What if your pastor announced that from now on all new altar servers will be boys?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lepanto
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think the average parishioner would have a reaction mixed with surprise, confusion, and dislike of the new rule. I don’t think the average parishioner has thought too much about the presence or absence of altar girls, but probably takes it for granted that girls should be allowed to serve as well as boys because of success of feminists in society. The average parishioner would probably oppose the decision on a basis of fairness, but at the same time, I don’t know how much they’d care about the decision. I doubt many parishioners would drive a few extra minutes or miles just to find a parish where they allowed girls to serve.
 
A friend of mine passed about a week ago…she was a Sister of Mercy…I attended her “memorial mass”…all the alter servers were women, more than half of them Sisters of Mercy, Mercy Associates and Sisters from Omaha from what I could gather.

After the memorial I heard more than one woman in the congregation commented how wonderful it was to see so many women serving at the alter.

As a Friend, I did not go up for the Eucharist, due to my own beliefs but out of respect for the Sister’s as well. ** I noticed the priest served the wafer and the women served the wine.**
You must have been at a Protestant funeral service in that case. In the Catholic Church God’s very Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity are offered at Communion, and not “wafers and wine.”
 
One of the greatest horrors I have ever seen are adult women acting as altar servers. Something just doesn’t seem right – particularity when they accesorize their albs with things that do not belong on albs like “scarfs” that look suspiciously like a priest’s stole…
 
The Fifth Chapter, Book 2, Imitation of Christ

Ourselves

We must not rely too much upon ourselves, for grace and understanding are often lacking in us. We have but little inborn light, and this we quickly lose through negligence. Often we are not aware that we are so blind in heart. Meanwhile we do wrong, and then do worse in excusing it. At times we are moved by passion, and we think it zeal. We take others to task for small mistakes, and overlook greater ones in ourselves. We are quick enough to feel and brood over the things we suffer from others, but we think nothing of how much others suffer from us. If a man would weigh his own deeds fully and rightly, he would find little cause to pass severe judgment on others.

The interior man puts the care of himself before all other concerns, and he who attends to himself carefully does not find it hard to hold his tongue about others. You will never be devout of heart unless you are thus silent about the affairs of others and pay particular attention to yourself. If you attend wholly to God and yourself, you will be little disturbed by what you see about you.

Where are your thoughts when they are not upon yourself? And after attending to various things, what have you gained if you have neglected self? If you wish to have true peace of mind and unity of purpose, you must cast all else aside and keep only yourself before your eyes.

You will make great progress if you keep yourself free from all temporal cares, for to value anything that is temporal is a great mistake. Consider nothing great, nothing high, nothing pleasing, nothing acceptable, except God Himself or that which is of God. Consider the consolations of creatures as vanity, for the soul that loves God scorns all things that are inferior to Him. God alone, the eternal and infinite, satisfies all, bringing comfort to the soul and true joy to the body.
 
You must have been at a Protestant funeral service in that case. In the Catholic Church God’s very Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity are offered at Communion, and not “wafers and wine.”
No it was Catholic…St. Stephens Catholic Church…so I was in the right church…plus it was a Catholic Sister of Mercy’s memorial.

I am not Catholic.
 
No it was Catholic…St. Stephens Catholic Church…so I was in the right church…plus it was a Catholic Sister of Mercy’s memorial.

I am not Catholic.
With over 600 postings on these forums you should know it’s the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus Christ and not “wafers and wine” unless you are simply trying to be rude…
 
With over 600 postings on these forums you should know it’s the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus Christ and not “wafers and wine” unless you are simply trying to be rude…
No I was not “trying to be rude”…the terminology is totally foreign to me, not only in my faith tradition but also in vocabulary. No offense was intended, so please, take no offense. To me, those words and concepts do not speak out of the Center of Truth…so I find it difficult to use them to convey a meaning that I do not share when I am relaying MY EXPERIENCE…I do not dispute yours…again, please do not take offense where no offense was intended.
 
Please stay on topic, people. And please refrain from making personal remarks within threads. Thank you.
 
A friend of mine passed about a week ago…she was a Sister of Mercy…I attended her “memorial mass”…all the alter servers were women, more than half of them Sisters of Mercy, Mercy Associates and Sisters from Omaha from what I could gather.

After the memorial I heard more than one woman in the congregation commented how wonderful it was to see so many women serving at the alter.

As a Friend, I did not go up for the Eucharist, due to my own beliefs but out of respect for the Sister’s as well. I noticed the priest served the wafer and the women served the wine.
Nuns and women religious are the only servers available in a convent usually. I don’t see anything wrong with her Sisters in religion serving at her funeral Mass. Especially since you say the priest offered the Host. That Mass was a special circumstance. At a Mass in her memory at say, the parish she grew up in, I would expect that the usual altar servers from that parish would serve.
 
Nuns and women religious are the only servers available in a convent usually. I don’t see anything wrong with her Sisters in religion serving at her funeral Mass. Especially since you say the priest offered the Host. That Mass was a special circumstance. At a Mass in her memory at say, the parish she grew up in, I would expect that the usual altar servers from that parish would serve.
It was a very moving service…it seemed very fitting for women to serve those whom the Sister served…the Sister was much loved in the community.
 
The rector of the parish should explain first the reason of the decision with theological basis before proceeding. I don’t have a problem at all regarding that (only boys as altar servers) because it is a Church Tradition that we should keep and nourish.

Peace
Praise the Lord Jesus Christ
To restore all things in Christ
 
I think that the pastors at my parish (the one my parents attend, I am at college) have subtly been only accepting boys as altar servers, since whenever I’m home they seem to be boys.

At my not-a-parish-but-someday-soon-by-the-grace-of-God-and-the-Bishop Latin Mass Community, everyone would say “Well duh.” They already are all boys.

At the university parish, the students are much more likely to support this sort of decision than the pastor…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top