C
Contrabass101
Guest
I am currently trying to wrap my head around the Reformation period, and I got to think about something, that I think is quite essential.
Luther, as opposed to the radical reformers, did not intend to become a schismatic, nor did he believe he was in disagreement with the actual Church Teachings, Tradition or Scripture. However reluctant, Luther came to a break with the Catholic Church. Again, Luther didn’t per se “break away”; rather he was excommunicated. The relevant historical document for this is the papal bull Exsurge Domine, which lists 41 “theses” that were condemned as heretical.
Luther burned the papal bull, and held fast to his teachings for the rest of his life.
It is arguable, how much Luther actually disagreed with the Catholic Church, and when he is just using different wording for the same thing (obvious example, faith alone should be understood in contrast to the via moderna school which everyone thought was a cool thing at the time, but which turned out to be heretical)
What I am wondering is, what should Luther have done in order to remain a good Catholic? Revoked the 41 theses condemned in Exsurge Domine? Listened closer to his spiritual director, Staupitz? Something else? Something more?
What might be the reasons he didn’t do that?
And please, keep Luther-bashing at an absolute minimum. And if you don’t know the difference between Luther and Calvin, please don’t reply to this thread at all
Luther, as opposed to the radical reformers, did not intend to become a schismatic, nor did he believe he was in disagreement with the actual Church Teachings, Tradition or Scripture. However reluctant, Luther came to a break with the Catholic Church. Again, Luther didn’t per se “break away”; rather he was excommunicated. The relevant historical document for this is the papal bull Exsurge Domine, which lists 41 “theses” that were condemned as heretical.
Luther burned the papal bull, and held fast to his teachings for the rest of his life.
It is arguable, how much Luther actually disagreed with the Catholic Church, and when he is just using different wording for the same thing (obvious example, faith alone should be understood in contrast to the via moderna school which everyone thought was a cool thing at the time, but which turned out to be heretical)
What I am wondering is, what should Luther have done in order to remain a good Catholic? Revoked the 41 theses condemned in Exsurge Domine? Listened closer to his spiritual director, Staupitz? Something else? Something more?
What might be the reasons he didn’t do that?
And please, keep Luther-bashing at an absolute minimum. And if you don’t know the difference between Luther and Calvin, please don’t reply to this thread at all
- CB