What should I do here?

  • Thread starter Thread starter NewsTheMan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s in the way you present the story. You corrected a wrong. That was good but you continually present him as the annoying guy who didn’t agree. That’s why it seems like your ego. Absolutely no compassion for his point of view.

It’s likely in your presentation that is causing the problem. He no longer feels comfortable and even though he was wrong in his statement you continue to just say “I’m right I’m right I’m right” which is true, but it isn’t the point. The point is that he is somehow completely uncomfortable with you and your approach and since he is outnumbered wants to discuss it. I could be that he has gone to the preist and the priest has answered with a bunch of “i dunno…ask NTM” and when the guy figured he couldn’t asked the priest…or the guy was whining about feeling depressed and ostracized and the priest suggested that you all meet.

What gets me about this is that this is basically a meeting with a priest and another person. A PRIEST. He’s not having you talk to him with a buddy, or a counceller or a poliece officer. And the priest has agreed to it, so unless the priest is a complete moron (which you haven’t thusfar indicated) then I can’t see how this is any more than a conversation with a witness.

Actually, in the Bible it says that if your neighbor/brother has wronged you go to him. (which he did) and if he dosn’t than bring along a friend. He has done wrong by spreading his hate to others…so that’s wrong. But for crying out loud just meet with the guy.

You’re close to reporting me…that’s a lark. The mods would more likely tell you to bug off and not annoy them. I stand by my caveman remark. You do seem more like a caveman grunting over killing a attacking racoon and expecting adulation than a gentelman who corrected a wrong and cares about the impact he makes on others.
👍 Suck it up - go to your meeting.

Be a grown up it is what college is for. If you do this in the real world you will get fired.

By the way purplesunshine is a woman so if we are going to toss cheap insults at least make them gender specific!
 
Liturgical questions of the type you are describing aren’t subject to democratic vote, unanimous vote, or any other vote of a liturgy committee. A liturgy committee’s job is to make decisions within the latitude provided by the boundaries of rubric. If there are any questions whatsoever by anyone on the committee about what those boundaries are, a committee that does not already have a liturgical expert on it should consult one.

The only question, then, is whether you have correctly interpreted the Church documents. By that I mean according to your bishop, who is the chief liturgist in your diocese, usually as judged by your priest, the person given liturgical oversight of your parish, church, chapel, or planned Mass.

In other words, this is not something to be decided by forum. Either the bishop, usually in the person of your priest, comes down on your side (that is, this is non-negotiably a boundary issue) or the other guy’s side (that is, the fellow opposing you is standing on ground that is outside your opinion but not outside the bishop’s opinion of where the boundary is.) In any event, it is not about you, and it is not about him. It is about a liturgy committee that has a good-faith question, taking it to the priest with authority over the liturgy. Were I you, I would ask the committee to take the general stance that if even one member is in doubt about the appropriateness of something or other that the question automatically be taken to an actual liturgical authority for your diocese who can give an educated answer. The first person that ought to be is the priest with pastoral care of the church or chapel or Newman Center. Only after he has been consulted should anyone else be brought in.

I would consent to have each of you discuss the issue privately with the priest, and the priest decides and explains the situation to the liturgy committee. Otherwise, the priest could be invited to a liturgy committee meeting to discuss the matter of rubrics. If one of you two does not like that, you either resign from the committee or request that the priest confirm his answer with the Liturgy Office in your diocese. I would not blame anyone for resigning from a committee that violates his personal conscience on an issue.

It would have to be a rather serious abuse before I’d take it farther than that, but that is just me. Since I don’t know exactly what the issues are, I can’t say for sure what I’d do in your situation. Certainly, there are liturgical issues for which people are willing to go to the Vatican, in order to get their bishop to stand up for what Rome has decreed. I hope for your sake that none of this needs to go that far.

