What To Do If Your Wife May Never Have Loved You? Part 1

  • Thread starter Thread starter platofan1983
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

platofan1983

Guest
Hi All,

I’ll try to keep this brief as no one really likes drama or woe-is-me sort of stories.

I’m 30 years old and have been married for eight years and am coming to the conclusion that my wife never may have loved me. I never really thought of it until recently, as I was pretty naive for a long time. I want to ask what to do in a situation like this.

My wife and I started dating as juniors in high school. I took her to Homecoming as a mutual friend and knew that night I wanted to marry her and have a family with her. I still feel that way. Shortly thereafter we started dating and were infatuated with each other. I don’t want to use the word love, because we were very young and it wasn’t sacrificing.

After we graduated, we planned on attending college together that wasn’t super far from home and was a good school. That summer she cheated on me with another guy she met online. I would have done anything to get back together with her (but she wanted to see this guy) so we agreed to take a “break.” She saw him for a week but didn’t really end up liking him. We got back together, but it became only platonic. I didn’t realize it as I was still naive and we were busy with school but there wasn’t any sort of deep emotional love there on her part. I forgave her and didn’t bring it up again. I don’t necessarily buy the whole “the trust was gone” thing either. The love was gone and we we’re friends, but having or not having trust didn’t really enter into the picture.

College progressed and I still looked ahead to the future. I wanted to be with her, start a family, and really deep down loved her. She for some reason (most likely because it was the next thing) wanted me to propose a year earlier than I planned. I proposed but planned to marry until after we graduated. Six months prior to our wedding while out at a bar with some of her girlfriends she danced with another guy. Then a few months later another guy danced with her and kissed her. And this isn’t like ballroom dancing either. This is how young kids dance. Think Miely Cyrus, but not as overt or with a foam finger.

She told me it was only because she liked feeling flirted with that is why it happened. I was dealing with my own physical illness at the time, so I just ascribed it to the fact that she was flattered.

We got married but things more or less remained the same in her attitude. A couple years ago, while drinking with friends she made out with a mutual friend (in a pretty physical, graphic, not clothed way). I was very upset and at the time angry. I remember going in the bedroom to talk about it. She said again it was because she liked how it felt. I said the husband in me wants to be mad at you but the Christian in me says I should forgive you.

Now, I’ve not been this perfect little husband either. Throughout college I was still loving and attentive. I forgave her, went to church with her, was best friends with her, did stuff with her and her girlfriends and did not say one negative or mean insulting thing to her. After we got married, that changed. I became bitter and angry toward her. I felt resentment. Here I was a dutiful boyfriend and she didn’t care. We waited to have sex until marriage because we are both Christians and that didn’t matter (I’m not bitter about that, just that she doesn’t see me as a special guy for wanting to wait). In college we never fooled around that much (kissing sort of stuff). She said she had no interest with anyone. She did in high school though. Marriage was the same. I was put on the physical and emotional back burner.

Because of my resentment, I became angry at little things. She gained a lot of weight (which I try to look past, but it’s hard as a guy when your wife is bigger than you), has no interest in me sexually (and has said so), has no emotional connection with me (or desires to), etc. The whole gamete. Basically she saw that our relationship in college was fine. She doesn’t understand why I can’t be like that now. It would be letting myself getting walked all over emotionally and her not even realizing anything was wrong or even voicing my frustrations or concerns.

I know many of you would recommend counseling. And we have tried that, however it was through a Protestant pastor and I don’t think he was very good. It was one brief session with all three of us then each a single session a week later. He tried saying that each person needs to rely on Christ for their emotional strength instead of necessarily relying on it from their spouse. They may compliment it, but if Christ is the rock their will be less instability. I understand where he is coming from, but that is a mile wide and an inch deep. She wasn’t even honest about her feelings or past wrongs. It would be like a short confession to a priest without being honest or completely truthful.

