:nope:Let me be very clear here -…:nope:
:nope: I in no way support nor condone the willful act of an abortion:nope:
:nope: This post should
not be interrupted in any way, that would suggest that I would do so at any time :nope:
Abortion is a grave sin. In fact, it’s intrinsically evil, so it is always a grave sin (in other words, there are no mitigating circumstances under which it might be considered not to be sinful).
A mortal sin is a sin that is a grave sin, which is committed with full knowledge of its gravely sinful nature and with deliberate consent to commit the sin. If these three conditions aren’t all met, then it is not a mortal sin. That holds for all sins, not just any particular one…
Gorgias,
There certainly are situations wherein the abortion isn’t automatically a mortal sin (or even a sin at all) for the person** receiving **the abortion - still intrinsically evil but not always a mortal sin (or sinful act)… You give the conditions right there, especially the two I’ve highlighted in red.
Of the two, lack of free choice is the more likely mitigating condition. Any person
forced to have an abortion (i.e. a minor child, an individual threatened with death (as can happen with prostitutes), or another form of coercion especially that relating to the loss of life or limb from self or others) fails the deliberate consent requirement. Still a grave act, still intrinsically evil, yet the person may not be guilty of mortal sin (or of any sin).
Also, we must keep in mind that there are people in this world that do not know or understand the severity of the act nor that it is intrinsically evil such as a minor child or someone of diminished mental capacity due to a medical condition; thus, such a person would fail the second condition.
This has been covered in a dozen threads, one such:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=657164
Also:
EWTN: Abortion - Excommunication
NOTE WELL To actually incur the excommunication one must know that it is an excommunicable offense at the time of the abortion. Canon 1323 provides that the following do not incur a sanction, those who are not yet 16, are unaware of a law, do not advert to it or are in error about its scope, were forced or had an unforeseeable accident, acted out of grave fear, or who lacked the use of reason (except culpably, as by drunkenness). Thus a woman forced by an abusive husband to have an abortion would not incur an excommunication, for instance, whereas someone culpably under the influence of drugs or alcohol would (canon 1325).
If Excommunication isn’t automatic, then neither is the act automatically a mortal sin or even a sin at all for that person - that of course does not relive the person performing the act - they are most likely committing a mortal sin (I can’t imagine a case where such a person wouldn’t be; however, there is the case of coercion should such a person performing the act do so under duress - must be done with free will!).
We must also consider that a medical act taken, without the intent to cause an abortion, that results in a spontaneous abortion may also fail to be a sinful act by anyone involved… For example, in the case of an ectopic pregnancy (where the baby develops outside the womb) where the mother’s doctors determine that the only way to ensure her survival is to remove the fallopian tube (resulting in the death of the baby) is not a sin because the death of the child was not the desired result, it is an unavoidable consequence of the procedure to save the mother’s life.
:nope:ONCE AGAIN, let me be very clear, I do
not condone the willful act of abortion for abortion’s sake:nope: