What should the Vatican Do?

  • Thread starter Thread starter cath2lic4ever
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why do they want to join the Catholic Church?

**Probably because they are looking for stability, sanity, and uncompromised truth.

Don’t you think?**
 
Why do they want to join the Catholic Church?
Because their faith has been corrupted. Women priests, women bishops, homosexual marriage etc. Christ promised that the gates of hell would not prevail against HIS Church. This does not apply to the Church of England.
 
anyone interested with the news regarding anglicans joining the catholic church. as a catholic what should be our take or gesture on this matter? GOD bless & prayers to all!

cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=59563
The Catholic Church cannot accept them in mass. I believe that over 400,000 Anglicans and 500 priests want to come back to the Catholic Church. We must proceed slowly. We must insure that they will adhere too ALL of the teachings of the Church. Only then can they be allowed to join the Church that they left 500 years ago.
 
The Catholic Church cannot accept them in mass. I believe that over 400,000 Anglicans and 500 priests want to come back to the Catholic Church. We must proceed slowly. We must insure that they will adhere too ALL of the teachings of the Church. Only then can they be allowed to join the Church that they left 500 years ago.
Please… I would like to see where 400,000 Anglicans want to join Rome. I don’t buy it.
 
A credible source which isn’t biased.
The 400,000 number probably comes from the Traditional Anglican Communion (TAC). That is their reported membership and they formally applied to Rome late last year for full communion. I don’t really see that happening, but I’ve been wrong before. There’s plenty info available, just do a Google search on TAC +Rome.
 
The 400,000 number probably comes from the Traditional Anglican Communion (TAC). That is their reported membership and they formally applied to Rome late last year for full communion. I don’t really see that happening, but I’ve been wrong before. There’s plenty info available, just do a Google search on TAC +Rome.
I don’t see any viable evidence of 400,000 Anglicans falling over each other to go to Rome. Sorry.
 
I don’t see any viable evidence of 400,000 Anglicans falling over each other to go to Rome. Sorry.
On their OWN news page is the partial text of their statement requesting full reunion with Rome.
themessenger.com.au/news.htm

Keep in mind, this group is NOT part of the Anglican or Episcopal Church that is undergoing all of the problems with the ordination of women and homosexuals. This is an exceptionally conservative group that broke away years ago. It does consist of about 400,000 members though.
 
The Catholic Church cannot accept them in mass. I believe that over 400,000 Anglicans and 500 priests want to come back to the Catholic Church. We must proceed slowly. We must insure that they will adhere too ALL of the teachings of the Church. Only then can they be allowed to join the Church that they left 500 years ago.
And yet, there is precedent for precisely that… admitting them all at once. It has happened several times, with the reunion of the Eastern Catholic Churches…
 
I don’t see any viable evidence of 400,000 Anglicans falling over each other to go to Rome. Sorry.
If you have not already done so, you should read about the TAC (schismatic) and their petition to Rome. As I said, I don’t think it will happen; in fact I don’t think it should happen with ANY Anglican/Episcopal or other ecclesial community. If people wish to become Catholic, they should only do so after prayer, study, contemplation and personal “witness” that the Catholic Church retains the deposit of faith and is that which brings them closest to God. Conversions en-masse, based on decisions made by an ecclesiastical hierarchy, could be largely superficial, divisive, and therefore not beneficial to anyone. It also raises the question of how to handle those who cannot come into full communion with the Catholic Church; e.g., civilly divorced and remarried laypersons and Priests.

Although I’m sure there will be some people “swimming the Tiber;” like you, I don’t see hordes of Anglicans/Episcopalians converting to Catholicism. Many of the seriously disaffected will also opt for Orthodoxy, more conservative Protestant denominations or simply become/remain schismatic. I think once the dust settles, most people will simply get used to the changes; perhaps begrudgingly at first for some, but ultimately accept them and go on as before.
 
Please… I would like to see where 400,000 Anglicans want to join Rome. I don’t buy it.
I heard on “The World Over” that it would be over 600,000. This will be interesting SIA. It’s something I saw that someone else brought up on here before.
 
If you have not already done so, you should read about the TAC (schismatic) and their petition to Rome. As I said, I don’t think it will happen; in fact I don’t think it should happen with ANY Anglican/Episcopal or other ecclesial community. If people wish to become Catholic, they should only do so after prayer, study, contemplation and personal “witness” that the Catholic Church retains the deposit of faith and is that which brings them closest to God. Conversions en-masse, based on decisions made by an ecclesiastical hierarchy, could be largely superficial, divisive, and therefore not beneficial to anyone. It also raises the question of how to handle those who cannot come into full communion with the Catholic Church; e.g., civilly divorced and remarried laypersons and Priests.

