Where do atheists go when they die?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lisa44
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Do atheists go straight to hell? Or can they go to purgatory, or even heaven?

Thanks
Depends on their behavior on Earth-- I mean, I personally believe everyone makes it to heaven, but assuming that none of you believe that, I’ll my safe road and say it depends on actions.

Ironically Yours, Blade and Blood
 
The Catechism of the Catholic Church
161 - thanks

Does the reading from last Sunday have any bearing on the subject? Atheists have no faith in God, and therefore it will be quite a shock to them when they die. Faith is a choice. For those who choose not to believe in God, it just can’t be good.

The catechism says they will not recieve eternal life.

1 Thessalonians 5: 1 - 6​

1 But as to the times and the seasons, brethren, you have no need to have anything written to you.
2 For you yourselves know well that the day of the Lord will come like a thief in the night.
3 When people say, “There is peace and security,” then sudden destruction will come upon them as travail comes upon a woman with child, and there will be no escape.
4 But you are not in darkness, brethren, for that day to surprise you like a thief.
5 For you are all sons of light and sons of the day; we are not of the night or of darkness.
6 So then let us not sleep, as others do, but let us keep awake and be sober.
 
Do atheists go straight to hell? Or can they go to purgatory, or even heaven?

Thanks
  1. Everyone who goes to Purgatory goes to Heaven also.
  2. St. Augustine and St. Anselm would probably agree with me in saying that atheists go to Hell. Atheists can’t really plead ignorance…atheism is contrary to reason. So yeah, atheism is a sin against the virtue of religion, it completely neglects the call of man to love God, and, quoting St. Augustine “to cling to the immutable Good.” So uh…yeah. Atheists shall burn in Hell. 🙂
 
  1. St. Augustine and St. Anselm would probably agree with me in saying that atheists go to Hell. Atheists can’t really plead ignorance…atheism is contrary to reason. So yeah, atheism is a sin against the virtue of religion, it completely neglects the call of man to love God, and, quoting St. Augustine “to cling to the immutable Good.” So uh…yeah. Atheists shall burn in Hell. 🙂
I’ll throw a difficult case at you, just to play (a very ironic thing to play in response to this) devil’s advocate. What about Fred Phelps’s son?

Beaten by his father every day, screamed at that God was hateful and that nearly all the world would go to Hell, that there was no salvation outside of the Westboro Baptist Church, none whatsoever. When he finally breaks free of his father’s brainwashing, he decides that religion is harmful and becomes an atheist.

When he dies, what will happen to him? He never really had a chance to develop normally in any faith. Think of what he must remember every time someone quotes the Bible. Will he go to hell?
 
I’ll throw a difficult case at you, just to play (a very ironic thing to play in response to this) devil’s advocate. What about Fred Phelps’s son?

Beaten by his father every day, screamed at that God was hateful and that nearly all the world would go to Hell, that there was no salvation outside of the Westboro Baptist Church, none whatsoever. When he finally breaks free of his father’s brainwashing, he decides that religion is harmful and becomes an atheist.

When he dies, what will happen to him? He never really had a chance to develop normally in any faith. Think of what he must remember every time someone quotes the Bible. Will he go to hell?
Yes. Quoting the Psalms and St. Anselm, “the fool has said in his heart there is no God.”
 
So this would not be a case of invincible ignorance, considering his very view of religion was twisted from birth?
I’m going to have answer in the negative. There are some cases in which you can genuinely argue this point, such as is the case for the Jew, the Moslem, the ancient pagan…etc, who have never heard of this thing called “Christianity.”

That said! Every man is under a moral obligation to seek after the truth. There is a moral imperative for every man to actively figure out what’s right.

No man can claim ignorance about God’s existence.
Romans 1:18-20:
For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and injustice of those men that detain the truth of God in injustice: 19 Because that which is known of God is manifest in them. For God hath manifested it unto them. 20 For the invisible things of him, from the creation of the world, are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made; his eternal power also, and divinity: so that they are **inexcusable. **
Likewise, the Psalmist says what I said that he does in the previous post. Whether we understand our knowledge of God to be a priori as St. Augustine, St. Anselm, St. Bonaventure, etc. do…or whether we understand it as a posteriori as Aristotle and St. Thomas Aquinas (to an extent errantly) do…well…we can’t deny that God’s existence is self evident. As St. Paul says, atheism is inexcusable. Period.
 
So this would not be a case of invincible ignorance, considering his very view of religion was twisted from birth?
The natural law is written by God upon everyone’s heart. Part of that law is the knowledge that their is one true God. Thus, denial of God is not in the same category of invincible ignorance, which only deals with revealed truth (i.e., Trinity, Jesus, etc.).
 
