What is "The Church"

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mangy_Donkey
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
What is the Church, and is it visible?
Hello Mangy and welcome to the forums. Below is a link to the Catholic Encyclopedia. It is quite lengthy but give great information on what “The Church” is. I hope it helps.

newadvent.org/cathen/03744a.htm

Also from the CCC

751 The word “Church” (Latin ecclesia, from the Greek ek-ka-lein, to “call out of”) means a convocation or an assembly. It designates the assemblies of the people, usually for a religious purpose. Ekklesia is used frequently in the Greek Old Testament for the assembly of the Chosen People before God, above all for their assembly on Mount Sinai where Israel received the Law and was established by God as his holy people. By calling itself “Church,” the first community of Christian believers recognized itself as heir to that assembly. In the Church, God is “calling together” his people from all the ends of the earth. The equivalent Greek term Kyriake, from which the English word Church and the German Kirche are derived, means “what belongs to the Lord.”

1076 The Church was made manifest to the world on the day of Pentecost by the outpouring of the Holy Spirit. The gift of the Spirit ushers in a new era in the “dispensation of the mystery” the age of the Church, during which Christ manifests, makes present, and communicates his work of salvation through the liturgy of his Church, “until he comes.” In this age of the Church Christ now lives and acts in and with his Church, in a new way appropriate to this new age. He acts through the sacraments in what the common Tradition of the East and the West calls “the sacramental economy”; this is the communication (or “dispensation”) of the fruits of Christ’s Paschal mystery in the celebration of the Church’s “sacramental” liturgy.
 
What is the Church, and is it visible?
The church, the Body of Christ, is the assembly of all of God’s people in Christ.

One is either in Christ or not in Christ.

One is either in the church or not in the church.

For everyone in the Body, there are no lesser members. By definition, no one in the Body is “separated” from any of the others in the Body.

The church is not the leadership of any assembly. The church is not any body of bishops. The church is not any elite set of teachers.

The church on earth is made up of redeemed human beings.

Human beings are all visible.

…
 
The church, the Body of Christ, is the assembly of all of God’s people in Christ.

One is either in Christ or not in Christ.

One is either in the church or not in the church.

For everyone in the Body, there are no lesser members. By definition, no one in the Body is “separated” from any of the others in the Body.

The church is not the leadership of any assembly. The church is not any body of bishops. The church is not any elite set of teachers.

The church on earth is made up of redeemed human beings.

Human beings are all visible.

…
And everyone will notice that Atemi cites no scripture . Why? Because not one bit of that is supported by the Word of God.
 
There is a visible church set up by Christ in Matthew 16 when Christ says to Peter " you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of the netherworld will not prevail against it" As Catholics, we believe this church to be the Roman Catholic Church which follows the successor of Peter, the Pope.

However, just as we are made of the visible and invisible, the body and soul, the church also has an invisible aspect to it. This is compromised of all of the true believers and deserve salvation. This doesn’t mean that anyone in the Catholic Church goes to Heaven and likewise, not all true believers are present in the visible Catholic Church. “Two common opposite errors are to reduce the Church to what is visible in human history and to reduce the church to an invisible community of souls” We are all one mystical body of Christ yet we are also contained in a visible society
 
What is the Church, and is it visible?
There are three parts to The Church. The Church Militant, which is the visible Church on Earth; The Church suffering which has all of the Faithful being purged of impurity before proceeding into the presence of God; and The Church Triumphant which consists of all the Faithful united with Christ eternally in Heaven.
 
**The church, the Body of Christ, is the assembly of all of God’s people in Christ.
One is either in Christ or not in Christ.
One is either in the church or not in the church.
For everyone in the Body, there are no lesser members. By definition, no one in the Body is “separated” from any of the others in the Body.
The church is not the leadership of any assembly. The church is not any body of bishops. The church is not any elite set of teachers.
The church on earth is made up of redeemed human beings.
Human beings are all visible.
And everyone will notice that Atemi cites no scripture . Why? Because not one bit of that is supported by the Word of God.
Which assertion is false?

If you need assistance in understanding such basic ecclesiology, I can help you.

…
 
Which assertion is false?

If you need assistance in understanding such basic ecclesiology, I can help you.

…
Wow, I am guessing this is the same Atemi that posts or posted over at CARM? Perhaps I am wrong, surely I am mistaken and the moniker is coincidence. I cannot for the life of me believe you lasting here for 1700 + posts without being removed.
 
