Whats God Got to do With it?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Charlotte408
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Charlotte408

Guest
I go to a public city college…and right now we are writing argumentative essays in my english class. (Argumentative btw is the style of essay, not my personality at all). We have to choose 2 essays out of our readers that oppose eachother, and argue the side of which we agree. I have choosen “The Rival Conceptions of God” - C.S Lewis (the ONLY story in the reader somewhat supporting God), and “Whats God Got to do With it?” -Karen Armstrong, who basically is stating that God isnt essential to religion, and that we should all adopt religions such as buddhism etc…which would promote peace…I know for myself God has EVERTHING to do with it…but I need to present a good argument as to WHY, in response to her essay. Please read the essay, its only like 2 pages, in its full text at this location:

http://www.newstatesman.com/200604100023

I would really appreciate any advice, quotes, or general direction any one can give me in order to make an educated, sound arguement defending my faith and God. This is very important to me because I go to a public city college, and I notice the way every semester the teachers find ways to almost, belittle those who have my frame of mind- it never fails. And most of the other people in my classes are kids straight out of high school who just soak in the secular propaganda…so…I’d like to offer another point of view. Thank you guys for all your help!!
 
Hi Charlotte,
I’ll try to offer some help.

Back in college (a gillion years ago it seems) I set forth a paper on my Christian experience and actually got an “A”, and I’ll pass on to you the notes that the teacher scrawled on that paper.

She said that she usually discouraged her students from writing about religion because it was so difficult to be concrete, but that I handled it very well. In such writing (even today) it is still the best tactic, so lemme see what I can do with this article.
**The great faiths share the same historical roots - and believing in a deity hasn’t always been necessary **
I would posit that even her title is fallacious since she makes this statement, she needs to prove her point with facts. We’ll see if she does.

Right off the top though I would say that she fails to differentiate between a religion and a philosophy. For instance, Confucianism, Taoism, and Zen are philosophies that (to the best of my recollection) do not include a deity per se, so to class them as religions might be inaccurate and fallacious. These appear to be examples that cast doubt on her premise.
The activity that we call religion is complex. Religious and non-religious people alike often share the same misperceptions.
We can agree with this.
Today in the west, it is often assumed that religion is all about the supernatural and that it is inseparable from belief in an external, personalised deity.
True as well in many cases, but that’s the West.
Critics claim that religion encourages escapist fantasies that cannot be verified.
Irrelevant. I think she’s padding her word count with this, especially since she cites no documentation to support her statement.
The explosion of terrorism (which is often given a religious justification) has convinced many people that religion is incurably violent. I have lost count of the number of times a taxi driver has informed me that religion has been the cause of all the wars in history.
This begins to have some substance. Now, though this is based upon unverifiable personal experience, it is something that some non-believers have put forth. You might offer your own personal experience one way or the other.

However, one can point out that the violent actions of members of any given religion are actually the result of the human frailty and failure of those individuals and most often in direct contravention to the tenets of their religion. Such would not indict the truth of the actual religion, just the morals of the individuals.
Yet we find something very different when we look back to the period that the German philosopher Karl Jaspers called the “Axial Age” (c.900 to 200BCE) because it proved to be pivotal to the spiritual development of humanity. In this era, in four distinct regions of the world, the traditions that have continued to nourish humanity either came into being or put down roots. Hinduism, Buddhism and Jainism emerged in India; Confucianism and Taoism in China; monotheism was born in Israel; and philosophical rationalism developed in Greece. It was a period of astonishing creativity; we have never really succeeded in going beyond the insights of such sages as the Buddha, the mystics of the Upanishads, Confucius, Lao-tzu, and the great Hebrew prophets. Rabbinic Judaism, Christianity and Islam, for example, can be seen as a later flowering of the religion that had developed in Israel during the Axial Age.
OOOOOOOkay. 🤷
Despite interesting and revealing differences in emphasis, these traditions all reached remarkably similar solutions.
Did they? You might explore this…
They can, perhaps, tell us something important about the structure of our humanity.
Perhaps…or possibly the fact that most humans innately seem to believe that there is more to the universe and life than just us. (If we are all there is then perhaps we are in a very sorry state indeed.:rolleyes:) The God of Israel was an important symbol of transcendence, but in the other Axial faiths the gods were not very important.And perhaps the moral standard was set higher by the God of Israel. Possible exploration here with compare & contrast.
Confucius discouraged speculation about spirits and the afterlife: how could you talk about other-worldly phenomena, when there was so much that you did not understand about earthly matters?
🤷 Might check to see if this is actually a true assessment of our Chinese philosopher, but again, isn’t this a philosophy and not actually a religion?
During the Indian Axial Age, the ancient Vedic deities retreated from the religious imagination. They were seen as unsatisfactory expressions of the sacred, and were either demoted to human status or seen as aspects of the psyche. Many of the Axial sages were reaching beyond the gods to a more impersonal transcendence - to Brahman, Nirvana or the Tao - that was also inseparable from humanity. Yogins and Taoists did not believe that their ecstatic trances represented an encounter with the supernatural, but regarded them as entirely natural to humanity. Later, the more sophisticated theologians in all three of the monotheistic religions would make similar claims about the experience of the reality that they called God.
Explore this…she makes claims without evidence.
 
