What Theological Contributions Have Protestants Made?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Randy_Carson
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, it’s what the Protestants *didn’t *contribute that I appreciate.

No indulgences.

No worship of Mary.

No canonization of thousands of ‘saints’.

No infallibility of the pope.

Thank goodness.
 
Well, it’s what the Protestants *didn’t *contribute that I appreciate.

No indulgences.

No worship of Mary.

No canonization of thousands of ‘saints’.

No infallibility of the pope.

Thank goodness.
AMEN!
 
Well, it’s what the Protestants *didn’t *contribute that I appreciate.

No indulgences.

No worship of Mary.

No canonization of thousands of ‘saints’.

No infallibility of the pope.

No proscription of contraception.

Thank goodness.
 
Well, it’s what the Protestants *didn’t *contribute that I appreciate.

No indulgences.

No worship of Mary.

No canonization of thousands of ‘saints’.

No infallibility of the pope.

Thank goodness.
Why would you be thankful for heretcal views?
 
Well, it’s what the Protestants *didn’t *contribute that I appreciate.

No indulgences.

No worship of Mary.

No canonization of thousands of ‘saints’.

No infallibility of the pope.

Thank goodness.
Total mischaracterizations. We do not worship Mary. What’s wrong with saints? They are what they are so why not call it like it is? The Pope is not infallible in everyday life. You should know that, and you should know when his TEACHING is considered to be infallible. Get your “facts” straight.
 
I can’t think of any theological contributions that Protestants have made to Christianity as a whole.

Can you?

If true, then why is this the case?
The only thing i can think of is that they cause people to disobey the Church. this has cause a trememdous lack of Faith by governments and people in general. it has greatly influenced secularism and individualism. their theology has caused separation of state and Church because no longer was one religion but many, causing the government to secularize and make laws that is harmfull to the Teachings of the Church, therefore harmfull to the cause of Christ and that is why the world is the way it is today.
forgive me if this has been said already for i have not read all the posts.
 
Since I was born and raised protestant and am now Catholic…I feel I can say this without being flamed. Protestantism, as a whole, from its inception to modern day, has provided nothing beneficial…only damage. It has split The One True Church…with that said, do I believe all protestants are evil or not genuine in their devotion to Christ? No, of course not…Heck I know some protestants that are better Christians than Catholics…still doesn’t take away that they are by their very nature and the Church’s definition, Heretics. Their existence outside of full communion with The Church, only hurts…it does nothing to help. Let us pray that our separated bretheren come into the fold very soon and learn the error of their ways.
I can’t think of any theological contributions that Protestants have made to Christianity as a whole.

Can you?

If true, then why is this the case?
 
I’m still holding that the seperation of Church & State is a positive theological contribution.
 
No proscription of contraception.
False. All of Protestantism forbade all forms of contraception up to 1930, which was when the Anglicans discerned that the Holy Spirit had “changed His mind” on the subject.

Not coincidentally, this was around the same time that Social Darwinism was taking hold in Europe, and ideas about “purification of the human race” were abounding. But how can you “purify” the human race, unless you are allowed to convince the “undesirables” (persons of mixed race, for example) to use some kind of contraception?
 
I’m still holding that the seperation of Church & State is a positive theological contribution.
do you? so, the state should be free from God’s Law? they should not obey God? they should not abide by God’s law?
 
do you? so, the state should be free from God’s Law? they should not obey God? they should not abide by God’s law?
I do.

The State can never be free from God’s Law.

Did I say that they should not obey God? There’s no reason that they should be in opposition to God but, there is no reason to entangle the Creator into mundane political decisions.

People should absolutely abide by God’s Law, which is why government should stay out of religion and vice versa. People should have that choice.
 
I heard a priest once say that every heresy had a seed of truth within it that the Church could then sift out and properly nurture.

As for theological contributions, I cannot think of anything that isn’t rooted in the Faith of the Church anyway, but I will tell you this, as a Catholic raised Baptist, and after spending five years as an Anglican: your average, maybe even your slightly below average, Evangelical knows more about the Bible than your average Catholic. I think one thing that we should borrow from Evangelicals, at least, is the idea of Sunday School. From infancy to old age, Baptists (for example) have Sunday School classes where they study the Bible (though I think Catholics should include the Father’s, the CCC, etc, as well). I learned songs as a little boy that helped me remember the stories of the Bible (“Zaccheus Was a Wee Little Man”, etc.). We ought to do that for our children.

Protestant congregations generally sing better and while Protestants seem to have dropped the theologically meaty old standards (“On Christ the Solid Rock I Stand” and “There is a Fountain Filled With Blood”) for “praise” music, they have, by and large, avoided the puerile and banal “self-affirming-Jesus-is-my-12-step-sponsor” rubbish that we’ve been afflicted with for several decades.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top