That’s what I’d suggest on the liturgical issue. The other issue is personal and political. Consult with the priest about how to handle that, encourage him to ask questions and be very frank with you, consider very carefully what he has to say, pray about it, and if you are not inclined to take his advice, then promise that you will consult a second priest about the problem. Do not do your consulting with the parties involved. You want experienced advice from someone with an eternal perspective and unquestionable ability to remain discrete. Do not give any fodder to the rumor mill. Do not pass on or accept any more second-hand accounts of what other people feel, except to encourage anyone with an issue to feel safe in approaching you about it directly. Do not give your opinion about the situation and especially do not give your opinion of others to third parties.

PS If the fellow in question has said nothing to you directly, you really do not know what he’s said or what he has thought in the past, let alone what he thinks now. Make that your stance: Until he or someone authorized to act on his behalf approaches you, his inner life is none of your business. Surely you would want him to be just as discrete and just as unwilling to jump to conclusions about you based on rumors, were the situation reversed.
 
1ke saves me so much typing. i’m happy-- i’m trying to get another week out of this cheapo nail job…

no matter what: skip the forum.

have a beer with the guy if he will. if he won’t just let it go.
 
Before I reply individually I want to make something clear, because some people just aren’t getting it and are too busy making their own judgements:

The “forum” has nothing to do with the Liturgical changes I suggested. It has to do with his disliking me. Furthermore, he, as far as I know, didn’t suggest the forum, it was other members of the commitee who suggested it after he told them he doesn’t like me. So it was their suggestion. So I told them well, thats silly, tell him to man up and speak to me, and they replied that I should think about having a forum and so I came on CAF. Again - the liturgical changes have nothing to do with this “forum” (forum isn’t even the right word, I’m just using it as they used it, its more like an intervention). The Comm accepted it - and in fact it wasn’t even about “accepting”, some things had to change. Whether they (or you) like it or not, thats just the way it goes. Now - if you are so quick to judge that you think the way I presented this to them is the same as how I presented it online here, you need to think about it for a second. I’m sure some of you would love it if I presented it to them in an uncharitable, forceful manner, almost like I am doing here. But there’s a big difference between internet world and story explanation and real life.

Phew.
 
Hi

I think we interpreted this as being related to the liturgical changes, because you said that after the changes were made, you got an email from this guy, which was nasty:
He sent me a rather vitriolic email. Basically, without judgement, he is poorly catechized. He asked me why I am so “ancient” and “addicted to Rome” and spoke about me kind of badly and questioned the writings of the Popes, but I just showed him the facts and explained our religion is ancient and Rome (Vatican, rather) is Rome for a reason, and Pope is Pope for a reason. Anyway I wasn’t too affected I was just like well a slight disagreement whatever.
It seems to me that his feelings about you are related to the liturgical issues. Perhaps it is not based on whether you were right or wrong, but how you came off. You said yourself that you are
pretty big guy and to be fair I can come off as, um, ‘hardcore’ and unapproachable and I am a ‘mans man’ in that I am upfront about things etc etc
so I am not surprised that if he feels he still wants to say something, he wants a third party there so he doesn’t feel “steamrolled.”

I think by claiming that the issues brought up in Committee have nothing to do with whether he likes you or not, you are being somewhat disingenuous.
 
Hi

I think we interpreted this as being related to the liturgical changes, because you said that after the changes were made, you got an email from this guy, which was nasty:

It seems to me that his feelings about you are related to the liturgical issues. Perhaps it is not based on whether you were right or wrong, but how you came off. You said yourself that you are

so I am not surprised that if he feels he still wants to say something, he wants a third party there so he doesn’t feel “steamrolled.”

I think by claiming that the issues brought up in Committee have nothing to do with whether he likes you or not, you are being somewhat disingenuous.
I think I agree.

His dislike of me is related. But related differently than how I think people are taking it.

I think many of you are imagining in your head all these things I’ve done and the evil ways I’ve gone about it.

My contact with him is limited to this:

Presentation of documents citing why/what/how needs to be changed (to all the committee)
His email to me telling me I’m wrong and I am making the Church archaic and “Roman” (i.e. less evangelical, as our Mass had a lot of problems in that way)
My email back saying the documents are there and if he wants to argue he must take it to the Bishop.