None of these sages was interested in dogma or metaphysics. A person’s theological opinions were a matter of total indifference to a teacher like the Buddha. He insisted that nobody should ever take any religious teaching, from however august a source, on faith or at second hand. One of the Buddha’s disciples pestered him continuously about metaphysics: was there a God? Who created the world? He was so preoccupied with these matters that he neglected his yoga and ethical practice. The Buddha told him that he was like a man who had been shot with a poisoned arrow but refused to have any medical treatment until he discovered the name of his assailant and what village he came from: he would die before he got this perfectly useless information.
I understand that Buddha’s last words were something like, “I am still searching” which is not very helpful to humanity. However, Our Lord’s final word’s from the cross were “It is finished” and “Father, into your hands I commend my spirit.”, this along with the documentation of the resurrection would make a concrete contrast between the two faiths.

As for Buddha’s disciple, if his ethics failed, (and we do not know what ethics are here referred to, so that might be worth checking out.) then that is one thing, but the point could be made that this fellow wanted/needed more transcendent answers than his master had.
The Taoists were also wary of dogmatic conformity; they believed that the kind of certainty that many seek in religion was unrealistic and a sign of immaturity. Eventually, the Chinese preferred to synthesise the schools which had developed during their Axial Age, because no single tradition could have the monopoly of truth. In all four regions, when a sage started to insist upon strict orthodoxy, this was usually a sign that the Axial Age was drawing to a close.
I have a copy of the Tao, and it’s a good read, but I think she’s wrong that they avoided dogmatism.
The prophets of Israel were more like political commentators than theologians; they found the divine in analysis of current events rather than metaphysics.
Really? The burning bush wasn’t metaphysical/supernatural. Voices and angels? See the problems here?
Jesus, as far as we know, spent no time discussing the trinity or original sin, which would later become so important to Christians;
We know she is dead wrong here as both are implicit in the gospels. For instance, why did Our Lord says that one must be Born Again if not for original sin and it’s effects?
and the Koran dismisses theological dogmatism as zannah
, self-indulgent guesswork that makes people stupidly quarrelsome and sectarian.I’d go looking for documentation of this rather than accepting it as stated because I think she may be misrepresenting Islam.
Religion was not about believing credal propositions, but about behaving in a way that changed you at a profound level. Human beings have always sought what the Greeks called ekstasis
, a “stepping out” of the mundane, in moments when we feel deeply touched within and lifted momentarily beyond ourselves. The Axial sages all believed that if we stepped outside of our egotism and greed, we would transcend ourselves and achieve an enhanced humanity. Yoga, for instance, one of the great spiritual technologies of the Axial Age, was a formidable assault on the ego, designed to take the “I” out of the practitioner’s thinking.I think this is a drastic oversimplification of the issue containing some correct info, but ultimately misinterpreting her sources. To the best of my knowledge all the deities sought to enable mankind to transcend and dictated dogmas that were codified by their followers as creeds.
But the safest way to achieve this ekstasis
was by the practice of compassion. Compassion - the ability to feel with another - was not simply the litmus test of any true religiosity, but the chief way of encountering the ineffable reality of Nirvana, Brahman, God and Tao. For the Buddha, compassion brought about ceto-vimutti, the “release of the mind” that was a synonym for the supreme enlightenment of Nirvana, a sacred realm of peace in the core of one’s being.So then she here contradicts herself about dogma since she admits that compassion (“Love the Lord…” & “Love your neighbor as yourself”) is the tenet of all of them.

More later.,…
 
All the Axial religions, in different ways, regarded what has been called the Golden Rule as the essence of religion: “Do not do to others what you would not like them to do to you.” Confucius was the first to formulate this maxim. It was, he said, the thread that pulled all his teachings together and should be practised all day and every day. Five hundred years later, Rabbi Hillel was asked to sum up the whole of Jewish teaching while he stood on one leg. He replied: “That which is hateful to you, do not do to your neighbour. That is the Torah. The rest is commentary. Go and study it.”
So then the question she has not answered so far is simply, “Why?”

IOW, why bother, as if there is no accountable supreme being then what does it matter if I am compassionate or not?

