FrmrTrad:
Do you think that there is one theological truth, and that different theologies are ‘best efforts’ to reflect or grasp it?
It’s OK, you are very intelligent. It is clear that you know a great deal of Eastern theology and I respect that. I am no expert, being rather knew to it myself, but I have adopted it as my own.
Yes, I do believe there is only one Objective Truth.
I have this analogy (but it’s a poor one) I’d like to share. I went digging for an old letter I sent to someone and happily I recovered it. I am a printer by trade, and color has played a large part in my working life, so it may mean less to others than to me:
**If I place an orange color swatch next to a peach color swatch, you’d think that the peach color was pink. If you place a pink color swatch next to a peach color swatch you’d think the peach was orange! In other words, your way of decribing the peach color would be informed by what you have to compare it to. In a sense, both (calling the peach color either
pink or
orange) might be good, although slightly innacurate ways of describing the same color to someone.
On the other hand both descriptions would actually be inadequate! Peach is peach and calling it orange can be a problem to someone who sees pink. Theology is like that too, God is bigger than all of us and everything everywhere, our little pea brains cannot take it all in, that’s why the East and West can have different ways of decribing the same idea, and often they will talk right passed each other! Should I condemn their best attempt to explain a mystery? No!**
Eastern theology is not as precisely detailed as the Western, there isn’t much anyone can do about it. If Mary’s “Yes” has saved us, the best we can do is say “Yippee!”, “Yahoo!” or the all time favorite “Alleluia!!”. The precise mechanism God employs to bring this about may not be well understood.
So I would say that there are a lot of areas where the theology will seem vague to people who are looking for, or accustomed to a lot more detail.
+T+