What would a grave offense against the 4th commandment be?

  • Thread starter Thread starter 7violinS
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
7

7violinS

Guest
What would be grave enough to be a mortal sin agianst one’s parents? What would be venial? I’m having a hard time debating as to wether every exageration, such as ‘neat freak’, is grave or even mortal. It’s a bit of a weakness of mine to talk foolishly with my friends and another item to add to my ‘Jesus help me’ list.
 
What would be grave enough to be a mortal sin agianst one’s parents? What would be venial? I’m having a hard time debating as to wether every exageration, such as ‘neat freak’, is grave or even mortal. It’s a bit of a weakness of mine to talk foolishly with my friends and another item to add to my ‘Jesus help me’ list.
If you know that “neat freak” is a misrepresentation of one of your parents’ character and yet choose to use the term anyway then not only is it an offense against the proper honor and respect due a parent but also a false witness about your parents to your friends. Both the fourth and the eighth commandment are implicated here.
 
One’s parents give us life, andt he expectation is also that they “teach us in the way to go” If a person rebels against a good parent that has presented a loving representation of the “parenthood” of God, then this would be a grave sin. The prodigal son comes to mind, as his rejection of the many gifts of his father caused him to wander aimlessly and squander his inheritance. Had he never returned home, his own children would, likewise, have been lost and without faith, thus sinning against both his ancestors and descendants.
I hope this gives some light to this good question.
 
What would be grave enough to be a mortal sin agianst one’s parents? What would be venial? I’m having a hard time debating as to wether every exageration, such as ‘neat freak’, is grave or even mortal. It’s a bit of a weakness of mine to talk foolishly with my friends and another item to add to my ‘Jesus help me’ list.
Have a look at this site which is a good guideline to mortal and venial sins. It lists serious issues under each of the 10 commandments:

catholic.org/frz/examen/mortal_main.htm
 
Basically, if you damage the relationship of love and trust between you and your parents, we might be heading into the grave matter territory. If you simply annoy them, you are in venial area.
 
The 4th Commandment includes all disobedience against lawful authority.

For catholics, this include obeying the church in teachings of faith and morals. Depending on the gravity of what is being done, some disobediences can be grave.
 
What would be grave enough to be a mortal sin agianst one’s parents? What would be venial? I’m having a hard time debating as to wether every exageration, such as ‘neat freak’, is grave or even mortal. It’s a bit of a weakness of mine to talk foolishly with my friends and another item to add to my ‘Jesus help me’ list.
It’s hard for me to see a circumstance in which describing your parents as “neat freaks” could be considered serious matter, and therefore a mortal sin.

If it ain’t serious matter, then it ain’t a mortal sin. Period.
 
One time the Pharisees ask Jesus why his disciples did not follow some small rule of religious observance and Jesus asked them in return why they did not observe important rules. Apparently there was a custom where a person could tell their parents that anything that person had was “dedicated to God” and therefore they no longer had to provide support for their parents. Jesus made clear that God’s command was that a person should support the material needs of their parents.

On the other hand, when Jesus’s mother came looking for him when he was teaching Jesus made clear that his family was those who “heard and kept the word of God.”

I take these verses to mean that failure to provide at least minimal material and emotional support to one’s parents when one has the means is a serious sin. But that doesn’t mean that we should live our lives according to the habits our parents may have.

Jim
 
I would be thrilled if my kids called me a neat freak.

I am afraid they will call me the opposite. sigh.
 
This is one of the more difficult commandments for me–since I have a verbally/emotionally-abusive mother.

–Barbara
 
It seems to me that in this discussion of the 4th commandment, a close examination of the 1st commandment is in order "‘I, the LORD, am your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, that place of slavery. You shall not have other gods besides me. You shall not carve idols for yourselves in the shape of anything in the sky above or on the earth below or in the waters beneath the earth; 1 you shall not bow down before them or worship them. For I, the LORD, your God, am a jealous God, inflicting punishments for their fathers’ wickedness on the children of those who hate me, down to the third and fourth generation but bestowing mercy, down to the thousandth generation, on the children of those who love me and keep my commandments. "

The commandment to “Honor your father and mother” has sometimes been interpreted (wrongly) to mean “obey your father and mother without question, even when you are an adult, and never imagine that they could be mistaken about anything.”

Some facts to keep in mind:

All parent’s (except possibly one) are flawed human beings and do an imperfect job of raising their children. The children suffer because of this but they also reap great benefits when their parents do the right thing - as sometimes happens.

The 4th commandment is not the 1st commandment, We are called to love God with all our heart, mind and soul, not our parents.

Jesus interpretation of that commandment does indicate that a person should provide material support for a parent as needed, but in his own life he made clear that he listened to God’s word before anyone elses, even his own mother - we are called to do the same.

One of the hardest things a person can have to do in their life is to deal with serious sins of their parents. It is very difficult to avoid falling into the same sinful patterns as one’s parents.

… thought some of this might be relevant.

Jim
 
I believe the OP is a young person still living at home. What do you think would constitute a mortal sin against the 4th Commandment for a child or teen?

Betsy
 
I believe the OP is a young person still living at home. What do you think would constitute a mortal sin against the 4th Commandment for a child or teen?

Betsy
I know I was once young… it’s just that it has been so long…😦

I think that truly serious sin against one’s parent’s would be something like assault or refusing to give them basic human assistance when needed.

That is not to say that having and displaying respect for one’s parents is not a good lifelong habit.

The OP’s comment about being a “neat freak” suggests the possibility that the parent is perhaps overly concerned with some worldly possessions. Or perhaps the OP is just being selfishly lazy about doing his/her fair share in keeping up the home front. I think the question is worthy of discussion depending on a lot of circumstances.

Based on what little information is provided, I would say the OP’s comment falls short of the ideal respect a person should have for their parents but is not something that would be considered mortal sin.

Jim
 
I believe the OP is a young person still living at home. What do you think would constitute a mortal sin against the 4th Commandment for a child or teen?

Betsy
Here are some things I think would be grave matter:
  1. Cursing at one’s parents or other seriously insulting behavior.
  2. Disobeying them in a grave matter (assuming what they told you to do was consistent with the law of God).
  3. Dishonoring the family name.
  4. Striking them in anger with the intent to cause them harm.
  5. A refusal to show them due affection and concern for their happiness.
  6. Divulging private family information that other people do not have a right to know.
  7. Harboring grudges against them or against one’s siblings.
Note that I said these things constitute grave matter. Whether or not a particular child commits a mortal sin when doing them depends on the other 2 conditions: full knowledge and deliberate consent.

Many children, for example, will not understand what family information should be kept private and what should not. Therefore they would not be guilty of a mortal sin if they divulged it to others.
 
The one that caught my attention was the fifth point you made, if my parents get really stressed out at me, am I suppose to comfort them? That would probably make it worse.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top