What should Luther have done?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Contrabass101
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Contrabass101

Guest
I am currently trying to wrap my head around the Reformation period, and I got to think about something, that I think is quite essential.

Luther, as opposed to the radical reformers, did not intend to become a schismatic, nor did he believe he was in disagreement with the actual Church Teachings, Tradition or Scripture. However reluctant, Luther came to a break with the Catholic Church. Again, Luther didn’t per se “break away”; rather he was excommunicated. The relevant historical document for this is the papal bull Exsurge Domine, which lists 41 “theses” that were condemned as heretical.

Luther burned the papal bull, and held fast to his teachings for the rest of his life.

It is arguable, how much Luther actually disagreed with the Catholic Church, and when he is just using different wording for the same thing (obvious example, faith alone should be understood in contrast to the via moderna school which everyone thought was a cool thing at the time, but which turned out to be heretical)

What I am wondering is, what should Luther have done in order to remain a good Catholic? Revoked the 41 theses condemned in Exsurge Domine? Listened closer to his spiritual director, Staupitz? Something else? Something more?

What might be the reasons he didn’t do that?

And please, keep Luther-bashing at an absolute minimum. And if you don’t know the difference between Luther and Calvin, please don’t reply to this thread at all 🙂
  • CB
 
I am currently trying to wrap my head around the Reformation period, and I got to think about something, that I think is quite essential.

Luther, as opposed to the radical reformers, did not intend to become a schismatic, nor did he believe he was in disagreement with the actual Church Teachings, Tradition or Scripture. However reluctant, Luther came to a break with the Catholic Church. Again, Luther didn’t per se “break away”; rather he was excommunicated. The relevant historical document for this is the papal bull Exsurge Domine, which lists 41 “theses” that were condemned as heretical.

Luther burned the papal bull, and held fast to his teachings for the rest of his life.

It is arguable, how much Luther actually disagreed with the Catholic Church, and when he is just using different wording for the same thing (obvious example, faith alone should be understood in contrast to the via moderna school which everyone thought was a cool thing at the time, but which turned out to be heretical)

What I am wondering is, what should Luther have done in order to remain a good Catholic? Revoked the 41 theses condemned in Exsurge Domine? Listened closer to his spiritual director, Staupitz? Something else? Something more?

What might be the reasons he didn’t do that?

And please, keep Luther-bashing at an absolute minimum. And if you don’t know the difference between Luther and Calvin, please don’t reply to this thread at all 🙂
  • CB
Hi Contrabass 🙂

What an exciting time for you! It is such a blessing that you are seeking so honestly for answers to your questions!

I am by no means the authority on this issue, but I wanted to offer what little I could.

I will use an analogy… Let’s say that I noticed something going on that I knew to be against church teachings. Say my parish was starting to sell indulgences.
I would first need to speak with the priest. If he didn’t listen, I would need to take it to the bishop. And if the “corruption” was going all the way through the hierarchy, I would need to humbly and with much prayer continue to serve Christ as best I could, and pray for the corruption to stop.
See…the problem is that, I think Luther (and many who see corruption in the church…take the recent scandals for example) tend to see these things happening and fail to realize that while there may be corupt things going on in the church…the CHURCH herself, will never waiver. While during luther’s time, indulgences were being sold, the practice was NEVER condoned by the church.
Code:
Christ promised that even the gates of the netherworld would never prevail against the church.  The holy spirit protects the truth and promises the gift of infallibility.  But what this gift doesn't promise, is that the pope will ever be perfect. We've had some popes who were not very "nice" people, and we've had some things happen within the church that were not so great.
Luther wasn’t wrong in searching scriptures and finding things he disagreed with. He wasn’t wrong in recognizing the corruption within the church. His mistake, was in the pride of taking his interpretations of scripture, and without the gift of infallibility, BELIEVING them to be the truth, against Christ’s church.
We are encouraged to search scriptures, to ask questions, and to seek truth. But it takes humility to accept that while we may not always understand or immediately agree with all church teaching, we must trust God to reveal and open our hearts to His truth, in His time.

