Where is God now?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mollypup
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

mollypup

Guest
I’m sorry, this is my 1st post on here, I came on here to look for help. I have been cursing god and have disowned him and I feel so alone now. My sister has been diagnosed with breast cancer and I cannot understand why, why would god let this happen to her… she is such a good person and has always done good… why does it happen to nice people…I prayed and prayed to god that her results would be ok and he didn’t answer me…pls help:(
 
I’m sorry your sister has breast cancer.Hopefully with good medical care she can beat this disease.I will be praying for her and her health care team.My friend "LIFE"happens to all of us.Good things and bad things,good people and bad people.Faith is the easiest thing in the world to have if you don’t have to rely on it.But to trust when there is no answers,to understand that no matter what life,other people or the devil throws at us,Our Heavenly Father loves and understands us.To trust Him that whatever happens,somehow it will be for our benefit.As Catholics we know the suffering,loneliness and agony our Lord Jesus experianced in the garden as He ask the Father to remove this cup(the Cross)but not my will but thine be done.Please try and trust that whatever happens,our Heavenly Father will bring good out of it.Peace,Rocky.
 
Mother Angelica commented that once when everything was collapsing she asked Jesus> “Why me?” To which she received the reply, “Yes Angelica, and Why ME?” One of the privileges we have which is denied the angels is to participate in His suffering.

With my prayers for you and for your sister. -Joe K.
 
I’m sorry, this is my 1st post on here, I came on here to look for help. I have been cursing god and have disowned him and I feel so alone now. My sister has been diagnosed with breast cancer and I cannot understand why, why would god let this happen to her… she is such a good person and has always done good… why does it happen to nice people…I prayed and prayed to god that her results would be ok and he didn’t answer me…pls help:(
You know, Love, I wonder if St Therese of Lisieux and her sisters might ever have wondered why their Mum got breast cancer. Lacking modern medicine and treatment, she succumbed when St Therese was four. Your sister has better medical hopes.
Recently, St Therese’s mother was Beatified and is now Blessed Zelie.
It must have been very hard for her to know she was leaving all her young daughters, especially her little Therese. Your sister please God will recover. She has a great chance in all the powerful treatments now available.

God’s love was in that family. The father is now Beatified also…so even with terrible illness, God is there. St Therese’s Papa suffered from some kind of dementia later on…and a distant cousing of mine who will be canonized as Australia’s first Saint in October, suffered from strokes later in her life. Illness is part of being human and afflicts anyone, “good” or “not-so-good”. Our human bodies aren’t glorified on this earth as they will be in heaven.

Dearest sister, illness doesn’t mean God isn’t with us. My dearest Dad will die sometime in the next few month, of cancer, but we and he know that God is with him and with us.

God is with you and your sister and your family. It doesn’t feel like it because you’re hurting so much and you’re scared and worried.
A hug from me, Trishie

Oh, and God understands how upset you are and why you have been angry with God. Tell him, sometime soon that you’re sorry, and that you don’t understand, and that you feel desperately miserable about your sister’s illness. And ask God’s help. You’ll possibly go through all those emotions more times, but I ask God to hold you and your family in His love.
 
I’m sorry, this is my 1st post on here, I came on here to look for help. I have been cursing god and have disowned him and I feel so alone now. My sister has been diagnosed with breast cancer and I cannot understand why, why would god let this happen to her… she is such a good person and has always done good… why does it happen to nice people…I prayed and prayed to god that her results would be ok and he didn’t answer me…pls help:(
No prayer goes unanswered. Though, that doesn’t mean the answer is always “Yes.” God says “no” or “wait” quite often, my friend. You see, if it’s not according to His will, it will not happen. To give up faith over that is just sad. My grandma, other grandma, grandpa, uncle, two friends, and some other loved ones have died very recently. I’m talking in a few years span. In fact, my grandma died on Christmas. My grandpa died on his birthday. My other grandma died right before her 50th marriage anniversary. My uncle died right before his birthday, and after a while of fighting to keep alive due to liver failure. I now have an aunt who is about to die due to diabetes, another friend about to die due to cancer, and a Catholic friend from here who just got diagnosed with cancer. Yet, my faith remains strong. Don’t be mad at God. First and foremost, you, I, and Satan alike are all responsible.We’ve all sinned my friend, and everything that goes wrong with us is actually justice for what we’ve done to God. We’ve all sinned, and that includes your sister. I’m sorry for what’s going on with her, but while she might be a nice person, no one is good. Only God is good. I’m not good, nor is my grandpa Jack good for saving his two brothers in WW2. Even the man with one sin is guilty of breaking the whole law of God. This is not to say your sister has no way of salvation, nor the same for you. In fact, we deserve to be dead right now. But God put your sins on Jesus, who was without sin, yet became sin, and sin was nailed to the cross. So believe on Jesus Christ my friend, and He will bear your burdens. Talk to your priest. Talk to someone.
 
