What would an alien think of our religions?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dave_B
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Bishops would have to determine if Eternal Salvation through Jesus is applicable to non-earth life forms.

Once this is resolved, Our Catholc history of evangalizing can help us with this. Would we tray the aliens like the conquestadors did in Mexico? Would we follow St Paul’s model?
 
Would they even know of Christ. What I mean is that we only know of Christ because we needed Christ in this world to wash away our sins. Their world may have turned out completely different.
 
If we were to imagine that aliens existed and they were to travel across the galaxy and arrive at planet earth, on seeing our contradictory belief systems, what do you imagine they would think of us?
There are many world religions.
The top 5 being - christianity, judaism, islam, hinduism and buddhism. But there are many others and thousands of gods and thousands of sects all over the world.
Judaism and Islam are both monthesistic.
Christianity is also monothestic but believes in a trinity God of father, son and holy ghost, three persons in one being.
Buddhism is atheistic.
Hinduism can be montheistic, polythestic or atheistic.
They all have different religious texts (the Bible, Quran etc), many different prophets, gurus, saints and holy men, and are divided into many different sects.
I imagine that an alien would look at us, and perhaps question our sanity.
Your thoughts?
No shock if some aliens (if real) would have the wrong re-
ligion, but this reminds me of an old movie, Enemy Mine:A human (Willis Davidge) and an alien (Jeriba Shigan)
were lost together on a dead planet, and though they
were not fond of each other, they shared and tried to
get along. Jeriba shared his philosophical/religious
writings, Willis read them, then remarked on how
familiar it was. Jeriba then responded,* . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . *“Truth is Truth.”
 
Would they even know of Christ. What I mean is that we only know of Christ because we needed Christ in this world to wash away our sins. Their world may have turned out completely different.
If Adam hadn’t fallen, we’d know Christ anyway-just a whole lot better than now.
 
Another thing worth noting:
If Aliens exist on other planets, I don’t believe Adam’s Fall would have
affected them, as Adam is our first covenantal head, not connected in
any way to Alien Races on other worlds. When Adam sinned, he had
spiritually crippled his descendants, not other peoples (not human).
 
Would they even know of Christ. What I mean is that we only know of Christ because we needed Christ in this world to wash away our sins. Their world may have turned out completely different.
Agreed … To rephrase my statement to be incisive of all religions (based on NB assumption that religion is family) … Would the human race leaders include the aliens as part of family or would we reject their current form and try to assimilate them through our wisdom?

Focusing on my family, with Jesus Christ as our brother, would we be able to theologically say they get eternal salvation through Jesus Christ? Jesus Christ is fully man and fully God; not fully alien, man, and God. So, how do we include aliens in eternal salvation? Are they already saved (similar to angels), need salvation (similar to mankind), or exist only in hhis realm ( like cats & dogs )?
 
Agreed … To rephrase my statement to be incisive of all religions (based on NB assumption that religion is family) … Would the human race leaders include the aliens as part of family or would we reject their current form and try to assimilate them through our wisdom?

Focusing on my family, with Jesus Christ as our brother, would we be able to theologically say they get eternal salvation through Jesus Christ? Jesus Christ is fully man and fully God; not fully alien, man, and God. So, how do we include aliens in eternal salvation? Are they already saved (similar to angels), need salvation (similar to mankind), or exist only in hhis realm ( like cats & dogs )?
Christ(fully God) is an “alien” as God the Father is an “alien.” I guess ET would fit better since they are not of this world. Christ came to earth in order to save humans. Humans would be considered of Earth if beings were found else where. I am getting a headache lol.
 
While obviously impossible to say with any certainty, the question is fascinating.

If these creatures were to bear a substantial resemblance to us (particularly in mental and cognitive ways), it is possible that they would have similar questions and reach similar conclusions/conflicts.If they are totally dissimilar, I’d have to think that just about anything is possible.
 
Christ(fully God) is an “alien” as God the Father is an “alien.” I guess ET would fit better since they are not of this world. Christ came to earth in order to save humans. Humans would be considered of Earth if beings were found else where. I am getting a headache lol.
I agree that humans are considered of Earth. However, some speculate humans originated from another alien civilization. This opens the questions on what that means to the relationship with the Trinity and eternal life.
 
