What was the relationship between Jonathan and king David?

  • Thread starter Thread starter theCardinalbird
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

theCardinalbird

Guest
What kind of relationship did they have? They weren’t married I hope, though it seems they were extremely close, and I think there was a verse where they kissed 😶. I hope I’m wrong
 
Last edited:
…ever had a best friend? …one which you would give your life for?

That is the relationship that these two men had…

No, there’s no bromance thing going on; there’s no confusion about their sexuality… just look at what David did when Saul was killed… he should have thrown the greatest party ever, shouldn’t he? Yet, he mourned the death of his king, God’s anointed!

Thems were different times and different values.

Maran atha!

Angel
 
kissing is still common in a brotherly/platonic way in Europe
 
And in the Middle East.

We in the US are very conscious of our personal space. Other cultures allow closer contact that we simply aren’t comfortable with.
Not a question of good or bad, just different…
 
Spyridon said:
This is an egregious offense against history, and it’s extremely offensive to see someone suggest that because they shared the common Eastern custom of kissing on the cheek, that they were somehow homosexual. Considering that both David and Jonathan are venerated as Saints, this is a highly inappropriate subject to bring up.
Click to expand...
My apologies Spyridon I was only asked this question because I was in a debate regarding homosexuality and the Bible, and one of the topics that came up was the relationship with Jonathan and David. I asked this question because I wanted a way to prove this person wrong about Jonathan and David. If I’m not allowed to create a thread regarding an issue that has been asked on CAF before, that can be easily refuted, and is something that may tarnish the legacy of two saints unless these accusations are put to bed, then what is the point in getting angry? I was only asking a question about a matter I was confused about. If I’m not allowed to do so then why is CAF here?

You are by far the only one who I met that decided to act rude about an innocent mistake and question which most of my generation would have made due to how society portrays love. My mistake and I’m truly sorry.
 
Last edited:
Why not google “friends kissing middle east” instead of creating a thread insinuating that two great Saints had homosexual relations?

That quick and easy google search turned up an article which would have enabled you to forego creating this thread in the first place:

Cheek kissing is a ritual or social kissing gesture to indicate friendship, family relationship, perform a greeting, to confer congratulations, to comfort someone, to show respect, or to indicate sexual or romantic interest.

Cheek kissing is very common in Southern, Central and Eastern Europe, the Mediterranean, the Middle East, the Horn of Africa and Latin America. In other countries including the U.S. and Japan, cheek kissing is common as well at an international meeting between heads of state and First Ladies[1] or members of royal and the Imperial families.[2][3]

 
Spyridon said:
Why not google “friends kissing middle east” instead of creating a thread insinuating that two great Saints had homosexual relations?
Click to expand...
I didn’t think about doing that. I also wanted to cover other topics than that. I guess I could have done a Google search on those as well. But why did you have to be so rude about this? Am I not allowed to ask questions on CAF about misinterpreted points from someone who I was debating with?
 
I wasn’t intending to be rude, simply direct. I tend to be very defensive of holy things, and I’ve been baited on these forums more times than I can count.

I apologize @Joe1, I could have gotten my point across more diplomatically.

I apologize doubly because I sense that you’re a young person (under 20), which means I should be even more patient when responding to you.
 
Last edited:
In my lifetime we have gone from seeing men in film, music, books as close intimate friends, to whee every time we see two men together we assume it is homosexual. Sad.

There was a lovely song I remember from my teen years about David and Johnathan. I need to find that!
 
Spyridon said:
I wasn’t intending to be rude, simply direct. I tend to be very defensive of holy things, and I’ve been baited on these forums more times than I can count.

I apologize @Joe1, I could have gotten my point across more diplomatically.

I apologize doubly because I sense that you’re a young person (under 20), which means I should be even more patient when responding to you.
Click to expand...
Thank you Spyridon. I apologize also. I probably should have worded the question better.
 
Last edited:
Hi, Joe!

I once was told that there was never a ‘stupid question’ when someone sincerely sought to gain knowledge; seeking the Truth (Christ) is the greatest quest ever… keep all of your question coming… if I do not have an answer, I’ll goggle it and assist you the best I can!

Maran atha!

Angel
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top