I’m sorry, this is my 1st post on here, I came on here to look for help. I have been cursing god and have disowned him and I feel so alone now. My sister has been diagnosed with breast cancer and I cannot understand why, why would god let this happen to her… she is such a good person and has always done good… why does it happen to nice people…I prayed and prayed to god that her results would be ok and he didn’t answer me…pls help:(
I too once was where you are now. I was angry when I prayed and prayed for someone I loved dearly to be spared from suffering, but they weren’t. Gradually God brought me back to faith in Him. It is very lonely and painful. Just look at a crucifix and know that God too knew the pain you are feeling when His Son died on the cross. But as Trishie mentioned, for your sister there is hope. I have 4 friends and a mother that are breast cancer survivors, so much progress has been made in medicine. I will pray for your sister and for you. :gopray2:My love and a hug,
mlz
 
I’m sorry, this is my 1st post on here, I came on here to look for help. I have been cursing god and have disowned him and I feel so alone now. My sister has been diagnosed with breast cancer and I cannot understand why, why would god let this happen to her… she is such a good person and has always done good… why does it happen to nice people…I prayed and prayed to god that her results would be ok and he didn’t answer me…pls help:(
forgive me, but reacting to an illness by blaming God is childish. Things happen for a reason, God has a plan for everything. Why does God allow illness and death, look no further than the creation story in Genesis, we as a race sinned we have to pay the price for our own foolishness, maybe your sister has cancer because having that struggle in life might contribute to her and her (your) family’s personal holiness. maybe God is deciding to call your sister home (by that i mean heaven) because she accomplished what she has been sent here to do, I dont know, i cant, you cant, no one can know God’s reasons for doing things or allowing some things to come to pass (read the book of Job in the Bible).

that being said i am genuinely sorry that your sister is suffering with cancer, and my prayers are with her and your family, but as i said blaming and cursing God is a childish reaction to illness.
 
Dear Mollypup,

I am very sorry to hear that your sister is ill. I will pray for her this evening.

Our Lord has not and will not abandon you, nor will he abandon your sister in her time of need ----
 
It is a test.
God is not here to bring us a good live on the earth. God is only interested that we get the eternal live, because our live here on the earth is very short and one day we all will die.
It is better to have a bad live and die in the age of 20 and get the eternal live than living for 120 years and go to hell.

Look at Lukas 16, 19-31 and you see how God is behaving!
 
“We trust ourselves to a doctor because we suppose he knows his business. He orders an operation which involves cutting away part of our body and we accept it. We are grateful to him and pay him a large fee because we judge he would not act as he does unless the remedy were necessary, and we must rely on his skill. Yet we are unwilling to treat God in the same way! It looks as if we do not trust His wisdom and are afraid He cannot do His job properly. We allow ourselves to be operated on by a man who may easily make a mistake – a mistake which may cost us our life – and protest when God sets to work on us.”
  • St. Claude de la Colombière
 
From St. Paul of the Cross -
"There could not be a surer sign of God’s love for you than this pain which He has sent you. Adore the divine will. You were in good health when you were in the world, but you were not then as dear to God as you are now. He loves you as a daughter, as a cherished spouse: this is why He treats you so generously.
Long illnesses are the greatest favors that God confers on souls whom He loves most
. . . . Repose peacefully in the arms of your heavenly Spouse, Who loves you much; hold yourself on the cross of sickness as tranquilly and silently as is possible. If the cause of your illness be the wound of divine love which embalms yO,ur soul, it is well if you die under such a stroke: yours will be a death more precious than life."*

Put a small Crucifix in your sisters hands when she is layed up from this disease. Let her embrace Him in her arms and let her unite her suffering to His. Let her offer up all of the pain to our Crucified Christ. He will understand and give her comfort. It is through these trials that He makes us stronger. Without them, none of us can grow in character and in Him.

Try not be angry. There is much suffering in this world and there always will be. It is up to us to embrace it and pray that we suffer well…
 
I am terribly sorry your sister has breast cancer and I hope you will be able to have the strenght to live through whatever happens.

I usually like to be a comfort to people but I also believe in honesty. I feel you are putting too much blame on God.
…I prayed and prayed to god that her results would be ok and he didn’t answer me…pls help:(
She had breast cancer way before she went for the test. To wait after her appointments and pray to God that the results are OK, is putting the buggy before the horse. Although you did not know the results until they came in, she did had breast cancer while you were praying. It is like when I was younger. I would not study for my test, write the test and know darn well I was not prepared and then pray to God for a miracle that I pass. It was too late for prayers.

I do not mean to imply that had you started to pray years ago, your sister never would get cancer. But I am saying that a real pray life needs to be started immediately, not when tragedy happens. Praying to God to thank him for what we have while times are good and for his will makes us better equipped to hear his voice when tragedy falls.

Also, I would like to say that since it is breast cancer, I am assuming both you and your sister are middle age. To be honest, I am jealous. I experienced my first significant loss before I turned 13. I had a lot of other crosses to bear in my life. From the sounds of your post, this appears to be your first big cross (unless there is detail you are not telling me about which is fair, you don’t have to). To make it this far in life without any big upsets seem like you have been very blessed.