Luther, to remain a “good catholic,” would have done better to commit himself to prayer and open his heart so that God would reveal the answers to the questions he found in scripture. To seek the sacrament of reconcilliation, and continue to trust in God, above his own ideas.

I know I didn’t delve into history too deeply in this post, but the general impression I’ve gotten the more I read on luther and the reformation, is that he was a very intelligent man, but his sin was in forgetting to temper his gift of intelligence with humility.

HTH!

God bless 🙂
 
Luther came to his postions largely because he did not deal with scrupulosity in a good way. His postions freed him from his over scrupulous mind. Perhaps his confessor did not give him the right direction, but then he should have sought another spiritual director. I honestly think he should have sought humility, his writings indicate a lack thereof.
If he was truly convinced that what he held was actually chruch teaching, he should have continued to dialogue with church officials.
 
Luther came to his postions largely because he did not deal with scrupulosity in a good way. His postions freed him from his over scrupulous mind.
It is for freedom that Christ has set us free.
If he was truly convinced that what he held was actually chruch teaching, he should have continued to dialogue with church officials.
He wanted to. That is what the theses were all about. He wanted to dialogue.
 
While I agree, that Luther could have used a bit more… tact, I still think there were some very valid issues, that needed to be addressed. Luther found himself suddenly in a lot of mess, having to defend himself from various sides, picking up theology as he went (it seems). He “grew” out of the Church gradually, rather than breaking away from it suddenly.

But what I wanted to find out is, when exactly did he cross the line?

When discussing these matters with Lutheran friends, we generally agree that the Church was very corrupt, that there were bad acts and bad teachings (not doctrine) all over the place. We agree that Leo X was a very inadequate pope, especially for the times. We agree, that Luther probably expected to reuinted with the rest of Christianity.

So while I am positive we can follow Luther a long way, I am unsure just when we must part ways with him… is it at the burning of the papal bull, and the rejection of Church authority / acceptance of private judgment that it signifies?

What would a pious Catholic do, when receiving a papal bull (not that a pious Catholic should be receiving papal bulls very often 😉 )? Are papal bulls infallible?
  • CB
 
So while I am positive we can follow Luther a long way, I am unsure just when we must part ways with him… is it at the burning of the papal bull, and the rejection of Church authority / acceptance of private judgment that it signifies?
  • CB
The significate event is when Luther is officially informed that his beliefs are heretical yet he continues to teach them. He removed himself from the Church.

The next significate event is the confirmation by the Church that he taught heresy by his excommunication.

He was given more than one chance, to repent of his ways and follow Christ.
 
What’s always confused me about this, is that Luther was excommunicated by someone who was appointed Pope due to politics - was barely a priest before he was Pope. What is someone supposed to do when even the Pope, the head of the Church, is corrupt?
 
Luther was a coward. He should have stayed within Christ’s Church to work on whatever issues he had and trusted in God. Instead he turned his back on the Church, and did not put his trust in our Lord.
It went rapidly downhill after that. He was so egotistical he thought he alone should be the sole interpreter of scripture. Its easy to see after reading his writings that he completely lacked humility and is a man filled with hate and rage. Not exactly a model Christian.
 
What’s always confused me about this, is that Luther was excommunicated by someone who was appointed Pope due to politics - was barely a priest before he was Pope. What is someone supposed to do when even the Pope, the head of the Church, is corrupt?
That is why the true head of the church is Christ:) Even a “corrupt” pope, a sinful, heartless pope, is still merely a servant of Christ, for the church. He is still protected on matters of infallible teaching by the Holy Spirit. He may by his acts, inflict harm on the body of Christ…but Christ still promises that the TRUTH of the church will never waiver. Not even corrupt popes, not even sinners, not even the arrows hurled at her by the reformation, not even the gates of the netherworld shall ever prevail against her. That is Christ’s promise:)
 
I am currently trying to wrap my head around the Reformation period, and I got to think about something, that I think is quite essential.

Luther, as opposed to the radical reformers, did not intend to become a schismatic, nor did he believe he was in disagreement with the actual Church Teachings, Tradition or Scripture. However reluctant, Luther came to a break with the Catholic Church. Again, Luther didn’t per se “break away”; rather he was excommunicated. The relevant historical document for this is the papal bull Exsurge Domine, which lists 41 “theses” that were condemned as heretical.