A friend of mine suggested something to me several months ago I didn’t even think about. He said, “Did you ever consider she doesn’t want you back?” I never thought about it like that. I’ve always been pursuing her and trying to want her to like and fall in love with me again, I’ve never consider that long, long ago, she stopped caring about me. She’s said as much though, so it’s not way out in left field.

Now, I don’t care about any past wrong mistakes on her part. I know stuff happens. All I care about is her heart (and not in a corny Disney way either). But I want her to come back to me emotionally and physically. We’ve had major fights and discussions. And I have said some really insulting things (I never mean them, but lose my temper for which I am wrong). I admit that and need to change that. But that is really all she “has” on me. She can’t say anything else as to why she doesn’t love me other than I’m a jerk when we fight, which is usually about me not feeling loved emotionally or physically. She gets it and acknowledges it, but doesn’t really want to talk about it.
 
Sorry I had to break this up into two parts! 🙂

She has said to me, there is nothing redeeming about me, it would be easier if I just dropped off the face of the earth, if she could go back and change things she would not marry me again, I’m not want she wants, only got back together with me because she didn’t want to really hurt me. But more than the words, has shown in action that I am not the man she wants. And she is the one who holds me accountable for ever word I say during a fight. Saying, “I didn’t mean it, I just said it in a fight or in anger” doesn’t count for her. She says that if I say them, I have to live with them. And that’s fine. But it makes everything she says much more poignant and stinging because she doesn’t say them in anger and means them! She says she loves me, but I just feel like that are platitudes. They don’t mean anything. I ask her why she married me or wanted to get married and she says she loved me. When really pressed she says, “I don’t know.” or “maybe we shouldn’t have” or “It was the next thing.”

All of her lack of love she attributes to the fact that I am mean or say mean things. And again, I do get angry when we fight (never physically) and rarely shouting. I do argue a lot, which I’m learning is not productive because you can’t make a girl see your logic no matter how truthful it might be. But if she didn’t love me when I was nice, why would she now? Is she only using this as a convenient excuse?

I haven’t been the perfect husband I fully admit that and will take that on my shoulders. My retort is that in college after she cheated on me and I forgave and moved past that and was still a great guy, she still rejected me. Over and over she started showing me a pattern, whether it be in the words, or in the actions, infidelity, not looking up to me, not trusting me, discounting me, what have you. And that was a pattern of rejection. She still shows me that to this day.

And I agree a professional Christian marriage counselor will probably help a great deal. Can they help a girl who was only once infatuated with a guy and who got married for the wrong reasons? Can they help a girl who cuts down every positive thing her husband tries to do and dismisses them? What if there isn’t much of a foundation to build on?

I’ve told her if she just would give an inch, she’d get a mile in return. I know she doesn’t feel loved from me, but does she even want that? Does she even want it when she rejected me when I was loving her? And it was more than just infidelity in college or now. It it was one issue like that, I would get that. Maybe I wouldn’t be meeting her needs in a certain area. Maybe there was a reason she would be looking for another guy. I get that. But when it pops up in every aspect of your relationship, it seems to point to something larger.

We both are very strong Christians (me growing up Catholic and her Baptist) and think divorce is wrong. She said she would have divorced me if it wasn’t a sin, but I wouldn’t do the same. It’s a cop out. I don’t even think its what God wants for us. I know He has an awesome plan if we follow Him and what he wants. I also think it’s one of the most selfish things I could do. I’ve told her that if I strip away all the external stuff, deep down I still love her, intrinsically for who she is. She doesn’t say the same for me she says the opposite. She doesn’t view me as special and thus interprets everything through a negative lens. Even good things I do! I think part of the problem was she never dated other guys. So it could be a case is, the grass is green on the other side of the fence.

