Whether Protestants like it or not, Protestants indirect believe in the authority of the Church, since the Church compiled the Bible into Canon of Scr

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mannyfit75
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Mannyfit75

Guest
Whether Protestants like it or not, Protestants indirectly believe in the authority of the Church, since the Church compiled the Bible into Canon of Scripture in the 4th Century. The message of Jesus Christ was preached orally and Jesus taught orally. His Apostles did the same. This is fact… this is HIStory.
 
This is the standard attack that has become common on this site by us charitable Catholics.

This is fact… this is history as well.
 
I have no argument. What is the point of the thread, though? Just historical fact.
 
The point of the thread is to poke the proverbial bear. Manny is starting to rival JimmyB on the length of his thread topic names. Maybe he is trying to take the reigns from Jimmy or something.
 
“The Church” back in the days when the Bible was assembled included the spiritual ancestors of all Christians, not just Roman Catholics. The Protestant position is that the official church, by the time of Martin Luther, had departed from its true calling and nature, essentially separating itself from faithful execution of its mission. The church as an organization had departed from the true catholic (small c) Christian church.

The eventual split of the Protestant denominations from the official church organization of the day is seen by Protestants as a return to the true church, a reclamation of the Christianity that existed in the early days, minus the supposedly corrupting institution of the papacy. The official Church of Rome is seen as the body that departed from the true church, at least temporarily.

Catholics see things quite differently, of course, emphasizing Apostolic succession.

Whoever you agree with, I think it’s fair to say that the tension with the Protestant denominations has helped keep the Catholic church honest, so to speak. Catholic Bible studies? These would never have sprung up without indirect pressure from Protestant churches.
 
Whether Protestants like it or not, Protestants indirectly believe in the authority of the Church, since the Church compiled the Bible into Canon of Scripture in the 4th Century. The message of Jesus Christ was preached orally and Jesus taught orally. His Apostles did the same. This is fact… this is HIStory.
I do believe you hit the nail on the head. All this talk of Sola Scriptura is all well and good, but the truth of the matter is that most “Protestant” churches ARE NOT. If you believe in the Trinity, for example, then you are not solely relying on only the Bible.

Why so much animosity towards Non-Catholic Christians, if your post is indeed true?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top