Unfortunately, I don’t think many people in the western world fall under that criteria. I’ve never met anyone in my life who never heard of a bible or Jesus Christ. And every athiest I know says “oh I don’t believe in that…etc”. They reject Jesus, but they also reject the entire notion of a God who loves us and who created the world.

I think children or even young adults might fall under baptism of desire, as they have not yet been educated about religion, growing up in an atheist house. Then when they are adults they may become baptized. However, the belief in god was always in them despite the fact that their parents did nothing to cultivate it and even tried to suppress it.
I said nothing of the odds or the numbers who fall under this category (and neither does the Church). I’ll leave the statistical analysis to God. 😉
 
JMJ_coder":
Thus, denial of God is not in the same category of invincible ignorance, which only deals with revealed truth (i.e., Trinity, Jesus, etc.).
To some extent, I’d argue that even the knowledge that there is a plurality of hypostases in God is self-apparent. See the Itinerarium Mentis in Deum (chapter 6) and the De Reductione Artium ad Theologiam (section 23) by St. Bonaventure.

I’d argue that even the Jew and the Moslem are without excuse. The only religions that I can really think of that are…well…“safe,” so to speak in claiming ignorance are maybe some of the Eastern religions.
 
You addressed something I never said. Respectfully, you did not address the substance of my post at all. Respectfully, go back and read it and addess what I wrote and I will be happy to engage.
I have reread your post and I stand by mine. Again in this one, you seem to complete dismiss the Church’s teaching that there are those who are brought into the Church other than by sacramental Baptism(whether that is your intent or not, that is how it appears).
I don’t think anyone is saved by being good. I do think Christians (Catholic, Protestant and Orthodox) are much more likely to go to heaven because they are baptized and primarily because they throw themselves on Christ mercy. You will notice that I started with a quote from Jesus himself on the matter. I don’t see how one can argue with that.
I don’t disagree that one is saved merely by being some ethereal notion of good. First, what does good mean? The Church teaches that those who by no fault of their own haven’t heard the Gospel (condition 1) and obey the natural law (condition 2) and if they would desire to be baptized if they had known about it (condition 3) may also enter the Church via Baptism of Desire and be saved (remember, God is not confined by His Sacraments). The numbers who fulfill condition 1 in this world of instantaneous communications are, in my opinion, dwindling year by year. Condition 3 is something only God could possibly know. Condition 2 is the clincher though. You must obey the natural law - which includes worship of the one God and avoiding evil (i.e., mortal sins such as murder, adultery, stealing, etc.).
No atheist in the western world is invinsibly ignorant. They are willfully rejecting Christ. Even if they do not have a full understanding of the gospel. If they reject the very idea of God they are clearly rejecting Christ and He said such a person is condemned already. Now if one dies on such a state we cannot contradict Jesus.
Atheism is a rejection of the existence of God, part of the natural law. Unless there is some sort of mental defect, this seems to imply a failure to fulfill condition 2 outlined above.
Faith comes through hearing. The exception is not the rule. Scripture and the Catechism are clear how we are saved. The exception clause has never been the primary teaching fo the church on the matter.
But the Church and us as members of the Church must proclaim the whole Gospel, not just the standard, ordinary parts of it.
 
Do atheists go straight to hell? Or can they go to purgatory, or even heaven?

Thanks
They go to the same place they were in for the billions of years before they were alive. Not such a bad deal, eh?
 
To some extent, I’d argue that even the knowledge that there is a plurality of hypostases in God is self-apparent. See the Itinerarium Mentis in Deum (chapter 6) and the De Reductione Artium ad Theologiam (section 23) by St. Bonaventure.

I’d argue that even the Jew and the Moslem are without excuse. The only religions that I can really think of that are…well…“safe,” so to speak in claiming ignorance are maybe some of the Eastern religions.
That’s debatable. I tend to lean on the side that the Trinity cannot be deduced by reason alone - which the Church teaches (CCC 237).
 
I’d like to ask a question that I think is important in such a discussion. These questions usually stem from the modern western notions of rights and entitlements. So:

Does man have a right or is he entitled to be happy and go to heaven?

I contend that no such right exists, and that admission to heaven and eternal happiness and beatitude is a privilege extended to certain men who have followed the will of the Lord - a privilege that is totally gratuitous and is of no merit of our own.
 
