When "Papist" just isn't insulting enough

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gamera
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

Gamera

Guest
Here’s an anti-Catholic slur which I’d never heard before (Catholic apologist John Martignoni’s e-mail newsletter contained this one in a quotation).

“Vaticanist.”

What is wrong with people? I don’t agree with, for example, Anglicanism, but I don’t sit around thinking up insulting alternative names for Anglicans. Seriously, how can anyone with even a passing familiarity with the Gospel think that it’s okay to sit around thinking up new insults?
 
I find “God murderer” slightly more insulting.

(The phrase comes from the Protestants who argue that we’re sacrificing Jesus again and again every Mass.)
 
I find “God murderer” slightly more insulting.

(The phrase comes from the Protestants who argue that we’re sacrificing Jesus again and again every Mass.)
I’ve never heard that before either. How awful.
 
I find “God murderer” slightly more insulting.

(The phrase comes from the Protestants who argue that we’re sacrificing Jesus again and again every Mass.)
The Jews have been called ‘Christ-killers’ for centuries, so at least we Catholics are in good company!
 
I don’t really get it. If someone were to ever call me a ‘Vaticanist’ or a ‘Vaticanite’, why would that be offensive?
 
The Jews have been called ‘Christ-killers’ for centuries, so at least we Catholics are in good company!
Hear! Hear! And at least there is a Vatican from which a formal apology for Catholic anti-semitism could be promulgated on behalf of all Catholics.

From where would Protestants issue an apology for anti-Catholicism on behalf of all Protestants? Wittenberg? Canterbury? Geneva? Zurich?

How about, nowhere. Protestants have no voice. Is that not one of the best arguments our there for ‘Papistry’? Come on, we can laugh about it. They like to make up derogatory names because they envy our unity. One God, one Church, one Pope, one Curia. It’s simple. Simple is good.
 
If you want to know who the smartest kid in school is, see which one all the kids are teasing. 😉
 
I don’t agree with, for example, Anglicanism, but I don’t sit around thinking up insulting alternative names for Anglicans.
Nor should you. But isn’t it slightly ironic that the first Protestants to use the English term ‘Papist’ were Anglicans? Yet even today, Rowan Williams, Archbishop of Canterbury, cannot speak on behalf of all Anglicans. All he could do was ‘pray and hope for the best’ when the apostate American Anglicans met in New Orleans to decide whether they would slide further into apostacy or heed Rowan’s powerless pleas to comply with the rest of Anglicanism. And Rowan is supposedly an Anglican ‘instrument of unity’. OK, there’s only one Archbishop of Canterbury. But he’s far from instrumental in anything that really matters, at least outside his province (southern England).
 
I don’t really get it. If someone were to ever call me a ‘Vaticanist’ or a ‘Vaticanite’, why would that be offensive?
I agree. I see myself as a citizen of the Vatican. I don’t live there, but I would if I could.

We should actually thank them for being so well informed as to know the Vatican is a sovereign state, and recognize us as citizens, no?

[My Lutheran wife won’t let me fly the Vatican flag on our house next to Old Glory, otherwise it would be out there right now :rolleyes: ]



[SIGN]FLY, you beautiful flag, FLY!![/SIGN]
 
My Lutheran wife won’t let me fly the Vatican flag on our house next to Old Glory, otherwise it would be out there right now
Surely you know that you and your wife are now officially in agreement on many aspects of the most important issue that once separated you: justification.

vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/documents/rc_pc_chrstuni_doc_31101999_cath-luth-joint-declaration_en.html

Wittenberg has always been closest to Rome amongst all Protestant denominations.

Anglicans please note that the Church of England has always been, in terms of its sacramental theology, a via media between Geneva and Wittenberg, never Geneva and Rome. That’s because no devout Lutheran would even dream of chucking ‘leftover communion’ into the rubbish bin (unlike many Anglicans with no belief in the Real Presence).
 
Surely you know that you and your wife are now in full and official agreement on many aspects of the most important issue that once separated you: justification.

vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/documents/rc_pc_chrstuni_doc_31101999_cath-luth-joint-declaration_en.html

Wittenberg has always been closest to Rome amongst all Protestant denominations. (Anglicans please note that the Church of England was when it was ‘created’, in terms of its sacramental theology, a via media between Geneva and Wittenberg, never Geneva and Rome.

That is surely not quite true.

vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/documents/rc_pc_chrstuni_doc_01081998_off-answer-catholic_en.html
 
That is surely not quite true.
Agreed. I’ve edited the post you quoted to reflect that more sober reality.

But the undisputed points of agreement are quite phenomenal.If anything, the JDOJ demonstrates the significance of the doctrine of justification as fundamental. In the end, the JDOJ reminds us that both aspects, imputation (‘assigned’ righteousness, ie Protestant view) and infusion (‘actual’ righteousness, ie the Catholic view), are necessary to a full account of human salvation.
 
Here’s an anti-Catholic slur which I’d never heard before (Catholic apologist John Martignoni’s e-mail newsletter contained this one in a quotation).

“Vaticanist.”

What is wrong with people? I don’t agree with, for example, Anglicanism, but I don’t sit around thinking up insulting alternative names for Anglicans. Seriously, how can anyone with even a passing familiarity with the Gospel think that it’s okay to sit around thinking up new insults?
Does that make them anti-Vaticanites?
 
I’ve heard Vaticanist, Romanist, Papist, Mary-worshipper, God-murderer, and a number of other slurs hurled at me.
 
Agreed. I’ve edited the post you quoted to reflect that more sober reality.

But the undisputed points of agreement are quite phenomenal.If anything, the JDOJ demonstrates the significance of the doctrine of justification as fundamental. In the end, the JDOJ reminds us that both aspects, imputation (‘assigned’ righteousness, ie Protestant view) and infusion (‘actual’ righteousness, ie the Catholic view), are necessary to a full account of human salvation./QUOTE]​

Please point to the sections in the JDOJ --in which the above is clarified.
 
I’ve heard Vaticanist, Romanist, Papist, Mary-worshipper, God-murderer, and a number of other slurs hurled at me.
All of which are like sweet kisses compared to what was hurled at Christ.

Let the anti-Catholics spread their lies. It is impossible to see the face of Christ in such unChristian behavior, and as those poor souls in anti-Catholic pews are confronted with the very Christian lives led by Catholics, the Tiber will swell with swimmers.

The wonderful thing about the Information Age is we are at last able to easily share the truth and wonder of the Church with those who previously could experience it only through the calumnies of wicked men.
 
How about this one – which, by the way, makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. I only wish I could remember where I saw it.

CATHOHOLICS.

Wow.

Peace,
Dante
 
I have always felt that deep down the reason for so much hatred hurled at Catholics, is because all other Christians are just afraid and deep down sure, that we are in fact the Church instituted by Jesus, and they are the disloyal ones who ran away behind the pied piper of Luther…

lol…It makes me feel good when I think that…😉 :signofcross:
 
I’ve heard Vaticanist, Romanist, Papist, Mary-worshipper, God-murderer, and a number of other slurs hurled at me.
You forgot “minnow munchers” and “mackerel snappers.”

I guess if you can’t beat them and don’t want to admit they are right - you just have to resort to name calling.

Stillkickin 😃
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top