Anyway, what do I do? What do I do having resentment? Is this what God wants for me? Does He just say to me, “You want forgiveness, continue to show forgiveness” “You want mercy, show her mercy.” “It might take her five, ten, twenty, or a lifetime or never years for her to come around to you, but just follow me.” It that what he wants? I don’t think that’s the case as I don’t think it’s that dire. Keep in mind we both would never get divorced and are committed to each other in that respect. Even if God says, “I want you to love her in spite of all that (as I have loved you), work on your anger, and just wait for your reward in Heaven.” Even if God says that, I can try to do that. But it wouldn’t be easy (I know marriage isn’t) and I would need help and tools to get a point where I could still be loving in spite of all that.

Sorry it got so long.

Thanks,

Nick
 
Get a real counselor, because yes, you need some help and some tools. You are chasing your emotional tail, constantly changing whatever rules of thinking about your relationship that you have in place, both changing them on your wife and changing them on yourself at every turn. You’re not trying to do that, but that’s a rough picture of what you’re describing. You are right: this is not going to get better unless something changes. What you’ve been trying is not working.

This is not about who is “right” or what thing in the past you’d change if you could or what you should or shouldn’t have seen differently at some other time. This is about you each having promised to love and honor each other for as long as you both live and both being committed to stick with your promise. Good. That’s a good place to start. Your vows were not about what is out of your hands, but about what you can do…only by your description, you two don’t know how to do it. You only know that you’re not getting the results you want. If you were to go out on a golf course, lose 50 balls, and lose track of how many strokes you took, wouldn’t you ask yourself why? And if after the obvious first question your answer was, “Well, no, actually, no one has taught me how to hold a golf club and how to swing consistently so I don’t slice or hook or top the ball”, then the answer is not to give up golf. The answer is to have somebody show you how to play golf. You’ve committed to play the game–learn the game. Get the skills. Then you’ll be in a position to evaluate what you really have between you. As it is right now, you don’t know.

You and your wife don’t know how to communicate. That much is clear from your account of your communications. You are still naïve about a lot of things concerning marriage. That’s no crime; you’ve been doing your best with what you have. Still, you need to let go of the judgments you’ve both made and the interpretation you’ve put on your situation and start from scratch with regards to how you look at it. The truth might be very different from either the story you’ve been telling yourself or the story your wife has been telling herself. Get a trained third party to help you out–seriously help you, not just three sessions–and go from there.

Good luck! I hope the rounds you have ahead of you will be a lovely revelation!
 
Start to really forgive today. We all make mistakes. Resentment, doubts, anger, envy… If allowed to come to fruition lead to death. In relationships, breaking of vows, separation in our vocations… Than it gets tough. Rarely in marriage are couples on the same page in spiritual “progress”. In quotations cause one is not for advanced than another. Understanding, trusting providence greatly, prayers. Love forgives a multitude of damages from sin. “I” statements are often strong even though justified. “We” statements do help and are inclusive. In each little interaction, meditate in the Our Father. ‘Hollowed be Thy Name’ Thy Kingdom come, Thy Will be done, on earth as it is in Heaven, Give us this day our daily bread, forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us, lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil. Amen

Displace resentment/neglect with thankfulness/ love in action, forgive them/ yourself, resist temptations to act on vices, and at the end if the day know that ‘Thy Will be done’. Blessings to you, wife, and marriage you both are entrusted with.
 