Then, months later he hates me.

Now I can only imagine what everybody is thinking - that “oh you definitely sent him a really mean reply”. No. I sent him a reply telling him that I stick to what I cited, and any further questions should be taken to the Bishop, and that unfortunately we are a Church steeped in history and a Church that is guided by Magisterial rules we must obey.

Now, I am not stupid, nor am I disingenious or self-decieving. I know when I have done something wrong, or something to offend, or something that is my fault. And I would openly say it.

But in this case - I genuinly have done nothing. The reason he dislikes me so intensely is because (not even publically) I corrected him (or rather, the Pope(s) and the Magisterium did, I just pointed out what they said). How is that my problem? I know he dislikes me because people do like me and agree with me. I know he dislikes me because he can’t get over the fact that I am more clued up then he is (that isn’t arrogance, nor boast, I say that online, not to everybody else, but its just a fact)

I am not fooling myself here. I came online precisely because I was not fooling myself - I know I have done zero wrong to this fellow, it is he who has done more wrong.

Except, as sometimes expected, people assign roles in their heads of people - and some posters have taken me to be this club weilding caveman going around shouting at people and telling them to kneel before me.

Let me tell you - I make an effort to like people and chat to people and be friendly to all, especially my Catholic brethren. If someone intensely dislikes me how must I help that? And that isn’t an immature rhetorical question - its a sincere statement made because I honestly cannot fathom where this guy comes off speaking about me badly and blaming his problems on me.
 
I think I agree.

His dislike of me is related. But related differently than how I think people are taking it.

I think many of you are imagining in your head all these things I’ve done and the evil ways I’ve gone about it.

My contact with him is limited to this:

Presentation of documents citing why/what/how needs to be changed (to all the committee)
His email to me telling me I’m wrong and I am making the Church archaic and “Roman” (i.e. less evangelical, as our Mass had a lot of problems in that way)
My email back saying the documents are there and if he wants to argue he must take it to the Bishop.

Then, months later he hates me.

Now I can only imagine what everybody is thinking - that “oh you definitely sent him a really mean reply”. No. I sent him a reply telling him that I stick to what I cited, and any further questions should be taken to the Bishop, and that unfortunately we are a Church steeped in history and a Church that is guided by Magisterial rules we must obey.

Now, I am not stupid, nor am I disingenious or self-decieving. I know when I have done something wrong, or something to offend, or something that is my fault. And I would openly say it.

But in this case - I genuinly have done nothing. The reason he dislikes me so intensely is because (not even publically) I corrected him (or rather, the Pope(s) and the Magisterium did, I just pointed out what they said). How is that my problem? I know he dislikes me because people do like me and agree with me. I know he dislikes me because he can’t get over the fact that I am more clued up then he is (that isn’t arrogance, nor boast, I say that online, not to everybody else, but its just a fact)

I am not fooling myself here. I came online precisely because I was not fooling myself - I know I have done zero wrong to this fellow, it is he who has done more wrong.

Except, as sometimes expected, people assign roles in their heads of people - and some posters have taken me to be this club weilding caveman going around shouting at people and telling them to kneel before me.

Let me tell you - I make an effort to like people and chat to people and be friendly to all, especially my Catholic brethren. If someone intensely dislikes me how must I help that? And that isn’t an immature rhetorical question - its a sincere statement made because I honestly cannot fathom where this guy comes off speaking about me badly and blaming his problems on me.
So follow the Biblical instruction - you, him, and the priest and be done with it so this can stop disrupting the group…
 
Hey News,

Rough situation you have there. Nothing is more drama-filled than college campus ministries!! I feel you, I’ve been there. But remember that even now God is preparing you go out and serve in a parish, where you will undoubtedly encounter many like the young man you are describing. Other men have not had the fortune you’ve had in developing a great deal of confidence or a strong sense of their Catholic identity, and it is your duty to be kind and compassionate (not that you haven’t been so, just a gentle reminder…).

