What is the difference between a formal and substantial locution?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Joseph73
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Joseph73

Guest
Could anybody who has experienced both write down their experiences in detail? I cannot find it in the other locution threads. Thanks!
 
Think of successive locutions as the inspired thoughts we sometimes have when we’re prayerfully recollected. It is “our” voice we hear … though influenced by the Holy Spirit. It is the comingling of our thoughts and God’s thoughts through the medium of prayer. This type of locution is not as rare as one might think. I have personally seen many posts on this forum that were the fruit of successive locution … no doubt about that.

Formal locutions, on the other hand, are typically brief utterances that come from “another” that we hear interiorly in our mind. Substantial locations are similar but they carry the effect the words signify. For example, one might hear “Be good” … and we would immediately and substantially become good. Or we might hear “Fear not” … and we will immediately be put at rest and peace.

The effect of the locution (or lack there of) is which differentiates the formal from the substantial. It should also be noted that formal and substantial locutions do not necessarily come while the soul is recollected (as in successive locutions); rather they often come “from out of the blue.” Substantial locutions are the most interior of the three … and they can not be doubted as coming from God.

I will not speak personally other than this: very early on in my spiritual life I “heard” the words: “It’s all true.” Since that moment on I have not doubted the depths by which it means to live by Faith a single time. Nor have I from that moment questioned Church teaching.

Chapters 29-31 of Book 2 of The Ascent of Mount Carmel speak of this in some detail.

Hope this helps,

Dave:)
 
Thanks very much, Dave.🙂 I have read through the St. John of the Cross material, but am still having trouble discerning whether my experiences were substantial locutions or simply formal locutions that were very, very, peaceful and calm, like a blanket dropping over your mind (and totally unexpected). These communications also did not quite have the brevity of a statement like “Be good” or “Fear not.”

I have had a lot of experiences, some true and some not, some involving an external being putting words in my head and some not, but these 2 communications seem singularly apart from the others.

I will send you a private message with the specific content.🙂
 
Thanks very much, Dave.🙂 I have read through the St. John of the Cross material, but am still having trouble discerning whether my experiences were substantial locutions or simply formal locutions that were very, very, peaceful and calm, like a blanket dropping over your mind (and totally unexpected). These communications also did not quite have the brevity of a statement like “Be good” or “Fear not.”

I have had a lot of experiences, some true and some not, some involving an external being putting words in my head and some not, but these 2 communications seem singularly apart from the others.

I will send you a private message with the specific content.🙂
One’s substantial and the other is formal, or maybe the other way around:shrug:
 
Maybe no interest to you, nor am I aware of other locution threads.
I had one. It was audible. And I’d like some thoughts if it was an Angel or Jesus.
It was definitely a male external voice. And said three words.
I was in prayer contempating the Passion.
:bighanky:
 
Do substantial locutions have to necessarily be words. I have, very rarely, experienced what you might call an “interior movement”, something like a very subtle “bubbling”, but which seemed to translate itself into words (words without words, as I describe it). The words understood had the effect of their meaning.
 
Do substantial locutions have to necessarily be words. I have, very rarely, experienced what you might call an “interior movement”, something like a very subtle “bubbling”, but which seemed to translate itself into words (words without words, as I describe it). The words understood had the effect of their meaning.
Hi Ora et Labora -
Perhaps what you describe might be closer to what St. John of the Cross describes as a “touch” or what St. Teresa of Jesus calls “intellectual vision.”

Whereas a substantial locution is something we “hear” in our mind … a touch/intellectual vision is something we just come to “know” without any sort of medium or communication whatsoever. This “knowing” is usually some insight into our own makeup … or deeper light into a particular attribute of Christ. A good example that comes to mind is St. Therese’s sudden realization that “my vocation is love” from her “Story of a Soul.”

In both substantial locution and intellectual vision, the experience comes as though out of the blue … in other words, not the fruit of our reflection or recollection. But intellectual vision is the one experience we can trust without question … because it is purely spiritual (ie, knowing) and can not be filtered or misinterpreted by our faculties (imagination).

Hope this helps,
Dave 🙂
 
Hi Ora et Labora -
Perhaps what you describe might be closer to what St. John of the Cross describes as a “touch” or what St. Teresa of Jesus calls “intellectual vision.”

Whereas a substantial locution is something we “hear” in our mind … a touch/intellectual vision is something we just come to “know” without any sort of medium or communication whatsoever. This “knowing” is usually some insight into our own makeup … or deeper light into a particular attribute of Christ. A good example that comes to mind is St. Therese’s sudden realization that “my vocation is love” from her “Story of a Soul.”

In both substantial locution and intellectual vision, the experience comes as though out of the blue … in other words, not the fruit of our reflection or recollection. But intellectual vision is the one experience we can trust without question … because it is purely spiritual (ie, knowing) and can not be filtered or misinterpreted by our faculties (imagination).