My heart bleeds for your situation. I don’t think anyone can give you concrete advice unless they actually know you and your wife and can speak to you both. Two things come to my mind, however. Firstly, just let me say that I am a woman. I’ve been with my husband for over 40 years–but, believe it or not, we actually got divorced and were apart for about 6 months before we got back together and made it work. Our marriage is still not perfect–whatever that is–but we do love each other and treasure our marriage very much. The primary reason in retrospect, that we ended up divorcing, was that I didn’t feel that my husband loved me anymore either. We married when I was only 17 and he was 20 and we believed back then that we were truly in love. He was going to be sent to Vietnam, so we got married–in the Catholic church. I don’t think either of us knew back then how to truly love, in the Christian sense—we were only kids, both very selfish and self-centered. I too, once thought that other men found me far more desirable than my own husband–and I too, let him know how I felt. Frankly,inside I wasn’t sure back then that I had ever loved him–or that if I had, that I still did! You said a mouthful when you mentioned the fact that your wife has gained so much weight. Inside, I promise you that your wife doesn’t feel attractive–to you or to any man. Women can look in the mirror and do, and we judge ourselves physically, WAY harder than you men judge us! I promise you that! She uses the attention of other men–any man–to make herself feel more attractive and if she allows you to find out about the other man’s attention, it is as if she is saying: “See, I know I’m not attractive to you, but I am to him.” The fact that it’s a recurring pattern makes me think that something happened earlier in her life that made her feel like she was unattractive–maybe when she was even a teen. Angry words are hard for most people–ESPECIALLY women to forget. I know how hard it is not to say those words however when you are mad. You really should consider finding Catholic counselling–both as a couple and probably individually as well. No disrespect to seeing a local parish priest, but remember that just because he’s a wonderful priest doesn’t make him automatically a great counselor. If you know of a priest that is known to be an excellent counselor, go to him. Otherwise, do your homework and find an actual licensed counselor who is either Catholic or is a Christian counselor committed to the sanctity of marriage. You might approach your wife if she balks at counselling again with the obvious fact that things cannot remain status quo. Let her know again that you want the marriage to work–but not if she isn’t truly vested in it, as that isn’t fair to either of you. If she will not consent to some real, serious counselling then you go yourself anyway. If you start the healing process within yourself, she may come on board eventually too. If she doesn’t and even after you are well down the path of counselling, she still refuses to work on the marriage and continues her infidelity, then for sure you need to speak to a priest. This brings me to my 2nd point. You cannot always make someone love you–and that’s the sad truth. Just because you love her doesn’t insure that over time she will grow to love you or that she ever did in the first place. If she’s unwilling to even try, you may have to face a separation or divorce down the road. Her rejection of you emotionally and physically and her repeated infidelity may be grounds for an annulment–something I can truly see you don’t want and hope to avoid. However, it is equally possible that with counselling and since you are both Christian and believe in marriage as a covenant before God, that you may look back on this period 20 years from now as a “rough spot in the road”! It CAN happen believe me–it did to my husband and I. Good luck and God bless you both!👍
 
You should also try a novena for healing of marriage just try and search with google.
 
First, I take it that you are not Catholic so that gives you an opportunity to correct your current course.

Look at what you titled your post. What does it say? Why would anybody want to continue in a loveless relationship? Your “wife” admitted to you that you are not attractive to her. You admit your no angel. Where are you two going with this union?

You really need to step back and examine your motives. Think about how much better your life would be if you release yourself from the doubts that plague you.

St. Paul put it best “Wives, be subject to your husbands” and “Husbands, love your wives”.

It must work both ways,
 
A couple years ago, while drinking with friends she made out with a mutual friend (in a pretty physical, graphic, not clothed way). I was very upset and at the time angry. I remember going in the bedroom to talk about it. She said again it was because she liked how it felt. I said the husband in me wants to be mad at you but the Christian in me says I should forgive you.
A couple of things in your post, but especially this, indicates to me that you might have a distorted idea of mercy. Mercy does not understate the crime. Your wife has egregiously broken her marriage vows right in front of your eyes; who knows what she has done when you are not looking? She has taken a sacred trust and spit on it. These are facts. God is angry at actions like these – what on earth do you mean by saying you want to forgive and not be angry?

There is no opposition between anger and forgiveness. And letting a person know how deeply they have hurt you – yeah, there’s certainly nothing wrong with that. In my opinion, you need to be really vulnerable here. With men, sadness often becomes anger, in an instant. Let her see your sadness.

Don’t focus on how she feels about you. That is just an opportunity for you to have offended pride, when what you really need is humility. The Protestant pastor was right; you cannot be enough for her. But she needs to see that you are laying down your life for her.

