What if "Your" mass time was switched from OF to EF. What would you do?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JRKH
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I don’t know how to start a thread but maybe someone out there will do this one…

What if “YOUR” mass time was ONLY an OF ?
would you…
  1. Be obedient to your faith, go and pray that God has His way?
  2. Would you prefer driving 50 miles more or less to avoid an OF?
  3. Would you go with a critical mindset and the intention of correcting the priest about every thing he does wrong?
  4. Would you just not go at all?
It would be interesting to see the numbers on that:D
.
Since, so far as I know, virtually every mass IS an OF mass, I don’t see your point here.
The object of this poll is, as I expressed in the OP, simply to determine if the oft repeated line of “nobody would go” or some such was true or not. It seems it is not.

Of course I do not know if you voted Auntie M, but I suppose that you are one who would choose to avoid the EF. To each their own.

Peace
James
 
See? Now that’s what I mean. We already had that happen when the NO was first unveiled in the late 60s-early 70s and yet here we are.

As far as a “critical mindset”, well some abuses (and even the Pope recognizes that some abuses crept in) “pop” out–don’t even have to look for them. Sometimes as far as the abuses in the NO, Mother Angelica was right–it’s the “Electric Church”, everytime one turns around there’s another shock.
AMDG,
While I do agree with you as to the “abruptness” with which the changes came in the 60’s, I would like to keep this thread as non-contentious as possible.
I certainly do not feel it is of benefit to anyone to “force” the issue of the EF or OF. Or to antagonize others. The past is the past. Let’s not repeat the mistakes of the 60’s as we work to bring about healthful growth in the Church. Both forms are valid. The Holy Father is doing what can be done to encourage the acceptance of both forms. We, all of us, need to support that effort in charitable and constructive ways.

Thanks

Peace
James
 
I already go to the EF so it couldn’t very well be changed to it 🙂
 
Since, so far as I know, virtually every mass IS an OF mass, I don’t see your point here.
The object of this poll is, as I expressed in the OP, simply to determine if the oft repeated line of “nobody would go” or some such was true or not. It seems it is not.

Of course I do not know if you voted Auntie M, but I suppose that you are one who would choose to avoid the EF. To each their own.

Peace
James
As a matter of fact, I voted that either way was ok with me. I would NOT drive 50 miles plus or minus to go to a “special” mass of either kind. I DO feel they are the same. As the Pope has stated.
BUT, most traditionalist DO NOT and therein lies the trouble.
The opinion I have gotten from most of the threads dealing with this issue is that most of the NO folks would go to either mass, whatever was approved by the Pope, whereas the majority of the EF would not. Even to the extremes of going to “other” masses not in communion with Rome. It’s kinda like “My way or the Highway”.
The Pope has certainly tried his best to reconcile these traditionalist, but some just refuse to accept that the two masses are one in the same, as the Pope has said many times before.

I am sorry, but I don’t hear alot of "Catholic/Pope/NO/TLM mass bashing coming from the NO folks. Even though some do not agree wholeheartedly with the situation. But, the “loudest” spoke on the wheel comes straight from the traditionalist.

I think most do agree, somewhat, that the Traditionalists have a valid point. But it is the WAY they have gone about bringing on the change is what has most people upset.🤷

I, personally do not like hearing them bash Benedict, nor did I like them bashing JPII. Nor do I like seeing people being led away from our church by people who are NOT in communion with Rome.🤷
 
As far as this poll showing what is true or not. Polls are not struck in stone. One may vote one way today and another way tomorrow.

James, only time will tell the real truth,
 
As far as this poll showing what is true or not. Polls are not struck in stone. One may vote one way today and another way tomorrow.

James, only time will tell the real truth,
Amen to that Auntie.

Peace
James
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top