When did the "Catholic" Church begin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Charlemagne_II
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Charlemagne_II

Guest
I am directing this question mostly at Protestants, though Catholics are welcome to assist.

I’d like a Protestant to explain to me when early Christianity “slipped” into becoming the Catholic Church. If the Protestants know their history, they ought to know just about exactly when the “Catholic” Church arrived to displace true Christianity. If Protestants cannot answer that question, how can they say that the Catholic Church ever failed to be the Church of Christ?
 
I am directing this question mostly at Protestants, though Catholics are welcome to assist.

I’d like a Protestant to explain to me when early Christianity “slipped” into becoming the Catholic Church. If the Protestants know their history, they ought to know just about exactly when the “Catholic” Church arrived to displace true Christianity. If Protestants cannot answer that question, how can they say that the Catholic Church ever failed to be the Church of Christ?
Let me pull on the fireproof underwear before the flames start.

Ok. Christianity per se was just Jesus and his Apostles until the resurrection. Then it was the original 12 - Judas + Matthias and then + Paul, Silas, Timothy et al.

At this point it could be argued that they were “reform minded” Jews who recognized that the Messiah had indeed arrived.

I would say that Christianity never “slipped” into Catholicism unless I could have been said to have “slipped” into adulthood.

But to peg a date I’m going with A.D. 67 with the death of Saint Peter and the Papacy of St. Linus.
 
Which “Catholic” Church…

Jesus, Who is the fullness of Truth, as is the Church (and they can’t have different truth and still be the fullness of truth)

The Visible Church, the Bride of Christ, which exists in its heirarchy to feed and tend His flock

or

The part of the Body of Believers who fully adhere to the Doctrines of Faith and do not separate themselves into other faith communities?
 
Just to be clear, I am not saying Peter was not Pope. Just that the Papacy is the continuation of the Barque of St. Peter.
 
From the Catechism…

*Paragraph 766 “The origin and growth of the Church are symbolized by the blood and water which flowed from the open side of the crucified Jesus.”…the Church was born from the pierced heart of Christ hanging dead on the cross.

Paragraph 767 …on the day of Pentecost…the Church was openly displayed to the crowds and the spread of the Gospel among the nations, through preaching, was begun."*
 
The name “the Catholic Church” (Greek: katholikos ekklesia) developed from Acts 9:31 “the Church throughout all” (Greek: ekklesia kath olos).
 
Are you saking about the Catholic Church or the catholic church? The Catholic Church may be defined as beginning when she first identified herself as independent from the Byzantine Church in 1054. Just a thought, not a firm position by any means 🙂
 
Are you saking about the Catholic Church or the catholic church? The Catholic Church may be defined as beginning when she first identified herself as independent from the Byzantine Church in 1054. Just a thought, not a firm position by any means 🙂
The Catholic Church (with a capital C) is the Church established by Christ on Peter. The Orthodox Churches are in schism and not the other way round.
 
Which “Catholic” Church…

Jesus, Who is the fullness of Truth, as is the Church (and they can’t have different truth and still be the fullness of truth)

The Visible Church, the Bride of Christ, which exists in its heirarchy to feed and tend His flock

or

The part of the Body of Believers who fully adhere to the Doctrines of Faith and do not separate themselves into other faith communities?
The phrase “Catholic Church” first appears in St. Ignatius of Antioch (+ 117 A.D.), Epistle to the Smyrnaeans viii 2 - “wheresoever Christ Jesus is, there is the Catholic Church.” The word “Catholic” is Greek and means “universal,” or literally, “according to the whole.” It follows, then, that the Church can be called “Catholic” in a variety of senses:
  1. PLACE - inasmuch as she is diffused throughout the world
  2. TIME - because she will always exist
  3. PEOPLES - having members from every tribe, nation, and tongue
  4. CONDITIONS OF MEN - for neither masters or slaves, neither wise nor foolish, are excluded from her fold
  5. DOCTRINE - in that she possses the entire teaching of Christ in its unimpaired truth
  6. THE MEANS OF SALVATION - because, as the whole of Christ’s Passion operates within her, she possesses a remedy against the spiritual ills of all men
  7. THE OBLIGATION AND NECESSITY OF EMBRACING THE CHURCH - which bears upon all, as she is the divinely appointed means of salvation.
 
So far as I can tell, no Protestant has arrived in this forum to tell us when the “Catholic” Church came into being and displaced true Christianity. The conclusion to be drawn is that the Catholic Church never did displace true Christianity because it *is *true Christianity.
 
So far as I can tell, no Protestant has arrived in this forum to tell us when the “Catholic” Church came into being and displaced true Christianity. The conclusion to be drawn is that the Catholic Church never did displace true Christianity because it *is *true Christianity.
Exactly! 👍
 
So far as I can tell, no Protestant has arrived in this forum to tell us when the “Catholic” Church came into being and displaced true Christianity. The conclusion to be drawn is that the Catholic Church never did displace true Christianity because it *is *true Christianity.
Hey! I’m a protestant and it looks like I was out argued about the start date by about 30 years but who can actually argue that the Catholic church displaced Christianity? That would take a [someone who can only be described by an uncharitable comment]

Actually, I had friends when I was in high school that were Baptists who told me that their church dated back to John the Baptist. Being raised by a seminarian I immediately told them to stop eating barbque if they were Jewish. We didn’t discuss religion much after that.
 
Hey! I’m a protestant …

…
. We didn’t discuss religion much after that.
I saw your bio…,

When are you coming home… or what is preventing you?

If it is prayer, I will add some for your intentions.

For you, the Catholic Church will come alive again when you come home.👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top