Every day I pray that God will help me do five things, in relation to my wife: Love her, serve her, cherish her, honor her, and desire her. You need to do these things, with all your heart, all the more because of the coldness you experience from her. But you also need to let her know, from the heart, how much she has hurt you.

And you probably need to come to terms with your own faults, too. Your post is probably more one-sided than the marriage is.

Blessings and prayers!
Prodigal
 
If you don’t mind could you make this about five sentences long and repost it. That’s about as long as my attention span affords me. You are going in way too much detail. Thanks!
 
She has said to me, there is nothing redeeming about me, it would be easier if I just dropped off the face of the earth, if she could go back and change things she would not marry me again, I’m not want she wants, only got back together with me because she didn’t want to really hurt me. But more than the words, has shown in action that I am not the man she wants. And she is the one who holds me accountable for ever word I say during a fight. Saying, “I didn’t mean it, I just said it in a fight or in anger” doesn’t count for her. She says that if I say them, I have to live with them. And that’s fine. But it makes everything she says much more poignant and stinging because she doesn’t say them in anger and means them! She says she loves me, but I just feel like that are platitudes. They don’t mean anything. I ask her why she married me or wanted to get married and she says she loved me. When really pressed she says, “I don’t know.” or “maybe we shouldn’t have” or “It was the next thing.”
You need professional counseling and every day that goes by is a day lost and a day harder to get out of this mess you guys are in.

Does your wife apologize for things?
Does she always blame you?
Does she get violent and/or threatening!
Does she manipulate situations to the point you sometimes wonder if you and her were having the same conversation or doing the same thing?

Based on what you wrote, especially the wishing you dead, pushing away, and promiscuity sounds very eerily familiar to my ex. There is possibly a personality disorder or other mental illness involved that needs to be addresses and only a licensed counselor can help. Just don’t let her (or you) manipulate the counselor into believing a projection of who she is and not the reality.
 
You need professional counseling and every day that goes by is a day lost and a day harder to get out of this mess you guys are in.

Does your wife apologize for things?
Does she always blame you?
Does she get violent and/or threatening!
Does she manipulate situations to the point you sometimes wonder if you and her were having the same conversation or doing the same thing?

Based on what you wrote, especially the wishing you dead, pushing away, and promiscuity sounds very eerily familiar to my ex. There is possibly a personality disorder or other mental illness involved that needs to be addresses and only a licensed counselor can help. Just don’t let her (or you) manipulate the counselor into believing a projection of who she is and not the reality.
Based on her destructive behavior, it does seem like she has issues of some sort, and mental health issues could very well be the culprit. It certainly seems like emotional maturity is lacking. But in either case professional help sounds necessary, as she is behaving in a manner that is not conducive to a healthy relationship.
 
If you don’t mind could you make this about five sentences long and repost it. That’s about as long as my attention span affords me. You are going in way too much detail. Thanks!
The OP doesn’t have a 25-words-or-less kind of question. If he could boil it down that much for himself, his problems would be half-solved!
 
Thank thank thank you guys so much for your posts!

Again, I want to be briefs, although tighty whitey didn’t think so…(lol) thanks for at least posting something tw. And your name made me laugh.

A couple points of clarification. I was raised Catholic and technically still am Catholic. She was raised Baptist. When we began dating I started going to church with her (just because I wanted to be with her) but really fell in love with Christ (whom I rejected in my early teens). I was pretty young and naive about theology at the time and accept Christ as a Born Again. Now as I am older I can see Christ in the mass, or the merits in Catholic Theology. I just missed the starting point! About 95% of the time we attend church with her parents. Catholicism isn’t even on their radar as they see it as a cult. We’ve fought about this, but again it stems back to the few main issues, so I don’t want to go round and round.

We were not married in a Catholic church but a Protestant one, not a Baptist one though. I didn’t write to my Bishop asking for approval (or even know about that at the time) and I don’t think she would even want to get our marriage blessed (actually she has said so) by a priest if I wanted to. Again, I’m not going to push every issue with her. We also have a beautiful daughter.