I think you could have the meeting. Although I agree that you are right, that this meeting may be unnecessary, that it’s bowing to pressure–there is nothing to be lost by this meeting. I realize a concern about an awkward situation with the priest (been there too!!), so go in with the intention of staying focused on the personal interaction between you two. Explain that you don’t want to debate the issues, but want to talk about ensuring your Catholic community is a place where disagreements occur respectfully.

This could be difficult; the priest could fail to back you up. The young man could spread lies or continue talk about you behind your back even if you do meet with him. But so long as you treat it as no big deal, are forthcoming and humble, and stick to your guns, I think you’ll be the better for it. Remember, if you are persecuted, you are being treated just as Christ was!

I see where your confusion comes from and I am inclined as well to say, “there’s nothing to have a meeting about. Stop being ridiculous.” But you lose nothing by meeting with this guy on his terms, so long as you go into it with a peaceful and charitable spirit.

Best of luck, friend! 🙂
 
Hey News,

Rough situation you have there. Nothing is more drama-filled than college campus ministries!! I feel you, I’ve been there. But remember that even now God is preparing you go out and serve in a parish, where you will undoubtedly encounter many like the young man you are describing. Other men have not had the fortune you’ve had in developing a great deal of confidence or a strong sense of their Catholic identity, and it is your duty to be kind and compassionate (not that you haven’t been so, just a gentle reminder…).

I think you could have the meeting. Although I agree that you are right, that this meeting may be unnecessary, that it’s bowing to pressure–there is nothing to be lost by this meeting. I realize a concern about an awkward situation with the priest (been there too!!), so go in with the intention of staying focused on the personal interaction between you two. Explain that you don’t want to debate the issues, but want to talk about ensuring your Catholic community is a place where disagreements occur respectfully.

This could be difficult; the priest could fail to back you up. The young man could spread lies or continue talk about you behind your back even if you do meet with him. But so long as you treat it as no big deal, are forthcoming and humble, and stick to your guns, I think you’ll be the better for it. Remember, if you are persecuted, you are being treated just as Christ was!

I see where your confusion comes from and I am inclined as well to say, “there’s nothing to have a meeting about. Stop being ridiculous.” But you lose nothing by meeting with this guy on his terms, so long as you go into it with a peaceful and charitable spirit.

Best of luck, friend! 🙂
Thank you! This just made a whole lotta sense. I guess I’ll go through with it then, sigh. Drama drama drama!
 
Thank you! This just made a whole lotta sense. I guess I’ll go through with it then, sigh. Drama drama drama!
Better to learn how to handle the drama now, because it is EVERYWHERE. Don’t think this is something that does not happen after college. Personality conflicts will happen wherever and whenever a group of people meet to discuss interests. In fact, some of the worst drama situations I’ve experienced have taken place in parent clubs, so you have that to look forward to if you ever plan to have a family.
 
Thank you! This just made a whole lotta sense. I guess I’ll go through with it then, sigh. Drama drama drama!
I think maybe you might want to read about what Protestants go through 😉 in many cases from what I have heard, Protestant congregations choose their minister. They have a much more ‘voting’ style of working things out than Catholics tend to do. There is always at least one person and maybe several on a committee who are going to be difficult for one reason or other. In one case I read, a Quaker minister refused to let one or two women join a church committee b/c he correctly predicted that they were already so adversarial, they would do nothing but cause trouble.

To me it doesn’t matter who is right or what the history is, committees involve situations like this. It’s rarer than it should be that an entire group agrees on something important without a significant amount of arguing. For an example, you could read A Man Called Peter which is about Peter Marshall who was a charismatic Presbyterian minister of a church in Washington, DC and the Senate chaplain. This book is set in the 40s and 50s but the issues are still the same. Although he was charismatic and preached great sermons, so much so that the church started overflowing with people and they had to add more services, he experienced significant conflict on committees and had to deal with it in different ways. It’s maybe not so much a reflection on you as that in a group, often not everyone gets along.
 
