When do identical twins receive their spiritual soul?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Buntspecht
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Divested of our human bodies, we will be outside of time and in eternity. We will receive an “eternal body” so as to live with our LORD in Heaven.
We will not be permanently divested of our human bodies. Our current physical bodies will be restored to us at the Resurrection in glorified form, as Jesus resurrected his same physical body (edit: our Lady, too, we believe retains her same physical body). At that time, our physical bodies will not have our current limitations and also be immortal.
 
You’re still arguing for a pre-existent soul.
That’s not correct. According to the donum vitae instruction, the soul is created at the time of conception. Before conception, there is neither a body nor a soul.

However, the soul is created by God himself, while the human body is usually created in the marital act.
It may be that you are thinking that bodies and souls are separate entities.
At least they have a different origin. However, that does not necessarily mean they are separate entities.

Best regards,
Buntspecht
 
The Church does not definitively teach that the soul is immediately infused at the moment of conception.
But how do you understand the following section from the donum vitae instruction?

From the moment of conception, the life of every human being is to be respected in an absolute way because man is the only creature on earth that God has "wished for himself " and the spiritual soul of each man is “immediately created” by God;

Best regards,
Buntspecht
 
The human soul is what animates a human body. It doesn’t “enter” a body, it is intrinsic to it. The instant a human being begins to exist s/he is a body and soul. S/he isn’t a body that “acquires” a soul.
Exactly. You have three separate zygotes in the process and three distinct bodies so you have three separate souls.

A5: Zygote A dies during the process of twinning and from the process emerges zygote B and zygote C, each with their own individual soul.
 
That’s not correct. According to the donum vitae instruction, the soul is created at the time of conception. Before conception, there is neither a body nor a soul.

However, the soul is created by God himself, while the human body is usually created in the marital act.

At least they have a different origin. However, that does not necessarily mean they are separate entities.

Best regards,
Buntspecht
Well, yes and no. Since the soul is what animates the body, yes, it certainly is created at the moment of conception, when the egg and sperm join to create a new human being. I wouldn’t put it that God creates the soul in a sort of fiat kind of way, though. The gift of immortal life is intrinsic to human persons, given by God in the initial creation of man. It doesn’t need any special act on God’s part to make it happen in each individual.

God knowing we will be created in the act of conception and him deliberately stepping in to make it happen are two different things.

My fear was that you seemed to be advocating that God has souls waiting on ice (to put it in a colorful term) waiting to be put into a human body. That was the point I wished to clarify. I’m very glad to read you aren’t proposing that kind of idea. 🙂
 
But how do you understand the following section from the donum vitae instruction?

From the moment of conception, the life of every human being is to be respected in an absolute way because man is the only creature on earth that God has "wished for himself " and the spiritual soul of each man is “immediately created” by God;

Best regards,
Buntspecht
It is true that from the moment of conception, there is a new human life, and hence that needs to be respected and protected. It is also true that each human soul is immediately created by God. The term “immediate” however is not meant in a temporal sense. We often speak of immediate as occuring in time right now. In theological language, however, immediate is distinguished from mediate. To say that God immediately creates the soul means that he does so without human agency intervening. Think of it as a synonym for “directly”.

A2 is tenable whether the soul is infused at conception or at some later time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top