As bad as I am (and maybe even being a little too much of self martyr now!) I really want to follow Christ. So for me, divorce and annulment are out of the question. I realize the theology behind it and understand it. But if Christ says “no to divorce” I have to accept that. I know he does make the acception for unfaithfulness, but I still want to follow him. And if we can move past it and if it doesn’t happen again, I am okay with that.

Mainly of you hit on a huge point which I didn’t want to talk about too in depth but I think is valid. That is feelings of self-worth and upbringing. Her family comes from a very type A almost to a fault, view. Having a deep, meaningful normal conversation is absolute foreign to her parents. (Surprisingly her brother and sisters and grandparents all are normal). But they are always busy bodies rushing around filling their lives with empty things. Even if we are just sitting trying to talk at a table, they busying themselves. I know it’s an old reference, but like the mom Mary Tyler Moore from Ordinary People. Obviously something is going on deep down. I don’t know what that is. I tried to figure them out, but it’s not my place. I think their Born Again theology gives them a false comfort but deep down something isn’t right in their hearts. That’s why they are very superficial and almost neurotic. My wife isn’t that bad at all, but she is the oldest (as am I) and I can see some bits of that in her. She’s not honest with her parents or even has meaningful conversations with them.

So that’s all of that background. And I’ve said to her, “If I am annoying or you don’t want to talk about this stuff with me, maybe their is a wiser, mature lady in your church you could talk to. Maybe someone who has been there and understands what you are going through rather than talking to me.” She hasn’t done that or shown any effort. After really talking last night she called and left a message with her Pastor for another meeting. I am glad for this, but I don’t know based on what everyone is saying if that is enough. She might need to sort out a lot of things with a trained trained Christian counselor.

Thanks,

Nick
 
You need professional counseling and every day that goes by is a day lost and a day harder to get out of this mess you guys are in.

Does your wife apologize for things?
Does she always blame you?
Does she get violent and/or threatening!
Does she manipulate situations to the point you sometimes wonder if you and her were having the same conversation or doing the same thing?

Based on what you wrote, especially the wishing you dead, pushing away, and promiscuity sounds very eerily familiar to my ex. There is possibly a personality disorder or other mental illness involved that needs to be addresses and only a licensed counselor can help. Just don’t let her (or you) manipulate the counselor into believing a projection of who she is and not the reality.
She rarely apologizes and has said “I don’t do that much I need to apologize for.” She apologizes for the indelity and stuff, but it’s a very Type A sort of apology. “I’m sorry, I shouldn’t have done it. Move on.”

She is not violent or threatening.

And your last question I was a bit confused about. She does twist things around and sometimes I feel like she is completely missing the point or talking to another person. If you are asking if she projects and manipulates, I would say yes, but she doesn’t even realize it and would laugh if I suggested she did it.
 
She rarely apologizes and has said “I don’t do that much I need to apologize for.” She apologizes for the indelity and stuff, but it’s a very Type A sort of apology. “I’m sorry, I shouldn’t have done it. Move on.”

She is not violent or threatening.

And your last question I was a bit confused about. She does twist things around and sometimes I feel like she is completely missing the point or talking to another person. If you are asking if she projects and manipulates, I would say yes, but she doesn’t even realize it and would laugh if I suggested she did it.
Yeah get into counseling, because that behavior is extremely destructive and the main reason I am now divorced.

Prayers for you !
 