Although I’m sure there will be some people “swimming the Tiber;” like you, I don’t see hordes of Anglicans/Episcopalians converting to Catholicism. Many of the seriously disaffected will also opt for Orthodoxy, more conservative Protestant denominations or simply become/remain schismatic. I think once the dust settles, most people will simply get used to the changes; perhaps begrudgingly at first for some, but ultimately accept them and go on as before.
Well I welcome my brothers and sisters back home. It is not their fault they are where they are. It is corruption of years long past that created this schism. It would be wonderful had they maintained the rite of ordination so as to have valid holy orders and eucharist, but that’s another thread. I can’t wait to see the reunion that would be a much needed addition to the faith. We need more orthodoxy within the Church and I beleive these folks would bring that with them. We have a community that converted near our home. I love it. They still kneel at the rail. Look communion with no hands and from a priest. He’s married, and a priest. That works for me. I go frequently to support them. 👍
 
There has been a small steady stream of Anglicans becoming either Latin Catholics or Orthodox for decades now. Not necessarily all over the Anglican communion but at least in the USA and the UK.

There have also been splinter groups. The TAC is one of these, it is not actually a part of the Anglican Communion. They do claim to have about 400,000 adherents, which would represent about 5% of the Anglican Communion if they were actually part of it.

There is a question about the actual numbers though, the TAC may be quite a bit smaller than is claimed (it’s hard to say), and it is simply possible that not all of those would make the leap when the time came.

The problem is…the Catholic-leaning Anglicans were possibly (even probably) not the majority of the Communion at any given time in it’s history since the reign of Queen Elizabeth I.

The “Catholics” practically disappeared completely by the end of the 18th century and only became a significant presence in the church again as a result of the Oxford movement in the early to mid 19th century (many Catholics are probably unaware that the Oxford movement remained an Anglican affair, most of it’s adherents did not go to Rome). But it was the evangelicals of England who did most of the heavy lifting in the great missionary push that spread the Anglican faith around the world (at first largely in British colonial territories). And that is what one will see today, the really significant churches in terms of numbers (like Nigeria) are very evangelical despite any Catholic looking ceremonial trappings. They are Bible Christians.

That is why these global Anglicans are opposing the innovations going on in the USA and Britain. Their beliefs are very rooted in scripture.

The long term trend appears to be the number of Catholic-leaning Anglicans is diminishing and the number of evangelicals is growing. There will be little hope of reuniting the churches unless that trend is reversed. If the Latin Catholic church were to aggressively poach souls at this stage we might expect something like anywhere from a half million people coming in, to perhaps even few million…but this then radically crippling the Catholic party in the communion and shifting the balance of influence much further into the evangelical protestant camp. If that were to happen you can expect to lose more than 70 million souls (and their descendants) for decades or even centuries more, if not forever.
 
…but this then radically crippling the Catholic party in the communion
I think the Anglican communion, by ordaining of Anglican priestesses, ordaining ‘married’ homosexual couples, Bishopesses(is that what women bishops would be called?), etc. has pretty well had the effect of “radically crippling the Catholic party in the communion” permanently all by themselves.
 
There have also been splinter groups. The TAC is one of these, it is not actually a part of the Anglican Communion. They do claim to have about 400,000 adherents, which would represent about 5% of the Anglican Communion if they were actually part of it.
Figures I’ve heard are
Anglican Communion: 70 million
TAC: 400,000 (hence < 1%)
 
If you have not already done so, you should read about the TAC (schismatic) and their petition to Rome. As I said, I don’t think it will happen; in fact I don’t think it should happen with ANY Anglican/Episcopal or other ecclesial community. If people wish to become Catholic, they should only do so after prayer, study, contemplation and personal “witness” that the Catholic Church retains the deposit of faith and is that which brings them closest to God. Conversions en-masse, based on decisions made by an ecclesiastical hierarchy, could be largely superficial, divisive, and therefore not beneficial to anyone. It also raises the question of how to handle those who cannot come into full communion with the Catholic Church; e.g., civilly divorced and remarried laypersons and Priests.
I would recommend reading the Balamand Statement (an agreed statement between Catholic and Orthodox), also know as “Uniatism, method of union of the past, and the present search for full communion.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top