I would meet this guy with the priest. If you’ve got a priest whose going to take sides with him and that’s what you’re concerned about, than you’ve got a much larger issue here than this guy.

I think the only reason people are saying you’re sounding egotistical is because you’re getting so defensive on this forum about “But I’m in the right.” You keep saying you’ll consider things, but you’re on the defensive of asserting your rightness.

It doesn’t matter how silly this guy is being. The priest should be there as a mediator, not as a person who takes either side. Sometimes just arguing the facts comes across as mean and people’s emotions need to be dealt with.
 
Do you mean to say that this has nothing to do with the liturgical issue? Feel free to resign yourself to the fact that not every otherwise fine person in the world is going to like you. Feel free to tell those busy bodies to butt out and allow two grown men to handle their own problems, thank you very much. For all you know, the other guy will greatly thank you. That’s all he needs is to have his friends stage an intervention every time he decides to carry a grudge. Even if he would like it, it is not good for him. Good grief.

It does not mean we have sinned when someone decides to get their nose bent out of shape or dislikes us. Not everybody is going to like you. Jesus had more enemies than you can shake a stick at, so obviously there is no sin required for someone to find an excuse to hate you. Besides, “not liking” is not incompatible with the fullness of charity. Not even all the monks in a monastery expect to like everyone else. In fact, if you are ever in a situation where everyone seems to like you, or even where everyone you very much want to impress seems to like you, I’d think an examination of conscience would be in order over whether you are an amiable person in a generally amiable group or whether you duck legitmate duties in order to curry favor. Just a prudent check for a prevalent danger, that’s all I’m saying.

It doesn’t matter if you did send him a nasty e-mail (excepting that if you did I would hope you would have apologized to him directly by now).

Codependence is defined by some as the “unhealthy psychological dependence of one person on another.” Go to someone who knows something about co-dependence, if you have to, in order to learn the psycho-lingo way of saying it that will get through to them what you’re saying, but reject the efforts of those who are inappropriately injecting themselves into this situation. They really need to encourage everyone involved to deal with their own problems directly, and to otherwise mind their own business. Trust me, you will not cure drama-addicts by giving them dramas to feed on.

If this guy has never talked to you, then you don’t know what he feels. It is all second-hand gossip. Treat it as such. If the guy comes to you and wants to meet with you or with you and a priest, great. If someone says, “He asked me to ask you if you would talk with him”, great. Otherwise, very respectfully say that the best thing for healthy adults to do is for those who have issues to handle those issues directly themselves, and* to respect the right of others to decide whether or not to deal with their own issues or not*. Surely we all learned in sixth grade that indirect or covert aggression and the alliance-building go-between mode is a drama-filled disaster waiting to happen. Adults do not go looking for an intermediary until normal direct modes of communication have been tried and found wanting. Healthy adults allow other people to manage their own emotional lives. Your own mothers should not be intervening in this situation.

This has nothing to do with being “manly”, and I would not use terms of that sort, lest someone use it as a pretext for taking offense. Grown women need to learn to use direct communication, too. Also, grown people need to realize that adults who do not particularly like each other are perfectly capable of working together. Adults who treat each other in a civilized manner but who do not like each other do not need to be made to like each other! That is an immature view. An adult can learn to accept the fact that not everyone they like is going to like each other. Don’t let anyone suck you back into a childish anxiety over the inevitable conflicts in life. That is a useless anxiety that is too easily manipulated, besides.

If the people trying to inject themselves want a forum with a priest, tell them you would be happy to take *them *in for a forum with the priest, if they want one, in order to convince them to butt out. If they don’t want your help in fixing themselves, though, tell them they have no business trying to fix the relationship between you and this other man. (And do always refer to him as a man. Bend over backwards to show this guy respect when you talk about him in any context, trust me on that one. Every word you say will get back to him.)
 