My heart bleeds for your situation. I don’t think anyone can give you concrete advice unless they actually know you and your wife and can speak to you both. Two things come to my mind, however. Firstly, just let me say that I am a woman. I’ve been with my husband for over 40 years–but, believe it or not, we actually got divorced and were apart for about 6 months before we got back together and made it work. Our marriage is still not perfect–whatever that is–but we do love each other and treasure our marriage very much. The primary reason in retrospect, that we ended up divorcing, was that I didn’t feel that my husband loved me anymore either. We married when I was only 17 and he was 20 and we believed back then that we were truly in love. He was going to be sent to Vietnam, so we got married–in the Catholic church. I don’t think either of us knew back then how to truly love, in the Christian sense—we were only kids, both very selfish and self-centered. I too, once thought that other men found me far more desirable than my own husband–and I too, let him know how I felt. Frankly,inside I wasn’t sure back then that I had ever loved him–or that if I had, that I still did! You said a mouthful when you mentioned the fact that your wife has gained so much weight. Inside, I promise you that your wife doesn’t feel attractive–to you or to any man. Women can look in the mirror and do, and we judge ourselves physically, WAY harder than you men judge us! I promise you that! She uses the attention of other men–any man–to make herself feel more attractive and if she allows you to find out about the other man’s attention, it is as if she is saying: “See, I know I’m not attractive to you, but I am to him.” The fact that it’s a recurring pattern makes me think that something happened earlier in her life that made her feel like she was unattractive–maybe when she was even a teen. Angry words are hard for most people–ESPECIALLY women to forget. I know how hard it is not to say those words however when you are mad. You really should consider finding Catholic counselling–both as a couple and probably individually as well. No disrespect to seeing a local parish priest, but remember that just because he’s a wonderful priest doesn’t make him automatically a great counselor. If you know of a priest that is known to be an excellent counselor, go to him. Otherwise, do your homework and find an actual licensed counselor who is either Catholic or is a Christian counselor committed to the sanctity of marriage. You might approach your wife if she balks at counselling again with the obvious fact that things cannot remain status quo. Let her know again that you want the marriage to work–but not if she isn’t truly vested in it, as that isn’t fair to either of you. If she will not consent to some real, serious counselling then you go yourself anyway. If you start the healing process within yourself, she may come on board eventually too. If she doesn’t and even after you are well down the path of counselling, she still refuses to work on the marriage and continues her infidelity, then for sure you need to speak to a priest. This brings me to my 2nd point. You cannot always make someone love you–and that’s the sad truth. Just because you love her doesn’t insure that over time she will grow to love you or that she ever did in the first place. If she’s unwilling to even try, you may have to face a separation or divorce down the road. Her rejection of you emotionally and physically and her repeated infidelity may be grounds for an annulment–something I can truly see you don’t want and hope to avoid. However, it is equally possible that with counselling and since you are both Christian and believe in marriage as a covenant before God, that you may look back on this period 20 years from now as a “rough spot in the road”! It CAN happen believe me–it did to my husband and I. Good luck and God bless you both!👍
Thank you for bringing your tender gentle honest woman’s view to this, which I see and really appreciate. You don’t know how dead on you were about your points. I read it about three times just to appreciate it.

I’m not sure about what happened (one event) when she was a teen. I’ve noticed a trend of A LOT of young girls just using guys for their egos. They go from one to the next without considering their feelings. I think it has a lot to do with women’s liberation. Shame is completely gone in our society. So girls now can sleep with guys, have relationships with guys, or use men for their own egos. It’s sad, but I see it over and over with guys my age and younger. They give themselves to a girl completely and love her, she gets bored and leaves him. But more than it being, “Nice guys finish last” as kind of always was the case, it’s so much more of a promiscuous culture that girls are basing their feelings of self worth and dignity off of sex. Alpha males benefit of course by having more pick of the litter so to speak. I was surprised everyone was so shocked by the Miley Cyrus thing. I thought to myself, do you realize that not quite as graphic, but for the most part, that is how kids are dancing in bars and clubs today? Christians need to wake up!

Anyway, I’d like to ask you when you were at this point with your husband, what could he have done that would have made him seem like more of a man in your eyes? Or what would have made him more attractive (not just physically) to you? Or is the fact that I’m even asking the question show my desperation and is unattractive? Lol
 
She rarely apologizes and has said “I don’t do that much I need to apologize for.” She apologizes for the indelity and stuff, but it’s a very Type A sort of apology. “I’m sorry, I shouldn’t have done it. Move on.”