That’s debatable. I tend to lean on the side that the Trinity cannot be deduced by reason alone - which the Church teaches (CCC 237).
The Catechism reads:
The Trinity is a mystery of faith in the strict sense, one of the “mysteries that are hidden in God, which can never be known unless they are revealed by God”.58 To be sure, God has left traces of his Trinitarian being in his work of creation and in his Revelation throughout the Old Testament. But his inmost Being as Holy Trinity is a mystery that is inaccessible to reason alone or even to Israel’s faith before the Incarnation of God’s Son and the sending of the Holy Spirit.
Note, I didn’t say this trinity. The thing about Christianity is that is an historical religion. Many of the Christian truths are entirely contingent (they could have been otherwise). Therefore, these truths can’t be deduced (in the strictest sense of the word “deduced”).

That there is a plurality of hypostases in God (I’m leaning towards 3, since that is what St. Bonaventure (St. Anselm also) said). Yet I agree with you in saying that this trinity cannot be deduced.

Thus the reason I said that there may be some other religions which have a believe in a single God with a plurality of hypostases that may be able to claim ignorance.

I’m pretty sure that this is perfectly in line with Catholic teaching, don’t you think so?

It had better be, lest St. Anselm and St. Bonaventure (and probably St. Augustine too, consider* De Trinitate*) be considered heretics.
 
Note, I didn’t say this trinity. The thing about Christianity is that is an historical religion. Many of the Christian truths are entirely contingent (they could have been otherwise). Therefore, these truths can’t be deduced (in the strictest sense of the word “deduced”).
The only thing that could have formed differently is the expression of those truths (for example the difference in Eastern and Western expressions of faith). The truths themselves come from God Who is Truth itself - they couldn’t be different.
That there is a plurality of hypostases in God (I’m leaning towards 3, since that is what St. Bonaventure (St. Anselm also) said). Yet I agree with you in saying that this trinity cannot be deduced.

Thus the reason I said that there may be some other religions which have a believe in a single God with a plurality of hypostases that may be able to claim ignorance.

I’m pretty sure that this is perfectly in line with Catholic teaching, don’t you think so?

It had better be, lest St. Anselm and St. Bonaventure (and probably St. Augustine too, consider* De Trinitate*) be considered heretics.
What other number could there be? There aren’t four persons in one God, nor just 2, nor 5 or 6 or any other number. There are 3 - and every orthodox Father of the Church agrees (I’m not counting heretics such as Arius or Nestorius). The Trinity was definitively proclaimed at the Councils of Nicea I and Constantinople I - and believed from the very beginning.

There is no other religion that believes in anything close to the Trinity (defined broadly as multiple persons in one divinity). There are many that hold to multiple distinct gods and goddesses, some that have their gods coming in different forms, but they are all a single person.
 
40.png
JMJ_coder:
What other number could there be? There aren’t four persons in one God, nor just 2, nor 5 or 6 or any other number. There are 3 - and every orthodox Father of the Church agrees (I’m not counting heretics such as Arius or Nestorius). The Trinity was definitively proclaimed at the Councils of Nicea I and Constantinople I - and believed from the very beginning.

There is no other religion that believes in anything close to the Trinity (defined broadly as multiple persons in one divinity). There are many that hold to multiple distinct gods and goddesses, some that have their gods coming in different forms, but they are all a single person.
Well sure. We are familiar with the Christian faith, and are looking at the history of Salvation in hindsight. But if you said to a Jew in the 1rst millineum Ante Christum, “Hey, in God there are 3 persons in 1 substance,” whereas I am sure that the Jew could have understood the truth of the statement, I am not sure that he would have grasped it as we currently do, now that we are able to look back and say “And God became man,” or “The Holy Ghost has been sent into the world for the forgiveness of sins,” etc.

As I said, I think the mystery of the faith is this trinity in God as we rightly understand it…but that there is in God a community of persons…that, I think, is not necessarily a matter of faith.

We’ll not be accusing the doctors of the Church of heresy, shall we?

PS: The religion I had in mind specifically is Hinduism.
 
  1. Everyone who goes to Purgatory goes to Heaven also.
  2. St. Augustine and St. Anselm would probably agree with me in saying that atheists go to Hell. Atheists can’t really plead ignorance…atheism is contrary to reason. So yeah, atheism is a sin against the virtue of religion, it completely neglects the call of man to love God, and, quoting St. Augustine “to cling to the immutable Good.” So uh…yeah. Atheists shall burn in Hell. 🙂
So what would you do if you had atheist family members? Would you try and convert them? Give them books to read? Tell them they will burn in hell?

This question is for anyone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top