What is the theological difference depression and despair?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Robert_Sock
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

Robert_Sock

Guest
I know that many claim that despair is a sin, while depression, I assume, is not. The two constructs seem to have a lot in common.
 
I know that many claim that despair is a sin, while depression, I assume, is not. The two constructs seem to have a lot in common.
I think so. They both seem to be related to lack of faith. Despair seems to be a complete loss of faith, while depression seems to be a state of mind that is too focused on the scary things in life and not enough on the good things in life. Peter showed his faith when he saw Jesus walking on water, and started to walk on water himself, but then started to sink when he put his focus on the storm around him instead of Jesus. The scary stuff around us will get us down if that’s all we focus on. But there’s also truth, music, beauty, and sports. And we also need to notice how amazing these are to fight depression. And be grateful to God.
 
depression as far as i understand, it’ an illness. the brain have some chemicals that are not produced right, so you can’t be guilty of depression more than you can be of other sickness.
 
depression as far as i understand, it’ an illness. the brain have some chemicals that are not produced right, so you can’t be guilty of depression more than you can be of other sickness.
Isn’t it common for severely depressed people to often experience despair as a result of depression?
 
Despair is the loss of hope in God’s forgiveness and mercy, it’s the mindset that tells us we are beyond God’s power to save. This is what Judas experienced and what led to him taking his own life after betraying our Lord. It is perhaps the most spiritually devastating problem to succumb to.

Depression is a physical ailment. Some one already mentioned how it can be the result of imbalanced brain chemicals.

Can depression lead/contribute to despair? I’m sure it can, but despairing influenced by depression certainly limits culpability.
 
Isn’t it common for severely depressed people to often experience despair as a result of depression?
I don’t know about common, but otherwise, yup.
I’ll be reading because I wonder about this, too.

It follows that if one has the illness of depression, then the despair that may follow is not a willful act, which, as I understand it, is a factor of the cuplability of sin.
Please correct me as needed; still learning!!
 
I know that many claim that despair is a sin, while depression, I assume, is not. The two constructs seem to have a lot in common.
Depression is a physiological manifestation caused by a chemical inbalance in the brain.
Dispair is the loss or lack of faith and or hope. It is the sin against the Holy Spirit.
 
Depression is a physiological manifestation caused by a chemical inbalance in the brain.
Dispair is the loss or lack of faith and or hope. It is the sin against the Holy Spirit.
Can you feel despair towards life in this world, while experiencing great faith in God and the Hereafter?
 
Can you feel despair towards life in this world, while experiencing great faith in God and the Hereafter?
well, im sure that is a diferent case of despair, not even sure if it might be a sin. yet is no good either.

let me give you an example: in school there are times where at the middle of the semester some student realises that he aint gonna pass certain class, so he loses the hope on it, he does not go to that class anymore, does not make the exams and finally don’t pass, if there was a chance that he could have passed, maybe extra works or something, he just blew it, that is despair. now if you despair on the world maybe if you had one chance of making it better will be lost, and it might be sinful, since you did not did what you should have done.
 
I feel despair in this world, something that goes beyond depression, but I still have a hidden joy in the Hereafter. Is this a sin?
 
The following is from the introduction to The Catholic Guide to Depression by Aaron Kheriaty, MD and Fr. John Cihak, STD.

Depression is a disturbance–often serious and sometimes life-threatening–in a person’s psychological and physical functioning. This description is only a starting point, however, for depression is a complex condition that cannot be described exclusively using a disease-based model alone. The science of medicine has taught us much about depression, but the full story of this affliction is more complicated. Depression is often caused and influenced by, in addition to biological and psychological factors, various social, cultural, and spiritual factors, some quite complex.

Later in the book, p. 76.

Christian doctrine teaches that experiencing an emotion such as sorrow, fear, or anger is not, in and of itself, sinful….The morally relevant question is not, What am I feeling? but rather, What am I going to do with this feeling?…Therefore, merely experiencing depression (or any other physical or emotional state) is not committing a sin.

From CCC 2091.

The first commandment is also concerned with sins against hope, namely, despair and presumption:

By despair, man ceases to hope for his personal salvation from God, for help in attaining it or for the forgiveness of his sins. Despair is contrary to God’s goodness, to his justice – for the Lord is faithful to his promises – and to his mercy.

From an interview with Aaron Kheriaty, MD and Fr. John Cihak, STD, Catholics and Depression, The Catholic World Report, January 02, 2013.

CWR: What are some of the spiritual disorders that lead to depression?

