Z
zab
Guest
Give our much maligned priests the benefit of the doubt in a case of this nature.
Give our much maligned priests the benefit of the doubt in a case of this nature.
Fr. David didn’t make any assumptions, he only said that we don’t know the situation. But I agree that we should assume the best until we know otherwise.I stand by my post. You are incorrect in your assumptions.
God blessThere is one major caveat to “adoration” on Holy Thursday. The Blessed Sacrament is not to be exposed in the monstrance during that time.I presumed that our Holy Thursday Adoration was licit:
After Mass there was a procession of the Blessed Sacrament to the parish hall. There we had a special table set up with candles and chairs and pews (with kneelers).
It was very reverent.
Anything not right about this?
Now, regarding the actual location of the place of reservation (for Holy Thursday), this is what Paschalis Sollemnitatis notes:
- The Blessed Sacrament should be reserved in a closed tabernacle or pyx. Under no circumstances may it be exposed in a monstrance
- For the reservation of the Blessed Sacrament, a place should be prepared and adorned in such a way as to be conducive to prayer and meditation; that sobriety appropriate to the liturgy of these days is enjoined, to the avoidance or suppression of all abuses. [55]
I hope this helps to clarify things, at least as far as Holy Thursday is concerned.When the tabernacle is in a chapel separated from the central part of the church, it is appropriate to prepare the place of repose and adoration there.
Yes, thank-you, that does clarify things. It may even clarify my memory – I think I was mistaken about the monstrance.There is one major caveat to “adoration” on Holy Thursday. The Blessed Sacrament is not to be exposed in the monstrance during that time.
Now, regarding the actual location of the place of reservation (for Holy Thursday), this is what Paschalis Sollemnitatis notes:
I hope this helps to clarify things, at least as far as Holy Thursday is concerned.
The original post says:do you mean reservation of the Blessed Sacrament in the tabernacle in a location where it is accessible to the faithful, or do you mean exposition of the Blessed Sacrament for perpetual or time limited adoration. No that question was not answered because OP did not give enough information.
I’m pretty sure the question and use of the word “adoration” is referencing exposition, as in a monstrance, not reservation in a tabernacle.I’ve only ever seen exposition of the Eucharist in churches and chapels, but today I was looking at the website of a parish that said they have Eucharistic adoration in a room in the religious education building. Is that licit?
At a Religious Community in New Zealand it was decided to celebrate Holy Mass in the dining room, on the dining room table, theory being “it would be more suitable.” (Agreeably one Priest was hostile to this happening, there being a Chapel with consecrated altar in the same house.)if the bishop has given them permission to use that room, and it is dedicated to that purpose, yes. No the Blessed Sacrament may not be reserved, much less exposed for Adoration, in a room that is being used for another purpose, for instance, a classroom while class is going on. Perhaps they have permission, if there is no other suitable space (why they are not in church I can’t imagine) to have Adoration in a large classroom or gathering area, but the tabernacle cannot remain there unless the space has been dedicated and reserved for that use. Maybe there is ongoing construction or another reason for the use of this space, as at a neighboring parish.
This is the second page of this response and I have not seen any response toward the internet. There is a site called <Savior.org> where you can adore Our Lord’s live image in the Chapel of a convent where the nuns are dedicated to the Adoration of Our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament. This was begun because of all those in Nursing Homes or at home and unable to get to a Church for Adoration or even to Mass. I am happy to be able to share this information to the Catholic Answers Forum. God BlessAt a Religious Community in New Zealand it was decided to celebrate Holy Mass in the dining room, on the dining room table, theory being “it would be more suitable.” (Agreeably one Priest was hostile to this happening, there being a Chapel with consecrated altar in the same house.)
At our church (and I notice at several other Catholic churches throughout the year) an alternative table is set up for the purpose of Holy Mass in preference to a consecrated altar.
Brave new world of ekkonomia. Where should the PC be located? Special/consecrated room? Bedside of those in palliative care?This is the second page of this response and I have not seen any response toward the internet. There is a site called <Savior.org> where you can adore Our Lord’s live image in the Chapel of a convent where the nuns are dedicated to the Adoration of Our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament. This was begun because of all those in Nursing Homes or at home and unable to get to a Church for Adoration or even to Mass. I am happy to be able to share this information to the Catholic Answers Forum. God Bless
Thank-you!!!This is the second page of this response and I have not seen any response toward the internet. There is a site called <Savior.org> where you can adore Our Lord’s live image in the Chapel of a convent where the nuns are dedicated to the Adoration of Our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament. This was begun because of all those in Nursing Homes or at home and unable to get to a Church for Adoration or even to Mass. I am happy to be able to share this information to the Catholic Answers Forum. God Bless
Once again, please keep in mind that without knowing all the details of what’s happening, no one is in a position to say that it is either licit or not licit. As I’ve been saying all along, what is happening could be licit because we don’t have any information to indicate that it is not licit. But at the same time, no one can make the statement that it is licit based on an absence of further information.The original post says:
I’m pretty sure the question and use of the word “adoration” is referencing exposition, as in a monstrance, not reservation in a tabernacle.
I’m pretty sure thomas jd is right on all accounts.