell you when to put down your pen, but no professor to mark your work, and no university to give you written proof certifying the quality results of your efforts for potential and future employers?
 
First…don’t feel like the “lone ranger”…you are not alone.
Unfortunately–for all others in this situation–this is true.
Second, you must remember that all of your prayers are the result of a grace from God…you say that there is no answer…so you pray again…well guess what…God has answered your very first prayer…he is telling you that he wants you to keep praying…so he gives you the grace to pray again…and again…AND AGAIN!
A seemingly endless cycle that leads at the time to confusion and perplexity? When if I had been able to figure out whether to be Catholic or Eastern Orthodox months ago, this would most likely not be happening?
Like Saint Monica prayed for 20+ years for St. Augustine’s conversion. This is so very critical…all goodness comes from God’s grace…praying to God is a great “goodness”…a goodness that can only be generated by/in his grace…so the grace to pray…to even think about praying is all from him.
St. Monica is an interesting case, on account of which I’m not simply able to dismiss the rest of what you say here. But…
Third…from the** Catechism**
[omitted for the sake of brevity/concision]
The skeptical part of me responds that my prayers originate from psychological factors. “I’ve been doing this frequently for some years already, so why stop now?” “I don’t have a roommate, so I can at least talk to someone about whatever is on my mind, not just revealing the superficial observations/stories/troubles of daily life.”
 
I am reminded of a debate I read between a priest and an atheist.

The priest finished the debate by saying “If I am wrong, I have lost nothing. If you are wrong, you have lost everything”.
But why hang your hat, with a whole life’s work in view, on such a clever–though true–line? If God is really up there, and Christ was who the Gospels claim him to be, why isn’t it more obvious?

“You’ll see in the end how wrong you were!” isn’t a very convincing argument. If a hardline Baptist warned me of the danger in which I was putting myself by looking into two supposed “false religions of men” which purportedly teach sacramental “works-righteousness”, I might pause for a moment and wonder about the truth of his claims, but would then recall that history is on the side of the Scripture+Tradition+Church and grace-conveyed-through-matter camp (technically, all three of their subdivisions), and laughingly discard all he said as the ravings of an uninformed, myopic ignoramus. I would ultimately have little concern for his previous fire-and-brimstone perrorations because I would know how absurd and vaccuous his whole case was.
 
For me, when I doubt, I consider that I am a dramatically better person now due to Christianity. Even if it’s false, it’s been the best self-help, character-improvement course I’ve ever taken 😃
True. 🙂 But I’m sure one could obtain similar results out of Buddhism, which calls for detachment from the world, or even Islam, if love for God can–despite the inherent flaws of the religion–be made to trump fear of him.

I haven’t become acquainted with any Buddhists in my life, but none of the Muslims I’ve known seemed to suffer from scrupulosity despite the “follow the rules (or pay for it eternally) without the benefit of a close personal relationship with the old man upstairs” style of their faith.
 
I didn’t PM you because I’m lazy? Lol
Haha, the original post seems to have sparked a discussion that should probably be moved from the Prayer Intentions forum. Depending on what the moderators do with this thread, I’ll PM you or reply here.
 
Would you keep writing an exam knowing of the distinct possibility that not only was there no proctor to tell you when to put down your pen, but no professor to mark your work, and no university to give you written proof certifying the quality results of your efforts for potential and future employers?
No, I wouldn’t.
 
No, I wouldn’t.
Well, then why bother pursuing anything in life? If “eat, drink, and be merry” keeps you content, why not go buy as much steak, Greek salad, butter chicken, and kimchi as you want, drink wine and rum to your heart’s content, and party till the sun comes up (winning over some beautiful young girls along the way) once or twice a week while holding down a decent office job and paying little heed to family and friends? 😛

And if you go bankrupt or lose immediate family in a car accident, why keep living? Ultimately, why shouldn’t one conclude that suicide would seem the best path to putting a permanent end to the misery caused by these irreversible events?
 
Well, then why bother pursuing anything in life? If “eat, drink, and be merry” keeps you content, why not go buy as much steak, Greek salad, butter chicken, and kimchi as you want, drink wine and rum to your heart’s content, and party till the sun comes up (winning over some beautiful young girls along the way) once or twice a week while holding down a decent office job and paying little heed to family and friends? 😛

And if you go bankrupt or lose immediate family in a car accident, why keep living? Ultimately, why shouldn’t one conclude that suicide would seem the best path to putting a permanent end to the misery caused by these irreversible events?
This is a false choice. It’s not one of utter piety where all is left to God on one hand vs. one of utter hedonism and bereft of any meaning on the other.