Here I think she messes up in supporting her premise that God is not necessary to these religions, and her reference to Hillel is misleading since the very fact that he is Jewish attests to the fact that he, and all Judaism with him, believe that there is a divine source to this most basic tenet.
The Chinese sage Mo-tzu (c.480-390) insisted that we had to have jian ai
, “concern for everybody”. The priestly authors of Leviticus urged the Israel-ites to love and honour the stranger; the Buddha taught layfolk and monks alike a method of meditation called “the Immeasurables”, in which they systematically extended benevolent thoughts to the four corners of the world. Jesus told his disciples to love their enemies. This impartial sympathy would break down the barricades of egotism, because it was offered with little hope of any return.Beside the point and ignoring the fact that half her examples derive their mandates from a divine source of accountability. Moreover, there is a glaring difference between the divine accountability of the Judeo-Christian faith and the niceness of the two oriental philosphies. Again, in a very real sense, if there is no accountability higher than myself, then why bother? (Granted Catholicism does not teach that the threat of that accountability is the only or best motivation, but it’s a valid point of consideration.)
If a ruler practised jian ai
, Mo-tzu taught, war would be impossible. The Axial religions all developed in regions that were convulsed by violence on an unprecedented scale. Iron weaponry meant that warfare had become more deadly; states had become more coercive; in the market place, merchants preyed on each other aggressively. In every case, throughout the Axial Age, the catalyst for religious change was always a disciplined revulsion towards this violence.🤷
In the 9th century, the ritualists of India systematically extracted all the violence from the sacrificial ritual, and in seeking the cause of aggression in the psyche, discovered the inner self. Renouncers, Buddhists and Jains all insisted that ahimsa
, “harmlessness”, was an indispensable prerequisite to enlightenment. In the Tao Te Ching, Lao-tzu pointed out that violence could only elicit more violence. The sage-ruler must always seek to bring a military campaign to a speedy end: “Bring it to a conclusion, but do not intimidate.” Some of the gospels present Jesus as a man of ahimsa who taught his followers to turn the other cheek.I guess this is her version of evidence, but it nowehere seems to me to preclude that god is optional.
Socrates, one of the greatest figures of the Axial Age, also condemned retaliation as evil. In general, however, the Greeks did not eschew violence. Ultimately, they did not have a religious Axial Age. Their great transformation was philosophical, scientific and mathematical, and pagan religion continued to flourish in Greece until it was forcibly replaced by Christianity in the 5th century CE.
Isn’t she kind of ignoring the whole Greek pantheon of deities here?
Compassion is an unpopular virtue. All too often, religious people have preferred to be right rather than compassionate. They have shielded themselves from the demands of empathy by making secondary and peripheral goals - such as theological correctness or sexual orthodoxy - central to their faith. As the Chinese sages pointed out, vehement professions of belief were essentially egotistic, a pompous trumpeting of self, and, therefore, they impeded enlightenment. Denominational chauvinism, like nationalism, should also be seen as a form of collective egotism or, in monotheistic terms, idolatry.
Here we can refute her from Catholic examples like St. Stephen, St. Francis of Assis, St. Therese of Liseaux, and St. Maximillian Kolbe among many others.
Nevertheless, in our torn, conflicted world, we need to revive the Axial ethos. This does not require orthodox belief and need not involve the supernatural. In the Axial Age, individualism was beginning to supersede the older tribal or communal expressions of identity. The sages were trying to moderate the clash of competing egos and they were all concerned about the plight of society. We are still rampant, chronic individualists, but our technology has created a global village, which is interconnected electronically, militarily, politically and economically. If we want to survive, it makes practical sense to cultivate jian ai
. We need to apply the Golden Rule politically, and learn that other nations, however remote from our own, are as important as ours.You might tie this in with some references to the newest papal encyclical Caritas in vertiate which has much to say about this compassion in truth.

I really don’t see where she has done anything very conclusive and convincing to make a case that God is irrelevant, but it’s pretty well written and makes a nice rhetorical sales pitch that I think you can probably decimate & get a good grade on.
 
I go to a public city college…and right now we are writing argumentative essays in my english class. (Argumentative btw is the style of essay, not my personality at all). We have to choose 2 essays out of our readers that oppose eachother, and argue the side of which we agree. I have choosen “The Rival Conceptions of God” - C.S Lewis (the ONLY story in the reader somewhat supporting God), and “Whats God Got to do With it?” -Karen Armstrong, who basically is stating that God isnt essential to religion, and that we should all adopt religions such as buddhism etc…which would promote peace…I know for myself God has EVERTHING to do with it…but I need to present a good argument as to WHY, in response to her essay. Please read the essay, its only like 2 pages, in its full text at this location:

newstatesman.com/200604100023

I would really appreciate any advice, quotes, or general direction any one can give me in order to make an educated, sound arguement defending my faith and God. This is very important to me because I go to a public city college, and I notice the way every semester the teachers find ways to almost, belittle those who have my frame of mind- it never fails. And most of the other people in my classes are kids straight out of high school who just soak in the secular propaganda…so…I’d like to offer another point of view. Thank you guys for all your help!!
Hi, here is my small contribution: By mariox.