She is not violent or threatening.

And your last question I was a bit confused about. She does twist things around and sometimes I feel like she is completely missing the point or talking to another person. If you are asking if she projects and manipulates, I would say yes, but she doesn’t even realize it and would laugh if I suggested she did it.
Ah. “I did marry Miss Right, but unfortunately I realized too late that her first name is Always.” :rolleyes:

Someone who laughs at the idea that they have toxic habits is not automatically a non-toxic person. The chances are that they are toxic in an entrenched way. Ask your pastor to help you find a Catholic counselor for yourself. You need someone to help you stay in touch with reality, and your wife is not it.

(BTW: Is your beautiful child baptized? Do you not see that there is a reason that failing to get a dispensation nullifies a Catholic’s attempt at marriage to someone outside the Church? That is something to talk to a priest about, though.)
 
Also, I really do feel bad about “gossiping” about my wife. I don’t like just airing her dirty laundry, as I am a sinner too. So I’m trying not do this from a judgmental view.

Counseling seems like the best bit. I want to do it in a Christian context. And would want to do it under a recommendation from our Catholic diocese. I doubt she’d even consider it in a Catholic context, so I may have to find someone more qualified in her faith.

Thanks for all of the responses!
 
She rarely apologizes and has said “I don’t do that much I need to apologize for.” She apologizes for the indelity and stuff, but it’s a very Type A sort of apology. “I’m sorry, I shouldn’t have done it. Move on.”

She is not violent or threatening.

And your last question I was a bit confused about. She does twist things around and sometimes I feel like she is completely missing the point or talking to another person. If you are asking if she projects and manipulates, I would say yes, but she doesn’t even realize it and would laugh if I suggested she did it.
Yeah get into counseling, because that behavior is extremely destructive and the main reason I am now divorced.

Prayers for you !
Agree here Jon. There are things here that speak to deep issues and personality traits that may never change and are extremely destructive.
Also, I really do feel bad about “gossiping” about my wife. I don’t like just airing her dirty laundry, as I am a sinner too. So I’m trying not do this from a judgmental view.
Understood. However - isn’t it nice to have such an anonymous venue in which to get feedback?
Counseling seems like the best bit. I want to do it in a Christian context. And would want to do it under a recommendation from our Catholic diocese. I doubt she’d even consider it in a Catholic context, so I may have to find someone more qualified in her faith.
I think that besides counseling as a couple, it might be wise for you to get counseling for yourself…or at least become more acquainted with what her behaviors might indicate and what (if anything) can be done.
Something that helped me tremendously was learning to avoid certain behaviors and ways to deflect other things so as to not fall into “traps” of argument and negative behavior.
Thanks for all of the responses!
You are welcome.

Peace
James
 
(By the way–I like “tightey whitey’s” name too–LOL!) I don’t want to beat a dead horse either, but if you want to make your marriage work , you are going to have to assert your self on at least one or two things—and I don’t mean by name calling or fighting. Stop and think a moment–she decides to go to counselling with a Baptist minister and you are supposed to simply accept her decision and tag along. Would she go to counselling with a priest? Remember that while marriage is not to be taken lightly in most protestant sects, it still doesn’t mean the same thing to protestants as Catholics. If you two end up divorced and remarried, she could go right on fully participating in her church, but not so you unless you got your first marriage annulled. I would insist that the 2 of you see a real counselor and if I were you, I’d go alone to my parish priest first and see if he can make suggestions of who to go see. She has you chasing your tail, so to speak. You are the one who has to forgive her infidelities–and you should forgive—but do you have any reason to believe that she is even sorry or actually plans to change? You want the marriage to work–and that is as it should be. However the fact that she has you going to her church most of the time–as you said-- and considers your church to be a cult is just one symptom of things awry in your marriage. Get some REAL help–and don’t allow her to dictate to you all the terms. Your marriage involves two people–and she is only one of those people. YOU are the other one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top