Msgr. Cihak: I think we could begin by observing that sin creates misery. Moral evil is not simply a bad idea; it harms and ruins peoples’ lives. The fundamental spiritual disorder is the choice of sin, which if left unchecked becomes habitual and begins to corrupt and even destroy that vital relationship with the Lord of life who desires our fulfillment and happiness. So being immersed in serious sin can certainly lead one to or hold one in a depressive state.

Dr. Kheriaty: Precisely. I will mention as well the sin of despair, which is contrary to the virtue of hope, and commonly leads to depressive states….
 
The following is from the introduction to The Catholic Guide to Depression by Aaron Kheriaty, MD and Fr. John Cihak, STD.

Depression is a disturbance–often serious and sometimes life-threatening–in a person’s psychological and physical functioning. This description is only a starting point, however, for depression is a complex condition that cannot be described exclusively using a disease-based model alone. The science of medicine has taught us much about depression, but the full story of this affliction is more complicated. Depression is often caused and influenced by, in addition to biological and psychological factors, various social, cultural, and spiritual factors, some quite complex.

Later in the book, p. 76.

Christian doctrine teaches that experiencing an emotion such as sorrow, fear, or anger is not, in and of itself, sinful….The morally relevant question is not, What am I feeling? but rather, What am I going to do with this feeling?…Therefore, merely experiencing depression (or any other physical or emotional state) is not committing a sin.

From CCC 2091.

The first commandment is also concerned with sins against hope, namely, despair and presumption:

By despair, man ceases to hope for his personal salvation from God, for help in attaining it or for the forgiveness of his sins. Despair is contrary to God’s goodness, to his justice – for the Lord is faithful to his promises – and to his mercy.

From an interview with Aaron Kheriaty, MD and Fr. John Cihak, STD, Catholics and Depression, The Catholic World Report, January 02, 2013.

CWR: What are some of the spiritual disorders that lead to depression?

Msgr. Cihak: I think we could begin by observing that sin creates misery. Moral evil is not simply a bad idea; it harms and ruins peoples’ lives. The fundamental spiritual disorder is the choice of sin, which if left unchecked becomes habitual and begins to corrupt and even destroy that vital relationship with the Lord of life who desires our fulfillment and happiness. So being immersed in serious sin can certainly lead one to or hold one in a depressive state.

Dr. Kheriaty: Precisely. I will mention as well the sin of despair, which is contrary to the virtue of hope, and commonly leads to depressive states….
What does “being immersed in serious sin” mean exactly? I think it could mean either one’s own personal sin, but also being immersed in a culture of death (i.e., the sins of others). I would say the latter is a form of oppression. And does that cause some folks to be in a depressive state? I think so.
 
I think so. They both seem to be related to lack of faith. Despair seems to be a complete loss of faith, while depression seems to be a state of mind that is too focused on the scary things in life and not enough on the good things in life. Peter showed his faith when he saw Jesus walking on water, and started to walk on water himself, but then started to sink when he put his focus on the storm around him instead of Jesus. The scary stuff around us will get us down if that’s all we focus on. But there’s also truth, music, beauty, and sports. And we also need to notice how amazing these are to fight depression. And be grateful to God.
Depression is not related to a lack of faith. One can be fully in faith, and suffer from depression. It is a physical ailment, manifested emotionally. Please do not ever say depression is related to a lack of faith. There is a difference between ‘feeling depressed’ (short term, often common in many people’s lives, but not life threatening) and ‘depression’ (can be long term, can be life threatening or longer term life altering). When at the depths of my depression, not prayer, truth, music, beauty or sports could make me better. Medicine did, the same as it would someone with cancer, diabetes, a broken leg and other illnesses or injuries. Telling a depressed person to be grateful to God, or for anything, will only make them feel even worse. I’m not angry at you for writing this, so please do not be offended; it’s the world I’m angry at, that teaches us that depression isn’t real, and that music, sports, art, beauty, can make us ‘better’, if only we just wanted it. 😦 😦 😦
depression as far as i understand, it’ an illness. the brain have some chemicals that are not produced right, so you can’t be guilty of depression more than you can be of other sickness.
Exactly.
Depression is a physiological manifestation caused by a chemical imbalance in the brain.
Exactly.

Depression can be a deadly disease, a terminal disease. Sometimes, the ‘cure’ is almost worse than the disease. It’s a tough spot; St. Dymhpna, pray for us.
 
