What is the difference between Confession and asking God for forgiveness?

  • Thread starter Thread starter catechumen08
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

catechumen08

Guest
Hi, could someone please help me with this question? Is there any scriptural evidence for the Sacrament of Reconciliation? What is the difference between talking to a priest and asking God for forgiveness in prayer? Thanks in advance!
 
John 20:22 And when he had said this, he breathed on them, and said to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit. 20:23 If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained.”

Jesus says these words to the apostles.
Reason tells us that in order for an apostle to make a decision whether or not to forgive a sin/s, he would first have to know what the sins were - the sinner would have to confess his sins to the apostle.
 
Do you know when we confess to a priest, we are actually confessing to Jesus?
The priest, a representative of Christ, is a screen through whom we are confessing to Jesus.

Jesus gave his disciples, and by extension, to priests, the power to loose and bind sins (Matthew 16:19, 18;18, John 20:23). The absolution imparted by priest is sacramental.
The Sacrament of Confession has Bible base and brings lots of God’s grace. One also learns humility by this practice. If one goes to the same confessor regularly, it helps the person be accountable and overcome his shortcomings effectively.
 
The Church teaches that only God forgives sin. When we turn to God with a contrite heart, and ask for forgiveness of our sins, He forgives us.

However, when we sin, we cause harm to the body of Christ here on earth, which is the Church and therefore, must be reconciled to the Church, which is done in confession. Through this sacrament, we also receive grace which helps us to avoid committing sin.

In the first centuries of the Church, going to private confession was forbidden by the Church. In those days, a person who needed confession had to stand up before the congregation, and confess their sins. However, there were only three serious sins that required this, apostasy(rejection of faith), theft and adultery.
After confession, the person would be given a penance and allowed back into the community.

During the time when the Church was under persecution in Ireland, the clergy were confined in a form of house arrest, where they had to stay behind monastery walls and were not allowed contact on the outside of those walls. So, the monks built little rooms along the outside edge of the monastery wall, with little windows looking into the room. Here, a person could enter the private room and speak with a priest. There they would confess their sins and receive absolution.

The people loved this form of confession, especially over public confession, and the positive effect was so great, that it carried on even after persecution ended and the form moved through the rest of Europe, until the Church finally lifted the ban against private confession.

Today, we continue this form of confession, and those of us who frequently go to confession, know the blessing it is.

The key is to find a good confessor. Once you find one, hang on to him for dear life.

Jim
 
The difference between asking God and talking to a priest?

Absolution - an assurance of forgiveness given by a priest, but not something you receive in a private conversation with God

Humility - stating your sins to another human requires a good bit more humility than asking God

Sanctifying Grace - a nice benefit of sacramental confession that can help us to overcome those pesky sins

Obedience - we are following along with Jesus’ plan for forgiveness

A Lighter-Than-Air feeling - not always, but often after sacramental confession, you feel the weight of the world lifted; do you get that when you just ask God?

The Sacrament of Reconciliation/Penance/confession is a wonderful gift to us. Likely you will agree when you experience it.
 
Thank you all for your responses! They’re much appreciated.
The difference between asking God and talking to a priest?

Absolution - an assurance of forgiveness given by a priest, but not something you receive in a private conversation with God
Is there any difference in the forgiveness you receive from a priest and from private prayer? How do you mean that we’re not guaranteed absolution when we ask God for forgiveness in prayer?
 
Is there any difference in the forgiveness you receive from a priest and from private prayer? How do you mean that we’re not guaranteed absolution when we ask God for forgiveness in prayer?
The absolution that I’m speaking of is the actual words - actual hearing with your own ears that you are forgiven. I think as humans this is an important need and one that is not satisfied when you kneel down by your bed and ask God to forgive you for whatever mistakes that you made that day. I belive that God CAN forgive you just for asking (though the church teaches that sacramental confession is needed for mortal sins and Jesus left the apostles with the power to forgive sins for a reason), but you don’t get that affirmation that you ARE forgiven.

Does that make sense or make things muddier?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top