I feel sorry for this girl you’re interested in, Belgarion. Obviously, we can all see, you are a great person, and her father, like many parents, keep their kids back from pursuing their own happiness and futures, because of their own selfish agendas. Not that he is selfish, but if she is nearing 20…what is he afraid is going to happen? He’s afraid she’s going to marry you or some other boy, and move on…and he wants her at home, so he can perhaps live vicariously through her, or control her, or have her tend to the house, but whatever his reasons, they seem to amount to his desire to hold her back from happiness and pursuing her own dreams, and relationships. I think if you were a different person, the result would be the same–a controlling father who can’t let his daughter go on with her life. I will pray for her in this situation, and you. It’s noble for you to wish to hang in there…that part is completely up to you. Just know, her dad isn’t overly cautious because it’s you…she’s not 15. He is being this way most likely, because he isn’t happy in his own life, and wants to prevent his kid from having a life of her own, filled with potential and happiness. Sad. I have a friend whose parents tried to sabotage her relationship with her ‘now’ husband…but, it was hard. Her mom was pretty controlling, and miserable, but has sought counseling, and is much better.
I don’t know her dad, of course, but there really is no valid reason to prevent one’s ADULT child from pursuing a relationship with a good person. None.
I understand and I agree. In fact, I wouldn’t be surprised if he was trying to live vicariously through her, and the rest of the siblings. However, the details of why I think that should remain private.
And I thank you for the compliments! Really, I’m undeserving!
LJN21:
At 18ish I would (and think I did) recommend just going along with her fathers wishes because she was still living under his roof and it was a little on the young side to actually get married. Nearing 20 and the length of time this has gone on it well past reasonable. Cut him how as much as possible and let her tell you what she wants.
well, she is still living under his roof, and will likely remain so until she is married. As I said before, there’s nothing wrong with that, my sister did the same thing. But she was given a little more freedom, I think
lenni:
so question now is - are you going to step up your game??
just even discuss it with her. the idea - find out what she wants to do.(dont make it awkward though, cause you both really like each other now, its dead obvious) but how do you even know what she wants to do if you havent asked her. Dont assume that she is her dad and she has the same opinions (that is what you have been doing for this past year). like another poster said - talk to her one on one and see where you want to go next.
Here’s the deal.
BECAUSE of these feelings we have for each other, and the family’s uber-traditional rules, we cannot even be alone with each other.
So, if I were to TRY to get her alone, it’d be bad. If I were to talk to her about this stuff, it’d be bad.
“Why?” you ask.
I’ll spin a tale of horror and mayhem.
The last one in the family to get married was the older brother.
One of the coolest and funniest guys I know.
Now, he and his now-wife started talking alone, over IM, etc. They got close, and his family started to notice. They didn’t think she was right for him, and decided that they shouldn’t be speaking to each other.
So they started leaving immediately after Mass, and choir practices to avoid any social interaction. The brother had no say in the matter. I believe they ceased interacting with her family, even though their families had been friends for YEARS.
So you know what? I am afraid they’ll try the same thing with me.
Yes, that’s right. Afraid.

That’s why I haven’t tried sending her a letter, or finding some way to talk to HER about this. Because I’m afraid they’ll try to take her away from me, and I won’t be prepared to do anything about it.
Fortunately for the brother, he moved out at that point and continued seeing the girl without famly permission or interference. I won’t underestimate her, but I don’t think the young woman I am interested in will do the same.
yes i know you mean well when you did say that but you have to put it into perspective. You are just at the friend level with his daughter and to randomly say to her dad - ‘i want to marry your daughter’ is actually quite big. and scary for a dad, because to him, it may mean, loosing another daughter. or she is tooo young to get married. if that helps clear up what i meant when i said - ‘forward’
Well I obviously didn’t come to him and say this the first time I talked to him about it!!!
I had gotten to know her for months, asked his permission to court her. He said wait, I waited for around a year and a half! Without anything at all from him! Just getting to know her better! And I did! So what I have learned about her has amazed me completely. More than I thought it would. Heck, more than I dreamt it would. This was serious for me. So I gave him a fair warning, and definitely not too soon.
Jade Tiger said:

Dude…
This is like one of those Romeo-Juliet novels, complete with father you (reader) love to hate.
I thought that never happened in real life!
Praying for you!
thank you for your prayers
…I didn’t know my drama was so entertaining…

One comment I’d like to add to that, though…I REALLY don’t want to kill myself…And I’d rather that she refrain from doing so as well… lol