Depression is not related to a lack of faith. One can be fully in faith, and suffer from depression. It is a physical ailment, manifested emotionally. Please do not ever say depression is related to a lack of faith. There is a difference between ‘feeling depressed’ (short term, often common in many people’s lives, but not life threatening) and ‘depression’ (can be long term, can be life threatening or longer term life altering). When at the depths of my depression, not prayer, truth, music, beauty or sports could make me better. Medicine did, the same as it would someone with cancer, diabetes, a broken leg and other illnesses or injuries. Telling a depressed person to be grateful to God, or for anything, will only make them feel even worse. I’m not angry at you for writing this, so please do not be offended; it’s the world I’m angry at, that teaches us that depression isn’t real, and that music, sports, art, beauty, can make us ‘better’, if only we just wanted it.
I’m not a psychologist. And the thread title isn’t asking a psychological question. It’s asking a theological/spiritual question. I can only speak for my own situation. Medicine is one way to treat that works for some people. That wasn’t my path. My path was more fellowship with other serious Christians, regular exercise, more music, less political talk radio. I can tell you that in my own case I was so focused on the evil in the world that I was in a state of anxiety/depression that lasted for years. The way out for me was not medicine. It was finding the right mental balance and changing my focus to the good things I mentioned. I had no joy. I had plenty of anger and fear. Now I have joy. I still have anger. But alot less fear. The other thing that helped in my healing was praying the words of the psalm over and over…“Be still and know that I am God.” I don’t have anxiety anymore…I am learning to trust in God more and myself less. I feel a heavy burden has been lifted. So my problem was a lack of trust in God…a lack of faith (not no faith)…and reversing this is a path that is working for me. God Bless. I’m not offended.
 
I’m not a psychologist. And the thread title isn’t asking a psychological question. It’s asking a theological/spiritual question. I can only speak for my own situation. Medicine is one way to treat that works for some people. That wasn’t my path. My path was more fellowship with other serious Christians, regular exercise, more music, less political talk radio. I can tell you that in my own case I was so focused on the evil in the world that I was in a state of anxiety/depression that lasted for years. The way out for me was not medicine. It was finding the right mental balance and changing my focus to the good things I mentioned. I had no joy. I had plenty of anger and fear. Now I have joy. I still have anger. But alot less fear. The other thing that helped in my healing was praying the words of the psalm over and over…“Be still and know that I am God.” I don’t have anxiety anymore…I am learning to trust in God more and myself less. I feel a heavy burden has been lifted. So my problem was a lack of trust in God…a lack of faith (not no faith)…and reversing this is a path that is working for me. God Bless. I’m not offended.
That was inspirational.
 
I know that many claim that despair is a sin, while depression, I assume, is not. The two constructs seem to have a lot in common.
I believe that depression leads to despair.
However, if that is your problem don’t be concerned about it.
What you are going through may be a symptom of repentance.
Repentance can make one feel sad, but that pain is what God answers to.
What ever it is forgive yourself,
Louise
 
For the record:
Any medical condition is not a sin. Cancer is not a sin. A broken arm is not a sin.

Whether your depression is medically related, or not, is not for me, or any of us to decide.

Medical depression cannot be cured by a simple walk, exercise or friends.

Depression (the blues) is a different animal with the same name (unfortunately).
 
For the record:
Any medical condition is not a sin. Cancer is not a sin. A broken arm is not a sin.

Whether your depression is medically related, or not, is not for me, or any of us to decide.

Medical depression cannot be cured by a simple walk, exercise or friends.

Depression (the blues) is a different animal with the same name (unfortunately).
Also for the record, in my case, the healing I experienced wasn’t overnight. It was more of a day by day process. Without going into too many details, he took me out of my comfort zone, and I experienced even more anxiety. But that was temporary. He wanted me to KNOW that he loves me and I can trust him. He is teaching me to let Go and let God. St Paul talks about the Peace that the world can’t give. I KNOW what he’s talking about. Three years ago, I couldn’t say that. My life is still kind of broken. But I’m worrying less about the details. I KNOW he’s working on those too. And I now have the realization that I’ve been blessed in so many ways. For years, I took these blessings for granted…kind of a sense of entitlement attitude. I also had to learn to let go of bitterness. Bitterness is unforgiveness. If I want to be forgiven, I have to stop my mind from going there. That state of mind and not trusting in God was a sin in my case. Jesus went to the cross, like a lamb lead to the slaughter he opened not his mouth. If I’m his follower, why should I expect to be treated any better than him? I had to learn to lower some expectations of the people in my life. Sinners sin. Get over it. Anyway, God Bless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top