If you are seeking to prove or to find someone who can prove the existence of God, you are wasting your time. We know about God only because He has revealed himself to us through the Bible. His revelation reached its fulfilment in Jesus Christ. Through the Bible and through His church he has also revealed Himself to you.

God chose to reveal Himself not to Buddha or Confucius but to his chosen people, through His prophets. The people mentioned by Karen Armstrong (an ex-Catholic nun and a student of religion who apparently had a negative experience with her vocation) were seekers of a way of life that gave them interior peace. They sought peace by looking for ways to “transcend themselves”, to achieve “enhanced humanity”. The author argues that this is all that is needed and that hence one can dispense with the concept of God altogether. Essentially, she argues that it is the way you live and interact with others which counts and not what meta-physical concepts you believe in.

Is not this exactly what most Christians are taught to believe too? Christians, and many people of other faiths too, know that it is good to be compassionate, and that one should do to others as he wants done to him/herself. But can one have these values in a vacuum, so to say? All values are derived from and are based on principles. Christians have 2 fundamental principles, to love God with all their might and to love their neighbour as themselves. All Christian values are derived from these two principles. Hence, forgiveness, compassion, charity etc. make perfect sense to Christians. But why should a non-believer be compassionate? What does he obtain from it? Self-transcendence, which means going beyond oneself and overcoming the self-centric urges of the Ego? This is a very hard thing to achieve, why should anyone try it? And how would anyone know that self-transcendence is reached in this way and that when reached it would produce the desired fruits?

If one were to confine himself to the belief that man is just a product of evolution, it becomes very difficult to justify these values. (Evolutionary biologists go through many intellectual contortions in their efforts to do so). Nature as revealed to us by science does not teach compassion, it only pushes for reproduction. It makes people, the product of evolution, egocentric beings. So where did these great men of the Axial Age obtain their values from?

God did not reveal himself to Buddha or to M-tzu. This does not mean however, that he did not plant His seed in their minds. 😉
 
newstatesman.com/200604100023

I would really appreciate any advice, quotes, or general direction any one can give me in order to make an educated, sound arguement defending my faith and God. This is very important to me because I go to a public city college, and I notice the way every semester the teachers find ways to almost, belittle those who have my frame of mind- it never fails. And most of the other people in my classes are kids straight out of high school who just soak in the secular propaganda…so…I’d like to offer another point of view. Thank you guys for all your help!!
The author Karen Armstrong is suggesting that we answer the innate human sense of the possibility of God by ignoring it. She is historically incorrect in obliquely agreeing with unnamed taxi cab drivers that religion has been the “cause of all wars in history”. Not religion, but precisely the negation of it, can be seen in the great wars of our age. Those who openly denied religion brought us the concentration camps, the gulags, the killing fields of Cambodia. Hitler said, “Thunderbolts do not spare churches.” and “If I can accept that a divine command exists it is this one: thou shalt preserve the species.” Marx postulated that religion is the opiate of the masses. Are these killers and fathers of killers to now be construed as religious?

And yet at the same time she acknowledges the effect of religion on society is palliative. She is opposed, therefore, to a belief in God but supports the promulgation of God-like behavior. The problem is that one cannot explain why human beings should behave in a way that pleases God without a belief in God. Furthermore, human beings will not naturally behave in the way she envisions, as the record of our age richly attests.

Her inclusion of a multiplicity of beliefs is used to cast doubt on the existence of truth and ultimately on the existence of God. One could just as easily offer that where there’s smoke there’s fire. The multiplicity of historical beliefs and the universality of the rational sense that God exists in some form documents that humanity in all its states of existence has found the existence of a deity likely. The diversity has been in an understanding of the qualities of that deity. And if God does exist, as man has found irresistibly likely, there must be a truth about him. If two views diametrically diverge, one must be correct and the other incorrect.

Reason, not experience or results, is the test of those diverging propositions. If belief cannot rationally and logically be supported, it cannot be true, for truth penetrates reason and truth will out. To proffer that man should sidestep the argument is to doubt the efficacy of reason itself and to leave man bereft of any remedy to the very conditions the author deplores.

Finally one can observe that the Judaeo-Christian belief begins with the most unlikely premise considering the state of man and the conditions of this existence: that God is all good, all knowing, all powerful, all loving, all just and that God is unseen but knowable. This difficult vision of God has persisted for ten thousand years and has been pursued and expounded by the flower of rational thought and by the humblest and meanest of men. That they have been willing to stake their lives to it and give their lives for it contributes to its credibility. To ignore it will not make it go away.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top