What should I do here?
I really like this guy and I want to know if you think he likes me back. Here are some signs:
  1. We’ve hung out every weekend for the past 5 weeks (he’s asked me to more than I’ve asked him)
  2. When we’re walking and talking, he looks at me a lot
  3. When we talk, he looks at my mouth alot
  4. A few times we’ve hung out with his friend and his friend seems to be playing wingman (like once i asked the guy a question and he didn’t hear me, and his friend said “she asked u something”)
  5. On my birthday he texted me in lieu of just writing it on my facebook
  6. When we hang out in a group, he always walks/sits next to me and once we got separated from the others and he made no effort in finding them and asked me to sit and talk to just him for a while
  7. A few times we’ve talked and he’s sorta given me that look that guys give when they like you.
The thing is, he hasn’t asked me on a date and he doesn’t call me to chat. He’s texted me once or twice though. He always returns all of my texts.

Does he like me? Should I show him I like him, and if so, how should I do that??
 
What should I do here?
I really like this guy and I want to know if you think he likes me back. Here are some signs:
  1. We’ve hung out every weekend for the past 5 weeks (he’s asked me to more than I’ve asked him)
  2. When we’re walking and talking, he looks at me a lot
  3. When we talk, he looks at my mouth alot
  4. A few times we’ve hung out with his friend and his friend seems to be playing wingman (like once i asked the guy a question and he didn’t hear me, and his friend said “she asked u something”)
  5. On my birthday he texted me in lieu of just writing it on my facebook
  6. When we hang out in a group, he always walks/sits next to me and once we got separated from the others and he made no effort in finding them and asked me to sit and talk to just him for a while
  7. A few times we’ve talked and he’s sorta given me that look that guys give when they like you.
The thing is, he hasn’t asked me on a date and he doesn’t call me to chat. He’s texted me once or twice though. He always returns all of my texts.

Does he like me? Should I show him I like him, and if so, how should I do that??
With all due respect, you should start a separate thread.
 
I think I agree.

His dislike of me is related. But related differently than how I think people are taking it.

I think many of you are imagining in your head all these things I’ve done and the evil ways I’ve gone about it.

My contact with him is limited to this:

Presentation of documents citing why/what/how needs to be changed (to all the committee)
His email to me telling me I’m wrong and I am making the Church archaic and “Roman” (i.e. less evangelical, as our Mass had a lot of problems in that way)
My email back saying the documents are there and if he wants to argue he must take it to the Bishop.

Then, months later he hates me.

Now I can only imagine what everybody is thinking - that “oh you definitely sent him a really mean reply”. No. I sent him a reply telling him that I stick to what I cited, and any further questions should be taken to the Bishop, and that unfortunately we are a Church steeped in history and a Church that is guided by Magisterial rules we must obey.

Now, I am not stupid, nor am I disingenious or self-decieving. I know when I have done something wrong, or something to offend, or something that is my fault. And I would openly say it.

But in this case - I genuinly have done nothing. The reason he dislikes me so intensely is because (not even publically) I corrected him (or rather, the Pope(s) and the Magisterium did, I just pointed out what they said). How is that my problem? I know he dislikes me because people do like me and agree with me. I know he dislikes me because he can’t get over the fact that I am more clued up then he is (that isn’t arrogance, nor boast, I say that online, not to everybody else, but its just a fact)

I am not fooling myself here. I came online precisely because I was not fooling myself - I know I have done zero wrong to this fellow, it is he who has done more wrong.

Except, as sometimes expected, people assign roles in their heads of people - and some posters have taken me to be this club weilding caveman going around shouting at people and telling them to kneel before me.

Let me tell you - I make an effort to like people and chat to people and be friendly to all, especially my Catholic brethren. If someone intensely dislikes me how must I help that? And that isn’t an immature rhetorical question - its a sincere statement made because I honestly cannot fathom where this guy comes off speaking about me badly and blaming his problems on me.
Hi again

Just to clarify, when I said you were being somewhat disingenuous, I was referring specifically to post #24, where you expressed an opinion that the “forum” he wants has nothing to do with the liturgical issues.