Luther burned the papal bull, and held fast to his teachings for the rest of his life.

It is arguable, how much Luther actually disagreed with the Catholic Church, and when he is just using different wording for the same thing (obvious example, faith alone should be understood in contrast to the via moderna school which everyone thought was a cool thing at the time, but which turned out to be heretical)

What I am wondering is, what should Luther have done in order to remain a good Catholic? Revoked the 41 theses condemned in Exsurge Domine? Listened closer to his spiritual director, Staupitz? Something else? Something more?

What might be the reasons he didn’t do that?

And please, keep Luther-bashing at an absolute minimum. And if you don’t know the difference between Luther and Calvin, please don’t reply to this thread at all 🙂
  • CB
CB,
There is a movie out about Luther. You can rent it at any video store. Get another point of view.
In case Jesus saves, not churches. 🙂

God bless,
jean8
 
CB,
There is a movie out about Luther. You can rent it at any video store. Get another point of view.
In case Jesus saves, not churches. 🙂

God bless,
jean8
Jesus established the Catholic Church to spread the gospel, baptise and lead people to salvation through Christ. If you wonder where the Catholic Church is in scripture (apart from where Jesus establishes it on Peter) then read it for yourself.
The name “the Catholic Church” (Greek: katholikos ekklesia) developed from Acts 9:31 “the Church throughout all” (Greek: ekklesia kath olos).
 
CB,
There is a movie out about Luther. You can rent it at any video store. Get another point of view.
In case Jesus saves, not churches. 🙂

God bless,
jean8
Haha…

If you’re refering to the Luther-movie, I have seen it. It shows quite well what the church was like at the time, and (to my surprise) has a very balanced view on the Catholics… For instance Staupitz is shown very positively, so it’s not all “evil Catholics vs. good Protestants”.

However, the Luther-character is a bit too fan-boy-ish for my taste. Sure, he had some valid concerns and had some mostly good motives, but he also had his faults. In the movie he is the spotless knight on a white stallion, who always does the right thing at the right time. All the negative things he did and said is either hidden away, or projected on to other characters.

Well written script and the actors are very good, but the Luther-worship kind of taints the experience for me.

But a movie is just a movie, and while it is well suited to convince the masses, I personally favour something with a bit more substance.

thistle, I don’t think it is right to say that Luther was a coward. I am actually pretty positive that a coward is the last thing he was. He may have been stubborn, filthy-mouthed and angry, but he was not afraid to voice his opinions or to stand by them in the face of death.

It is a bit more tricky on the issue of humility, because while he is extremely bold in some places, he is very humble in others. Luther’s writings are not a consistent whole, but they are different thoughts at different times, contradicting each other very often. To me it paints the portrait of a man, who wants to be humble, but cannot, since there is nothing left for him to rely on, save his private judgement - which he may not himself perceive that he exercises. Indeed he claims to “just read what it says”.

I grew up Lutheran, but am at present leaving that, in favour of the Catholic Church. I figured it would be relevant to get a good understanding of this Luther-character that everyone keeps talking about 😉 Or rather, having already a good idea of the man from a Lutheran point of view, I would like to hear what some Catholics think.

There are some of his objections that were very valid:
  • The need for a more central place of the Scriptures in theology (which had been generally neglected in the scholastic period).
  • A reformation, or cleansing of the ecclesiastical hierarchy.
  • A condemnation of the way indulgences were practiced
  • A condemnation of the via moderne-school which claimed that man was saved by his works.
In each of these, however, Luther went a bit to far and stated:
  • That Scripture is the only source of truth and authority
  • A rejection of the ecclesiastical hierarchy itself.
  • A rejection of the doctrine of indulgences even when rightly practiced.
  • A total rejection of the necessity of works, even in the context of faith.
And so on and so on…
  • CB
 
He should have acknowledged his many errors, confessed, and repented.
 
Luther should have been more like St. Francis.

The Church needed a reformer but got a schismatic instead.
 
