What if Vatican II is false?

  • Thread starter Thread starter McatholicN
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

McatholicN

Guest
This has been bugging me. I’ve been worried about whether Vatican II was false or not. (It wasn’t infallible right?) Wasn’t it Pope Paul VI who, when referring to Vatican II, said that the smoke of Satan had entered the Church? (Not totally sure about that one.)
If it isn’t, I would be committing mortal sin by attending the Novus Ordo mass. I’d like to get into the whole sedevacantism thing, but I’ve heard that’s forbidden here.

Anyway, could someone provide some conclusive evidence that Vatican II was valid?
 
Vatican II was a validly convened council so it can’t be “false”.

There can be debate about some of the documents produced by the council but the council itself is a valid council.
 
Vatican II was a validly convened council so it can’t be “false”.

There can be debate about some of the documents produced by the council but the council itself is a valid council.
Is that to say “Novus Ordo” could be false?
 
This has been bugging me. I’ve been worried about whether Vatican II was false or not.
Define what you mean by “false.”
(It wasn’t infallible right?)
Every ecumenical council is infallible when defining doctrine. Vatican II did not issue doctrinal statements.
Wasn’t it Pope Paul VI who, when referring to Vatican II, said that the smoke of Satan had entered the Church? (Not totally sure about that one.)
No.
If it isn’t, I would be committing mortal sin by attending the Novus Ordo mass.
(a) Vatican II did not create the New Order Mass.

(b) The Mass is not doctrinal, therefore it is changeable.

(c) The Pope has authority to change the Mass, therefore you cannot be in mortal sin by attending it.
Anyway, could someone provide some conclusive evidence that Vatican II was valid?
What do you believe to be adequate “evidence” and how do you define “validity”?
 
Is that to say “Novus Ordo” could be false?
No, see what 1ke said. The Missal of 1968 is what is commonly referred to as the Novus Ordo. The missal is not a document of VII. VII did call for a review of the liturgy and that has been done many times in the Church’s history. To call VII into question for doing so is to cast doubt on the whole idea of valid Church councils.
 
This has been bugging me. I’ve been worried about whether Vatican II was false or not. (It wasn’t infallible right?) Wasn’t it Pope Paul VI who, when referring to Vatican II, said that the smoke of Satan had entered the Church? (Not totally sure about that one.)
If it isn’t, I would be committing mortal sin by attending the Novus Ordo mass. I’d like to get into the whole sedevacantism thing, but I’ve heard that’s forbidden here.

Anyway, could someone provide some conclusive evidence that Vatican II was valid?
Pardon me, but whatever came to you to come to this thought that you are questioning the validity of VII? It seems to me the devil is planting these thoughts in you.

i think you are familiar with Gospel verses on the keys and bind and lose, the guidance of the HS…put your trust in the Lord that His divine guidance was present when Paul VI called for VII, that whatever came out of VII had divine blessing, otherwise, the devil would have prevailed on Christ’s Church, and thus making Jesus a liar, which I think you do not believe so.
 
How do we know that there is a God? How do we know that Catholicism is the right religion?

I think it boils down to a leap of faith. Do you put your faith in the church, or not? If you do, you accept (you don’t have to like) their leadership. If you don’t, you declare your not Catholic, and move on.

I really think it’s just a matter of faith, pure and simple. You either have it or you don’t. And not just faith that God exists-but faith that Christianity is the right path, and Catholicism is the most direct route.
 
At every council in history there have been lots of folks who called it an invalid council, or an heretical council, or any number of other things. At many of the early councils like Nicea, the majority of the bishops rejected them completely. That does not make them right. It is the blessing of the See of Peter that gives an Ecumenical Council its authority, now the same as at any other point in history. I believe it was Bl. Pope John XXIII who called Vatican II, and his successor called it to a close. So, certainly the council was valid.
 
Pope Pius V in Quo Primo declared

“We order and enjoin that nothing must be added to Our recently published Missal, nothing omitted from it, nor anything whatsoever be changed within it.No one whosoever is permitted to alter this notice of Our permission, statute, ordinance, command, precept, grant, indult, declaration, will, decree, and prohibition. Should anyone dare to contravene it, let him know that he will incur the wrath of Almighty God and of the Blessed Apostles Peter and Paul”

It makes one wonder how this could be THE Mass of the Catholic Church with Pius declaring God’s wrath on anyone who messed with it or replaced it, etc. and yet that is exactly what happened with Vatican II. The Novus Ordo turned into the new regular Mass and Tridentine took a back seat and in most areas disappeared altogether…

I wonder what Pius would make of Vatican II 😊

Some posters have said that the Mass can be changed by future Popes. It sure didn’t seem like Pius thought so! 😛
 
Pope Pius V in Quo Primo declared

“We order and enjoin that nothing must be added to Our recently published Missal, nothing omitted from it, nor anything whatsoever be changed within it.No one whosoever is permitted to alter this notice of Our permission, statute, ordinance, command, precept, grant, indult, declaration, will, decree, and prohibition. Should anyone dare to contravene it, let him know that he will incur the wrath of Almighty God and of the Blessed Apostles Peter and Paul”

It makes one wonder how this could be THE Mass of the Catholic Church with Pius declaring God’s wrath on anyone who messed with it or replaced it, etc. and yet that is exactly what happened with Vatican II. The Novus Ordo turned into the new regular Mass and Tridentine took a back seat and in most areas disappeared altogether…

I wonder what Pius would make of Vatican II 😊

Some posters have said that the Mass can be changed by future Popes. It sure didn’t seem like Pius thought so! 😛
The form of the Mass is a discipline and most certainly can be changed by any Pope. A Pope (no matter how strongly he feels about a particular matter) cannot bind a future Pope in matters of discipline. Whether anyone feels changes have been for the better or worse is irrelvant to the fact that changes are permitted.
The only part of a Mass which cannot be changed are the words of consecration.
 
