What Ifs...

  • Thread starter Thread starter _Zorgirl
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Z

_Zorgirl

Guest
If God is out there, why is he not visible to us? I mean, sure this world is great and unexplained things happen, but how does that mean that we as Catholics have it all? Why do I feel The Catholic faith is so full of deep meaning, and yet so full of talking points. I hear so often, God is good, we are weak sinners who need God, trust in God, it all happens for a reason, we are such bad people who need to be so hard on ourselves. We do things that almost the whole rest of the world says is ok, including in depth studies, and suddenly we cut ourselves off from God. What if it really is all just an old control thing, religion? What if we really do not have the answers in full depth? Are we wasting all this time on a faith which is not true? Why is the answer to all questions prayer, fasting and going to church when that is the very thing people question at times? Please, help settle my mind…
 
Prayer helps build your relationship with God. The Summit of our faith is the Eucharist. Partake in it as often as you can. (daily Mass) Live daily and practice the Corporal and Spiritual Works of Mercy. Do these things and your questions will be answered.
 
Zorgirl,

You ask some big questions and there is nothing wrong with them. It is good to question. I do believe God wants us to question as we seek to understand Him. The word “question” has the word “quest” in it. To quest means you are on a mission, seeking. God asks that we seek Him. We will never know the mind of God fully until we are with Him in heaven (and even then -maybe not ??- someone correct me), but we can certainly always strive to know Him better.
Code:
As far as I know and what i have come to find, we do not have all the answers in depth.  In fact, if you read more about what saints have said and even the history of the church you will find things that seem contradictory and end up with more unanswered questions!
I think everything comes down to one thing and that is faith in Jesus Christ. Our focus should be on Christ. When we get into the peripherals and what-ifs… things become a swirl of confusion, fear and black voids- like being lost in outer space and so far from home! It is best to just abandon it and focus on what is important:

Love never fails. If there are prophecies, they will be brought to nothing; if tongues, they will cease; if knowledge, it will be brought to nothing.

For we know partially and we prophesy partially, but when the perfect comes, the partial will pass away. When I was a child, I used to talk as a child, think as a child, reason as a child; when I became a man, I put aside childish things. At present we see indistinctly, as in a mirror, but then face to face. At present I know partially; then I shall know fully, as I am fully known.

So faith, hope, love remain, these three; but the greatest of these is love.

( - 1 Corinthians 8-13)

The questions you ask are ones I think are common among believers. Even seasoned believers. As Scripture says, we don’t hope for things we see, but in things we don’t see/know. Otherwise, its not hope- as no one hopes for something they already have! (Romans 8:24) A better way of thinking is: so what if it isn’t true? What else do I have? What other options? St. Peter exclaimed “Lord, to Whom shall we go?!” (John 6:68)

What if it really is all just an old control thing, religion? Then ask what good has it done? What harm has it done? What is a better way of living? -and if you think so, why? What if it is an old control thing?!!! Is that so bad? Do we not need some sort of control? Are atheists any better off? Are anarchists?! Are those in other religions/belief systems?

What if we really do not have the answers in full depth? We do not, but through saints that loved God, we have examples and they have paved a way that is supernatural- that is, that which is above what our normal human nature’s do. They did things that mended hearts and caused peace… and even more amazing things that can’t be explained except it was the hand of God.

Are we wasting all this time on a faith which is not true? Maybe, for some in what they do and how they do it… then again, maybe not. What is the benefit of not believing? What is the benefit of going through the motions of religion if one doesn’t love it, believe in it or cherish it?

Why is the answer to all questions prayer, fasting and going to church when that is the very thing people question at times? Because all humans want and need the truth and no soul wants to be decieved- it is right and just that they question. Yet without stepping out in faith, you really aren’t showing to have faith, though maybe one has a little mustard seed’s worth! 😉 …and that is still good.

Please, help settle my mind…
Code:
When you start to feel that swirl of confusion, fear and black voids it is best to just abandon yourself to divine providence.   Every one of us will die.  This is fact that none of us can change (though some in science have been trying) so truly all of us are held to our mortality.   We only get one life as we know it, what is the best way to live it?   Everyone of us has to decide.   Everyone of us will have to meet fate.  What is the best way to meet Him?
Keep questioning!!! And pray! 👍
 
The Catholic Church teaches that it has the fullness of what has been revealed by God. No, the church does not have all the answers and has NEVER claimed to…but what God has revealed to mankind …the church has been given divine authority to teach and preach it and has been promised divine help to steer us and keep us on the right path.

We claim only to have the fullness of the info God has willed to share with mankind.

St augustine was walking along the beachside and seen a little boy trying to fill a hole in the sand with the sea water. St. Augustine (one of the most knowledgeable theologians of all time) asked the boy…“what are you doing ?” The boy said "I’m trying to fill this hole in the sand with the entire sea " …St Augustine said " that’s ridiculus…you’ll never be able to fill that little hole with the entire sea " …and the little boy transformed into an Angel and said " Neither can you Augustine possibly understand all the mysteries of God " .

Theology …is the study of God. God, being infinite and ultimatley a mystery will never be FULLY understood or exhausted … He is a fathomless, DEEP, most beautiful mystery that we will FULLY get lost within! God is not invisible…He’s too visible. He’s so visible and interwoven in us, through us, around us that we do not recognize any "space between us and God…and indeed THERE IS NONE. God was made most tangible and recognizeable in Christ who was more concretley manifested to us.

The greatest reason to come to the church is because it allows you to enter into that mystery and offers a guide (by it’s authority Christ gave to it Himself) the more you frequent the sacraments wothily…the more you recognize your place in God, who you are and who He is.

You want questions answered ??? The church is able to guide you…but only to that which God has revealed…it then helps you enter the mystery. And by entering the mystery…the mystery being God Himself…you enter into Eternal life

God bless and good journey to you!
It’s good to ask these questions…God has wanted this of you…look what it has done. It has made you uncomfortable and making you search…it gave you that feeling of “grasping in the darkness” …which is soooo necessary for holiness…soon, youll recognize that God IS the “darkness” you are swimming in. Christ and His Church help you see and KNOW Him.
 
The way I think of it, God comes and taps us on the shoulder. He then runs away, hoping that we will come after Him. God wants us to seek Him instead of feeling forced into a relationship. To give an illustration, God provides us with enough light to find Him if we so desire. However, it is dark enough where we can ignore or not seek Him if that is also our desire. If God gave us too much light, we wouldn’t be able to ignore it and may even be blinded. People wouldn’t love or search for God. They would feel coerced into a relationship with Him. That isn’t love.
 
Thanks for all the replies. I think I feel really full of guilt for wondering, and guilt whenever I question things or even when I sin or want to sin. Or, for that matter, if mass just does not feel to be helping me. This level of guilt is not healthy or helpful, minus the fact that it might drive me to go to mass, be a good person and avoid sin. Yet, since it makes me feel worse, it feels like it is dragging me down and confusing me. Am I a bad person for not wanting to go to mass and feeling confused? I do not think I am, yet I feel this faith is insiting that I am cutting myself off from all chances to get into heaven by taking some time to soul search. I feel people want a quick solution and this hurts. I am writing it here since I need to get my words out in front of me and in a place of feedback before telling people in person how I feel and coming to terms with these feelings.
 
I strongly recommend reading St. Thomas’ Summa Theologica. He gets into the nitty gritty of this in a very logical and easy to understand way.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top