To turn the tables here: Luther‘s ideas took a large part of central Europe by storm, and it took several decades following the Council of Trent before some regions in central Europe and their princes found a renewed sense of Catholic identity. In the 1580‘s, Catholics fulfilling their Sunday obligation in Austria would go to Roman Catholic Mass and hear Lutheran doctrine from the pulpit. What should a faithful Catholic do in such a situation? Protest, rebel? Refuse to worship under the unfaithful shepherds? Found a house church? The majority simply rode it out, going to Mass anyway, identifying themselves as faithful to the papal Church, navigating their way the best they could.
“The search for a ‘suitable’ church makes the man a critic where the Enemy [referring to God] wants him to be a pupil. What He wants of the layman in church is an attitude which may, indeed, be critical in the sense of rejecting what is false or unhelpful, but which is wholly uncritical in the sense that it does not appraise*– does not waste time in thinking about what it rejects, but lays itself open in uncommenting, humble receptivity to any nourishment that is going.“ (C.S. Lewis, The Screwtape Letters)
That doesn‘t mean leaving your brain at the church door. On the contrary, one of the most compelling reasons why Catholics should be on their toes about knowing their faith is because, from indulgence-peddler Johann Tetzel to the Lutheran preachers in Europe‘s 16th century cathedral pulpits to Nancy Pelosi‘s view of doctrine, there is never a shortage of ideas and practices that are improperly labelled Catholic. Luther did right in voicing objection to the abuse of the doctrine of indulgences for financial gain. He went too far in calling the doctrine itself into question, but that was no doubt an honest mistake. When officially told that his view was unorthodox, he should have found it in his heart to say „I stand corrected“. That was where he went wrong – he wore his loyalty to the Church more lightly than his own views.
 
I am currently trying to wrap my head around the Reformation period, and I got to think about something, that I think is quite essential.

Luther, as opposed to the radical reformers, did not intend to become a schismatic, nor did he believe he was in disagreement with the actual Church Teachings, Tradition or Scripture. However reluctant, Luther came to a break with the Catholic Church. Again, Luther didn’t per se “break away”; rather he was excommunicated. The relevant historical document for this is the papal bull Exsurge Domine, which lists 41 “theses” that were condemned as heretical.

Luther burned the papal bull, and held fast to his teachings for the rest of his life.

It is arguable, how much Luther actually disagreed with the Catholic Church, and when he is just using different wording for the same thing (obvious example, faith alone should be understood in contrast to the via moderna school which everyone thought was a cool thing at the time, but which turned out to be heretical)

What I am wondering is, what should Luther have done in order to remain a good Catholic? Revoked the 41 theses condemned in Exsurge Domine? Listened closer to his spiritual director, Staupitz? Something else? Something more?

What might be the reasons he didn’t do that?

And please, keep Luther-bashing at an absolute minimum. And if you don’t know the difference between Luther and Calvin, please don’t reply to this thread at all 🙂
  • CB
Luther should have worked for the changes he thought were necessary by praying, fasting and meeting with others of influence in private to sway their judgments and opinions.

Instead, he chose to hurl a firebomb, and the blaze got out of control to the point that even Luther lamented the situation.

“This one will not hear of Baptism, and that one denies the sacrament [Real Presence], another puts a world between this and the last day: some teach that Christ is not God, some say this, some say that: there are as many sects and creeds as there are heads. No yokel is so rude but when he has dreams and fancies, he thinks himself inspired by the Holy Ghost and must be a prophet.” (De Wette III, 61. quoted in O’Hare, THE FACTS ABOUT LUTHER, 208.)

“Noblemen, townsmen, peasants, all classes understand the Evangelium better than I or St. Paul; they are now wise and think themselves more learned than all the ministers.” (Walch XIV, 1360. quoted in O’Hare, Ibid, 209.)

“If the world lasts, it will be necessary, on account of the differing interpretations of Scripture which now exist, that to preserve the unity of faith, we should receive the [Catholic] councils and decrees and fly to them for refuge.” (Letter to Urlich Zwingli.)

I think that as the rebellion he started grew, he became intoxicated by his own power and influence over public opinion.

My $.02.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top