You mentioned in your OP that you know of agnostics and atheists who seem pretty fulfilled and upright despite their unbelief. So I return the question to you - how DO they seem to manage this? Is it all for show? Are they all only masking utter misery and emotional chaos under their seemingly normal, happy lives?

Even if we acknowledge that you need to believe in God to have any meaning in life, or basis for doing right and wrong (I don’t concede either point, fyi), then to me, it only restates the issue - if they can find a way to be happy without God, irrational as though that idea may be, there’s no reason that you can’t too.

How one can find meaning in life without involving the supernatural is, of course, a reasonable question. But I think it would do you well to truly acknowledge that such an idea is possible in the first place.
 
I have a couple of examples I would like to share with you.

1.My previous parish priest told us all many times during his homilies that it is quite normal for us all to feel doubts from time to time.It is good when these times happen to pray about things ‘talk’ to God and investigate through the bible if we have questions we need to have answered.It is also good to discuss with your priest if you feel comfortable doing that and this site CAF can be very helpful.So I guess you are doing the right thigns already!

2.Albert Camus a French author, journalist, and key philosopher of the 20th century. He was noted for his beliefs most especially for ‘Absurdism’.

While writing his thesis on Plotinus and Saint Augustine of Hippo, Camus became very strongly influenced by their works, especially that of St. Augustine. In his work, Confessions (consisting of 13 books), Augustine promotes the idea of a connection between God and the rest of the world. Camus identified with the idea that a personal experience could become a reference point for his philosophical and literary writings. Although he considered himself an atheist, Camus later came to tout the idea that the absence of religious belief can simultaneously be accompanied by a longing for “salvation and meaning”. This line of thinking presented an ostensible paradox and became a major thread in defining the idea of absurdism in Camus’ writings.

He once said …

“I would rather live my life as if there is a God and die to find out there isn’t, than live my life as if there isn’t and die to find out there is.”

I thought this a very interesting quote from an atheist that he thought it better to live as if there is God than live with the consequences of there not.

I shall pray for you to find your faith in God once again.God bless you

Lord, I believe:
I wish to believe in Thee.
Lord, let my faith be full and unreserved,
and let it penetrate my thought,
my way of judging Divine things and human things.
Lord, let my faith be joyful
and give peace and gladness to my spirit,
and dispose it for prayer with God
and conversation with men,
so that the inner bliss of its fortunate possession
may shine forth in sacred and secular conversation.
Lord, let my faith be humble and not presume
to be based on the experience of my thought and of my
feeling;
but let it surrender to the testimony of the Holy Spirit.

Amen.
 
Trebor, you seem very confused as once was. Instead of jumbling all your doubts together, though, you should work on them one at a time. The most fundamental question is atheism vs. belief in God. I highly recommend you read “The Case for a Creator” by Lee Strobel for that. Once I was finished with this book, I came to the conclusion that Richard Dawkins and his ilk are not just wrong but irrational.
 
Trebor, you seem very confused as once was.
Haha, well, at least I’m not the only one to have been in that situation.
Instead of jumbling all your doubts together, though, you should work on them one at a time. The most fundamental question is atheism vs. belief in God. I highly recommend you read “The Case for a Creator” by Lee Strobel for that. Once I was finished with this book, I came to the conclusion that Richard Dawkins and his ilk are not just wrong but irrational.
Thanks for the book recommendation. 🙂 I’m not so impressed with Lee Strobel, given that he looked into the early days of Christianity and, as I’ve read, is… some kind of Evangelical Protestant. :confused:

I’m basically out of my semi-agnostic phase now, after gobbling up some of the work available at the Christian ThinkTank (run by another Evangelical Protestant, oddly enough), seeing God at work in my life, and hearing about him at work in that of a friend.

I appreciate your concern over my onetime state of confusion–God bless.
 
By the way just to return to your original question and add a little persepctive…

so what if it is all a fraud?

What have you lost? Nothing

What if you turn away from God and it is all true?

You lose nothing by praying and striving to have faith whereas you lose everything if you turn away and it is all true.

God bless
 
By the way just to return to your original question and add a little persepctive…

so what if it is all a fraud?

What have you lost? Nothing

What if you turn away from God and it is all true?

You lose nothing by praying and striving to have faith whereas you lose everything if you turn away and it is all true.

God bless
To Pascal’s Wager shall we always return… 🤷

But you’re right.

And for me Christianity is the most plausible religion out there.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top