I think they would see the similarities. All religions ackowledge an ultimate supreme reality (Hinduism, though sometimes apparently, polytheistic, acknowledges that the each image of God represent and ultimate reality. Buddhism treat the Void as ultimate reality). All religions encourage moderation of the sensual appetites, justice and charity.

The aliens might see the invention of a religion as a biological charateristic of the human race. Or they could see us as having found the same truth, but expressing it through different images and languages.

I suppose it would depend upon the beliefs of the aliens. Are they Catholic aliens?
 
The few I have met are Catholic or in the Catholic equivalent of RCIA on their alien planet
LOL…
 
I think they would see the similarities. All religions ackowledge an ultimate supreme reality (Hinduism, though sometimes apparently, polytheistic, acknowledges that the each image of God represent and ultimate reality. Buddhism treat the Void as ultimate reality). All religions encourage moderation of the sensual appetites, justice and charity.

The aliens might see the invention of a religion as a biological characteristic of the human race. Or they could see us as having found the same truth, but expressing it through different images and languages.

I suppose it would depend upon the beliefs of the aliens. Are they Catholic aliens?
A fascinating possibility that cannot be ruled out!
 
What IF the alien had a greater knowlege of Heaven and Hell than a do?

Gosh, I must be brain washed from our secular culture selling the fact that Sci-Fi is only yo disprove God. Should my faith be strong, I should explore how Godwould be present for life forms everywhere. Since wisdom is a Grace from God, it’s like gravity an the natural principals of Grace of wisdom would be consistant throughout the Universe; just like gravity is the same all over.
 
Gods commandments are probably universal. Since the first are to love God with our whole hearts, we can then conclude that He would introduce himself to other intelligent life (unknown assumptions are where they fit with God; saved, free will, or separated from God). We assume all intelligent life is aware of God (dogs, cats, ect), but not all receives the grace of eternal salvation (which is another link in OP earth religions). We are taught that Hell is the absence of God; therefore if intelligent life had no experience with our God, technically, they are from hell? (Right??? Sound in on this brain fart of mine please )
 
How Glorious and loving is our God that He choose to reveal himself as a man, born of a woman; NOT as an Allien. This thread is making me love Christmas even more!!!
 
This reminds me of a funny story the British satirist Alan Coren wrote about an alien knocking on the front door of an American family’s home.

It starts with the son opening the door and calling out, “Hey, Pop, there’s a little green guy standing in the doorway.”

it continues on with the householder inviting him in and then proceeding to boast that his kids’ bridge work cost more than Guatemala’s annual budget, and that they’ve got enough fire power to wipe out the rest of the world. The kid pipes up, telling his sister that if they let in more of the little green guys, “How do you think you’ll feel when you have eau-de-nul children? Huh? Huh?”

It finishes up with the little green guy going back to his mates in the flying saucer, and commenting how depressing the human barbarians are. They wonder if we’re a lost cause, and one of them remarks, “Oh, I dunno. Someone has to pick the cotton.”

I wonder indeed. I mean, we can fly to the moon, split the atom, focus on cancer cells with radiation treatment, posit quantum mechanics, quantum teleport.

But then we’ll sit down to dinner with a T-bone steak, and at the end pick up the bone and gnaw on it like any contented cave man, and maybe dig the marrow out of a joint with a knife.

We’re a strange mix, and I think any aliens that got here would probably find a lot to joke about, including our eclectic mix of religions.
That’s a great anecdote. Reminds me of the movie “Down and out in Beverly Hills” for some reason. All these crazy people running around doing crazy things but the sane one is the homeless guy.
 
I read many years ago something from Fr Andrew Greely about alien civilizations. As best I can remember, he believes that such groups could either not need redemption or have it or be awaiting it. Are we to be missionaries to the stars?
 
I was preparing the altar at the offertory during Mass a few years ago, the congregation singing away, when the thought crossed my mind: If some Martians walked in right now, what would they think? There’s a roomful of people singing, while one individual, dressed in a conspicuously different way from the rest, is readying an elaborate gold cup and plate…and soon they’re all going to be kneeling and bowing down in front of it!

My conclusion was that this act is so ludicrously absurd that it has to be of divine origin! We could never come up with it on our own!

Fr Steve Petrica
Waunakee, Wis.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top