God has not let you down. Keep praying and he will be your best source of help

CM
 
Thankyou everyone for your support, prayers and answers. After reading some of your replies I realised that I have indeed been childish and ungrateful and I hope god will forgive me, he has given me so many blessings in life and I am truly grateful. My mum had breast cancer 18 years ago and she is still with us today, she was helped through her ordeal by her church and has said that she would never have made it without them. I have been lucky, i’m 41 (the lucky sister) I have a good job, healthy children and happy marriage, I realise that I have taken this life for granted up until now. With his love my sister will get through this…the pope is coming to Scotland in september 2010 and with god will we will look forward to his visit .
 
Of course God will forgive you. This is the time he wants to take you in his arms and hug you the most. Don’t ask only for his forgiveness, ask also for his comfort !
 
I picked this up today on a Jewish site. The rabbis have much wisdom to share.

An Aish HaTorah Rabbi whose wife had metastatic breast cancer shares his tools for developing trust in God.
As with all good things in life, trust in God does not just happen. You don’t go to bed one night feeling that God is out to get you and wake up the next day confident that you can rely on Him – no matter what you take.
If you want to trust God, it is going to take conscious effort to develop and maintain the emotion. . . .
 
Where is God now? A similar question (“Where was God?”) was asked following the events of 9/11/01, and a wise person (unfortunately, I do not remember who) responded, “He is the same place where He was when His Son was being nailed to a cross.”

DaveBj
 
I’m sorry, this is my 1st post on here, I came on here to look for help. I have been cursing god and have disowned him and I feel so alone now. My sister has been diagnosed with breast cancer and I cannot understand why, why would god let this happen to her… she is such a good person and has always done good… why does it happen to nice people…I prayed and prayed to god that her results would be ok and he didn’t answer me…pls help:(
I know a very poor widow in Africa who is still praising God. She lost her husband and 3 kids to HIV/AIDS but she is still praising God. If you curse God, you are killing yourself and if you “disown” God, you are digging your own grave. Our limited minds cannot understand everything about God. God is a Loving Father and He wants the best for His children. I am not saying breast cancer is the best for your sister but God knows best. God knows why. If you don’t understand God, don’t curse. There are many things to consider first before cursing God. God did not put you in Africa to die of hunger in the first place. It is always good to count all your blessings before cursing God. It is never too late! God is a Loving Father and is ready to forgive and forget anytime. Just go to Him in prayers. Tell Him your sins and tell him you are very sorry for your sins and He will forgive and give you a new life. To answer your question “Where is God Now?”, my answer is GOD IS HERE. God is not asleep! He lives and He knows best.
 
Trust me, I know life can be hard, and yes it is human nature to try and rationalize why. But first and foremost this life is just a means to our eternal life. We only get a very short time on this earth, no matter how you look at it. I also believe, though some may disagree, Jesus did not come to us to curse us, but to save us. No I don’t have all the answers, but I know that there is a bigger plan that in no way can we truly understand, but someday we will, we will see the big picture so to speak.

Give you a little insight in my past. I was told from the time I was 18 I would never have children, the one thing that I always always wanted. I met a man, to whom I fell madly in love with. I told him that if you marry me, we will probably never have children. Now him being Italian, that could be a deal breaker (LOL a little humor); but he took me as I was, and married me…

Several years later, the doctors all told me it was "medically impossible for me to get pregnant. And after I prayed, and prayed, cried, and cried out to God, I told my husband if it is God’s will I will become pregnant. But somehow deep inside me, I knew that I would have a child. Do you know about the same time I told my husband that, I conceived my son…

Within 4 weeks of having my son Anthony, we became very ill, and I thought oh God why would you give me this gift, and then take it from me, why… (trust me, you don’t know fear and pain, until you see your child suffer). I immediately thought Mary and what she must of went through as she watched her son on that Cross. And it came to me, it did not matter what happen in this lifetime, for Anthony would ALWAYS be my son for all eternity…

I need to leave soon, cause I need to go to Church tonight… so I will give the whole wonderful story of my son’s first year, and the miracle that followed him, but I will say this… I just watched my son graduate his 5th grade class today! And everyday with my son is a gift from God, and what I went through with my son not only brought me closer to our Lord, but to our Lord’s mother as well. I think by going through what I did with my son, help me to see what Mary went through with Her beloved son. I am sure any parent could understand…

My point is this. Yes in this life there will be trials, for by these trials we purified, and also brought either closer or further from God. If it was not for Jesus, we would all be damned, we really would, but God so loved us, He gave us his only Son. That is love, God brought Jesus into this world fully knowing what Jesus would have to go through to save you and I, and He did. That is love,

Pray and believe, don’t lose faith. Yes, your faith will be tested, that is life. Don’t count it all lost, for you have not lost. Trust and lean on God through his Son, Jesus. Pray to the blessed Mother Mary, for she surely knows what our sorrows are. About all know this, we are all here but a moment, but we have all eternity to be together. Get into the Word of God, find every Scripture on healing, and stand on the Word, and believe and see what Jesus can do for you!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top