I must say, I do agree with you that his dislike of you is not your fault, nor is it your responsibility to solve his problem. Not everyone has to like everyone, we just have to be respectful and civil.

I would also go so far as to say, on the face of it, from what you have posted here, he sounds somewhat unstable. Unfortunately, the world is full of people like this, and I think your instinct to just want to stay drama-free is a good one.

As far as your interpreataion of why he dislikes you (I bolded above in the quote), is this what your other committee members have told you? Or just your feeling about what he is thinking?

I think if you decided to go to the forum, it would be in order to smooth things out for the committee, to just ease the tension. Of course, you could also just shoot off an email to him, saying your getting some feedback from people that there is a problem, and you’d like to know, what is it in reference to? Because if it’s to further argue the points already decided, there’s really no point in it. If he wants to tell you in front of a priest that he doesn’t like you, there’s no point in that either. I’d be curious how he would reply.
 
Of course, you could also just shoot off an email to him, saying your getting some feedback from people that there is a problem, and you’d like to know, what is it in reference to? Because if it’s to further argue the points already decided, there’s really no point in it. If he wants to tell you in front of a priest that he doesn’t like you, there’s no point in that either. I’d be curious how he would reply.
With all due respect, the fewer things in our lives of emotional import are communicated via e-mail, the better. As soon as we know a topic is having or is likely to have emotional repercusions, we ought to take care of it in person, or at least by phone. I wouldn’t even write letters–how many overwrought letters should never have been sent?–but certainly no e-mail. A letter, if sent, would be very much to the point, a prelude to in-person communication: “I have been told by a third party that you are upset with me. If this is not true, then I am relieved to hear it. Please disregard this. If you are upset with me, I hope we’ll get a chance to talk about it in person and try to clear it up. Please let me know, if you’re at all interested in that. Regards, NewsTheMan”

Writing is a very good way to sort out our own feelings. Once written out, though, shred the writing and talk them out.
 
News the Man,

With difficult people, sometimes one must ask “Is he/she worth the effort?” - kind of like shaking the dust off your feet. Only you can answer this question.
So follow the Biblical instruction - you, him, and the priest and be done with it so this can stop disrupting the group…
I believe the first step in the biblical instruction was to meet one-on-one, and if that does not resolve the situation , then involve third parties. Unless I’v emissed something, News is still trying to do the one-on-one thing.
 
News the Man,

With difficult people, sometimes one must ask “Is he/she worth the effort?” - kind of like shaking the dust off your feet. Only you can answer this question.
Often, it is often not even a matter of whether they are worth the effort, but whether the effort has any likelihood of being rewarded. Or, as a friend used to say:
“You can’t teach a pig to sing. You just frustrate yourself and annoy the pig.”

It doesn’t matter if you are the pig or the music teacher. If this is your situation, opt out.
 
With all due respect, the fewer things in our lives of emotional import are communicated via e-mail, the better. As soon as we know a topic is having or is likely to have emotional repercusions, we ought to take care of it in person, or at least by phone. I wouldn’t even write letters–how many overwrought letters should never have been sent?–but certainly no e-mail. A letter, if sent, would be very much to the point, a prelude to in-person communication: “I have been told by a third party that you are upset with me. If this is not true, then I am relieved to hear it. Please disregard this. If you are upset with me, I hope we’ll get a chance to talk about it in person and try to clear it up. Please let me know, if you’re at all interested in that. Regards, NewsTheMan”

Writing is a very good way to sort out our own feelings. Once written out, though, shred the writing and talk them out.
While I agree with your overall point, I suggested email because I suspected that the other fellow is intimidated by the OP. I thought a phone call or in person meeting would be difficult, and that was why he wanted the priest there. I thought an email asking about the nature of the problem might give the OP more information first hand, rather than just taking the third party gossip at face value.

Of course, I could be wrong. Hard to say when only knowing one side of the story.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top