Thank you all for the posts, in recent conversations with a friend, that is a non denom, belonging to a church called the “Invisible church” He questioned the visibility of the Church. His premise, I suppose, is that without knowing, with assurance, the state of ones soul or relationship with God how can the Church be visible.

Thanks Again.
 
Which assertion is false?
Essentially what you are doing is denying the visible church and following the protestant that there is only a mystical church of all the believers. However, the Apostles set up a church and did gather to pray and break bread. To deny a real church is to deny first what is said in Matthew 16 about the “upon this rock I will build my church” and to then deny all the times that the bible mentions the church such as “constant prayer was offered to God for him by the church.” Acts 12:5. You also seem to be partaking in what was described in Hebrews, “We should not stay away from our assembly, as is the custom of some,” by denying the Church, you are denying what Christ and the apostles worked to create on this Earth
 
Essentially what you are doing is denying the visible church and following the protestant that there is only a mystical church of all the believers.
How am I denying the church is visible when I make the case that the church is visible? :confused:

That does not even make sense.
You also seem to be partaking in what was described in Hebrews, “We should not stay away from our assembly, as is the custom of some,”
It seems you did not read my post at all.

I assemble with the brethren regularly, often multiple times a week. You should be careful with such false accusations. You could ask next time.

…
 
Which assertion is false?

If you need assistance in understanding such basic ecclesiology, I can help you.

…
Oh come on now. Your being cutesy. You have diverted from what he said which is true.
And everyone will notice that Atemi cites no scripture . Why? Because not one bit of that is supported by the Word of God.
He didn’t say what you wrote was false only not in Scripture.
If you have scripture, please cite it and make sure it is on point.
 
The church on earth is made up of redeemed human beings.

Human beings are all visible.

…
No, the church made up of redeemed human beings is the invisible church no matter how visible humans are. I can’t look at a person and tell if he is a redeemed human being or not. The visible church is the one made up of people that does have a hierarchy and is present in what can be seen as a community following Christ. Christ himself set up a church in Matthew 16. In your post, you seemed to be denying the visible Church by only mentioning the Church of believers and commenting on how it isnt the leaders.
 
Oh come on now. Your being cutesy. You have diverted from what he said which is true.
So what I said is true?

If so, why would any Catholics have a problem with it?

If you see something I said that was wrong, point it out and I can address it.

…
 
Invisible Church. Maybe the dog ate it. 😃

If he refuses to listen to them, tell the church. (Matthew 18:17)

And if you don’t like what they say, just go around to some of the smaller, visible manifestations of the invisible whole until you find one that tells you what you are doing is really OK because God loves you just the way you are.

If the Church is invisible, it is also inaudible… unrecognizable… ignorable… irrelivant.

-Tim-
 
So what I said is true?..
Are you being cutesy again? Or do you have trouble with reading comprehension?
I said that what Church Militant said was true that you don’t provide scripture for your opinion. Obviously if you had any you would provide it instead of trying to side track the issue.
Like Church Militant says everyone can see.
 
=Atemi;8008822]The church, the Body of Christ, is the assembly of all of God’s people in Christ.
Only the baptized are members of The Church
For everyone in the Body, there are no lesser members.
Not everyone in the Body of Christ have the same gifts.“And God has appointed in the church, first apostles, second prophets, third teachers, then workers ofmiracles, then healers, helpers, administrators…” 1 Cor. 12:27

The aposltes held the office of Bishop ( Acts 1:20)
Bishops are a visible mark of the One True Church.
The church is not the leadership of any assembly. The church is not any body of bishops. The church is not any elite set of teachers.
Read 1 Cor. 12:27 and Acts 1:20
The Church established by Christ was pastored by men made Bishops through the laying on of hands… It was the Bishop who had the authority to teach sound doctrine and to “confute those who contradict it.” TItus 1:9
WIthout a valid apostolic Bishop you cannot claim to be The Church.
The church on earth is made up of redeemed human beings.
All have been redeemed. Not all are saved. Only the baptized belong to the Body of Christ.
 
Invisible Church. Maybe the dog ate it. 😃

If he refuses to listen to them, tell the church. (Matthew 18:17)

And if you don’t like what they say, just go around to some of the smaller, visible manifestations of the invisible whole until you find one that tells you what you are doing is really OK because God loves you just the way you are.

If the Church is invisible, it is also inaudible… unrecognizable… ignorable… irrelivant.

-Tim-
I think this is a very good point, and a scripture often forgotten.

