What is the spirit?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lady_Love
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Lady_Love

Guest
What is the “spirit”? Is it our attitudes?

I often wonder about this question because I can hear a person say all the right things but they say it in a negative spirit. So that, instead of the good words being heard, the negative spirit gets heard. I can sometimes hear a spirit of anger or condemnation or self-pity. I might agree with what they are saying but the spirit in which they are saying it does not agree with me.

The same is true for humor. Some one can have good humor which has a spirit that lifts up and some one can have bad humor which has a spirit that tears down.

Do you know what I am talking about?

I wonder sometimes, is it what we say or the spirit in which we say it that counts?
 
‘A spirit has no shape, has no size, has no colour, has no weight, does not occupy space.’ He said, ‘That’s the best definition of nothing I ever heard.’ Which was very reasonable of him. I had given him a list of things spirit is not, without a hint as to what it is.

In theology, spirit is not only a key word, it is the key word. Our Lord said to the Samaritan woman: ‘God is a spirit.’ Unless we know the meaning of the word spirit, we do not know what He said. It is as though He had said ‘God is a –.’ Which tells us nothing at all. The same is true of every doctrine; they all include spirit. In theology we are studying spirit all the time. And the mind with which we are studying it is a spirit too.

We simply must know what it is. And I don’t mean just a definition. We must master the idea, make it our own, learn to handle it comfortably and skilfully. That is why I shall dwell upon it rather lengthily. Slow careful thinking here will pay dividends later. This book is not planned as a hand-gallop over the fields of revelation. It is an effort to teach the beginnings of theology.

We begin with our own spirit, the one we know best. Spirit is the element in us by which we know and love, by which therefore we decide. Our body knows nothing; it loves nothing (bodily pleasures are not enjoyed by the body; it reacts to them physically, with heightened pulse, for instance, or acid stomach; but it is the knowing mind that enjoys the reactions or dislikes them); the body decides nothing (though our will may decide in favour of things that give us bodily pleasure).

Spirit knows and loves. A slightly longer look at ourselves reveals that spirit has power, too. It is the mind of man that splits the atom; the atom cannot split the mind, it cannot even split itself, it does not know about its own electrons.
SHEED

Read more at: superflumina.org/spirit_sheed.html
 
So is “attitude” a spirit?

If the mind controls the body and the spirit controls the mind, does that mean that if we sin with our bodies our spirits are corrupt? So is it the spirit that conjures the attitude and the attitude determines decisions and decisions determine what the body does?

Or is our spirit Holy and our minds are corrupt (being that they are part of the body and therefore affected by sin and it’s weakness)? Does our “will” find it’s source in the mind to be able to choose to surrender to the spirit or the body?
 
Yes.

The spirit animates the body. The body presents and reflects our unseeable souls in this seeable/sensible/physical world.
 
What is the “spirit”? Is it our attitudes?

I often wonder about this question because I can hear a person say all the right things but they say it in a negative spirit. So that, instead of the good words being heard, the negative spirit gets heard. I can sometimes hear a spirit of anger or condemnation or self-pity. I might agree with what they are saying but the spirit in which they are saying it does not agree with me.

The same is true for humor. Some one can have good humor which has a spirit that lifts up and some one can have bad humor which has a spirit that tears down.

Do you know what I am talking about?

I wonder sometimes, is it what we say or the spirit in which we say it that counts?
Absolutely, LL. This description you’re offering packs a lot in a few words, and completely agrees with some of the ideas I’ve come to, but from a different angle than you have. And I love the way you put it into words.

After all, the spirit is inside of us so it’s too bad so many people seek God anywhere but in our own hearts – our very essence in the image of God.

I watched an excellent History Channel documentary on “The Secrets of Body Language” in which they claimed over 2/3 of what we convey in a conversation is nonverbal body language, tone of voice, etc. If you have time, I recommend it. They also discuss “microexpressions” which I think are key to how people feel in each others’ presence, as their bodies convey messages they may not even realize.

Alan
 
The soul/spirit is all the parts of us that are unseeable/physical:

Will,memory,intellect. The body is our physical part that is animated by the soul. We have what is known as a dual nature (both physical and spiritual).

Our will is the statement on which our soul finds itself by the workings of our intelligence/memory (our enlightenment to situations) and by means of our brokeness( our wounded nature by original sin and the sin we’ve permitted in our lives since)/willingness to work with Gods saving grace.
 
I can recognize so many new ages replies in this thread.

I am clearly not an expert but i can share what i understand.

When you speak in term of Spiritual body, mental body or emotional body, it is new age talking.

Perhaps a priest could explain better but in my understanding, Catholic faith speak of the voice of conscience (Holy Spirit that guide us to make the right choice). We have also the voice that evil that can access from our weakness (pride, insecurities, etc…), which lead us to temptation and if our conscience isn’t strong enough, we can make the wrong choice. Sometime, a person will speak the truth but it is mix up with our human way of thinking, perception or understandings. Other time, a person will speak the truth completely from the Holy Spirit. If we practice the virtue of humility, charity, compassion and even self denial, i have no doubt we can achieve this and totally surrender to God’s will. Sister Faustina wrote that a soul that is completely humble is untouchable by evil.