Hope this helps,
Dave 🙂
To contextualize: I was in a situation where I had to speak to a group of people, who were, for the most part lapsed Catholics, but who apparently didn’t seem to interested in hearing about what the Church has to say. I am terrible at speaking with strangers, especially when I know I’ll be at odds with them. Yet out of the blue came this bubbling which seemed to say “be strong and speak; let them ridicule you, if need be, but know that if you pass these things, it is for love of Me”.
 
Hi Ora et Labora -
Perhaps what you describe might be closer to what St. John of the Cross describes as a “touch” or what St. Teresa of Jesus calls “intellectual vision.”

Whereas a substantial locution is something we “hear” in our mind … a touch/intellectual vision is something we just come to “know” without any sort of medium or communication whatsoever. This “knowing” is usually some insight into our own makeup … or deeper light into a particular attribute of Christ. A good example that comes to mind is St. Therese’s sudden realization that “my vocation is love” from her “Story of a Soul.”

In both substantial locution and intellectual vision, the experience comes as though out of the blue … in other words, not the fruit of our reflection or recollection. But intellectual vision is the one experience we can trust without question … because it is purely spiritual (ie, knowing) and can not be filtered or misinterpreted by our faculties (imagination).

Hope this helps,
Dave 🙂
This is fascinating stuff, Dave. I hadn’t known before of “touches” though of course I know about St Therese of Lisieux’s sudden realisation of her vocation. Thanks for posting this! 👍
 
For those interested in reading more, St. John of the Cross’ Ascent of Mount Carmel is a wonderful guide.

Here are the appropriate passages for the communications discussed in this thread:

Touches:
catholictreasury.info/books/ascent/asc42.php

Successive Locution:
catholictreasury.info/books/ascent/asc45.php

Formal Locution:
catholictreasury.info/books/ascent/asc46.php

Substantial Locution:
catholictreasury.info/books/ascent/asc47.php

Dave 🙂
Thanks much for the links! In the “substantial” section, I am intrigued by what St. John says here:
St. John of the Cross:
  1. With respect to these words, the soul should do nothing. It should neither desire them nor refrain from desiring them; it should neither reject them nor fear them. It should do nothing in the way of executing what these words express, for these substantial words are never pronounced by God in order that the soul may translate them into action, but that He may so translate them within the soul; herein they differ from formal and successive words.
Not sure what I can add to that other than it makes sense that we ought to allow God to work his words within our soul rather than attempting to figure out what the locution may mean…the meaning has been provided within the soul already.
 
Sweet! Thanks, DBT!

catholictreasury.info/books/ascent/asc47.php
I have tried to read this whole chapter ’slowly’. It cleared up much that had me confounded for about five years now.
The words that my ears heard while deep in prayer, contained a ‘virtue’. But I was never sure if the locution came from God, my Angel or the evil one. Even a holy priest wasn’t sure.
I see now it was not a mandate but a supernatural gift, when I needed it, infused into my soul from God. It’s not an option, but grace to imitate Jesus. It could not be otherwise.
It took a Saint to help me discern.
Love is repaid only by love <3
+
O Lord, please bless me with all of thy virtues. Make my heart like unto thine. Amen.

Father Don & fetal microchimerism (07:20)
youtube.com/watch?v=J0CAZD-M3gc

Have you smiled today?
youtube.com/watch?v=DSr-wZKXYkU
 
So years ago I was going through a rough time, and I was in my car when a “voice” said to me “Everything will be all right”. I “heard” this in my head, and it was not a feeling, it was distinctly words. However, a peaceful feeling followed. Is this what is considered a “formal locution”?
 
Another question: The other day I began thinking about a certain subject and actually discussed it in Bible Study. After Bible study I got into the car, turned on the Catholic radio station, and the very same subject was being discussed and the exact words I used about the subject were said by the host of the show. A “feeling” came over me that these words were meant for me. Would this be considered a locution? I can’t see that it was mere coincidence.
 
Hi CB Catholic -

It would seem your first example is closer to a substantial locution since it immediately produced the effect the words signify … peace. The “effect” is what differentiates the formal from substantial.

And regarding the second, I’m not sure if there’s an actual name for it but St. John of the Cross often describes how God will provide confirmation of our thoughts and hunches in a variety of ways … the words of scripture that particularly speak to us that we just happened to read, a compelling homily from a visiting priest, the stray comment of a friend etc. As you say, there are no coincidences. 🙂

If our thoughts are simply raised to the love of God from the confirmation then we just embrace it and thank Him for it. But if we feel compelled to “do” something because of the confirmation - particularly if it involves a big matter in our lives - then it would be good to test the spirit in a manner like St. Ignatius describes in his Spiritual Exercises.

Hope this helps,
Dave 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top