Some posters have said that the Mass can be changed by future Popes. It sure didn’t seem like Pius thought so! 😛
You are incorrect.

Pius was referring to those who made changes in the way that various people made unauthorized translations of the bible. With the printing press coming online during this era, Piu was giving instructions instruction as to authorized versus unauthorized changes, and suppression of certain rites, not some sort of promulgation that the Mass can never be changed.
 
What part of the Philippines do you live in, thistle? My wife is from Baguio City. We were just in the Philippines last June—Manila and Baguio mostly…

As far as “faith and morals” being the teaching office of the Holy Father, I wonder how Mass is just a discipline and not the faith encapsulated in worship itself? I wonder why Pius V would practially anathamize anyone who altered a word from his Tridentine Mass? Some Catholics I talk to think the encyclicals of popes are infallible. Lumen Gentium 25 tells us that we have to completely give our will and minds to everything the pope teaches, officially or not. I wonder why Quo Primo can be discarded so lightly…:confused:
The form of the Mass is a discipline and most certainly can be changed by any Pope. A Pope (no matter how strongly he feels about a particular matter) cannot bind a future Pope in matters of discipline. Whether anyone feels changes have been for the better or worse is irrelvant to the fact that changes are permitted.
The only past of a Mass which cannot be changed are the words of consecration.
 
What part of the Philippines do you live in, thistle? My wife is from Baguio City. We were just in the Philippines last June—Manila and Baguio mostly…

As far as “faith and morals” being the teaching office of the Holy Father, I wonder how Mass is just a discipline and not the faith encapsulated in worship itself? I wonder why Pius V would practially anathamize anyone who altered a word from his Tridentine Mass? Some Catholics I talk to think the encyclicals of popes are infallible. Lumen Gentium 25 tells us that we have to completely give our will and minds to everything the pope teaches, officially or not. I wonder why Quo Primo can be discarded so lightly…:confused:
I live in Las Pinas City, Metro Manila.

The form of the Mass is a discipline. The words of Consecration cannot be changed but whether we receive on the tongue or in the hand, what language is used, whether the sign of peace is moved to a different place in the Mass etc are things which can be changed.
I’m not saying change is necessarily required or good. All I’m saying is that changes in the form of Mass are allowed.
 
It would seem to me that, like most popes have/do, Pope Pius V invoked the “royal WE”, meaning that not he - the man - was forbidding change, but he - as the office of Peter - was forbidding change. Ergo, a future successor of Peter is not bound by that directive since the office doesn’t cease with the death of the man but lives on through the successor(s). The directive seems to apply to any and all BUT the Pope himself.

I mean no offense to anyone by this statement, but my personal opinion is that it would reduce Pope Pius to egotistical ignorance to assert that he was implying no future pope held authority to bring about a change in doctrine or discipline.
 
Change in doctrine??? :eek:

I thought doctrine does not change, only develops?

No offense taken. 👍

-Tim-
 
Change in doctrine??? :eek:

I thought doctrine does not change, only develops?
No offense taken. 👍

-Tim-
Vatican 2 didn’t change any doctrines and no they do not change, they develop, meaning that our understanding of doctrines gets better as we study and pray. 🤷

Back to the original question though…Read the documents at the link above and see for yourself.
 
How do we know that there is a God? How do we know that Catholicism is the right religion?

I think it boils down to a leap of faith.
Exactly. It does all begin and boil down to faith. Faith in a Creator. Faith in the NT. Faith in the Catholic Church’s interpretation of Herself. Faith in ECFs. Faith in what a person believes the ultimate one truth to be. But no one knows for certain. That’s why it’s called faith.
 
Pope Pius V in Quo Primo declared

“We order and enjoin that nothing must be added to Our recently published Missal, nothing omitted from it, nor anything whatsoever be changed within it.No one whosoever is permitted to alter this notice of Our permission, statute, ordinance, command, precept, grant, indult, declaration, will, decree, and prohibition. Should anyone dare to contravene it, let him know that he will incur the wrath of Almighty God and of the Blessed Apostles Peter and Paul”
Where did you get that quote? It’s been falsified. And so you’ve come to the wrong conclusion. Somebody took two different parts and joined them together to make it look like the penalty for changing the TLM was “the wrath of Almighty God” - not so. Here is what Quo Primo actually says:

“We order and enjoin that nothing must be added to Our recently published Missal, nothing omitted from it, nor anything whatsoever be changed within it under the penalty of Our displeasure.
…
Therefore, no one whosoever is permitted to alter** this notice** of Our permission, statute, ordinance, command, precept, grant, indult, declaration, will, decree, and prohibition. Should know that he will incur the wrath of Almighty God and of the Blessed Apostles Peter and Paul.”

papalencyclicals.net/Pius05/p5quopri.htm

So you see, at worst, Pope Paul VI incurred the “displeasure” of Pope St. Pius V - and I believe he did. The penalty of the wrath of God was for anyone who would alter or misappropriate this decree itself. Now, this might seem strange that the penalty is much more severe for altering the decree, which would be of no effect other than to deceive people, than to actually alter the Mass! But Pope Pius knew very well that a future Pope could change the Mass because it is a matter of discipline, and had been changed many times before.

By the way, let whoever falsified your quote know that they have incurred the wrath of Almighty God and of the Blessed Apostles Peter and Paul. God bless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top