I use to think that once we die, our soul was intact, but now i understand that our choice in every aspect affect our soul. It either tarnishes it or polishes it, so to speak.

All the best!
 
the scriptures say many things about the mind, the heart, the soul, the spirit and the conscience. sorting it out is not simple.

from my perspective, the spirit is to the soul and the soul is to the body.

regeneration of the soul from sin comes through Jesus Christ by way of the Holy Spirit of God becoming one with the human spirit. This brings healing to the soul from the effects of sin. When the soul is healed of sin the body is usually healed also, or at least in will be in better health.

We have inclinations to sin because we live in imperfect, fallen physical natures. These inclinations war against the conscience of our souls and against the spirit of our soul which is united to the Holy Spirit.

Emotions are usually of the soul either as memories, or as inclinations that are triggered by our imperfect physical state. As long as we live in an imperfect, fallen, physical nature we will be sending mix messages. The Holy Spirit will be sending holy messages to our spirit/mind, while our fallen physical nature will be sending conflicting messages to our soul.

If we are living in the attitudes of the nine fruits of the Holy Spirit/and or the nine beatitudes, then conflicting messages from our body/memory soul will be over ridden by the Holy Spirit which is united to our human spirit.

It takes many years of understanding our own emotions, and learning which emotions should be, and need to be tempered by the Holy Spirit. Of course, we have to ask for this temperance, and not assume it will come our way.

When we become united in body, soul and spirit, then we become real. As the apostle Paul says, ** may the God of peace sanctify you wholly, in body, soul and spirit that you might be kept blameless at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ.**.

A corollary to this prayer of St. Paul is this: "The Lord make you to increase and to abound in love, one to another and toward all, to the end that your hearts might be blameless in holiness before God even our Father at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ with all his saints."

Until then, we live shadow lives with intentioned and non-intentioned facades of on-going inner conflicts. (As I understand it.)

God’s peace and love be with you

micah
 
I can recognize so many new ages replies in this thread.

I am clearly not an expert but i can share what i understand.

When you speak in term of Spiritual body, mental body or emotional body, it is new age talking.
Why is this “new age” talk? Is it not rather the truth? Doesn’t the human being have a spiritual, mental and emotional aspect? If the Catholic church says somewhere that we do not have these traits, please show me. I think to deny any one of these would be to deny your humanness.
 
Why is this “new age” talk? Is it not rather the truth? Doesn’t the human being have a spiritual, mental and emotional aspect? If the Catholic church says somewhere that we do not have these traits, please show me. I think to deny any one of these would be to deny your humanness.
My wonderful SD, a Redemptorist priest, told me on my first visit in 2001 that a whole person has six components: physical, mental, spiritual, emotional, social, and sexual. A healthy person has all six factors in tune.

The reason professionals have such a bad record of healing is they tend to specialize in one or maybe two of those factors, and try to treat a whole person through just that point of view. The Holy Spirit can heal them all, but human experts are too tunnel vision. Not to mention so many of them are process people and aren’t really that good at listening. If we stuff our minds with lots of information about Christianity, that doesn’t necessarily translate into any sort of spiritual movement. It can be all mentally focused, and frankly in the case of apologetics I think it’s easy if not tempting, to be very sterile and intellectual in that regard. 🤓

btw, he (my SD) took sick several years ago and left town for a hospital in Ligouri, MO, now after several years, he’s better and is chaplain for the hospital there at age 88. Go Fr. Gerry!

Alan
 
What is the “spirit”? Is it our attitudes?

I often wonder about this question because I can hear a person say all the right things but they say it in a negative spirit. So that, instead of the good words being heard, the negative spirit gets heard. I can sometimes hear a spirit of anger or condemnation or self-pity. I might agree with what they are saying but the spirit in which they are saying it does not agree with me.

Do you know what I am talking about?

I wonder sometimes, is it what we say or the spirit in which we say it that counts?
Great question Lady Love,
I agree its not in the words. Because some are fake and know how to manipulate words. And others use lots of truth, but have bent intentions.

Paul talks some about discerning the Spirit of people. The woman who for days chanted that Paul and (Luke?) were servants of the most high God. And they proclaim the way of salvation. Then Paul, annoyed by her, tells the “spirit” to leave.

This woman was not helping them. Being a distraction, and not respectfull. This spirit gained her power before and it tried to advance herself in Pauls ministry. But there is no room for personal advancement in preaching the gospel. He must increase and i decrease.

Some debate on this forum because they love to be “right” but are not concerned about getting the person who is asking a question to a better place. And I probably have too.

Some peoples errors in the Lord are obvious while others are not evident until later in time, when it finally comes to light. I hope to bring my errors into light, in confession. Its difficult.

I hope that pertained to your question. I think it does, when considering the spirit that motivates people. Gods spirit takes much effort to conform to. To keep and follow. To hear and obey. The Devils spirit will overcome us and influence us if we do nothing.

Thanks for the good question,
Michael
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top