I do believe that to some extent the church is invisible in that we cannot know the hearts of people. Certainly there are people who love God and want to serve Him and are in temporary (hopefully) ignorance about which visible church is the one Christ established. There are also those who are impeded from joining the church b/c they are oppressed for any number of reasons. And there are also those who have not heard the gospel yet or who simply do not have the ability to understand, or the ability to research… So, there are many reasons to believe that the church (militant) is not altogether visible - at least as far as being physically in communion with the church (people are visible, afterall…).

Correct me if this is wrong, but I do believe this is also Catholic teaching. I think it may have something to do with the teaching on baptism.

But the main point is that for those who ARE capable of understanding and seeking, it must be possible to determine which church it is. The hindrance to many (including myself) is what criteria to use in determining such.
 
I think this is a very good point, and a scripture often forgotten.

I do believe that to some extent the church is invisible in that we cannot know the hearts of people. Certainly there are people who love God and want to serve Him and are in temporary (hopefully) ignorance about which visible church is the one Christ established. There are also those who are impeded from joining the church b/c they are oppressed for any number of reasons. And there are also those who have not heard the gospel yet or who simply do not have the ability to understand, or the ability to research… So, there are many reasons to believe that the church (militant) is not altogether visible - at least as far as being physically in communion with the church (people are visible, afterall…).

Correct me if this is wrong, but I do believe this is also Catholic teaching. I think it may have something to do with the teaching on baptism.

But the main point is that for those who ARE capable of understanding and seeking, it must be possible to determine which church it is. The hindrance to many (including myself) is what criteria to use in determining such.
The Church cannot be invisible. she is very visible. that is why Jesus says: go into the whole world and teach all that I have commanded you. an invisible Church cannot do this. of course there are those who never got a chance to hear the Word before they died. then there are those who through oppression never got a chance to hear the Word. but these people don’t make an invisible Church, they are just individuals who may receive the Grace of Salvation for these reasons.

God is not going to give a Command then hide His Church from the people. that doesnt make any sense if we believe that He is just. this is an argument made by those outside the Church to justify their willfully desire to be independent from the Church. Jesus gave his life for the Church, He must love this Church very much. those outside the Church are in disobedience to Christ and God. St Peter talks about how God hates lies. if there is one Truth and One Church then all others are lies.
 
The Church cannot be invisible. she is very visible. that is why Jesus says: go into the whole world and teach all that I have commanded you. an invisible Church cannot do this. of course there are those who never got a chance to hear the Word before they died. then there are those who through oppression never got a chance to hear the Word. but these people don’t make an invisible Church, they are just individuals who may receive the Grace of Salvation for these reasons.

God is not going to give a Command then hide His Church from the people. that doesnt make any sense if we believe that He is just. this is an argument made by those outside the Church to justify their willfully desire to be independent from the Church. Jesus gave his life for the Church, He must love this Church very much. those outside the Church are in disobedience to Christ and God. St Peter talks about how God hates lies. if there is one Truth and One Church then all others are lies.
I agreed that the church is a visible entity.

There may be those who willfully desire to be independent from the church, but I, for one, do not, as I indicated in my post. For those like myself, who are sincerely seeking the truth and are believers in Christ and desire to be in communion with His church, I do not believe such people are not part of the church. Everyone who uses this argument does not willfully desire to be independent from the church. Everyone outside of the Catholic Church is not willfully desiring to be outside of Christ’s church. Not all those outside the Catholic church are in disobedience to Christ and God. You paint a very black and white picture with very little compassion. All else is not necessarily a lie. I don’t think you are even representing true, Catholic teaching with such statements. The Catholic church does not call non-Catholics liars. “Separated brethren” is a far cry better than that, and certainly better than its former label “heretic”.

Here is a source to support my argument. Please give some sources to support yours (that all else are liars and everyone outside the Catholic church willfully desires to be independent from Christ’s church). Thanks.

Vatican 11 (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church, chapter 11. The People of God) “Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, and, moved by grace, try in their actions to do his will as they know it through the dictates of their conscience-those too may achieve eternal salvation.”

The logic follows that if there is not salvation outside of the Catholic Church, then such people must somehow be part of the church.

Some Scripture also:

Mark 9: 38 “Teacher,” said John, “we saw someone driving out demons in your name and we told him to stop, because he was not one of us.”
"Jesus said in reply: ‘Do not try to stop him. No man who performs a miracle using My name can at the same time speak ill of Me. Anyone who is not against us is with us.’ "
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top