What is "speaking in tongues"?

  • Thread starter Thread starter michael-kaw
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

michael-kaw

Guest
Is it a good thing or a bad thing. I think it is mentioned in the New Testament and I think it has something to do with speaking a language you have never spoken before. Am I right?
 
Last edited:
Yes, the Apostles were given this gift so they could spread the Gospel around the world.

St. Paul mentions speaking in tongues differently but that would be a rarity not something that hundreds of millions of people claim they do every night.
 
It is good!

Speaking and praying in tongues is one of the gifts of the Holy Spirit mentioned by St Paul. It is approved and encouraged by the Catholic Church.

Any person who claims otherwise is speaking their own uninformed opinion, and not the will of God.
 
Last edited:
To me - at church one time - my brother’s church - " non denominational "
you have a guy in a suit and tie - talking complete gibberish -
I looked at him - he looked at me - he was trying to get me to imitate him -
Only at that church - have I heard such - chatter -
never at a store - or at the park -
I don’t see the point of it - it’s like some sort of secret agent code inspector gadget thing -
 
If you search these forums, you will see that it is a hotly debated topic!
 
I heard real tongs before, its a language of its own. Once you heard the real one you’ll know and you will be able to decern the fake from the real.
 
Its just some sort of psychosocial group mania.

There’s no credible mention of it’s existing prior to the 20th century and attempts to retroactively justify the novel practice are clearly retcons and biased reinterpretations of history.
 
Acts 2:Verse 4

Began to speak divers tongues. Perhaps the apostles spoke only their own tongue, and the miracle consisted in each one’s understanding it as if they spoke it in his language. (St. Gregory of Nazianzus, orat. xliv.) — But St. Augustine and most others, understand the text literally; though the apostles had not this gift on all occasions, nor on all subjects, and therefore sometimes stood in need of interpreters. See St. Augustine, in Psalm xvii.; Expos. 2.; and Serm. 188. — The same Father observes, that the conversion of all nations to the Church, and their being united in one faith, all having one language or confession, is a perpetuation of the same miracle in the Church.

1 Corinthians 14:Verse 2

He that speaketh in a tongue, which others at least understand not: nay, which sometimes, perhaps, by the 14th and 15th verse, he himself that spoke tongues, did not understand, can only be said to speak to God. In spirit he speaketh mysteries, edifies himself, because in his spirit he is piously and devoutly affected; but he must endeavour that the Church, or people present, may be also edified. Let him then pray for the other gift of interpreting, what he speaks, or let another interpret. (Witham) — Not to men. Viz. so as to be heard, that is, so as to be understood by them. (Witham)
 
1 Corinthians 14:19 All the same, when I am in the assembly I would rather say five words with my mind, to instruct others as well, than ten thousand words in a tongue.
 
It’s when one can speak in different languages then they know. The gift of tongues has been given to certain St. throughout Church history.
 
It depends. It is a beautiful thing when it’s of the Holy Spirit, a possibly bad thing if it comes from the individual, and a very bad thing if it comes from a demon. The gifts of the Hilt Spirit can be practised solo but are best practiced within a group so the gifts of interpretation and discernment may be practiced along with tongues which is considered the least of the gifts.
 
So this guy, in a suit and tie, clean shaven, bible in hand, says to me, " Frezupighezerpfftequefriklifipor " !!
:crazy_face: so I said all I could think of, " Shazbot. Na nu na nu " :alien:
 
I’ve never met anyone - who could interpret someone else - speaking in tongues.
There’s NOT many Catholic books written on that particular subject.
Jesus - never spoke that way either.
 
Last edited:
I’ve never met someone who could interpret someone else - speaking in tongues.
That you know of. I have never announced the gifts of the Holy Spirit I’ve received and only make their practice known within a prayer group.
There’s NOT many Catholic books written on that particular subject.
I don’t think there needs to be, do you? It’s not a gift I have so I only own one just for reference but there are a few.
Jesus - never spoke that way either.
How do you know?
 
Last edited:
Lol, I had a thread related to this topic, and it got shut down pretty quickly.

You’re right, speaking in tongues isn’t incoherent gibberish which no one can understand. It is one of two things:

1: someone speaking a foreign language which you have never studied before, and someone can interpret it authentically.

2: someone speaking their own native language, or another language in which they are fluent, and have someone else hear you in their own native language, which is different from the one you are speaking.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top